• Hey Trainers! Be sure to check out Corsola Beach, our newest section on the forums, in partnership with our friends at Corsola Cove! At the Beach, you can discuss the competitive side of the games, post your favorite Pokemon memes, and connect with other Pokemon creators!
  • Due to the recent changes with Twitter's API, it is no longer possible for Bulbagarden forum users to login via their Twitter account. If you signed up to Bulbagarden via Twitter and do not have another way to login, please contact us here with your Twitter username so that we can get you sorted.

TEEN: the envy of eden

xiii. nightmare
517MS8.png

xiii. nightmare

※​

That night her dreams are muddled. There’s a male human you’ve seen before, his figure big and hulking like Teppy after he evolved into an emboar. The human’s face is in shadow but his eyes blaze red, so bright it pierces through the murky dark, and he’s angry and he’s frustrated and it’s always something new. Will he yell this time, or will he explain how he feels in other ways? His fists were loud the last time you saw him.

“Dad, please!” And she’s looking at him, her neck craning up as he towers over her like a mountain.

You don’t wait to find out which way he wants to respond. Pink smoke swirls around him, twines up his angry fists, down the veins bulging out of his neck, pulls him into misty depths. He roars something inhuman, and then he vanishes into the black fog. It’s the scent of roses that remains.

She turns over in her sleep, sighs a little. You can hear her outside of the pink haze, but you can’t see her.

He’s with you now, trapped in your shared nightmares. All that matters is making sure he doesn’t reach her. He howls in anger. Fueled by her imagination, he seems to grow another thirty feet and charges towards you. You’re scared. But you can take it. You have to. For her.

※​

Your name is Munny. You had a name at some point, but it isn’t one that your Bianca can pronounce, and besides, she was too busy to ask, and besides, at this point correcting her would be terribly rude and you don’t want to bother her.

Your name is Munny. Four moons ago you met your trainer. You are her munna and she is your Bianca. You are partners, equals. This is the way of things.

Right now, she’s sitting cross-legged on a bench in the pokécenter, sipping at a plastic cup half full of lemonade and paging through her pokédex with her free hand. “Look at this, Munny! It says right here that when you evolve, you’ll look like this!” Her finger jabs at the picture of the musharna on the screen. “Isn’t that amazing?”

You squint at the screen and try to hide your disappointment when it’s just a picture you already recognize. You’ve seen a musharna before. Your mother was a musharna, and your father too. Before Bianca showed up, they and your littermates were the only beings in the entire world who had ever touched you, cuddled close to you. During the day, when you all rested, you would gather close and close your eyes and hum softly before sleep. You remember the feel of your father’s leathery skin as he curled protectively around you, wisps of your mother’s smoke tracing gently into your dreams.

“Oh, it looks like you lose your flowers when you evolve. That’s sad. I like those.” She’s pinched the screen and flicked her fingers apart so you can both zoom in on the musharna’s half-and-half markings.

Your mother told you a story, once. Once upon a time, long ago, musharna were pure purple, the color of a cloudless sky just after sunset. They were gifted by the spirit of the moon with the ability to slip into dreams, and many followed Her back and forth, between the lands of waking and dreaming. Over time, many musharna decided that the peaceful tranquility of the dreamlands was a welcome respite to the chaos of the waking world. They chose not to leave, and stayed slumbering, forgetting themselves and where they were, where they came from, where they were going.

The waking musharna cried out to the Moon, asking for Her guidance, and She descended.

{Be careful, my children,} warned the Moon. {Though, like me, you wax and wane through waking and dreaming, you must always remember who you were meant to be.}

And She exhaled, coating all the musharna in pink. For half-day, and half-night. To mark all musharna as passengers to the dreamworld, but to remind them to return to Her on the other side.

The split isn’t perfect, of course. Your father’s mother, he told you, had evolved almost two-thirds pink! It was truly an auspicious sign, to have one so touched by the Moon.

You’re hopeful. Flowers are nice, but perhaps a new pattern will help you make sense of where you’re supposed to be.

“Oh, and it says right here that dream mist is pink when you eat good dreams, and different colors when you eat bad dreams. That’s so neat!” Your Bianca has already scrolled past the page about musharna habitat and behavior. The light of the screen is reflected in the crescent of her eyes.

Huh? That’s not true. Dream mist is pink no matter what. You would know. Who wrote this?

“Oh, and black dream mist means a nightmare, or a sad dream. Okay. That’s good to know. I’ve never seen black dream mist from you before, Munny.”

She hasn’t, and that’s true, but some of her dreams were truly terrifying.

Maybe they don’t count as nightmares. But you were always told that the reason is that your mist is always pink, because it comes from the Moon, and is a reflection of Her.

But … maybe your Bianca is right? And maybe the dreams she’s been having, the ones she’s asked you to help forget … maybe those don’t count as nightmares. There’s another pokémon, the one who tries to eat the Moon, and he’s pitch-black, right? So it would make sense if he sent bad dreams and made them out of black mist, yes. That’s very true. Your Bianca is very smart, and you’re not. She knows these things. You’re just not strong enough to know what a real nightmare is.

“Hey, Bi, wanna do a quick spar? Maxis just evolved and I wanted to try out some new stuff.”

You look up in alarm. Oh, good. Her Cheren wasn’t talking to you. You resume looking back at your paws.

Your Bianca’s already on her feet. “Sure thing! We’re always down for a practice match. Isn’t that right, Munny?”

Oh. Now she’s talking to you. Oh no. You obediently chirp in affirmation, but you weren’t quite listening to the question. Is she looking at you? It’s hard to tell; the lights here are quite bright and, really, your entire species was designed for being awake at night, so your vision isn’t—

“Alright, Munny. Let’s show him how it’s done!”

Her voice shakes. Often, your Bianca strokes your back and tells you how she feels. Her Hilda is a good friend, she says. But sometimes she’s worried about her Cheren. He’s so angry sometimes. He has so much that he wants to prove. Your Bianca’s face clouds when she talks about him, in ways that it never should. Her Cheren doesn’t like losing, she’d explained once in a solemn voice. So sometimes he’ll pick fights he knows he can win.

You can think about your bad vision later. You follow your Bianca outside. This is good. If you’re close to a pokécenter, then it won’t matter so much if …

“Maxis, you’re up.”

Ah, yes, now that you’re outside in the harsh sunlight and you aren’t looking at pokédex articles that are directly in front of your face, this gets a little harder. You see the brown smudge of a trainer, and the shorter, greener smudge that’s probably his pokémon. His simisage? Is that what her Cheren had mentioned? You remember he had his pansage at some point.

“Alright, start off with a Psybeam!”

Okay, here goes. You contort your face, and then release a charge of psychic energy, as much as you safely think you can. The green smudge moves out of the way—you can hear him screech in pain just a little as the attack clips his tail—and you try to track him, but by now his trainer is already shouting, “Get in close for a Bite!”

His simisage transitions to all four legs and starts scampering across the ground, growing bigger and bigger in your vision until it’s close enough for you to make out all the features and confirm that, yes, it certainly is his simisage—and then it’s sinking its teeth into the top of your back. Pain blooms across your body and you scream out in alarm, shaking back and forth, trying to dislodge it. You float up into the air, straining against the weight, and it finally gives up and drops back to the ground.

You look back nervously. Your Bianca is too far away for you to see her face, but she probably isn’t happy with your showing on that one. You pant heavily; your back burns, something hot and wet is running down your skin—

“Alright, Munny! We can still do this!” Right! You can! You have to. You puff up your body as big as it’ll go. His simisage doesn’t seem intimidated in the slightest, and is waiting patiently for its next command. You wish you could do that. Waiting patiently. But sometimes you’re anxious and doubtful, which is bad, because who could ever doubt your Bianca when she says—

“They can’t hit us when they’re asleep! Use Hypnosis, Munny!”

This strikes you as a particularly bad idea, because his simisage is quite agile, and it does seem like he’ll be able to dodge out of the way again. Hypnosis travels faster than Psybeam, and you haven’t quite done the math and you do trust your Bianca, of course, but—

“Dodge with Acrobatics, and then use Seed Bomb,” says her Cheren calmly.

You scrunch your eyes tight and begin generating pulses of mesmerizing, swirling energy, but his simisage is already jumping high into the air, and it’s around then that you process that Seed Bomb sounds like it might hurt a bit, and by that point the clusters of green energy that sprouted up around your feet are detonating.

The last thing you remember is your Bianca crying out in dismay, and then a horrible banging sound blots out the rest of your hearing, and then your vision, and then everything else.

※​

You have the strangest sensation, floating through the ether—a bolt of energy strikes you, and adrenaline surges through your veins. Once, the Elesa invited you to practice spar with her emolga, and he knew a move called Discharge, and for a split second before the pain sunk in you remember how it almost felt energizing, like waking up after a good night’s dream.

You flinch, waiting for the other shoe to drop, for the electricity to come surging in, but … there’s nothing.

“Hey there. That should do the trick.”

There’s a flash of red light, and you drop out of your pokéball. The act is so surprising that you almost plummet to the ground before you remember to reassert your telekinesis; something is wrong here; this doesn’t feel right; what’s—

You catch yourself a foot later and swivel around to see a blob of pink hair. Blue eyes, maybe? Green? You don’t want to be rude and hover closer to get a better look at her. The hair draws you in the most; it’s bright, fiery, poofs around her like a protective wreath of dream smoke.

“Hey, hey there. Don’t worry. I won’t hurt you.” She’s tilting her head back and forth like an enormous pidove, but she doesn’t get any closer—scrutinizing you from a distance. You like that. “How are you feeling?”

{Very good, thank you,} you chirp back politely. {Where am I?}

She giggles a little, and says, “I’m glad! You were in pretty rough shape, but you’re safe now.”

You wait expectantly, but she doesn’t say anything else. Where are you? Who is she?

Oh. Oh no. {My trainer,} you say, floating closer to her now. She seems friendly enough. You get close enough that you can see the pattern of her own flower-spots on her cheeks, freckled bits of brown. {Is she okay?} No, you’re so stupid! Of course your Bianca is okay. She’s not weak and dumb like you are; she would never end up in this situation. {Where is she?}

Her eyebrows bunch up. Blue. Her eyes are blue. They’re a nice color, like the sky—“Oh, don’t panic! Are you still hurt?” She starts rifling through her backpack, which hangs loosely off of one shoulder. “I used my last potions on a herdier already and we can’t really go to a pokécenter, but I have some berries that’ll do the trick.”

You shake your head. {My trainer.} You vibrate up and down for emphasis, cycle a flash through all your flower for emphasis. {Trainer.}

“I’m sorry,” the girl says. “I don’t know what you’re asking for. I, hmmm, one sec.” She reaches into her pocket and pulls out her x-transceiver. Good! She can call your Bianca, and then this whole mistake can be settled before anyone gets mad. She types something on the screen, and then puts the device away.

{Call my Bianca,} you chirp.

“I’m sorry,” she says, and it really sounds like she means it. “I don’t know what you’re saying. But I have a friend who can translate for us. He’ll call me back and then we can figure out what’s up.”

You suppose that’s a start.

“You want to rest? Go anywhere? We’ve got a little time, and I don’t want you to get bored or anything.”

You? Oh. She’s talking to you. You look around nervously. Your Bianca’s done most of the sightseeing in Castelia—a lot of the places she wants to go aren’t pokéfriendly after all, not her fault—and besides, with your bad vision? What’s even the point? You chirp back something half-heartedly, hope she’ll read into it and pick something out for both of you to do.

“Hmm. Okay. Do you want to go somewhere in the main city, or maybe by the docks?” The smudge of her face fiddles nervously with her hair. “Actually, scratch that. Do you want to go downtown? One chirp for yes, two chirps for no.”

Oh, that’s actually really clever of her! You like this human. That’s a very smart idea. From what you’ve heard of downtown, it’s noisy and smells bad. Two chirps.

“The docks?”

What’s a dock? Um. No chirps. That’s a strange word. Dock. You know that audino sometimes work for humans called doctors, but you’re feeling quite fine—

“Oh, sorry, the ocean. There’s a nice lookout of the ocean.”

Ah. That does sound nice. One chirp.

She beams. “That’s a great idea. I know a really nice spot where we can watch the ships come in; my mom used to take me there all the time as a kid.” She hoists her backpack up and swings it over her back with practiced ease. You can’t help but balk at how comically large it looks on her, the way it almost engulfs her shoulders like a tirtouga shell. What in the world does she have in there? Your Bianca’s bag is much smaller. The Rhea motions with her head. “Come on, follow me!”

Unwittingly, your eyes flit over to the pokéball—she isn’t going to recall you? What if she walks too fast?—and then you hover after her.

※​

You like the ocean. It’s big, wide, sparkling. The color is reassuring, almost like a night sky. You can’t pick out the details of the waves, but you almost don’t need to—when it all blurs together, the sun reflects off of the water and makes a thousand vanishing stars for you.

“I grew up down the street from here,” the girl is saying. “My mom used to take me and my little brother here on the weekends all the time. Free entertainment, you know?”

You don’t know, but you chirp politely.

The girl looks up in alarm suddenly, and she’s quick to stand at attention. Her back is as straight as the lamppoles dotting the pier. “My Lord N!” Her voice is higher-pitched than before. Almost a squeak. You like her. “I didn’t mean for you to come out this way. I apologize for interrupting; I thought you were going to call.”

He waves a hand. “Don’t worry about it, Rhea. I was in the area anyway. How are you?”

Her voice is rapid-fire now. Official. Low, serious. “The extraction went fine. Tourmaline covered my tracks. Best to keep her out of the eastern boroughs for a few days, and obviously we’ll have to scramble the tags on the pokéball if we want to take her back to a center, but no trackers.”

Something about her statement brings a smile to his face—at first you think it’s the strange words like boroughs or scramble or trackers but—“How’s Tourm doing? Is she happy?”

Despite herself, the Rhea smiles. “Yeah. She’s a liepard now—that doesn’t help the fur problem much—but I think she likes the new form a lot.”

“If both of you think you have some time, I’d love to say hello after this.”

The Rhea chews her lip. Calculating something, you think, and then she says, “We should probably go north of here. I was planning to be out of here by sundown.”

They’re talking in some strange code. Why do they have so many schedules? Your Bianca came and went as she pleased, and was much happier for it.

“I understand. I’m heading north as well. Could you give us a moment?”

“Of course, Lord N,” she says, and then strolls purposefully down the pier.

That leaves, well, just you.

“Hello,” the new human says. He’s a smudge of green and white on the horizon, and if not for the accessories he’s chosen to wear, you’d think he were a tree. He comes closer to you, but not too close, and then sits cross-legged on the wood of the dock with his chin in his hands, a full two feet away. These are a respectful bunch. “My name is N. Do you have a name?”

Well that’s an interesting question to open up with. No one’s asked you that before. {Munny.}

The features of his face flash and knit together for a moment, and then he says, “Ah, that’s a very nice name. Haven’t heard that for a munna before.” His teeth glimmer from beneath his smile, but it doesn’t seem like he fully means it. “Rhea over there tells me you’ve been very agitated. I wanted to ask you why. Are you hurt? Are you satisfied with how she’s taking care of you?”

{No, I’m fine, actually.} You normally wouldn’t push confrontation, but luckily you actually are fine, so this is a good day for everyone. {Oh—I was wondering what she did to make me feel better?}

“What she did?” he asks. “What do you mean?”

{It’s just that normally only audino can heal pokémon,} you explain patiently for him. {Humans can’t heal pokémon. She must be very special. Touched by the Moon.}

The N quickly shutters his eyes, and you aren’t quite sure what he means by that. He steeples his fingers across his nose and exhales sharply; you recoil in alarm as tendrils of his emotions suddenly flare out, big enough for you to see. You aren’t a good empath yet and you really can only sense things when humans are asleep, but he’s angry and he’s frustrated and it’s something you said and you want to shout sorry sorry sorry but won’t that just make it worse and—

“Oh, hey.” His voice is quiet all of a sudden. “Hey, hey. I’m not angry at you. This isn’t your fault.” Is he talking to you? You nervously peak one eye open and uncurl a little, just a hair. He’s blurry, but he’s certainly looking at you. But if he’s not mad at you and it’s not your fault, whose fault is it? “Munny? Can you hear me?”

Big silence. You’re a roiling sea of emotions and he’s the nightmare on the other side, lightning waiting to strike—

“Do you mind if I sit a little closer? I think it’ll be easier for us to talk that way.”

Oh. {Okay. If you’d like.}

“Only if you’d like, Munny. I didn’t mean to scare you earlier, but that was my fault. I’m sorry. I’ll try not to let it happen again.”

That’s very nice of him. You … didn’t really expect that. {Okay.}

He inches a little closer. Still a solid foot away, very respectable distance. He doesn’t look like a munna, but he seems to understand proper spatial etiquette much better than most humans. They’re incredibly touchy creatures. Maybe he told the Rhea how to be polite as well. The ocean sparkles to your left.

“I, uh, where were we?” He smiles nervously, a bit flustered. “Your question. Rhea is a normal human.”

{She’s a very nice human!} you say defensively.

“Oh, yes, she’s a very good human. Sorry.”

He apologizes quite a bit to you. That’s normally your job. {It’s okay.}

“Rhea is a very good, nice, human, but she doesn’t have magical healing powers,” the N corrects. “But humans have made inventions that can make pokémon feel better. They can use these inventions to heal pokémon, even if humans can’t heal pokémon themselves.” Big pause.

Oh, that’s very nice of them. Why would they waste them on you, thought? Bianca had explained this once—they did sell Potions and Revives but they were very expensive, and to buy them you had to be good at battling, but to be good at battling your pokémon had to be healthy, but for your pokémon to be healthy you had to buy the items, so. It was a circle and the two of you were on the outside.

“Anyway, I wanted to ask you about your trainer,” the N says.

{Oh yes.} A pang of guilt. You feel bad for forgetting, but there’s just been so much to keep track of today. {I wanted to know. Where is my Bianca? Can I return to her?}

“That’s,” N says, and sighs heavily, “what I wanted to ask you about.” He traces a pattern in the bench with his index finger, over and over again, and then all of a sudden he looks you squarely in the eyes. His eyes. They’re the color you see behind your eyelids right before you fall into slumber. “Rhea’s been watching your trainer for a while. She says that your trainer battles with you until you faint a lot.”

Oh, that. Yes, it’s quite embarrassing. You don’t really know the numbers but you’re quite sure that, of Bianca’s team, you’re the one who’s knocked out the most. Even Mienny, who’s the newest and the youngest.

You look up at N, but he’s fallen silent. Is he waiting for you to respond? That’s weird. You’re not used to that. It’s weird talking to someone who expects you to talk back. {I know,} you say glumly. {I’m trying to get stronger, really, I am! Then my Bianca can do better and I won’t faint as much.}

The N sighs. You don’t think you gave the right answer. Oh no. Is he mad? No, he’s smiling now, a small one that doesn’t reach his eyes. “Do you think your trainer should be allowed to do that? It hurts you a lot.”

{She heals me up right after!} Okay, not right after. Sometimes not for a while, and your bones ache and your mist is more of a wisp, but that’s not her fault either! She tries her best, and it’s not like you could do any better anyway. {And it makes her happy, so I’m happy as well.}

He builds a mountain out of his fingers and rests them under his chin. He thinks for a long time. He’s not like you; you can tell that every word is weighed carefully in advance before it even has the time to approach his lips. “Rhea is in a group with me. Our goal is to make sure that pokémon don’t get hurt. If you want, we could put you somewhere else. Wherever you’d like. You wouldn’t have to battle any more.”

Your flowers flash a bright pink before you can control yourself and tamp them back down. {I … I wouldn’t have to battle?}

“Not unless you want to.”

Oh, moon and stars. That would be such a relief. You wouldn’t have to think about how you’re too slow, or how your attacks aren’t strong enough, or how it hurts when you aren’t tough enough to tank a blow. You wouldn’t have to feel bad about letting everyone down, and—best of all, you wouldn’t have to feel guilty for when you did get stronger, and you made other pokémon hurt instead of you. Your flowers are practically glowing now, bright like the reflections of the sun on this ocean. {That’s … that would be lovely. Can I really?}

The N nods. Doesn’t say anything else. He smiles. Seems happy you’re happy.

And then.

In a very small, very polite voice: {But will my Bianca be mad at me?}

He fidgets with his fingers nervously. You’re suddenly struck by how long they are. He absently twirls a set of gold bracelets around and around on his wrist, where they make a gentle clacking sound. “You wouldn’t be returning to Bianca. You would go somewhere else.”

{Somewhere else?} The lights stop flashing through your flowers, and suddenly you feel dim, deflated. That future of you not fighting suddenly vanishes until it’s nothing more than wisps of dream smoke. {Where?}

“Wherever you’d like,” the N says quietly, still twirling the bracelets.

{Can’t I go back to her?} This doesn’t seem fair.

“If you do, you’ll probably have to battle again. She is a trainer, Munny. You are a pokémon. That’s part of what she does.”

{Oh.} Yes, he’s quite right. You were stupid for thinking otherwise.

“You don’t have to answer right away. I want you to think it over first.”

This isn’t a very fun thought. You want to change the subject. Right now. {You look like someone who has interesting dreams.}

There’s a big black-and-white hat on his head, so the shadow almost obscures his eyes, but you see him flinch back in surprise. Then, his lips crack into a smile. “You’re very observant, Munny.”

{What kind of dreams do you have?}

“I dream of the future.”

{The future?}

“Yes. It’s a place where pokémon are free to do what they want, and they live happily amongst one another.” His voice is quiet now, but it’s still low and fast, so it’s almost in perfect rhythm with the waves dashing against the pier. “A lot of the details are blurry, though. Sometimes it doesn’t even feel like it was even a dream I had to begin with.”

{Oh. Home.} You actually know a lot about these. You’ve dreamed about your home as well. And those bits about forgetting a lot of the details … you know that as well. {The kind that goes away when you wake up?}

Yes, he’s smiling, but it doesn’t look happy in the slightest. “Sort of. But I’ll get there again one day. It won’t be a dream forever.”

{I hope so. Sad dreams are the worst.}

You want to correct yourself, but you don’t want to waste his time. But as soon as you say it, you realize your mistake: sad dreams aren’t the worst. When you wake up from a nightmare, you open your eyes in a better world. When you wake up from a happy dream …

You both sit in silence for some time. The waves wash in, and then they wash out.

Finally, he shakes his head, almost like he’s flicking water out of his mane or something, and he clears his throat. “Whether you decide to go back to Bianca or not is entirely up to you,” the N says, but you can’t shake the feeling that he doesn’t think this is fine, that you’ve somehow made the wrong choice already. “You’re allowed to do whatever you’d like. You can stay with us and we can talk about where you’d like to go from here.” There’s a long pause. When you don’t say anything, he adds, “Or Rhea can escort you back to your trainer.”

Oh thank goodness. Hopefully your Bianca won’t be mad at you. {Thank you. I’d like that.}

There’s. Another long bit of silence. He seems upset somehow, and you don’t know what you did to cause it. “Before I leave, though, do you mind if I trouble you for one more question?”

You wait expectantly, but he doesn’t ask the question. Oh. Right. {No, go ahead.}

{Your trainer,} he says, and a little chill goes down your back as you realize he’s not speaking with a human tongue any more. There’s suddenly layers that the human tongue never has, the way trainer has the same cadence as friend. {She gives her dreams to you. Is it just her nightmares, or do you get to share the happy ones as well?}

You’re so stunned at the sound of his human voice speaking your language that you don’t even know how to respond to him, let alone think over the words that he’s saying. You hover perfectly still, the munna equivalent of a blue screen, and by the time you can scrape together some words, the N is standing up; the Rhea is back.

“Thank you, Rhea, for escorting her to her trainer,” the N says. “And thank you for your time, Munny.”

You can’t tell properly from this distance, but the Rhea’s face is contorted in fire. “I can’t just take her back; she’s only going to get hurt again.”

“It’s her choice, Rhea,” the N says quietly, casting a look over his shoulder towards you. He doesn’t sound convinced. Not like your Bianca, who always knew what was best. “We can’t force her to stay; that’d be just as bad.”

“Just as bad as forcing her to faint again?”

That shuts the N up for a second, and you can see him cycle through his open mouth and closed mouth positions without any words coming out. His head hangs so that his mane hides his face. “Could you please tell her, Munny? Tell her what you told me.”

{She can’t understand me, can she?} You almost hope not. You’re not used to this many people asking your opinion, and your words aren’t nearly as good.

“Not the actual words. But, it’s like you said. Rhea is a very nice human. She’ll understand the meaning behind it.”

You float closer to Rhea, so close you can almost see the way the light reflects off of her eyes, far too close for a respectful munna but just close enough for a respectful human. {I love my Bianca! I do. She gave me everything I have. It’s not her fault that I’m not strong enough yet, and better yet, she’s going to help me become stronger! She’s a very busy human, and out of all of the munna in my dreamyard to join her team, she picked me, so of course I need to work hard and repay her! If I left now, she’d be really sad, and besides—}

It takes all of your energy, the bits that the Rhea gave you and a little extra besides. You aren’t like a big musharna; you can’t control your smoke very carefully, but you have to try. So you gather it all up and scoop it into a rough approximation of your feelings, and that all takes the form of the day you first met your Bianca. She scooped you up into the air, her hands far, far too tight around you, and then she held you close, smiling, the way only your parents would, and she whispered a name for you. She became your whole world, your Moon, plucked you from a dark night and made herself into your light.

{—if this is what it takes for her to love me like I am, then … that’s what I’ll do, don’t you think? I’ll get stronger, and then I can take it!}

There’s a long silence.

The smoke swirls tighter, condenses in the image of her clutching you to her stomach. In the mist, you’re completely pink, touched by the Moon. With her you know exactly who you are supposed to be.

You look at both humans, nervous. {Did I do okay?}

The Rhea is crying. The N’s mane and hat are in the way, but it looks like he might be as well.

You wish they were asleep so you could take their bad dreams away, so they wouldn’t cry like this. But they aren’t. They’re awake, and you’re awake, and you can’t wake up.

※​

Your Bianca sniffles, even thirty minutes after you’ve reunited with her and the trouble is all cleared up. You try to cheer her up, but it doesn’t work.

“Oh, Munny,” she says, wiping her nose on the sleeve of her shirt. “The girl who found you said some horrible things. She said that I was a bad trainer for letting this happen to you, for letting you get hurt. She said if I really cared so much about learning about all of you, I should just do that instead. Imagine! Me, the researcher?” Another sniff. “I’m not a bad trainer! Right?”

No! You nuzzle her fiercely. She is a good person. You know she won’t understand that, but you hope that, like the Rhea, she gets the meaning behind your words.

She laughs weakly, but it’s more of a sob. “Oh, thank you, Munny.” She hugs you tight, so close it’s hard to breathe. “I know you can’t be mad at me, but everything she said just made me feel so bad, and …” She trails off. “Oh, I just feel so horrible.”

You want to cry too. Your heart breaks for your dear Bianca, who doesn’t deserve to feel bad. After all, it wasn’t her fault that any of this happened, and you both know it! You chirp at her reassuringly, but it doesn’t seem to help. Her pain is important! So important. She doesn’t deserve to hurt like this, to have her flaws brought out under a magnifying glass, burned like leaves under the lens. The Rhea doesn’t have a potion to make your Bianca’s pain go away, and that doesn’t strike you as fair.

Your Bianca needn’t worry. You’ll get stronger. You’ll think less about your parents, of your home at the dreamyard, of the Moon that’s outside of her orbit. You’ll stop losing so much. Then it won’t matter. If you don’t faint then no one can be mad at you for making them feel bad, right?

That night, as you all settle in for sleep in the pokécenter, you think about what the N asked you, about the answer you never gave. Your Bianca asked you if you could eat her bad dreams for her, true. And you’d never dream of taking the good ones from her; that simply wouldn’t be fair. She worked hard for those. She gets to keep them.

That night, she dreams again of her father, hulking and monstrous, and you take it from her. You take it all. Her dreams are dark and scattered, fragmented like shards of broken glass. They hurt to touch, but you lovingly scoop them all up anyway, just like every other time she’s asked you to protect her. In the morning she wakes up rosy-eyed and refreshed, and you curl a little closer in your cloud of pink smoke. Sad. For a moment you can’t shake the image of how the Rhea and the N cried for you on the docks. For a moment you have the feeling that you’re sleeping and you can’t wake up.

But you have to wake up. It’s a new day, and your Bianca is waiting. The Moon is set.

It’s not her fault. She gave you her nightmares, but she never asked you to give her your love.



p | n
 
Last edited:
xiv. nocturne
561MS8.png

xiv. nocturne

※​

You were born from the earth nine hundred and twelve thousand, eight hundred fifty-four nights ago. Human hands pulled you from deep, deep underground and gave you a body to contain your breath.

Practiced hands gave you form. You were wet clay, shaped. Widespread wings to engulf the sky. Enormous eye to survey, to watch and guard.

Careful hands gave you color. Gold you were, for the fields of wheat. Blue, for the endless sky. Green you were, for the towering trees. Black, for the glimmering night.

Calloused hands gave you fire. From the kiln you received warmth, and from that warmth your skin grew strong enough to withstand any impact.

But gentle were the hands that gave you life. Into your shell he breathed a name—sigilyph. You were made to protect.An obsidian knife flashed across an open palm, calling blood to rise above skin. It was smeared on the tips of your wings, across the edges of your being, and in that moment the pact was complete: red you were, for the human that shared your life. From the moment that the blood touched your skin, you were one life, one pain.

And so the two of you were one, human and pokémon. He gave you some of his red and in return you protected the red he kept within him, until, one day—the roar of dragons split open the skies, cleaving day and night. Lancing thunder struck down the towering forests. A raging inferno devoured the plains of wheat. Blue, black, green, and gold faded, and when the fighting eclipsed all else and reached your home, they took your red as well and cast him deep into the earth.

The land and his flesh were blown away. The earth that had once been protected by the humans and their hands withered and rotted into the brown of the desert sands. But you remained, your skin a multicolored farce of what the land used to be. The events of that day were sad. But far worse was when the sun rose and fell around you, crafting a tragedy two thousand years in the making until only the dunes remained, dotted here and there with crumbling relics, a lone spire.

Only the dunes remained, and you, to watch the sands dance.

※​

You call upon the zen ones sometimes. The ancient darma stand guard over the remains, guarding the castle you once served even as it sinks further into the sands.

When they were solidified into stone, they were given no eyes, no ears, no movement. Unlike you, they received no red when they were chiseled out of the earth’s loving embrace, and so they stand solemn guardian, unable to move or feel. Their burden is to witness, and to those who are worthy, speak.

Where you were once two and now one, they were once five and always five, the last living things to remember your era. You return to the entrance of the ruins once each sun, to remember and bid them tidings of the world they never saw. They are five specks of green in the desert, like the forests you once knew.

{Greetings,} you say, hovering over to them.

{Greetings, loresinger,} says Four. {Were the sands kind to you?}

You dip low, your own sort of nod of affirmation. {The sands were kind. I hope they were for you as well.}

{They were, and we have known nothing else. Tell us something new, loresinger,} says Two. {Tell us what you have heard this year.}

And there is so much, and yet at the same time there is so little. It feels like you are living in a halcyon period. You’ve seen it happen before. First the air settles, then the clouds roll in, and then the rain pours down. For a few serene hours, the maractus wander across the moonlit dunes, the spines of the desert greedily gathering all the moisture they will see for an untold number of moons. The sands are quiet, and the desert is calm. When the sandstorm returns, it will do so with stinging winds and scorching sands, but until then, there is a fragile peace.

{Yes, loresinger,} says Five. {What news do you have of the world?}

Tonight the winds are still, but one day soon they will sing. And with them will come a sandstorm so great that you fear this entire world will be consumed. You have seen it in the clouds. And yet, despite that, the people are calm, unaware of what lies just beyond the horizon. And so you find yourself saying: {I have nothing new to share. The sands were quiet this year.}

Three is unsatisfied with that. You sense that much. Even if they no longer have the movement to convey it, it lies in their voice. {Nothing new?} Three says scornfully. {Then give us something old, loresinger. You who have seen so much.}

Something old. Unbidden, the memory springs to you, an echo of the sandstorm rising on the horizon. What you think of is more than old; it’s ancient, and yet it’s the same story that you’ve heard wander across a thousand nights. A story whispered into your clay as soft hands stretched your wings, gave you shape, gave you flight. There is beauty in what precedes the storm in these parts. You imagine the calm before the rain, the way the winds crescendo and then fall silent to listen for just an instant before the downpour begins. After all, you are the loresinger. What better tale to tell on a halcyon night than this one?

{Very well,} you say, echoing words you have not heard aloud for two thousand years. {Listen carefully my friends, as I tell you of the gift of Stormdancer.}

※​

This world was born into chaos. A great storm raged in the skies and battered the plains below. Harsh winters gave way to blazing summers. The earth froze, and it burned, and it shuddered. In the storm was only violence: ice, fire, and thunder roared in equal parts.

Amidst that chaos, a great dragon was born. And she looked at the world, and she wept for it. In the flames, her tears seared off into the sun; in the cold, they froze; in the storms, they washed away. And even though she saw that it was futile, even though there was nothing she could do, she wept. From her tears rose a great ocean, which grew so vast that it absorbed the lightning, quenched the fire, halted the glaciers. The dragon then swallowed the ocean inside of herself, and the battle raged within her chest, so that through her, the land grew peaceful once more.

For many suns, the great dragon roamed the earth she had tamed, alone. Where lesser beings may have only seen a barren wasteland, she saw an avenue for great beauty. The flood had watered the earth, and she saw within it the potential for great beauty, a world that could be shaped like clay. With her wings she created the first wind; with her talons she scraped furrows that sprouted into forests; with her tail she swept mountains and valleys. Within her, a battle raged—the storm of ice, fire, and thunder that she had calmed could never truly be at peace—but without, the earth flourished.

The land that she had watered gave way to life, and the dragon witnessed this with both awe and pride. Soon, her children crawled across every corner of the earth, and yet she feared they would not be strong enough to face the troubles ahead, should the land lapse into chaos again. For the Dragonmother sensed that one day her body would fail her, and the primordial storm would break free once more. She knew her children needed to be prepared.

So to all living creatures, the Dragonmother gave out great gifts. She set some to be the guardians of the winds, others to be the guardians of earth. Piece by piece the Dragonmother gave out more and more, until she was diminished. From her rose hundreds of species of pokémon, who travelled far and wide across the lands.

This the Dragonmother watched, and she smiled, and she prepared to rest.

But as she folded her wings around herself and prepared to enter the eternal slumber, she heard a voice crying out. Unlike the rest of her children, who had grown mighty, this one was feeble and pitiful. When she had doled out her gifts, it had been forgotten, and so, like a seedling in the shadow of a red rock, it could not grow strong.

With doleful, rheumy eyes, the Dragonmother turned to her youngest child. Human looked back at her, toothless and fangless, with no weapons to call its own. It begged her for help, even as the rest of its siblings raged around it with their newfound strength and the stormclouds gathered overhead. Weakly, Human called out again, a pathetic cry that was consumed by even the faint sounds of the Dragonmother’s labored breaths.

Mother. Please.

{My sweet child, I am so sorry. I am diminished,} said the Dragonmother sadly.

And it was true. Her scales had lost their luster; her limbs had leeched off their strength. The battle of ice and fire and thunder had sapped her dry. But the Dragonmother could not bear to leave any of her children to suffer, and so in her last moments, she called close her oldest daughter.

{Stormdancer,} she said quietly, her breath growing short even as her words became ever more urgent. {To your youngest sibling, I beg that you show compassion and mercy. Teach them your strength. Lend out your gift, so that they may be like you.}

Stormdancer nodded solemnly, and with this final mandate, the Dragonmother gave up the last of her breath and turned to stone. The earth rumbled, and then unnaturally dark clouds gathered overhead, seething and more violent than any sky any living creature had ever seen. It was as the Dragonmother had feared: without her to contain it, the primordial storm was free once more.

And so Stormdancer turned to Human, who sobbed and clutched tightly to their mother’s stony form.

“Forgive me, dear sibling,” said Stormdancer, bowing low. “This is all I know how to give.”

The starry river stretched above her in a silver ribbon; below, the clouds swirled and rumbled with the terrible storm that the Dragonmother had set free at last.

But Stormdancer pirouetted once, and then wove her limbs into a twisting spiral, danced so gracefully and sang a melody so sweet and pure that the entire earth fell quiet to listen. The clouds themselves hushed. Stormdancer sang for Human and paid the oncoming storm no heed.

Like their mother before them, Human witnessed. The beauty of her performance drove Human to weep bitter tears, which fell instead of the raindrops and darkened their stony mother below.

When Stormdancer was done, Human was speechless for one day and one night, drenched in the downpour that finally came, that Human endured. Finally, Human said, “Your music was beautiful, Stormdancer. But how can I learn from this? I cannot dance like you; my limbs will never be as graceful as yours. How can I learn your gift?”

“My sweet sibling.” Stormdancer smiled. “Listen to yourself. You already have.”

“What do you mean?”

“Come back to me on this day each year, and I will sing for you my aria, and so share with you my gift of Voice. When I sing, the world has no choice but to stop and listen.” Stormdancer swept out one leg and curtsied deep. “The same holds true for you now, dear sibling. When you speak, all creatures in this world will listen. This is the gift we share.”

※​

By the time you finish your story, the winds have fallen completely silent. A rarity for this deep in the desert.

Four speaks up first. {Thank you, loresinger. That was a good offering.}

{A good offering,} Two repeats solemnly.

{It was only mine to share.} Unbidden, the words of the old traditions fall from you, like spare feathers. {May you pass it along.}

“I always heard there was a different ending,” says a voice, and you and the zen ones all turn to see a human emerging across the moonlit dunes, casting a sharp shadow on the fuzziness of the sand.

{A different ending?} Three asks.

“Yes, one that a hydreigon told me.”

{Aha, and my friend the King of Unova told me you’re full of shit,} says Five, which sends a few titters echoing amongst the zen ones. {A dragon, telling stories to a human. Imagine that.}

But One isn’t so easily stirred to humor. {Besides, what would you know of these matters?} they scoff.

“It was just a story I heard once,” repeats the voice, walking up to you and then folding himself so he sits cross-legged in the circle of the zen ones. “Forgive me, my friend. But your words do not fall on deaf ears. When you speak, I have no choice but to stop and listen.”

{Oho!} Three chortles. {You are a feisty one indeed. Look at this human, my brethren. One gifted with a voice, deigning to speak to the voiceless. See how he claims to know the secrets of dragons and tells us a new ending to our own story. You humans are all the same, trying to put words into our mouths while claiming to listen. But we are of the sands, foolish boy, and we will not sit quietly while you reshape our history to us.} One laughs whole-heartedly alongside, and Five chuckles, but Two and Four are silent. Curious. Like you. He heard your story, but it’s more than that—he speaks like someone who understands what it means.

“I apologize for intruding upon your sands,” says the human. Around his neck he wears a strange symbol: a black orb with rings of blue. It shimmers with the reflection of the milky stars stretching above. “If you want me to leave, tell me, and I will immediately go.”

{Do so, paleskin!} shouts Three, gleeful. {We Darmanitan have guarded this place from your kind for centuries, and we shall do so for centuries more. Your soft words cannot delude us. You may have a human voice, but when you speak we will not listen.}

You tense, expecting fire. The human carries no pocketspheres at his waist; he has no servants to whom to issue commands. He is gifted with voice but he has yet to use it to make others into his weapons. How will he fight them off?

“I understand,” he says instead. “Thank you for your letting me share your company.” He unfolds once more, extending long, gangly legs like those of a zebstrika, and he bows low. “May the sands be kind.”

{For you as well,} replies Three, almost without realizing, and before any of them can say anything else, the human pads away into the silent night.

{May the sands be kind,} you say quickly to the zen ones, the words almost coming out in a jumbled mess, and even as the chorus of “for you as well” rings behind you, you’re already fluttering up behind the human, your shadow twining with his on the smooth dunes as he retraces his steps.

From behind, you can see the corner of his lips tilt up into a smile. “Hello. It’s nice to meet you.”

{You are not like other humans.}

He exhales quietly, his breath cold in the desert night. “I get that a lot.”

He keeps walking with a single-minded determination, one foot in front of the other. Around you, the sand is untouched, windswept, indented only by a single pair of footsteps trailing towards the desert ruins, and the half-trail that loops back the way it came.

{Where are you going?}

“Truly? I don’t know yet. Forward, I suppose.”

There’s the soft whisper of his footsteps in the sand, and nothing more.

{Are you angry that the zen ones dismissed you?} you ask at last.

He squares his hands in the pockets of his pants, hunches his shoulders against the wind—but the night is calm. There’s nothing to guard against. “A little,” he admits. “But I don’t know if anger is the right word. It isn’t their fault. They aren’t wrong to scorn me.” He pauses. “Putting words into our mouths while claiming to listen.” And this time, there’s no mistaking the tinge of bitterness that colors his words. “Pokémon never tell lies. The darmanitan can see it, even if I no longer know myself.”

This human reminds you of the stone carvings your old human once made of the Dragonmother, her chest a writhing mass, the edges of her body sharp and jagged from the chaos she can’t contain. {Can see what?}

He doesn’t answer your question, not at first. Instead, he stops and whirls to look at you, takes in your entire form. He’s not angry, he’s not awed, he’s not greedy. Over the years a hundred humans have looked at you rising above the sands, but few of them heard the questions you asked and tried to answer. “When I was a child, I heard the same legend as the one you just told now. He called it Meloetta and the Nocturne Lament, and it was a story of music so powerful that it had the ability to change hearts and minds alike. She was the true bridge between humans and pokémon, able to switch readily between her fighting and her words. When humans called to her, she gave them her voice, and turned to her dancing instead. But the dragon who told me this story had a different ending. Would you permit me to share it?”

You bob up and down expectantly. But when he doesn’t take that as affirmation, you quickly chime in, {Of course.}

He nods, and then, with a quiet storyteller’s voice, he speaks. “For years, the human returned to Meloetta on the longest night of the year, when winter was at its peak and the world was at its coldest. And on that night, Meloetta would perform her relic song, a final vestige of an older time.” He tilts his hand toward the silhouette of the ruins on the horizon, speckled with the five zen ones. “They named her venue the Relic Castle, for the gift of her song. Eventually, humanity prospered, and soon it wasn’t just one human, or two—an entire generation gathered for her. They were always silent when they watched her, and at the beginning of her performance they only greeted her with the sounds of their hands, but when she was finished, they could all Speak, and they sang their praises with their lips and shared her gift amongst themselves.

“But one day, a war broke out between two nations. Intending to hit his enemies where they would suffer the most, and wanting to end the war quickly before it would cause any more harm to his people, the king of one of the nations gathered his armies and found where Meloetta rested before the winter solstice. He sought to steal her gift for himself and his people, so that it could no longer be turned against him. And so he commanded his people to creep up on Meloetta as she slept, and they surrounded her, and they tore out her throat.

“They made a fatal mistake, for they could not kill their sister so easily. But even as they clutched their prize in their hands, even as she lay bleeding in the dirt, Meloetta looked at the one who had gathered all the others to his side, and she chose not to strike them down where they stood. Instead, with the last of her strength, with her voice stolen from her, she rasped her final gift.” The human looks at you, and he looks past you, and he looks through you. And when he speaks again you can hear the power leave his voice. He’s quiet. Hesitant, almost, when he says, {Our mother gave out many gifts, but remember this, dear sibling: she gave gifts of strength, not power. You must never forget that. Strength allows you to endure pain. Power lets you inflict pain on others. Now that you have my gift of blood, you must learn the difference, or else lose yourself.}

He falls silent.

{You can speak like us,} you say at last. It’s the easier thing to address.

The human stops walking for a second, and turns back to look at you. His hair blows in the wind. You haven’t seen many human smiles, but this is certainly sadness in the shape of one. {The dialect of sand is my native tongue.}

The only sound is your wingbeats, and even that is dampened on the massive expanse of sand. It feels wrong to fill the moments after Stormdancer’s song with anything but silence.

This is a strange human indeed. He has Stormdancer’s gift, but he speaks, and he listens. But what drove him this far into the desert? What does he seek? And what has he found?

Strangers to the desert may not understand what makes it so strange, not at first glance. It takes hours, days even, to see: the sands shift with time. Imperfections are buried. If you do not know where to look, you will lose yourself. This human looks everywhere but forward.

{Why does understanding our tongue make you sad?} you ask finally. If you must break the silence you may as well do it with a question. {It is a great gift. Many humans would be jealous.}

{Do you think they would? I find that many humans already think they have this gift. They listen and think this precludes them from understanding.}

You don’t quite know how to answer that.

The human continues: {When I set out, everything seemed so simple, so black and white. But the more I speak to humans and pokémon, the more I realize they are both afraid to change. My voice alone cannot convince them. I wonder if a better human might be able to do more; or perhaps if a pokémon with the power of Voice might’ve been a better messenger than a human with the ability to listen.}

You still momentarily. {You dislike the way things are.}

He doesn’t understand what you’re saying—you can tell that immediately, because he answers, {It saddens me that we make pokémon fight, yes.}

Fight. You’ve seen what these humans and their pocketspheres call fighting. It does not strike fear in you. These battles, at least, are survivable. No longer do they call fire and thunder as they once did. These fights do not leave scars in the earth that will last for a thousand years. {My kind have not been forged since the Great War,} you reply evenly. It’s an empty statement, but one that you don’t fully know how to express. There is a story for this, perhaps. If you could but remember it.

Perhaps, despite himself, he adds, {Humans have changed since the sigilyph were forged. At first you were the only ones we made to fight. But now we think that is the purpose of all pokémon.}

Your purpose.

You were forged for a war. You know that much. They painted you with their colors, but they shaped you with their hands. And the shape they gave for you was one for violence. You had eyes, to take in the battle. Wings, to fly above. A great magic, sealed within you, to unleash in rippling waves on the unprepared.

But the war came and went, and all those who started it went as well, but you stayed. Without the war, what purpose would your Red have given you?

And with the war, if that was all you had, what would you become instead?

Perhaps as if to answer your question, your gaze drifts northward, to the crumbling ruins of a desert tower in the sand.

{I have heard your ending before,} you tell this human at last. {It was a sad one, then and now.}

{As a child I thought it was a pokémon who sought to steal Meloetta’s gift,} he admits, sounding almost ashamed. {But as I grew older I realized it could have only been a human.}

An interesting assumption, one you never would have made. You were shaped with many purposes, but the one you wanted most of all was a mouth. They forged you for a purpose, but that purpose was not to speak. If you could steal his Voice by simply tearing out his throat, wouldn’t you? Wouldn’t anyone?

While you consider, his mind goes in a different direction. He blinks against the stinging wind. {Do you think she knew?} he asks quietly.

{Knew?}

{When she was the first to invoke the nocturne lament. Do you think she knew what it would come to mean?} The questions spill from him with the force of having been pent-up for centuries. This strange one carries the sandstorm inside of him. {Stormdancer gave her greatest gift to help those who would never understand the true weight of her sacrifice, what it would one day cost her to share her Voice with those who envied her gift. And she helped a lot of people, yes, but do you think she knew how much it would hurt her?} You watch. He swallows nervously. Looks off into the distance. {And if she knew, do you think she would’ve done it anyway? Or would she have held her tongue, and simply watched the human suffer?}

You can sense the second question buried beneath his words, archaic and imposing, a relic in the sands. He is one with the gift of voice. Should he share his words with those who would sooner tear out his throat than hear his wish?

He is quiet for a long while. As are you.

You feel rather than hear a tremor run through the sands, something stirring deep below, a rumbling so ancient and powerful that it could only have one source—

What he asks is a pure ideal. If there is such thing as sacrifice, if a gift can be given with the understanding that nothing will come out of it. And it is in understanding this gift that you know what answer you can give him, even if you know it will take him time and more time to understand it.

You know. Gentle hands shaped you, once. Gave you form. Drenched you in red. They gave you a great gift, and you gave them one in return. But neither of you ever asked or took, only gave.

{We have our two endings to the story,} you tell him quietly. {In mine, Stormdancer sang for the humans, as she did in yours. But her ending was much the same. As she sang, her Voice poured out of her and into Human; the light faded, and her magic left her. On her final pirouette, she no longer had her voice; by the time Human left her to face the world, she could only dance. From that moment on, she was still Stormdancer, but a part of her was diminished, just like her mother. Without her Voice, she faded from our world and was swallowed by time.

{In both of our stories she lost a part of herself. But which is truth? I have seen two thousand years and I could not tell you which is which.} You look at him and his sad smile. {I prefer to think she knew, and gave of herself anyway. Stormdancer had two gifts, after all. From her the humans received their voice, and with it the power to be heard by all. But to pokémon she gave the nocturne lament, and with it the strength to see things through to their bitter end, to protect those who cannot protect themselves. Her words carry great power—across all of Unova, no matter what language we speak, every pokémon can recognize the nocturne lament, and we know what it calls us to do, and what will become of those who steel the courage to invoke it.}

Your singular eye blinks once. You think of the day that you first heard the dragons roar. You survived. You stayed. You were forged for a war, but it wasn’t duty that held you there. You remained for your Red, and you remained every day after that.

The human nods, but he doesn’t look convinced. {That was the mistake the king made. Stormdancer’s magic was not in her throat, but in her voice,} he replies softly.

The tremor stills. Unaware, perhaps, the human does as well.

Perhaps unintentionally, he has betrayed his thoughts. He cannot fathom a world in which Stormdancer would choose to give of herself; the only one he could believe in is the one in which her gift was taken from her.

So you tell him what you learned then, what kept you going even after your red vanished into the desert sands. {When you love someone more than you love yourself, you give it power over you. Whether Stormandancer sang until her voice grew ragged and her gift flowed out of her, or whether the humans one day crept up and stole her song for themselves—I think she knew what her fate would be. The truth is she did not care what it would cost her, and not caring destroyed her. That was the price she paid for us to receive of her gifts.}

The green-haired human goes completely motionless, and it is when he stands still that you sense it fully: a sandstorm rages within him, so great that he will consume the whole world, forge it anew. His hands are practiced, calloused, careful, gentle—he will shape this world, surely, someday.

He is young, though, and it will take him time. He is too wrapped up in questions of purpose, of being. If Stormdancer meant to do this. If you were meant for war. If he is meant for a destiny beyond his comprehension.

There is a reassurance to be found in decisions made beyond your control. You know why he would prefer the ending where Stormdancer’s voice was stolen alongside her choice. It is simpler sometimes to imagine that the world that shaped you is stronger than you, that the form you are forged into must determine your life.

After the war, you became the loresinger. You decided it for yourself, without your Red, because that was who you wanted to be.

So you ask him a question to see which one he will offer in response, a tradition from long ago. {The dragon who told you of Stormdancer. What did he tell you happened to the Dragonmother when she rose from her stony slumber?}

{She was sundered by a pair of selfish humans,} he answers immediately. {Two irreconcilable creatures arose from her stony form, and they have never touched since.}

{Like you,} you say, {I have heard a different ending. Again, I do not know which is truth and which is imagination. Would you permit me to share it?}

{Of course.}

{The Dragonmother was lonely. When she next awoke, she saw that all of her children had grown away from her, and she walked the world without equal. The earth’s children love their mother, but she has strength that cannot be matched: where she wanted companions, they saw only a goddess. She chose to divide herself into two, so that there would always be one in the world to understand her. It hurt her greatly. From that day forward she was never her whol self. But from that day forward, she would always have one who could stand beside her. One became two so that two could be like one.}

He looks at you for a very long moment, and when he speaks again, it is the question you wanted him to ask all this time, with his Voice: “Why are you telling me this?”

You look at him, and imagine a voice pouring from the mouth no one saw fit to give you. {Because Stormdancer inherited more from our mother than just her Voice. She took our mother’s burden: to be understood by the world you must give it some of yourself. To shape the world you must accept its contradictions.}

He blinks against the cold wind, and then says, “Do you think that’s why she did it?”

Easier to answer his question with another. {I wonder which you think is most important. Does it matter why Stormdancer’s voice was lost? Or when, or how, or by whom? Or for her, does it merely matter that she no longer has it?} You have seen wars, and death, and time. They will shake you no longer; ever since your Red died, they ceased to hold power over you. Here in the desert, the sands of time became a blur. But you know, as this one is beginning to learn, that the most important questions, the ones that lived through the suns, were always the ones that began with why. These were the questions that became the lore. These were the questions that led you to sing.

This time, he does shiver in the cold wind, in the storm that brews around him. He is strong enough to endure it, to change this land, and yet you know: it will change him as well. That is what the winds always do, even to the tallest rock. “It is a question with no answer,” he says slowly. “She had no choice.”

{She had no choice.} You mull his response over and find you disagree thoroughly. It was in thinking of the Dragonmother that you saw who you wanted to be. She was unsatisfied with herself, how she fit her purpose—so she changed. So you changed as well. Perhaps she was afraid, in that moment before she decided who she wanted to be. Perhaps she didn’t hesitate. You certainly did. {But did that stop her from doing what needed to be done?}

This time, the question makes him flinch. “No.”

You come to a halt in front of him. This child would wander for miles into a desert to find a better ending than the one he was told, but it never occurred to him to tell one of his own. He will find that such answers do not come easily. But if he gets nothing else out of this, he must understand this. {You think questions of why matter less than questions of what. Then allow me to ask you one final question. Have you ever heard the nocturne lament Spoken?}

{Spoken?} His voice lilts on your pronunciation. Not a true native speaker, then.

{Not spoken, but Spoken,} you confirm, and this time he seems to understand the emphasis. {We can retell her words without feeling them, as we can with any words. As I did in my story just now—I spoke. But.} You draw yourself up to your full height, wings outstretched, voice unyielding. {If we understand it. If we mean it. For a brief moment she lives again. She Speaks, and through her, so do we.}

Across the sands, you have seen and heard so much. Yet each time you see Stormdancer’s words given life again, you find it beautiful, and terrifying. Sometimes she is invoked in these words, secreted down across the generations, across the world. Sometimes she only lives on in a gesture, in a cry, a gaze. Yet the intent is unmistakable.

“Her story is a reminder to me that the world only changes through sacrifice. You must embrace the imperfections of the world if you want to shield others from them,” he says softly, after much consideration. But you see that in him the words are inert; they do not spark his torch into flame. The two of you walk a bit further. The zen ones and their domain receded into the night long ago. “But in our stories, Stormdancer and the Dragonmother both got to choose the nature of their sacrifice,” he says at last, refusing to look you in the eye. “And both of them chose to give of themselves. But … if the change I seek requires someone else to sacrifice in my stead—would you still call that sacrifice at all? Would that still be worth the change?”

If you could’ve died in your Red’s place, you would have, without question. But that choice was never offered, and instead your Red chose to die for you, and leave you to endure the sands alone. {I suppose that sacrifice’s worth,} you say levelly, {depends on if you can believe in it.}

Legends say that the Twin Gods draw strength from conviction—but you have always found it such a distinctly odd, distinctly mortal idea that this would be unique. All things draw strength from conviction; all things matter only as much as people think they do. Once you live enough suns and see what sinks, what stays, this simple fact becomes undoubtable.

“You think belief is that powerful?”

{Do you think power is that inevitable?}

The question is out before you can stop it; it was born and lived too quickly for it to be purely rhetorical. But once it hangs in the desert air you can inspect it, and question it, and wonder if you were asking it of him or of yourself.

{In her generosity,} you continue, {Stormdancer was swallowed by time. History is unkind to the voiceless. But across the sands I have heard many stories of Stormdancer and the Dragonmother, from many who wander.} He may be the first human in many suns to trade stories with you, but he is certainly not the first person. {For some, Stormdancer is a great ocean spirit, who at the change of the tides switches skins between a man and an enormous turtle and ferried many people away from the first flood. For others, she is the trickster, who took pity on a human child and taught them how to lie. For others still, she is the bravest of their clan, marked with the stripes of the storm to symbolize how they stand apart from the rest.}

When your Red passed, for a while you had no purpose. Only he could command you to rest. Without him, what could you be instead? The desert winds revealed the answer to your own question of purpose, as they always did. Like a fossil slowly shaking free from layers of sandstone, you came to see the sun again. You are the loresinger. You know the stories, and you pass them to others, so that those who live on in you will live on in others as well.

Stormdancer’s gift to you was a personal one, even if she didn’t know she was giving it: she reminds you that a word is only as important as those who will listen. You were not made to speak, but that does not mean you cannot find your voice on your own, that you cannot recount the voices of others.

{For me, she is the muse,} you conclude. {But which is more important: who she truly was, or who we believe she is?}

You cross the desert sands with him, waiting for him to return your question with one of his own. Night turns to day, and still you receive no response.

No matter. You have the time.



relic song

p | n
 
Last edited:
xv. na-šāyad
cw: depictions of physical abuse, mentions of blood

532MS8.png

xv. na-šāyad

※​

Your father told you this once—if you wanted to get strong enough to make something worth anything, you would need a human. That’s simply the way it is. You can stay in the forest a little while longer if you’d like, but every young timburr needs a human to work alongside. That was how he had achieved the form of conkeldurr, and so had his father, and his father’s father before him. Pokémon needed humans to unlock their true potential.

You remember looking up at his fists, each one big enough to cup your entire head. Thick tendons twined around the well-used muscles of his arms. He had grown strong. His human had gotten him there. One day, you would too. And that day is today.

So! Your father guides you to the shallower parts of the forest, and you watch the trainers go by.

{This one would be nice,} he notes, pointing.

Your nose crinkles. This human is old, hunched over. She has a piece of timber of her own, a tiny one, that she uses to guide her as she walks. It’s a respectable effort, you can’t help but think. There’s a weariness in her shoulders that reminds you of your own grandmother.

But … if you wanted your grandmother, you could just ask her. You shake your head.

Your father is silent while the two of you watch three more trainers go past. Finally, he rumbles, {This one looks kind.}

This one has green hair, the tail of a purrloin fluttering down his neck like a bright ribbon. He and the purrloin seem engaged in a deep conversation.

But he wanders slowly down the path. Far too slowly.

{He looks lost,} you remark.

Your father tilts his head; his knuckles shift on the surface of his beam. {That is a fair assessment.}

By afternoon, you see the one you want. A young human boy—a timber of his own in his hand, which he uses to swat the grasses out of the way.

{I want this one,} you tell your father.

{That one?} He pauses and considers carefully. {He does not look kind. See how he hits the forest, because he does not believe it would hit him back.}

You turn back. The human looks young, which you respect; he will understand what it means to want to prove himself.

{I want this one,} you repeat.

Your father nods. {Very well. I respect your choice.} Another pause. Then, he holds his hand up, and says in a low voice, {Return to me when you are this tall, and teach me what you have learned.}

{I will,} you promise.

You don’t look back. Instead, you run in front of him, and allow him to catch you without a fight. And just like that, you’ve made it. You finally got yourself a human partner. You hope you’ve got a good one.

You blink as the red light fades from your eyes. This must be a human settlement. There are other humans milling around. Towards the back of a room, an audino and a human clothed in pink are hurrying back and forth between a strange machine and a counter. There’s another human standing at a table with an array of objects in front of him (her? it? you’re so bad at figuring out with the humans), shouting numbers.

And! There’s your human in front of you! It’s finally your turn to prove yourself. You will help him do a great many things. When you watched him from afar you only got the details—he has black hair, and he’s shorter than you imagined humans would be, probably because of his age. Up close, his hands are uncalloused—they remind you of yours when you were younger, still too young to practice swinging a proper bough.

You straighten your back. Chin up. You have to impress! {Hello! My name is Samson!}

“I’m Tim,” says your new human. “Your name is Charlie.”

That isn’t quite a pronunciation you’ve heard before. {Samson,} you repeat. A little slower, for emphasis.

“I’m trying to beat Lenora,” Tim explains. He doesn’t quite talk as slowly as you’d like, so it’s a little hard to figure out what he’s saying. Who’s Lenora? “Her herdier is really tough. Pushed my tympole’s shit in last time. So you’re my secret weapon, got it?”

You tilt your head a little. That one is a little hard to parse. Secret? Weapon? You glance down at the bough in your hands. It was the biggest one you could carry, and even so, you struggle with its weight. Your father could lift it with one hand. When you can do the same, you’ll be ready.

But it’s not a secret. Never a secret. Your bough is a symbol for all the world to see. You hold it high, even though your limbs shake a little, and proclaim your agreement. {I will help you, with all the strength I have.}

“Well, not secret. Maybe if I walk up with you she’ll just forfeit.” But he’s already turning away. “Come on, my gym match is scheduled in fifteen minutes. We gotta hurry. If Pinwheel Forest wasn’t such a damn maze I wouldn’t be late.”

You hurry after him. The city is interesting. It’s your first time in a human city; your father always told you to stay away from this city until you were older. You take in every detail that you can so that you can explain it all back to him and tell him what you’ve learned. There are many more sights and sounds than you’ve seen in the forest. Mostly humans on the path, which is wider than any path you’ve ever seen. They’ve got a strange ground-covering here that’s simultaneously smooth and rough on your feet. The most amazing thing about this place are the sounds—people chattering everywhere. You can’t quite catch the human conversation passing by you (they speak quite fast), but there’s a pair of pidove overhead discussing the wind patterns, a purrloin calling out mockingly to a lillipup as she turns tail and climbs nimbly up a gutter.

It’s a nice town that he lives in, you remark to him. Very good architecture. The craftsmen is impeccable, and—he’s already ahead of you. You hurry to catch up.

The gym is the building that’s important to your human, you gather, and you approach it at his side. At first, you think that it’s just the strange designs on the sides of the building extending into the decorations on the ground, but as you get closer, you see that they aren’t decorations at all—they’re people! They seem to be lying on the ground, humans and pokémon alike, scattered all around the entrance to the gym. You can’t help but stare.

“C’mon, Charlie,” Tim says. You’re too short for him to reach his hand, but he grabs the top of your beam and drags you forward.

You almost stumble in shock—he doesn’t realize the disrespect, you have to tell yourself quickly. He doesn’t understand what’s being said when he lifts your load as if you aren’t strong enough to carry it yourself. {I’m strong enough,} you reassure him, and raise your bough out of his reach.

In front of the one closest to you is a sign. Your father taught you how to read human when you were young, swapped his cement for a stick that was dwarfed by his enormous hands and carved each letter into the soft dirt after a spring rain washed over the forest. It was slow work, but deeply important, he’d said. If you ever wanted to work for a human, help them shape great things, you would have to understand their drawings as well as their voices.

This was what your family did, he’d told you. You had big hands and strong arms to shape and build. He’d put together many a home for humans and pokémon alike, and finally, when the time had come—he and his human both put away their tools and put themselves towards raising families instead of buildings. His human still comes to visit sometimes, a burly man whose hair has turned grey.

You struggle to remember the lessons your father gave you. It’s a little hard, but luckily the font on the sign is clear. You’re fortunate that it’s written in such big, blocky letters.

THE EARTH’S CHILDREN SHARE ONE BODY,

You almost forget that Tim’s there at all. You stop short again. Behind the sign, there’s a human sprawled out on the ground next to her venipede, who’s lying on his back, legs straight up in the air. If they were curled you would’ve thought he was dead for sure. You peer closer. The venipede is hard to tell, since the carapace is so still, but the human has a rise and fall in her chest.

{Are you hurt?} you ask. {Do you need help?}

“Charlie,” Tim says, a bit more sharply this time. “Ignore them. They’re faking to get attention. Plasma’s always up to no good.”

Plasma?

But you keep walking. Your first gym awaits. This is where you get to prove yourself! You will become stronger, so strong that you can carry the whole world on your shoulders. Like your father, and his father before him.

The next sign almost catches you by surprise.

FOR WE WERE ALL SHAPED FROM THE SAME CLAY.

Oh! It’s a continuation of the first sentence. They’re all saying something together. That’s nice of them. This sign is in front of a boy, younger than Tim, who’s lying facedown with his limbs sprawled in a tangled heap around them. Beside him is a pidove, who isn’t doing quite as good of a job at acting as the venipede—you can definitely see her blink a few times.

But it doesn’t answer your question. Why are they acting?

Tim’s shouting at you, and you have to tear your eyes away from them again. Why are they all lying on the ground like this? You barely register what he’s saying, but you catch the last bit “—seriously, if you keep this up, I’ll recall you.”

Oh, that’s no good. You want to be on your own two feet when you enter the gym. How weak would you be if you had to be carried into your own trial? You hurry after him, but you peer over your shoulder.

WHEN THIS LIFE WE SHARE CAUSES WOUNDS TO ONE,

Wounds? You ponder the wording absently. Strange choice of words. Perhaps the translation is different in human.

Oh! Maybe it’s a performance of sorts. There were some in the forest who enjoyed playing pretend, but you were always interested in other things. You glance back at the pidove, who blinks as she stares at you with wide eyes. If it’s a performance, she’s not doing a really good job.

You pass by the pokémon and human pair by the next sign, and the blocky letters make themselves clear to you before you can stop yourself. Tim wouldn’t want you to read. He’s certainly trying not to. His hood is up over his eyes and he’s got his head down, hands in his pockets, everything.

THAT HURT ACROSS THE WHOLE BODY IS KNOWN.

You’ll be quick about it, you decide. {What is this?}

The pokémon by this sign is also a pidove. {It’s a faint-in,} she trills nervously.

{A what?} At first you aren’t sure if you heard correctly.

{A faint-in,} the pidove repeats again, which answers one of your questions but not the other. {It’s a protest against gyms.}

Against gyms? You look at Tim nervously, and then at the timber in your own hands. Why protest? You have a million questions now, but you can’t let Tim see that you’re slowing down, or else he’ll yell again.

Is that? Blood?

No, you realize as you get closer. You can’t smell the iron, only chemicals. It’s just red paint, splattered around on the grass where the human is lying. Next to him is the small form of a herdier. You almost mistook it for something else; the red paint changed his coloration so much that you can barely see the navy and tan beneath.

“Pretentious jackasses,” Tim mutters under his breath as you pass by the pidove and his owner. “Always sticking their noses everywhere.” He glares at the human nearest to him, who is lying on his side and curled in a fetal position, and calls in a louder voice, “It’s illegal to be out here, dipshit. I’ll call the cops.”

“The grounds outside of a gym are public property, which are legal and protected grounds for protest,” the boy recites, without opening his eyes, and then falls silent again.

Tim mutters something foul under his breath and makes a motion with his foot as if to kick, but seems to catch himself instead. He wrenches at your bough again. “Come on. They aren’t going to scare us with a little fake blood.”

You’re still confused about that bit, actually. {Why is there fake blood?} you ask, but he doesn’t answer.

There’s some at the next sign too, and this time both the human and the purrloin next to him have covered themselves in it.

YOU, WHO CLOSES YOUR HEART TO YOUR BROTHER’S PAIN—

You have to be quick about it now. But you’re ready this time! {Why are you protesting gyms?}

The purrloin’s ears prick up. The rest of her does not move, but she whispers, {Because they make us hurt.}

Hurt? That can’t be true. You think of your father and his human, how the human comes to visit and they sit and watch the river and the trees. Tim wouldn’t do that to you, not without good reason. You fumble over your next question, and it costs you precious time—you’re almost to the doors of the gym now. {The gyms make you hurt?} you manage to stammer out.

The purrloin’s answer is quiet, but as steady as concrete. {The trainers do.}

{Why? How do they make you hurt?}

Tim wrenches open the door to the gym.

Almost imperceptibly, the purrloin flicks her tail towards the last sign.

YOU ARE UNWORTHY OF THE NAME OF MAN.

The door slams shut behind you.

※​

Lenora is taller than Tim.

That’s the first thing you notice about her. What had Tim said about her? She was a book person. Not a traveler, not a builder. He’d said it disparagingly, but you weren’t sure what that meant or where the shame came from. Your father was all three—he had his books, his travel, and his building. But from his general disdain for her you’d expected someone weak, inexperienced—but she seems confident, imposing. You haven’t seen many humans before, but it looks like her forearms are more corded than Tim’s.

This is good, you decide. You can’t prove yourself to an unworthy opponent.

“Back so soon?” she asks, one hand on her hip. An easy smile is stretched across her face. She flicks her chin in your direction. “Hope you trained that timburr, kid. You aren’t the first to go to Pinwheel Forest and come back with the first fighting-type that showed up.”

He doesn’t answer her taunts. Instead, he rolls his eyes and says, “One versus one?”

She raises an eyebrow, and then snorts derisively. “Two versus two.”

Something about the room changes. Lights seem to swivel down out of nowhere, and when you look down you realize that you’ve been standing with Tim in the middle of a large, perfectly rectangular patch of dirt. There’s a line across the middle, lines snaking down the sides. Tim moves back, and you turn to follow him, but he hisses, “Charlie, stay put.” Oh. Okay. So you do, and tilt your head around to look at the rest of the room. It has nice construction. The lighting hits it in all the right ways; the wooden beams in the ceiling lost their scent of pine long ago, but they stand strong.

“Challenger Burr vs Gym Leader Lenora shall commence!” shouts a voice, and you squint up in surprise to see a third human standing nearly directly between you and Lenora, a strange silvery device held up to his face. “Both sides shall use two pokémon. Standard knockout rules apply. The challenger is to send first.”

You glance back. Tim’s the challenger, and you’re the send. You know how this works. You’ll spar, and you’ve been practicing for this, and you’re strong enough! Soon they’ll all see.

Tim’s got his hands folded across his chest, a smirk carved into his cheeks and the wrinkles between his eyes. “I’m ready. Your move, Lenora.”

You spin back forward to look at Lenora. “Petra,” she says curtly, and tosses something into the air. You watch it arc into a blur of red and white, and a watchog emerges, tail flicking urgently like it’s keeping time. Her stripes glow yellow once, alongside her eyes, and then she falls perfectly still, ears cocked.

{Hi, Petra,} you say nervously. {Nice to meet you.}

The watchog tilts her head. Her fur is the same color as the paint the protestors were using outside. {First time?} she asks quietly.

{How’d you know?}

“Stop them in their tracks. Hypnosis, Petra!”

Petra leaps into all fours and begins darting around you in tight circles. {What other pokémon does your trainer have?}

You’re so surprised you answer on reflex. {Me. And a tympole. I think. But Tim says they’re not good at fighting. I haven’t met them.}

{Oh, that one again. Back so soon,} says the watchog, her eyes fixed not on you but on Tim behind you. She almost sounds sad. {Listen. That tympole is terrified and you can’t take two of us alone. I’ll go easy on you. Mig and Lenora will not. Save your strength.} The yellow rings of fur around her body begin to glow again, and your eyes are inexplicably drawn to the way that the light chases down her body from stripe to stripe. {Look away. My attack will stop in five seconds. Look away, and then do whatever your trainer tells you. You’ll be okay. You can do this.}

“Dodge it, Charlie, and then use Low Sweep!” Tim shouts.

You don’t run forward right away. Instead, you stare at your branch and count to five. The translation of his command is something you’ve never heard before, but it’s easy enough to understand. You’ve just … never done it to an unarmed person before. This watchog is small. Her limbs could not carry a weapon. You’ve only ever sparred with those who carry boughs. She cannot deflect. What will she do instead?

“Come on, Charlie!”

When you look up, she’s done flashing. You walk up to her slowly. You’re supposed to attack now. It’s your turn.

{Hurry,} Petra says urgently. {Lenora isn’t going to hold back. Neither should you. I’ll be fine. I can take it.} She’s standing still, front paws raised, stance wide and easy to disrupt. It’s inviting, almost.

You swing your bough experimentally. You’re almost not used to hitting a living target; you haven’t sparred anyone but your father, and even then, you weren’t trying to hit very hard.

She’s not your father. Her muscles have not grown rigid like stone. Instead, the air leaves her body in a whumph, and you feel something crack. She was lighter than you’d expected. Petra arcs through the air and hits the ground. There’s another crunch when she makes impact with the floor of the gym, and then it’s quiet.

You can’t help it. You scream. {Someone help her!} You look up at Lenora, who’s still got her arms folded across her chest. You look over your shoulder. There’s Tim, who’s cheering you on. {She’s hurt!} You run over to Petra, who’s limp on the gym floor. {Hey! Are you okay?}

“Lenora’s watchog is down. Eight, seven, six—”

{Petra?!}

There’s no blood, real or fake. Or maybe the fur covers up the color. She doesn’t answer.

“Petra, come on! Get up!”

“Charlie, finish it off!”

You can’t you can’t you can’t

“Three, two, one! Knockout!”

You don’t have to. There’s a flash of red light, and she dematerializes.

“Migaloo! Your turn! Hit ‘em hard with Retaliate!”

Lenora holds out a pokéball in front of her, and her second pokémon emerges. You recognize her as a herdier. Like Petra before her, she’s perfectly still when she appears on the battlefield, but unlike Petra, you can see it already—beneath the tawny fur of her legs are tensed muscles; the navy fur running down her back bristles—she’s ready to fight. Uneasily, you plant your bough into the ground. Petra said she wouldn’t hesitate. But even though you know you’re supposed to be preparing, you can’t shake the image of her crumpled in a heap from your eyelids; it’s like it’s built there in wood and iron and stone. Dimly you hear Tim shouting at you, but you can’t make out the words. You square your shoulders, spread your feet a little further apart. It’s hard. The dirt here is firm, too solid for you to plant your bough. You won’t get a good—

There isn’t another warning. You and Tim aren’t ready. Migaloo leaps into the air, each leap clearing five feet at a time, and in an instant she’s removed the space within you and slams into you head-on.

You and your bough go flying back, but Migaloo was smart: she hit you in the head, not your feet, so your momentum sends you straight down instead of arcing up.

There isn’t time. You hit the ground so hard your vision sparks black and white. There’s pain first in your back, and then in your head, and then all over as each part of your body hits the ground in turn. But what worries you most of all is the way that your bough tumbles out of your hands. No! You can’t let it fall, not here, not when you have to prove yourself.

“Charlie! Get up!” Tim commands.

You’re staring straight up at the fluorescent lights of the gym. They wash over your vision, but there’s patches in it; something really, really hurts in the back of your head, where neck and skull meet. Why does it hurt so badly?

“Charlie!”

Your father, standing strong above you. The corded muscles of his arms stretched taught like stone as he helps you pick out a bough that’s too heavy for you to carry, watches you with pride in his eyes as you struggle against it anyway. This is the way in your family. You have to get up.

“We can’t lose here, Charlie! Come on!”

You have to get up!

“Take Down, Mig!”

You blink. The world is cut in half. A second later you realize it’s because one eye is swollen shut from where you took the herdier’s impact head-on. You can’t see her running towards you, but you can hear her footsteps. You square your shoulders, and then roll to your feet just in time to get a half-split image of her bounding towards you, teeth bared.

Plant your feet. Swing your bough. If you win, the pain won’t stop, but at least there won’t be more of it. Right?

You bat the herdier out of the way. Migaloo goes flying, but you don’t make the same mistake twice. Tim doesn’t need to tell you to follow up quickly. You’re already running up towards where you know she’ll land. By the time she hits the ground with a bone-cracking thud, you’re swinging your bough down again and again and again—

“And that’s a knockout!” says the man with his echoing voice. “Herdier is unable to battle!”

You blink. Your breath comes to you slowly along with your senses. Migaloo’s sprawled out on the ground like the other herdier you saw outside. Still no blood on her, you notice absently, but then—you rub the back of your head from where she slammed you into the ground and it comes back wet, sticky.

You hesitate. Your voice sticks in the back of your throat. You limp heavily on your bough and try to get closer. But not too close, in case it’s a trick. {Are you,} you begin, and then stop. The signs outside. What the purrloin told you. You feel pain all over, but how much of it is for you and how much of it is for her? {I’m sorry,} you say instead. But your words aren’t magic. They can’t heal her or bring her back to consciousness.

Tim’s shouting behind you, exuberant. “Great job, Charlie! We did awesome.”

You. There’s.

You feel sick.

{I don’t want this. I want to go home.} You try to keep your voice firm, but you can’t keep the tears out. You. You don’t want to do this any more. You want to go back to your father, the forest. You’ll get stronger a different way, find a different kind of strength—what this human wants to teach you isn’t what you want to learn.

But he’s chattering something to Lenora, not even looking in your direction as he holds something red up and points it at you, and your world dissolves.

The gym is gone. The people in front of it are gone. You’re grateful that you don’t have to see them on the way out. You think the purrloin would probably stare daggers at you and your bruises, at the real blood on your face that doesn’t look anything like the fake blood on hers.

In this strange intermediary space, you don’t feel your own body, your own pain. You just float. It’s peaceful, in a way.

You don’t feel your own pain, your hands have no form, but you can’t unfeel the sensation of the impacts—when Petra had crumpled under your bough, when Mig slammed into your head, when you smashed her into the ground in retaliation. Those feel as real as anything.

※​

When you materialize again you’re screaming.

{Hey, hey, calm down,} one of the audino is saying, a matrix of pink energy already fizzling in her hands. {Everyone gets hurt in battles from time to time. You’re going to be okay.}

She presses her hands to the back of your head, and the pain tapers off and then numbs. You reach up to touch it—for a moment you’re convinced that she’s simply removed your neck entirely—but you feel the muscle and skin before she brushes your hand out of the way. {I’m almost done, sweetie,} she says gently, and leaves you to stare at the red crust on your fingertips.

{Is Petra okay?}

{Petra?} She’s dabbing something on the back of your neck now, and even through the numb you can feel the cold liquid dripping down your back. {Is she one of your teammates? I’m sure they’re all fine.}

{No, Petra was …} You struggle to remember. Your mind is going in too many directions at once; like a splintered branch, most of it is going the right way, but there are too many details to keep track of. {She was with Lenora. She got hurt pretty badly. I hurt her pretty badly. I hit her with my bough and she wasn’t ready.}

The audino pauses. {Oh, you’re asking about one of your opponents?} One of the curly feelers beneath her ears wraps around your right arm, and she places both of her hands on your shoulders and looks at you. {Was this your first battle?}

You nod tearfully.

She squeezes your shoulders tightly. {Petra’s going to be fine, just like you are, okay? There’s nothing to worry about.}

{I hurt her,} you confess again, since she must’ve missed it the first time. What would your father say? And then the way that you hit Migaloo again and again, hoping that if you hit her hard enough she’d just do what you wanted and stop hitting you back—

{Shhhhh, sweetie,} the audino says, and for a moment you can almost feel the manufactured calm radiating from her feelers before it’s washed away by your roiling panic. {You feel all better now, right? And I’m sure that they’ve taken Petra to get looked at and she’s feeling just fine too. It’s going to be okay. You’re both going to be fine.}

You reach up to the back of your neck, and the skin there is unbroken, unbloodied. She must’ve wiped it away when you weren’t paying attention. You’re fine. You’re both going to be fine.

{I can pass a message on so my human talks to your trainer,} she says in her soothing, reassuring voice. Has she always talked this slowly? {She’ll make sure he knows that you’re new to this, and ease you into things better. How does that sound?}

That sounds like a good idea. You nod.

{Okay, I’ll do that, and I’ll try to see if Petra’s here as well, okay? You’ll be okay, sweetie.} You can tell she’s distracted; her eyes are already darting around the room. Why? {I have some other patients I need to look at, but I’ll come back and check on you in a little bit, okay? Just sit tight for now.}

Another nod. What else would you do anyway?

And then she’s already sweeping away, muttering under her breath, just a child how could they possibly—

The door swings shut behind her, and you’re left to hug your bough and scoot closer to the wall. The wall. You desperately look at it to distract yourself, does it have nice architecture, who do you think built it? But it’s white, and the paint is fresh and covers up any clue you possibly could’ve gleaned from it.

{First battle?} a voice asks from behind you, and you turn around to see a small blitzle, roughly your height. The bright purple bandage around her front leg clashes brilliantly with her stripes.

{How does everyone know that?}

She shakes the white fur of her mane out in irritation. You can tell she’s itching to put weight on her injured foot by the way she rocks back and forth. {You act very new to this.}

{Is there a different way I’m supposed to act?}

She snorts but doesn’t answer your question.

{I’m Samson,} you say in a small voice.

{I’m Amara, Thundersinger of the Plains.}

You don’t like the tone of her voice, but you want to know. Your father had never mentioned anything like this when he reminisced about his human. Was he just covering up the truth? {So you’ve battled before.}

{Loads of times,} Amara says confidently. {I’m my trainer’s best battler. I’ve helped her win two badges already.}

Wow. That sounds impressive, but you struggle to put into context what a badge even means. {Do … do battles always end up violent?}

{Not if you’re good.}

Her answers for you are short, curt, convinced. She says them with the same practiced air that your father used when he taught you, and there’s something vaguely reassuring in her enunciation—she surely knows these truths deep down if they surface so easily now.

{I don’t like this,} you admit. {I didn’t want this. My father said I would find a partner to grow strong with.}

{This is partnership,} Amara replies in the time it takes her to pace a three-legged circle. {This is strength.}

Migaloo’s bared teeth flash across your mind again, before they’re swatted away by a bough that wasn’t meant to hurt anyone. {It can’t be. I hurt someone.} Another thought strikes you suddenly, and you frown: {Have you won badges without hurting people? Without being hurt?}

The blitzle stamps her foot and flicks her tail. She’s growing irritated, you sense. Perhaps pokémon back here weren’t meant to talk to one another, just like they weren’t meant to talk on the battlefield in the gym—but where were they supposed to talk, then? Where did it matter? {Who did you fight? A gym trainer?}

{Migaloo. And … and Petra.}

The blitzle stares at you expectantly.

{They worked at the gym,} you hazard, and then, when she still says nothing, you add, {They fought for Lenora.}

Her eyes widen and her ears swivel back. {You fought both of Lenora’s pokémon and won? You must be strong.}

You’re going in circles, you realize, watching her continue to pace her lopsided square on the ground. {I’m not—}

Amara pulls up short. {When we fought them, they hurt me. They’re strong. But strong people can’t be hurt. So if you were able to defeat both of them all by yourself …}

She trails off expectantly. Tentatively, you answer, {Then I’m strong?}

{And strong people can’t be hurt,} Amara concludes proudly. {Think about it. Lenora’s pokémon fight all the time. They simply can’t be hurting any more; there’s no way they could bear it. They got better, until they were too good for their pain to really hurt them.}

You rub the back of your neck absentmindedly. It doesn’t even hurt you any more. Her bandage—is it there for show? You realize that at some point in her conversation she’s stopped favoring her good leg and stands on all four of them equally. So it’s fixed then, right? Petra must be feeling better too.

{And besides,} Amara adds, her voice sinking into a conspiratorial whisper after studying the way you pick at your bough for a while. {Only weak people get hurt. I don’t want to be weak. Do you?} You don’t answer and she doesn’t wait for one. {We aren’t like humans. We get stronger when we get hurt. And then we get strong enough that we don’t get hurt.}

This doesn’t feel like anything your father ever told you, all of these questions of hurt intertwined with worth. You know he wooed your mother by stacking stones taller than the oldest pine tree until they formed a spire in her craggly image, with his twin concrete columns at the base. Surely that was strength, lifting all those stones up so carefully, and then even more carefully bringing them down to earth to build the walls that became your home.

You saw your father raise his fists against another precisely once in his life, and it terrified you: a scolipede cantered across your path when you were young. Her eyes were wide and crazed; her spines dripped with poison while her mouth foamed and burbled an unnatural orange. You stared; your father raged across the forest with bellows that shook the trees. But no sooner was he between you than he pulled up short, hands raised but restrained, while the scolipede keened in unparseable fear. They stared at each other; neither of them struck. And then, she shambled away.

Neither of them hurt. Perhaps your father wasn’t strong in that moment, not according to Amara or Tim, but you know at least he was brave.

Your father isn’t here to explain the difference. But the blitzle is. And if she knows so much, maybe she can answer the question the purrloin from before didn’t have time to explain. {Why do we do it this way?}

{We’re fighting for them,} she says simply. {They are too fragile to do it alone, so we help. That’s our duty. And that's what we all want, right? A duty.}

That does make sense. Your father spoke with pride about how he learned to lift blocks of concrete, and enormous steel beams, how one day with enough practice you’d be the same way. A human could never do that alone, not without help from someone very strong. But you think of Petra laid out on the ground, and Migaloo, and all of the humans and pokémon sprawled out around the gym. {Do you … are you proud of your duty, then?}

{To protect my trainer? My partner? Am I proud?} Amara bows her head, her mane sparking fiercely. {More than anything.}

※​

Crack.

The first thing you register is something warm and wet dripping out of your nose. The pain comes shortly after, and then lastly there’s Tim, your trainer, your partner, solidifying in your vision. He’s breathing heavily and the hand he used to strike you is clenched into a fist.

“Embarrass me like that again,” he says coldly, “and losing will be the least of your problems.”



p | n

Chapter title + poem used in this chapter are roughly translated from "Bani Adam".
 
Last edited:
xvi. nepeta
※​

509MS8.png

xvi. nepeta

※​

You run up to the human, careful to show off all your strengths. Lithe, powerful, graceful, nimble.

{Train me,} you command.

You watched her from a distance. Left her gifts you thought she’d enjoy. A potion, for her weaker teammates. A pokéball, for you. You could tell just by looking at her that she needs all the help she can get, but if she gets it, she’ll go far. She’s a fighter, like you. Scrappy, like you. She wants the world, like you. It’s a good match. She just doesn’t know it yet.

She probably doesn’t understand you, but the intent is clear enough. There’s a strange green pokémon with big eyes at her ankles. Smells like grass. Your nose crinkles. She’s got a smug look on her face, like she knows she’s better than you.

(Like she is better than you.)

The human has pulled out her pokédex and is pointing it at you. She’s not even looking at you; she let’s the machine do that for her. That’s fine. You’ll pose for it as well. “Purrloin, huh? Tricky to raise, average offensive prowess, and a few warnings for mischievousness. Oh, and if that’s not ironed out, that could manifest as extreme aggression after evolution. They will disobey trainers they do not respect. Yikes.” She looks down at the simpering, smug one by her feet. “Still, not a dealbreaker. What do you think, Vaselva?”

Oh, she’s asking the plant for an opinion. Did you say simpering, smug? You meant supremely superior. Of course. {Please,} you say in the dialect of forests, even though begging tastes like birdshit on your tongue. {Tell her I want to train with you. She’ll listen to you. I’ll be the best companion.}

You wait, your heart throbbing in your chest.

The green one fluffs up her fronds, clearly annoyed. {Why.} It’s not a question.

You don’t hesitate. {I want to be strong.}

{This is my human. I protect her. You do not.}

That’s fair. What the green one doesn’t know won’t hurt her. {I want to be strong for myself,} you say. And that’s not even a lie. You do mean it. {But being strong means having strength to spare.}

The green one considers. Thoughtful. Yes, she would make a good partner on the field anyway. You’ve picked well. Finally, she shakes her head, and then tugs at her human’s pantleg with her scaled hands. Looks up. Nods.

You’ve done it! You have a human! She will be yours! You will call her something witty, clever. Hummy, perhaps. Brownie? She has the hair for it.

Wait, no. The human is shaking her head. She’s already put the red device away. Still isn’t looking at you. “Sorry, Vaselva. I think we’ll pass. Bianca says there are blitzle in the grass outside of town, and I think that’ll round out your flying weakness better. It’s not worth the risk, and, I mean … we can’t really afford to have extras right now.”

No!

No no no no no!

They’re turning away. You dash around them on all fours, and then skid to a halt, blocking their path. {Train me,} you repeat. {I will be good. I will take care of the birds. I am exceptionally good at taking care of the birds. I will feed myself. No birds will bother your grassy one.}

The snake’s face is carved like a statue. {She said no.}

“Awww, aren’t you the cutest!” says the human. “Do you want a snack?” She’s reaching into her satchel now.

No, you want a trainer; you do not want a—

She pulls out a berry and you salivate immediately. You’re hungry. You’ve been hungry for days. You—

Are eating ravenously.

When you look up, they’re gone.

※​

You’re more careful choosing the next one. The rejection stings. The human you’d chosen didn’t look particularly powerful; she certainly wasn’t that much stronger than you. So for her to say that you weren’t good enough? For her?

She looks like she crawled out of a gutter. Your mother belonged to one of their elites. Her trainer was one of the best in Unova, and she taught all of her moves to you before old age took her. So what does this little human girl know about dealbreakers?

Nothing. She knows nothing, you have to remind yourself. You don’t need that particular human to know you’re worth something. Your mother belonged to one of their elites, until he gambled away his fortune, and his fame couldn’t protect him. He sold the expendables. Her new life wasn’t so bad; the humans who bought her were wealthy and took good care of her. But when she grew out of her prime, they discarded her like an old toy. She scrounged for a new home, and her once-proud head bowed for scraps, which she ferried back to you.

The anger festers, but the message is clear time after time: humans determine your worth in this world. If the little girl who rejected you doesn’t understand your worth yet, you will have to find someone who does. It’s that or go hungry.

So you watch him watch them. He has a strange gait, you decide. He doesn’t walk like a human, all confident and loud. He pads around, always nervous, always gentle, always quiet, as if he knows he doesn’t belong and is trying to draw as little attention to his outsiderness as possible.

He wouldn’t last a day as a purrloin, hunting them so obviously. Even as a kitten you learned how to hide from your prey. And your predators.

But he certainly has the eyes of a hunter. He surveys the other humans with a quiet, withdrawn sort of air. Even watching him carefully, you can’t quite tell if he’s looking at them or if he’s wistfully studying the trees. But he always times his entrances and exits flawlessly; always arrives just in time for the battles before melting seamlessly back into the crowd, as if he was never there to begin with.

Yes. This one will be yours. He doesn’t know it yet, but he will soon.

You leave the oran berry by his hand while he’s sitting on a park bench, even though holding it makes your mouth water, your stomach rumble. You place it where he’ll see it the second he turns around, and then you mold back into the grass behind him, eyes wide as you watch.

It takes him a while. He’s observant, but you are stealthy. When the human children withdraw their pokémon, one battered and the other no longer able to stand, he shifts his weight and almost crushes your offering. You watch as he turns, looks at the palm of his hand, and pulls the berry up closer to his face. He doesn’t smell it for ripeness, fool that he is, but he turns it over in his hands, runs one finger over the ring of bite marks from where you held it in your teeth.

He bares his own teeth in amusement—the smile seems genuine. He looks around, almost guilty, almost amused, and, when he fails to notice you through your perfect stealth, he shrugs and deftly begins to peel it.

Excellent. You are bonded for life now.

When he gets up to leave, you linger, watching. You pad over to the spot on the bench he had occupied, which still is faint with his warmth, and as you leap onto the slats, you realize that he’s left precisely half of the oran.

You are too hungry to hunt him down and question him for his disrespect, so you eat it instead.

※​

You deposit the second gift while he’s alone.

You sort of have to, you see. It’s not by choice. You’d much rather give it to him where he and everyone else with eyes can see what a good hunter you are, to bring him so many gifts. Then everyone will have no choice but to be amazed at your prowess, and they’ll all be jealous. Everyone wins.

But. The bird is quite loud. It squawks periodically, and then falls silent, as if it’s forgotten that it wants to be obnoxious. And then it remembers, and it’s shrill calls echo again. So you’re stuck with the unsavory task of half-walking, half-dragging it through the streets until he’s alone, staring over the railing into the depths of the Forest of Pinwheels.

What does he see out there? He still hasn’t fought, or battled, or done anything in this strange town except watch. You’re beginning to wonder if you made the wrong choice.

No. You would never make the wrong choice.

You deposit the broken-winged pidove on the steps behind him. You’ll leave him with the honor of finishing it off. He is a frail one. You are the better hunter. And now you can make good on your promise: no birds will bother him, or any of the others he seeks to protect. You curl up around the balcony railing and blend into the shadows.

He turns around at the low coo of the pidove. His eyes rove across the observatory deck, at first too high, and then he sees the bird slumped in a pathetic pile of grey feathers. He gasps, and rushes towards it—

Good! He’s seen your gift!

—“What? Who hurt you like this? Oh, no, you poor thing.” He’s got his hands hovering a solid foot away from the pidove in either direction, seemingly torn on if he should try to move it or leave it be.

Ugh. He pulls out a pokéball and catches the stupid thing, hopefully so he can eat it later. Is he really going to waste his time with one of those?

He hurries off to the pokécenter, and you’re left following after him.

※​

You look for the third gift while he’s standing in the midst of a crowd. Hunting, probably. He blends in with the rest of the humans if you don’t know where to look.

He is the distracted type. You see him fiddling with the collars on his wrists constantly, twisting them in golden spirals up and down his forearms. Where does he go, when his eyes wander far away? He certainly isn’t seeing this world.

There is a child with a fidget-cube. Her fingers are too chubby to manipulate it properly; she’s too young for it. That’s what you tell yourself, at least, when you approach her. All fluff and smiles, something big and purple and colorful to look at, and when she throws her arms around you, you endure it. One moment, maybe two.

Yes, this is all part of your plan. She has to hug you for at least five seconds. Or ten. Yes, when she’s nuzzling her head into your neck, mixing strands of her hair with your fur. This is part of your devious plan as well. She has to get her guard fully down, this miniature human, or else you’ll never succeed. Absolutely.

“Purr! Purr!” she says, an utter butchering of your name. Despicable. How can you stand her, the way she squeezes too tightly, lets her warmth and love bleed into yours? Thank goodness you’re so strong.

“Riley!”

Oh no. Big human.

You look up guiltily. The big human has business clothes on; you recognize the flappy bit of fabric around his neck as plumage that only the adults have. On his face is carved a scowl, also the kind that only the adults have. “Riley! Get away from that!”

No no no, you’re friendly, you aren’t going to—

He swats you off with open palms, and then with gentle hands picks up the small one.

You hiss, puff up your fur defensively at the smarting blow, but he’s already hoisting the mini human onto his hip. “See, Riley? You can’t play with strays. They’ll always show their true colors.”

No! That’s … he … you didn’t start this! He did.

The mini human dropped her toy when the big one picked her up. So you do the only sensible thing and steal it, and then run away, and then very gently deposit it at your future human’s feet.

{Train me,} you yowl, and your persistence is rewarded when he turns around and looks at you with a warm smile.

You wait for him to send out a pokémon, to attack you. Something, anything at all. You need to prove yourself. You won’t make the same mistakes as before. You’ll win this time. He’s already accepted your gifts, so he is caught deep, deep in your cunning traps.

“Hello. My name is N. I’m travelling across Unova,” he says instead. Crouches down so that his eyes are on your level. You back up instinctively before you remember to be brave.

{Train. Me.} You keep the words simple. Mewl alongside them for emphasis. Maybe he’ll hear the question in it.

“Yes,” he says. “That too. Only if you want to.”

What a silly, silly trainer he’ll make. Of course you want to fight. Why else would you seek out a human? {I will fight for you. Loyally, and without fail. I promise that.}

“Oh?” He chuckles at that one.

You arch your back. You aren’t to be laughed at. You are better than this. You huff, turn to leave. You’ll find another human, and then he’ll see. You’re three steps into your dramatic walk away when you realize he isn’t stopping you. {You’re just going to let me leave?} you mewl over your shoulder. {What, a purrloin isn’t good enough for you? Too common?}

“No. I would be honored.” Long pause. “If that’s what you want.”

He’s lying, even if he doesn’t know it. No human is honored like this for long. New pokémon are prizes to be won, interesting at first and then lackluster if they can’t prove their worth. You’ll lose his fascination and he’ll put you up on a shelf when you start losing. You know this. Your mother knew this, and taught you all too well—she was a trainer’s pokémon once, until she wasn’t.

You won’t make the same mistakes. You won’t be useless.

{Train me,} you repeat, and your heart almost bursts from pride when he extends his hand.

※​

N talks to you more than you thought a trainer would. He has too many questions—where are you from? what’s your name? what interests you in battling? am I talking too fast?—and at first you think it’s part of a test, so you answer him honestly. Accumula. Tourmaline. Strength. Yes, absolutely, do you ever stop?

(The last one you don’t say out loud.)

Slowly he peters off, when he seems to pick up that you aren’t really into it. You aren’t here for the chitchat. You’re here for the magical part where humans make you stronger than you could’ve been on your own. And if he thinks this interrogation will help, you’ll give it a try, but otherwise … you can’t get distracted.

You’re immediately distracted when you see her again.

{That girl,} you say, tugging on the collar of his shirt. You’re curled around his neck like a purple scarf, tail fluttering down his back. {I want to fight her.}

“You want to battle? I, um.” He stumbles over the words. “I don’t know how.”

{What do you mean, you don’t know how? You’re a human. All humans know how to fight.} You alight from his shoulders and land smoothly on the ground. You yowl to the girl and her green one. {Hey. Fight me.}

The green one looks up in alarm. {You again?}

{I got my own human,} you say, gesturing smugly with your tail. {He will make me strong. I will fight you now.}

{Hilda would’ve made you strong, too.}

{Hilda,} you say, the new name stretching your mouth into impossible shapes, {didn’t want me.}

{Don’t get mad that she was too busy training me. That’s not her fault.}

“You guys want a battle?” her human says, and yours gives a sort of strained grunt.

“Alright, Vaselva, let’s do this,” says the Hilda. She puts her hands on her hips like she’s analyzing the situation carefully. Silly. She should be more like your human, who isn’t staring at the opponent at all. “Vine Whip.”

The snivy nods, and then extends two thorny fronds from her backside—where was she keeping those??—and launching them towards you. You narrowly twist out of the way of the first one, but the second one hems you in from the other side, smacking you upside the face before you can duck.

The first impact doesn’t hurt that badly. But the vine hits you hard enough to throw you to the ground, and the ground is harder than the vine, and your eyes are full of stars for a moment when your head hits the concrete of the street. You whine in alarm before you can stop yourself. You can’t look bad in front of them.

You’d watched humans watch these all the time. The pokémon there weren’t crying out in pain, although surely it must’ve hurt just as badly. Were they just stronger than you? Desensitized to it? Your mother said that when she was on the circuit, she’d just moved all the bits of her that she thought were soft and delicate and hidden them deep in her chest. {Which is where I hid you, Tourmaline, my love,} she’d whispered, nudging you with her nose. {So you wouldn’t be hurt.}

Hide them away. It’s your turn now. You pull yourself up, feel N’s concerned gaze burning into your back. {I’m fine,} you hiss back, an answer to his unspoken question. If he thinks you’re weak he’ll throw you to the side. If she thinks you’re weak she’ll know she was right to. {Tell me what to do.}

“I don’t know!” He sounds truly desperate.

You file him out as background noise for the moment and study the snake. Her vines have a predictable attack pattern to them. Left, right, left. There’s an arc and a sway that they all share; she hasn’t yet had her human point that out to her and train her out of it. You duck under the first, and then start running headlong in. The vines chase you, but you’re moving fast—they don’t retract as quickly as they extend. You get in close, and you rake your claws across her face. She manages to close her eyes and shy away just in time to protect those big, ruby eyes from the worst of it, but drops of red start sneaking down her face. She screams. You go in again. And again. Your claws ache under the impact of her skin. She’s got scales, and they’re still soft, not yet battle-hardened, not meant for this, like your claws, but if you can rake fast enough, you’ll win. You have to. Your chest aches and your head throbs and your paws are weary but—

“Vaselva, now! Vine Whip into Slam, like we practiced!”

Her vines are back. You didn’t consider that. She wraps them around you and raises you five feet into the air, prepares to smash you into the cobblestones. And before you can stop yourself, a wordless scream rips from your mouth—

“I forfeit!” shouts your human before she can complete the attack and send you into the ground, to match your shame. “Stop!”

The snake freezes, almost guiltily.

{What are you doing?} you snarl at him as she places you back on the ground. {I almost had her.}

But he’s not looking at you. His breath is coming in short, uneven bursts. He’s reaching into his pocket, pulling out a wad of green paper, counting out a handful, shoving them towards Hilda. “Here. You win.”

And then, in a softer voice, he looks at the snake. Sounds almost hurt. “You … you didn’t even hesitate. Why?”

She looks up at N, one leaf on her tail torn. The fronds around her neck are in disarray, and she shakes them out disdainfully before answering. But she doesn’t meet his eyes. {She told me to. For her and her dreams, I would do anything.}

“But … why?”

Vaselva flicks her tattered tail dismissively, like it’s the most obvious thing in the world. {Because that’s what pokémon are for.}

Your breath is coming in short gasps. Something in your ribcage feels bruised. Your fur is all ruffled. You grit your teeth. This is what you wanted. This is what you want.

“Are you hurt?” he asks, crouching down to look at you. Hilda’s saying something to him, but he doesn’t seem to hear.

{I’m fine.} He can’t know you lost this so badly. He’ll think you’re weak and then you’ll be back at square one.

You picked a strange human, one who can understand pokémon. But he doesn’t listen, so he immediately sees the way you’re holding your chest, the gash in your leg from where you hit concrete.

And that’s how you end up glaring at the stupid pidove again in the pokécenter, both of you bandaged up and neither of you in the mood to speak.

※​

The pidove is still quailing in its roost at the pokécenter, but you won’t sit around quietly. You’ll be the most useful member on his team, and then he’ll see. But he doesn’t go near the trainers, even as you follow him resolutely through the streets, down the streets, across the streets. For a while, he’s silent, his hands shoved deeply in his pockets. You imagine a miniature thunderstorm brewing around his shoulders. A few blocks in, he stops and crouches, as if to tie his shoe; though it fills your heart with shame, you accept his offer and perch around his neck. There’s still a dull ache in your legs from the battle, and all this walking isn’t helping anyway.

He must’ve been expecting it, because he doesn’t shoo you off. He doesn’t say anything else though, either.

Accumula is a nice town from up here. This tall, and you can look down on the things that used to seem so big. There’s a street cart with wisps of smoke curling off of the grill, fencing off a man selling hotdogs. He waves when you and N approach. Down the road from him is a pair of humans hogging the sidewalk, but they shuffle to the right so that you and N can pass.

This is what it means to have a human, you remind yourself. None of them would’ve given you the time of day if you’d been alone. This is what you wanted.

“Are you busy this evening, Tourmaline?”

It’s the first thing he’s said to you since you lost, so it must be important. But what a dumb question it is. You’re a pokémon. You’re a pokémon who is now owned by a human. What else would you be doing this evening? But you get the feeling he’ll be disappointed by that answer, so instead you just say, {No.}

“I’m helping my friends try something out and I think you’d enjoy it,” he explains quietly as he pushes open a gate, steering the two of you off of the sidewalk and onto a garden path. “But it’s a little new. Do you like music?”

{Do you?}

He pauses for a moment, like he’s never considered that question. The gravel crunches beneath his feet. “Yes,” he says at last.

So then that settles it. {Yes.}

Something in your voice makes him pause. “Forgive me for asking. Are you just saying that—”

{Yes.}

There’s a long silence.

{Do you want me to see this place or not?} you growl at last, when it’s clear that he isn’t going to be the one to say anything else.

“Well, we’re here already,” N says with a weak laugh, but when you perk your head up to look at him, he isn’t even trying to smile. “So you see it. But the real magic will happen in … soon. I need to help set up. But it’s a performance of sorts. Many of my friends will be there. Do you want to watch?”

What a stupid answer for a stupid question. Perhaps you wasted your gift. No. Not in a million years. Your mother picked a bad human but you haven’t made the same mistake. {I will see this place with you tonight.}

‘This place’ is an empty garden just before sundown, with three humans and a watchog fiddling with some speakers. N’s bad at stealth, so when you and he slip in, all of them turn to wave at him when he enters. “The show will start in an hour,” he says in a quiet explanation that, like most of his statements, doesn’t seem to explain anything at all. He pauses. “If there’s anywhere else you’d like to be.”

You’re a trainer’s pokémon now. Where else would you go? But you don’t have the energy to argue, so you alight from his shoulders and watch them archly from a stool in the corner of the garden, furthest from the stage, your tail flicking.

Humans are strange. They rearrange all of the furniture into a grid shape, and you have to move twice (twice!) until they’ve gotten all the chairs in a layout they’re happy with. The joke is on them though; all of their furniture is so mismatched and slapped together—there’s no way to arrange two dozen chairs that look like they came from two dozen places nicely. At the center they put up a little makeshift stage, and N is fussing with some cords on the ground when the others start to trickle in.

“Oh!” he says, too loudly, and immediately drops what he was holding to run over to the leavanny standing by the garden’s gate. “I’m so glad you could make it, Briselle.” They both fold one hand in front of their chests and bow. “Did you have any trouble finding us?”

{No,} she answers very slowly in the dialect of forests. {Your directions were very good.}

“Do you need any help setting up?”

{No,} she repeats solemnly. {I have brought everything I need. Can I help you with anything?}

“There’s some lights over in the corner I was hoping to hang up before everyone else showed up,” N says, pointing to a tangle of wires, and the leavanny delicately stalks over and begins unpicking them with her leaves.

N and one of the other humans struggle with the lacing of a large banner, its paper crackling as they try to hang it over the stage. You watch with veiled interest; the lettering means nothing to you, but it must surely be important. The watchog scampers from chair to chair, laying a little piece of paper on each one.

When she skips your stool, you hiss, {What are those?}

{They’re for the humans,} she says, and when you look, you can see that they’re all crawling with the same illegible letters. {You can have one if you want,} the watchog adds.

You snatch it from her waiting paws and frown at it, trying to trace over the symbols with your tail. Belatedly, you realize you should’ve asked, What are they for? but she’s out of hissing range and if you shout at her they’ll all see how stupid you are for not knowing. So you curl your tail tightly around your paws and trace over the strange symbols.

“Oh, hey Hilda! Welcome!”

Your head flicks over. No. What’s she doing here?

She looks like she doesn’t know the answer either. One hand fiddles with her hair and she’s shifting her weight back and forth. But it’s the eyes that really give her away—her gaze flicks over every corner of the room, taking it in with rapid precision, analyzing the important bits and storing the information away. Her eyes slide right over you and back to N. “Hi. I hope I’m not too early?”

“You’re right on time!” N says. “Could Vaselva make it?”

Hilda blinks politely. “Pardon?”

N flinches and seems to catch himself. “Oh, pokémon are welcome in this space. If Vaselva would like to join us, we’d love to see her.”

Maybe he would, but—

“And she’s already met Tourmaline, so perhaps they could catch up a bit!”

Before you can interject, the snake is already out of her pokéball, blinking sleepily in the garden light. Your hackles raise immediately. Does he not realize that you don’t fraternize with enemies?

{I’m not talking to her,} you yowl from your perch.

Vaselva calmly shakes out her tail. {Scared?} she asks before N can respond.

Your claws sink into the wood of the stool. {I’d be happy to entertain our guests,} you say frostily to N, and he flashes you a grateful smile.

“Thank you,” he says. “Oh, and Tourmaline, could you save me a seat?”

{Of course,} you promise, and then belatedly realize you’re not sure how to do that. A problem for later; the snake and her human settle in next to you, and of course, Hilda doesn’t sit between you. So you have to glare over the snake’s scaly head to watch Hilda shuffle into her seat and almost sit on the paper on her chair.

But she does notice it, and she begins to read it. You strain to catch the words as she murmurs them under her breath, her forehead creased with a frown—“First performer, Tiallys of the Yarrow Clan, from Lostlorn. He wants to be an idol performer, like Roxie, to catch the attention of his family. Second performer, Brex, from Pinwheel Forest. He usually prefers singing underwater. Third performer, Briselle, also from Pinwheel Forest. When she’s not practicing her harp, she’s working on a leaf-inspired fashion line … what?” She looks around the room, her brow furrowed, but N’s off by the stage messing with a tall light.

{Did N tell your human what this is for?} you ask the snake, while Hilda falls keeps scanning the strange paper, mouthing the words to herself.

{Perhaps, but she didn’t tell me,} Vaselva replies.

There’s a long silence.

{Are you still mad that I won?} she asks.

Not one to mince words, this one. You ignore her under the pretense of grooming at a particularly matted bit of fur under your ear while you search for the right words. {No.}

She stares straight ahead. {You certainly act like it.}

The snake wouldn’t understand. You’ve seen her type before. Bred for battle. It’s not like she ever had to struggle, blessed as she was by her birth to make her someone the humans coveted. Snivy are powerful, uncommon. She probably had everything she ever wanted given to her from the moment she hatched.

{You fought well,} you say instead, your voice stony. {Perhaps we’ll fight again.}

{Perhaps your trainer will be better when we do,} she says primly.

Your mouth is open for a retort when you realize you don’t know what you want to say. It’s not about my trainer; it’s about me—but that’s not true, is it? Hilda was smart, so they won. You could’ve beaten the snake if Hilda hadn’t helped. But it’s not N’s fault that you lost. It’s yours.

Before you can find an answer, more people begin filling in the seats behind and around you. There’s a commotion as some of the chairs have to get rearranged to make room for a venipede, and a human boy tries to take the seat you’re saving for N, so you have to yowl at him until he stops. By the time you turn away from that, Vaselva has nuzzled up against Hilda’s leg, her eyes half-closed as Hilda gently strokes the yellow scales beneath her chin.

When you look at them, it isn’t anger that fills you. That could’ve been you. If you were—

No. You have your own trainer. This is what you wanted.

Someone flicks a light on by the stage, and then the rest of the room goes dark. The hushed chatter fizzles out, and everyone watches as N takes to the stage. You can’t help but lean forward. This is what he wanted you to see, right?

“The—” He flinches back as the microphone in his hand screeches, and when he starts over again he’s careful to keep it further from his face. Which is a problem, because he speaks softly, and you feel the rest of the audience straining in to catch his words. “The performers will be introducing themselves, and there are also programs on your seats for the hard of hearing.” He clears his throat, and you watch his gaze dart nervously around the crowd. “Um, thank you all for coming. We’re really pleased with the turnout, and the Accumula chapter will be trying to host more events in the future.” Another pause. “That’s all.”

He replaces the microphone and slinks off the stage to scattered applause. There’s a tiny, localized wave of disturbances as he picks his way through the tightly-packed seats—it looks like he struggles to see in the dimmed light, but you can watch him fumble around perfectly—and you trace the mantra of “pardon me, sorry, thank you” until he makes his way to the back row and takes the seat by your side.

{Is that what you wanted me to see?} you whisper, but he just points at the stage.

You’ve seen these a few times before, from when you greedily watched human television through their windows. But you’ve never seen one with—

A minccino quietly totters up the steps, and scampers up the ascending boxes that have been arranged so he can be tall enough to reach the microphone. {Hello. My name is Tiallys,} he says quietly, in the dialect of forests. It would seem he learned from watching N; he’s careful not to get too close to the microphone, but his voice carries smoothly from the speakers. {I am from the Yarrow Clan of Lostlorn Forest. This is a song that my siblings and I used to sing in celebration of the Short Night. Traditionally—} He pauses.

His tail twitches, and that’s when you see how dirty it is. Strange. Usually the rats clean one another; it’s the first thing they do when they meet. {Traditionally, it should be sung with at least five others, but the Yarrow Clan was separated when our part of the forest was clear-cut. Um. The melody is very simple, and you are welcome to join in on the chorus if you would like.}

He pauses. The room is silent. Then he begins.

When he sings, his voice resonates in a deep vibrato, one that you wouldn’t have believed could fit in his tiny body. The words are lost to you, but the melody settles around your shoulders like a heavy blanket, warm, comforting. It lilts in a strange way, with pauses that feel like they should be filled by another. But it happens all at once: he’s halfway through threading a lyric, some stupid rhyme about “my love” and “stars above”, when—

You’re curled up against your mother, in the rare shared moments she had with you. Her humans couldn’t know about you, she’d explained. They’d make you fight. So she hid you carefully in the alleyways during the day while she fawned around her humans, and ran to you at night. {But I was thinking of you the entire time, my love,} she whispers with a soft laugh, her tongue rasping against the fur on the back of your neck. Her breath is warm, and you’re bundled tightly to her flank, and as you drift off to sleep, she begins to croon a lullaby—

Short night, good night,

Find your way in the moon’s soft sight.


You blink back to reality. It’s a different song; a simple one, like Tiallys said; roughly half the pokémon in the room have joined the rat on the chorus. You want to focus on how they aren’t as good as he is, how they’re distracting from the real talent in the room, but you can’t. You can’t even bring yourself to join them; you just stare, stare at the stupid rat as he finishes his song with his eyes closed.

Short night, good night,

May we meet in the morn’s sweet light
.

Your heart feels like it’s sunk all the way to your paws, and there’s a heavy weight on your shoulders that forces your head down, your ears back. The snake’s got her tail curled tightly around herself, and she clutches it like it’s something precious.

A tear traces down Hilda’s cheek. Does she even know why?

The rest of the show is a blur.

※​

After the show, people start to trickle out. A group of humans approach N; he answers their questions with a stutter and a fake smile. The pokémon performers are gathered on the stage, and you almost could go up and join them, thank them, but what would you say? So you sit quietly.

Eventually, the crowd thins. Hilda walks up and clears her throat, and when he looks at her, she says, “Thanks for inviting me. This was … this was really nice. And different.”

N practically beams. “I’m so glad.” He fumbles around until he finds the stack of flyers in the chair beside him and presses one into her stunned hands. “The Accumula branch of Plasma has chapter meetings every other Wednesday, and for travelling trainers there’s listserv that’ll go directly to your x-transceiver so you can see what’s going on when. There are chapters in all the major cities now.” His smile fades and he trails off. “You don’t have to do anything you don’t want to, of course! But if you were interested …”

Hilda scrutinizes the flyer in her hand—what, does she think it’s going to answer for her? “I think I will.” She swallows. “I learned a lot tonight. And you had a good time too, didn’t you, Vaselva?”

The snivy nods, and then adds quietly, {This was a very nice performance. Thank you.} She looks at both you and N when she says it.

The enthusiasm is back in N’s voice. “I’m so glad! I think a lot of people—and trainers—could benefit from seeing things like this, if we just …” He frowns and picks his next words very carefully. “If we just helped them see a world where pokémon are free to be people.”

Hilda’s face clouds in confusion. You see the question burning on her lips, but N doesn’t, and maybe she doesn’t either. She nods and waves before slipping out of the room, Vaselva at her heels.

Most of the room empties until there’s just a core group of people left. As far as you can tell, no one says a word, but somehow they all know what to do, and they begin rearranging the chairs (again) into a large circle. A human and the watchog from earlier drag a heavy black bowl into the center. Someone turns on a set of string lights that almost seem to float overhead, twined in the branches of the oak tree above. The remaining half dozen or so people lounge in spots around the ring of chairs; someone passes glass bottles around them.

That night is a quiet one. Somewhere deeper in the city, a fester of sewaddle are gathering, humming as their legs click together. Their music drifts gently through the leaves.

N’s hunched over the black bowl, and with his own two hands he shakily manages to trap a flame. Oh. You remember those. You saw them in the city windows. Envied the ones who had their warmth.

He’s careful. You watch him from atop your stool, entranced. You’ve never seen someone handle fire so delicately. Normally you’d expect him to be afraid of it; it’s fire, after all. But he’s not, as he gently pokes at the embers with a stick, blows a little into it, and coaxes it into a crackling hearth.

You’ve always wanted a human. Maybe this isn’t what you meant, though. This one is strange. This one will not get you to where you want to go.

But. Is that so bad?

The fire crackles as he steps back, casting shadows up his face and neck. You watch him survey the ring of people, and then he comes and sits next to you.

He leans back, but his back stays hunched, like he’s some sort of misproportioned sawk. He’s much too tall for the chair he picked, but he doesn’t seem bothered by it. You leap down from the stool and pick your way over to him, nuzzle yourself under his hand and curl up in his lap.

“Did you have a good time, Tourmaline? I’m sorry if you were uncomfortable being alone.”

You ignore his question. You can handle the snake and the girl, and he doesn’t need to know if you can’t. {Why didn’t you perform?} you ask instead.

“It wasn’t my place. I wanted that to be somewhere for pokémon to be who they want to be.”

When Brex sang, a human girl drummed the sides of his bucket. When the tympole dove underwater, the warbling effect from his voice echoed with the rhythmic rapping sound from the metal. It was a nice duet, you remember, but by that point your heart and your mind were far, far away. {There were some humans up there as well.}

He smiles stiffly. “That’s true.” The smile fades. “But I’d much rather watch.”

You think about how Hilda watched, frozen, the tear on her cheek glistening in the lights of the stage. When Tiallys finished his song, she’d wiped it away and clapped with all the rest, but you couldn’t help but wonder: did she know? Did she understand?

Your mother could’ve taken you to the forests. It’d be easier to hunt there, and she wouldn’t have had to preen and posture for her humans to get enough scraps to feed the two of you. But the wilds were dangerous in their own ways. Too easy for humans to decide that your home, your family, was theirs now. Tiallys sang for his siblings. If they were dead, he would’ve started with that. There is no shame or sadness in losing one to the wild. But if they were taken, scattered across Unova—he could sing as loudly as he wanted, but he’d probably sing alone.

Did she sense the magic in the room when the others joined in? Did she know who they were singing for?

No. Surely not. She might’ve tried, but she’d never be able to understand, not when all she could do was watch.

You certainly weren’t wrong in picking your human. You can see that much now. But—

{You lost to that girl. I was humiliated.}

“I’m sorry you were hurt, Tourmaline. That was my fault.”

{I don’t want your apologies. I want to know how to get better.}

N swallows nervously. He’s staring into the fire, so all you can see is the bottom of his chin, the way it throws different shadows alongside the flickering light. “I think you did a really good job. You tried your best.”

{My best wasn’t good enough.} It’s your pride that stings more than the ache in your bones, now that you’ve been healed. You lost to the green one, and you won’t forget it. {You didn’t give me any commands.}

“I’m sorry,” he says, and from the sounds of it, he’s not making that up. “I’m new to battling, honestly.”

{New? But you’re so old.}

“I waited a bit.”

Ah.

“It makes me uncomfortable to try to give pokémon commands. I didn’t think you’d prefer it. You know yourself so much better than I do.” Idly, he begins to scratch at the spot where your nose bridges into your forehead, and you close your eyes. The fire is warm on your fur; the crackling light sends patterns spiraling up the inside of your eyelids. “I hope that if you ever find a new trainer who gives you a command that you don’t want to obey, you don’t feel obligated to listen.”

He’s certainly new to this, if he doesn’t realize what humans are. They’re meant to command. That’s their only purpose. Pokémon fight. Humans call the shots. That’s simply how things are. He’ll learn his place one day, as you’ve learned yours.

{I will do what it takes,} you promise instead.

“Do you think it’s fair that battles work like that?” he asks, almost casually. But you can sense the loaded intent in his words. If they had form they would be an adult liepard, rear legs bent taut and ready to pounce. “Is that what you want?”

{What else would I want?} you respond testily.

He doesn’t take your question as an answer, even if you wish he had. “I’m not sure. That’s why I like organizing events like this. It’s good for the trainers, but I hope that maybe the pokémon who attend can see if there’s something else they want instead.”

{I’m not going to sing.} You think of the leavanny and her harp, who introduced herself tremulously and explained that she’d admired the lyre since she was a sewaddle. Is that what he wants from you? {And I’m not going to play a stupid instrument, either.}

“You don’t have to.”

{You didn’t sing either,} you say, in case he’s got any grand ideas about getting the two of you onstage in a duet. {You organized the whole thing, right? If you hadn’t spoken up at the beginning, they wouldn’t have even known you were there.}

“No, they wouldn’t have.” He shifts his legs slightly, and you hiss in annoyance until he stills. “But I find that I hear quite enough of my own voice these days.”

You aren’t sure how to answer that. He keeps petting you, but he goes silent.

“That pidove you left me.” He pauses for a while, eyes distant into the open flame. “Why?”

{You knew it was me?}

The next long pause tells you all you need to know. “You were very stealthy,” he says, very carefully. He’s a very bad liar.

{I wanted to show you I was strong.}

“I believe you’re strong. You didn’t have to do it like that.”

{Do what?}

“The pidove almost—she was badly wounded.” His fingers stop on a snag in your fur, and he delicately begins pulling a small bramble out of it. Gentle. You haven’t had anyone groom you this way since your mother— “Did you intend to battle her for me?”

{Not a battle. You seemed like a bad hunter.}

“Ah.” The bramble’s tangled deep in there; had it come from the snake’s vines? You don’t remember. “Forgive me. I don’t actually know. Do you normally hunt pidove for food?”

{No. Territorial spats, sometimes. I would wound them or chase them off. In times of great famine, perhaps. If there is no other choice. Otherwise, no. They are irritating and more trouble than they’re worth.} So loud. Your mother picked the loudest spot in the alleyway to hide you when you were younger, where the pidove screamed at all hours of the day.

He’s got the bramble out. He inspects it in the firelight carefully, and then throws it aside. Resumes his petting in nice, slow strokes. “Would you hurt a human like that?”

{No. Absolutely not. I would never.}

“Why? Even for territorial spats? If one took your nest?”

Your tail flicks idly. He speaks like one who has never had to hunt. That is okay. You will do the hunting for him. You weren’t a good hunter in the city, but when you grow older you’ll be good enough for both of you. {Pidove are stupid. If I attack one pidove, the flock leaves us to settle our grievances alone. Even if I’m weaker, and two or three of them could easily overwhelm me. If I attack one human, they will all come. I will lose.}

That doesn’t seem like the answer he was expecting, but he smiles anyway. “Interesting.” Someone is getting up from the circle; N waves at them before they go. You don’t turn to watch. When he settles, he says, “You said you wanted to show me you were strong. What does that mean to you?”

Mean? Why would he ask that? Humans are for making meaning. {I want to win. I want to be stronger.} Maybe if you repeat it, it’ll sink in.

Maybe not. “What is stronger to you? The power to crush your foes? To have teeth and claws so sharp that none would dare challenge you?”

You … you aren’t sure. But stronger is certainly the opposite of what you are now. Can you get there on your own? You don’t think so. Your mother always told you the humans were the ones with all the power. They were the strongest. So of course you’d have to learn from them.

What would you learn from this human, though? How to call people together and help them sing? How not to battle? How to hang posters from trees?

There could be good lessons in there, you suppose. Perhaps even strength. But would they be what you want?

These are thick concepts. You’re reminded of trying to tear apart a backpack with your teeth to find the sweet prizes inside—it’s heavy work. The cloth is thick and must be wrestled with. You’re tired. Today started so long ago.

“You don’t want to stay with me, do you,” he says at last. He’s not looking at you. He’s staring into the fire.

Those words send a lurch of alarm through your paws. You stiffen. {What do you mean?}

“I think we’re both realizing I can’t make you strong the way you want, Tourmaline. I apologize.” He’s still petting you, and with your eyes closed the world is reduced to just the warmth of the firelight, and the pressure of his hand on your back, and the softness of his voice. “But I respect your desire. If you wanted to train, I have a few friends who have more courage than I, who can stomach violence. I think you would like them. They could help you become strong. Or, if you’d like, you can seek out your own trainer until you found one who fit.”

{Are you …} The anger crystallizes through the exhaustion. {Are you rejecting me?}

“If that’s what you want,” he says quietly, staring straight ahead.

You blink very slowly up at him. Fatigue is starting to slip in, enveloping your sore limbs, your confused mind. It’s a hard question. Maybe tomorrow you will leave him, find a trainer who will help you fight and become strong. Maybe you’ll stay. It could be that tomorrow you wrestle with what it is that you want from your humans, what it is you want with this world. It could be that the answers are easy once you look at them in the sunlight.

Somehow you know they won’t be. They never are.

Your mother wanted you to stay in the alleyway forever, even as the box she tucked you in grew smaller and smaller and you no longer fit. She wouldn’t have wanted you here, following her pawprints. But it’s what you wanted. She hadn’t been able to hide the glints of glamor in her voice, the way that all of Unova used to erupt into cheers, chanting her name like a magic spell when she fought.

When the humans here applauded for Tiallys tonight, they were quiet, hesitant. Even though opening his heart up like that, finding all the soft and delicate bits that he’d hidden deep within his chest and sharing them with the world—that must’ve been harder than any battle. Your wounds from fighting Vaselva healed already, but there’s a pressure on the top of your head, the kind that feels like your mother’s breath on your fur. Tiallys had put that there without even touching you. It feels warm.

That … that was some power indeed.

Perhaps he could teach you this tomorrow, or N. Perhaps, tomorrow, one of N’s friends could teach you a different strength. If you could only find the one you wanted.

But that is tomorrow. Tonight, you curl up with him by the fire, watch the stars above, shutter your eyelids as N softly sings a lullaby in a language whose words you do not recognize. Tonight you can be at peace.


p | n
 
Last edited:
oh hey it's sunday somewhere

some housekeeping updates: I've added/edited some bits of necktie and nocturne. I do lots of stealth edits and assume they never get reread. Honestly, like most of those edits, these are quite short and I'd pretend like they aren't important to anything upcoming (and they aren't important to this chapter), and hey, they're kind of cool on their own. but I mean, then I wouldn't be calling them out, so.
necktie said:
But when you think it all through, it isn’t the vocabulary that she lost in Unova, or her hand-voices, or even her name. There’s a concept that your people learned from hers, or perhaps the other way around—that of four we’s. The language that she speaks now has forgotten it, and when they hear it in the dialect of dragons they do not understand it. There is the we that means you and us without them, and there is the we that means us and them without you. The third we is the one Unovans pretend to use—you and us and them—when in reality you think they simply mean we without you and them.

For you and Iris, it is always you and I. It can be with them, or without. You do not care. Plasma claimed to want to give you back your freedom. What they fail to understand is that your soul has only ever known a leash. Unova has always held you both by the neck; there is no separating your struggles from hers. Not one without the other.

nocturne said:
Have you ever heard the nocturne lament Spoken?}

{Spoken?} His voice lilts on your pronunciation. Not a true native speaker, then.

{Not spoken, but Spoken,} you confirm, and this time he seems to understand the emphasis. {We can retell her words without feeling them, as we can with any words. As I did in my story just now—I spoke. But.} You draw yourself up to your full height, wings outstretched, voice unyielding. {If we understand it. If we mean it. For a brief moment she lives again. She Speaks, and through her, so do we.}

Across the sands, you have seen and heard so much. Yet each time you see Stormdancer’s words given life again, you find it beautiful, and terrifying. Sometimes she is invoked in these words, secreted down across the generations, across the world. Sometimes she only lives on in a gesture, in a cry, a gaze. Yet the intent is unmistakable.

and now for something completely different:
 
xvii. enharmonic
xvii. enharmonic
(end)

※​

Telling the story forwards, the way everyone else says it should be told, makes it a sad one. You talk to a lot of people and everything gets worse. You walk across an entire continent only to end up right where you started, and the only option ahead of you is to separate humans from pokémon indiscriminately, because some wrongs cannot be righted, only undone.

It’s much easier to look at things this way instead. Turning things on their head is what Unova does best, after all. Now right is wrong, black is white. Put the effect before the cause and it’s immediately clear that there were a thousand times you could’ve been stopped, helped, before you had no other choice, if anyone had just listened. If you had just known how to ask them to understand.

It’s much easier not to look at any of that. It’s easier instead to let the beginning and the end intertwine. Zahhak told you a story like that once, about a human who met an adamantine dragon and was permitted to see through the web of time, to watch a war in reverse.

It’s reassuring to pretend you’re that human now, and to quietly undo your own tragedy. Told backwards, everyone gets a happy ending. Hilda solemnly walks away from a healing battlefield and returns all of her badges and pokémon, her scowl fading piece by piece as they leave her, until she’s grinning through tears as she claps for a mincinno. Tourmaline is taken from a trainer she hates, returned to two humans she loves, and sleepily rouses herself by the fire. Zahhak stretches himself out, unharmed, from enormous pile of rubble; his scars fade; he smiles toothily. Human children all over the country enthusiastically direct pokémon to fling themselves away from one another. Hundreds of pokémon are pulled away from lives of violence and accompanied by their human friends into the wild to live quiet, peaceful lives among their kind.

And further back still. A clever human scientist unstifles a gasp of surprise after freeing a pokémon from the first pokéball, and deconstructs it with shaking hands so it will never imprison anyone against their will again. Sagaris rears up on her hind legs and swallows a torrent of dragonfire so that it doesn’t burn anyone; in turn, humans plug her gaping wounds with their weapons and remove them once her roars of pain turn triumphant. Stormdancer opens her eyes and inhales as blood bursts from a king’s hands back into her throat. Reshiram and Zekrom reconcile back into the Dragonmother, who draws all of her children close once more.

Every victory, every defeat, every pain—it all gets wound back until everyone is smaller and simpler and less violent, until no one can hurt anyone else ever again. There is nothing more beautiful and terrifying than their innocence.

Perhaps selfishly, you focus on a very small child with green hair who watches with wide eyes as screams to turn cheers, who lays down his burdensome mantle of being the hero and closes his eyes in a peaceful world.

※​

The moment before it all ends is serene. And then:

{Hero of Truth. Is this what you want?}

You can’t quite hide your surprise. Both at the words, and at their speaker.

“Zekrom?” you ask slowly.

{I have listened to you, and I have listened to the Hero of Ideals, and I have come to an understanding,} Zekrom rumbles.

You say nothing. Pure truth is a response.

A massive fracture crawls across the room, inevitably toward Reshiram; by the time they touch, you will have split two worlds that will never rejoin again.

{I sensed your presence when you passed by Relic Castle, many moons ago. I slumbered deep inside of the Dark Stone, and yet your conviction for a better world stirred me. But unformed hope for a brighter future is not an ideal; I did not and do not believe you have the capacity to struggle for a dream that you cannot see. And yet, even as we stand here at the end, I sense that you are not fully convinced in your truth, even as Reshiram stands behind you. So I ask you again: is this what you want?}

You aren’t sure if gods have a concept of rhetorical questions. So instead you look Zekrom in the eye before your better judgment holds you back, and in the depths of red you see unfathomable wisdom, pain, and hunger. A black eyelid shutters, granting you a brief moment of respite. “What do you want instead?” you manage.

{What I want no longer matters,} Zekrom says, wearily casting one arm across the cratered battlefield around you. {Hero of Truth, all that matters now is your heart, and if you still can believe enough to extend it.}

The words sit heavily in the room, which you find has grown unnaturally still. In this one, serene moment, everyone else but the dragon before you is frozen in place.

{You seek to reset us. I find that quite unideal, and instead I seek to compromise. I believe neither of us want this ending, although you think your hand is forced. Even I have no faith in wishing on the past. Do you understand what I am saying, Hero of Truth?}

At first you don’t even understand the question, the situation, any of it. What is Zekrom trying to tell you? That your choice here will be irreversible? You know that; you’ve known that all along. That some concepts are never meant to be merged as one; that your beliefs are as incompatible with the current world as fire and water? You’ve known that as well.

But Zekrom, who surely knows far more than you ever will, must know both these things and more. They wouldn’t ask you if there wasn’t a reason, something they need you to understand.

Why are you making me do this?”

Unbidden, the memory surfaces. Your father played chess with you when you were younger. You asked him in a very clear voice why he insisted on playing you, because that you thought it was silly and he was always going to win. And the rules were quite foolish. Some pieces could belong on some squares; everything had to be divisible. You’d asked him why black and white had to be cordoned off into their own boxes.

And Ghetsis had coldly answered all of your questions at once: “Because some people don’t have a choice.”

You hated that game, how every piece had only its one set of moves, how kings could go nowhere at all but were somehow the only piece that mattered. But you hated most of all how the board reset like nothing had ever happened, as if a dozen pieces hadn’t fallen for a polarized victory. At first you thought you disliked the game because you kept losing, but you once you tasted victory you hated winning even more, because it never felt like success, not when there was simply an endless string of games ahead.

The answer coalesces along with the image of tiny, trembling hands resetting the pieces across the board, prepared to start it all over. “You’re trying to tell me that I cannot fixate on the past. I cannot return things to the way they used to be and expect better results.”

Zekrom rumbles an agreement. {Reshiram and I are in eternal conflict over which force should be the driving factor in this world. I suspect we always will be. To explore and know the truth, you must look to the past and understand how previous actions have guided you to where you are today. To explore and know your ideals, you must look to the future and understand what steps you must take to walk the path to where you wish to be. But if you desire only to return to the past, if you seek to create a future that was simply what once was … you, like us, will be trapped in a cycle of conflict forever.}

It’s an ugly truth, and an even uglier one to hear from the Dragon of Ideals.

“I know. But Reshiram and I knew of no other way to help. This is all we can do.” You look away. It takes all of your self-control not to burst out then. You know that, and yet—there’s nothing else you can do. No other way to reverse this situation. Surely even Zekrom can understand that truth: if there was a better path, you would’ve taken it long ago. But it’s more than that. You remember the stories you were told growing up, about the black dragon who had strength beyond compare and yet whose greatest gift was to have faith in others despite everything. “Would you also stand there and let things continue as they are, knowing what you know now? Could you do nothing when there are people who cry out for you?”

Zekrom says quietly, {You remind me of my eldest daughter.}

On reflex, you can’t help but look back at them. “I’m sorry?”

{In times she was like you, with her green voice. In times she was like my Hero of Ideals, with her fighting spirit. But in her best times, she was both. That was who she was always meant to be.}

Your stomach clenches. Stormdancer. Does Zekrom know?

You see something in Zekrom’s eyes twist and seethe, and the truth strikes you with the same sort of certainty with which you’d say the sky is blue. Zekrom knows what happened to Stormdancer and her voice, and what happened in turn to the rest of the Dragonmother’s children.

“I’m sorry.”

Zekrom breaks your gaze. {You are not the one I have chosen, but I respect the goal that you seek. When I was reborn amidst a battlefield and the very first thing my Hero of Ideals did was command me to attack another one in suffering, one who would invoke my daughter’s words in the face of certain death, I understood: even her Ideal world would involve pain for the innocent. Perhaps not for everyone, perhaps only for a few, but pain enough that I hesitated then. Pain enough that I believe I could shelve my conflict now with you and my sibling to break us from this cycle. And, of course, even I understand the other simple truth—if I do not try to intercede here, you will act anyway. I cannot stop you.}

They’re … not wrong.

{This future you envision, where so many people struggled for so long, only for you and my sibling to rip their rewards from their hands—I cannot say it is an ideal one. I hope we both agree there.}

Zekrom waits for you to respond, so you have to try.

There had been a single moment, back when you were idly standing in the Icirrus pokécenter, the TV buzzing gently as background noise, when it had all finally come together for you, months too late. There was a crowd gathered round, watching intently, but you hadn’t noticed them at first. It was late at night and Spur was talking about an interesting thought experiment involving a traveling man and a map, and there was a weird feeling in your chest—Zekrom, you’d realize later. You must’ve sensed the dragon from halfway across Unova.

What made you look up was his voice, tinny but unmistakable. You pushed through the crowd to see him on the screen. Zahhak, beaten and bloody, glared up at this god and invoked those words, the full thing, the parts he hadn’t been able to truly say back in the castle, and it felt in that moment that his words were for simultaneously for you and for all of Unova: forgive me, dear sibling.

The last time you’d seen him, you’d split the oath between yourselves; he’d taken on the sacrifice and you’d taken on the regret, but in front of Zekrom he’d accepted them both, and when he was done, he passed them on, relinquishing the mantra of martyrs for another. Those words were never meant to be held for long.

Something inside of you had caught fire that night. There was once a childish, hopeful part of you that still hoped for a way that didn’t involve suffering, and that night it burst into a flame.

In those flames you could steel yourself to the harsh reality that you’d seen Zahhak accept. Changing the world would require a piece of yourself in return. Denying that fact only meant that someone else would suffer while you waited. Sometimes a little, sometimes a lot. In that one moment that drive had taken all of Zahhak, and a little bit of you as well. And from that one moment there was no more avoiding it; it was time to give the rest up to the flames.

There is no change without sacrifice. This is the conviction upon which you called to Reshiram. This is the fire that roared so loudly it stirred a god.

To look Zekrom in the eyes, and to say that you could still believe, that you could still look to an ideal that you had always sought but had been taken from you, time and time again? Can you agree?

No. You cannot. You tilt your head up. Bitterly, like every human in Unova before you, you choose silence.

{My sibling and I,} says Zekrom when you fail to answer, gesturing with an errant flick of an arm the size of your body towards Reshiram, {were once one being. You have surely heard the stories of how we were embroiled in aiding in a battle of brothers, much like the one you are in now.}

Your brow furrows, but you understand before you have to ask for clarification: the tongue of dragons has no word for civil war. It is a purely human construct, to pretend that wars could be civil. Zahhak once— “Yes. I know the legends. The conflict was so fierce that you and Reshiram were sundered.” You can’t bring yourself to look Zekrom in the eyes, but you hope the regret carries through in your voice at least. “Humans did that to you. I’m sorry.”

“N,” she says suddenly, voice shaky. “Do you … do you trust us?”

Behind the dragon, one hand outstretched, one tear tracking through the ash smudged across her cheeks—Hilda has been here this entire time. Watching, silent, listening.

Trust her?

It’s such an innocent, impossible question. How could she trust you? That night you did nothing but watch as Zahhak ripped Amara to shreds. She couldn’t have known that that was the last thing you’d wanted, that half of why you’d tried to hard at Dragonspiral Tower was because you knew what Ghetsis would do when you failed—but you couldn’t ask Hilda to separate you from them. Indirectly or not, you’d known that was the inevitable end to the path he’d set himself on. He was a dragon, after all. A dragon who thought that the only gift he had left was violence. You’d seen the hesitation on her face, even before you summoned Reshiram. For once, she hadn’t wanted to battle you. Was it because she knew it would come to this? Because she, like you, had come to doubt the drive that had gotten her here?

But doubt isn’t reconciliation. Regret isn’t redemption. How could she ask you to trust her? She couldn’t even understand half of this conversation; hers is a one-sided scream into the void that Zekrom somehow chose to answer. Hilda tried, and she tried very hard, but what does she know? What does anyone else know? How was it so easy for her to call to a dragon whose words she would never understand?

In the frozen moment that follows, you want to tell her so much. Of Stormdancer and the Dragonmother, of a chord the two of them had formed on a starry night in a time long-since dead, of the gift your ancestors stole to get you both here today. But your words die in your throat.

What would she say? What would she choose?

Did she know?

When you don’t respond, Hilda’s the one to break the silence. “You used the word sunder to describe Reshiram and Zekrom,” she says quietly, almost hesitantly. “Do you know where that word comes from?”

She’s repeating your words back to you. Draconic. There was fire in your voice when you told her the tragedy of Sagaris not ten minutes earlier, fire that you aren’t even sure came from you. But you can’t hear rage in her. You look hesitantly to Zekrom, who nods, so you shake your head slowly.

“My mother told me a story when I was young.” You can see the tremors racking up her arms, but she keeps her voice steady. “Our Great Mother was born with two hearts. Seeing the strength she was given, she tasked herself to safeguard this world. But while her role was very important, it was very lonely. To walk without equal is a horrible thing. And so the Great Mother sundered into the Twin Gods.”

You want to spit her retort back at her. You know how the story of Reshiram and Zekrom ends. One became two so that two could be like one. But just because it turned out one way hundreds of years ago doesn’t mean it’ll work out this way now.

“The word sunder for us is a special one.” Hilda’s voice finally quavers. “It comes from our ancient word for alone. My mother often reminded me that her language has many words to divide, but only sunder has that connotation. I always thought the distinction was important. I’ve never tried to explain it before. Do you know why they chose to split in that moment, when before they had endured so much as one? To me it’s only obvious if you know why we chose sunder. If you know why they chose to stand alone.”

You almost don’t want to answer her. You’ll just prove her right, after all, and you can’t doubt, not here, not when you’re so close. But you know how this story ends. You know what this ending calls you to do.

The words slip out despite yourself, and the dialect of dragons is heavy on your heart when you say, “So they would always have one who could stand beside them?”

“So they would always have one who could stand beside them,” she repeats solemnly, her smile watery.

Can you imagine it? Zekrom and Reshiram opening their newly-sundered eyes and beholding the other. How did it feel in that moment, doing the hardest thing a person could do? How did it feel to face yourself?

Something tells you it can’t have been entirely unlike what’s happening now.

Nothing would hide the truth that the harsh fire of Reshiram’s truth revealed. Nothing could quench those flames now that you’ve stoked them with yourself. But perhaps within them, you could reforge yourself instead. Hilda must have, somehow, if she could still stand here and believe after everything she’s lost. The invitation is clear, if you could only just take it. If you could just believe.

“Do you trust Zekrom?” she asks. She hesitates. “Even if … even if you don’t trust me?” She tilts her head up defiantly, the same rigid determination she’s worn into every battle glinting in her eyes. But there’s something else now, too. Desperation. “I don’t fully know what Zekrom’s planning, N. Or if it’ll even be what I want. But I know … I know Zekrom knows we can’t do it without you.”

So they would always have one who could stand beside them.

Maybe it didn’t just refer to Reshiram and Zekrom. Maybe there was a reason pokémon chose to partner with humans, no matter the myriad of ways that that partnership led to pain. Maybe they’d realized that the alternative was just failing alone.

It has to be a trick of the light. But for a moment, you don’t see Hilda standing by Zekrom. There’s another child there with wide, innocent eyes, another black dragon standing by a human, and—

Did Stormdancer trust Human? Did Human trust Stormdancer? Did she care? Did she know?

Did it matter?

The answer to all those questions, surely, was the same as the one you must give now.

And in that last, serene, fragile moment before it all ends, you decide.

You look at that child and exhale. “We can’t be you.” Blink. Hilda’s there again. For a brief moment you wonder if Reshiram saw the same trick of the light; if the power of Zekrom’s ideals showed them two dragons standing as one, the beauty of a future that could’ve been, that could still be. “But we can help you. And we can learn from you.” You look up to the resplendent white dragon at your side, feeling for all the world like a petulant child. “Can’t we?”

Reshiram is still hesitating, still on the verge of fracture. Pure truth is a response, after all.

In a slow voice, Reshiram finally answers. {When Zekrom and I were one, we had an immutable gift. The strength to imagine any ideal and the power to make it true. We could not handle that burden. We split, and each sought Heroes like ourselves, and our quarrel in turn sundered Unova.}

Reshiram’s neck snakes down until their eyes are level with you. {In my millennia of slumber I came to regret my actions in choosing to stand against my sibling, and the damage we wrought upon your world, but I understood as well that my actions could not be undone. You were correct before when saying you were too idealistic to be the Hero of Truth like you knew in legend. You called to me, and I chose you, not because you embody what I am, but because you carry what I lack. What I cast aside all those years ago.}

You follow Reshiram’s gaze over your shoulder, where Hilda stands next to Zekrom.

{And I see now,} Reshiram rumbles, {that I was not unique in my regret.}

Blue blood drips down Zekrom’s throat. {Could we not be in accord once more?}

The two dragons stare levelly at one another.

{We cannot be us again,} Reshiram says after a long silence. {But for this moment, in this very last moment, I believe a temporary alliance could be brokered between us, and we could work together to protect the peoples of this world, as we once did so long ago.}

Both dragons turn once more to look at you, and suddenly you know without doubt what the Heroes of Ideals are asking you to do, what Truth’s response must be. Your heart is suddenly heavy, and full.

Ten thousand years ago, in this very spot, a legend says a human clutched a dragon’s body and cried into the night for help. You can’t say for sure what happened next. But you can believe this: beneath a starry sky, despite everything before or since, the world changed.

You face the shattered battlefield, Hilda, the ancient dragons, and you bow low before invoking the words that will once again change Unova forever:

“Forgive me, dear sibling. This is all I know how to give.”

※​

o. new

※​

The last notes of a long-forgotten song fade away.

“N!” Footsteps. “Are you okay?!”

“He will live, Hero of Ideals.”

There is a heavy, weighted silence.

“Zekrom?”

“Yes, Hero of Ideals.”

“What … what did you do?”

What follows is incomprehensible, a strangled hiss.

“N?”

“He says: ‘The dragons have given pokémon a Gift, Hilda.’”

“… Reshiram?”

“Reshiram and N reached an accord, just as you and I did, Hero of Ideals. I represent this land as it could be, a Unova that we can aspire for. My sibling stands for the Unova that is, the ugly realities that bind us. In our struggles we have forgotten how we were once one, how we once stood for a world that could be beautiful because of its flaws, not despite them.”

“We stood for the Unova that is becoming. My sibling is correct. We both forgot this. Even if we had the power to split these worlds, to return all of you to a universe in which pokémon live on their own and humans are kept far away to make their own disasters—we could not without first giving everyone a fair chance to make things right. Pokémon never had a chance to dictate the terms of their partnership. Humans never had to listen for an answer. That much we understand now. We could not ignore your plea, but nor could we ignore our own. And so it is quite simple. From N we took, and to pokémon everywhere we gave, the gift that we lost so long ago. We gave Voice.”

A strain of music echoes in the distance.

Another incomprehensible hiss.

“He says: ‘No more can you speak and humans live in blissful ignorance in the gaps between your words. When they speak, you will hear.’”

“But what … what happened to him?”

“In giving his Voice fully to others, he has lost his own. That is how the world is, and how it has always been.” Pause. “One day we will create a world where it no longer has to be.”

“Is it permanent?”

“Yes. But all four of us knew that before we began.”

Another pause.

“I know.”

“He says this, Hilda: it isn’t your fault that pokémon were betrayed in such a way for you to have your gain, nor is it our place to mete judgment by ripping pokémon and humans apart. This world was made for you, and you did not make it, but for those of us who received so many gifts, the burden is on our shoulders to make it right. My hero sought to solve the equation that would change the world, but along the way we learned: that equation is an inequality. It cannot and will not be solved by our hand alone, nor will it be solved today. But we must try, and we must do so together. For that future … he says he is more than willing to join those who sacrificed their own gift.”

“And thanks to them our work can truly begin, Hero of Ideals.”

The sound of crumbling stone.

“To you, dear sibling, and to you, Hilda—and to all people—N and I warn this: with the gift of Voice, you and we have allowed humans to hear the words pokémon speak. We cannot make humans listen, nor can we force them to understand. This is merely one step down a long road. There will always be injustices that we will need to fight. We have given one half of a gift. You must teach the other. You must prove that humans meant what they said when they wished to partner peacefully with pokémon, and that it was only because you could not hear them before that you were deaf to their cries. You must welcome them now into a world where they are free to be people. If you plug your ears now, if you harden your hearts to their pain, if you insist that battling and violence are the only way you can understand them, then we will have no choice.”

Wingbeats. The sound of crumbling stone. A roar with no words.

“We say this: if we must roar again, he will not speak to humans, nor will I give his Voice to pokémon. We will bare our fangs, and we will call the storm.”

※​
 
Last edited:
So as I find myself wrapping up this fic, I also get to take a little step back and be in awe over how social this entire process ended up being--not even because I was particularly unsocial in fic before, but because I got to meet some people I probably wouldn't have met otherwise.

This is a story about voice, and art, and doing brave things, and doing silly things. If I'm being fully honest, having a fanart gallery has always been a thing that I've been a little jealous of/a hidden secret goal of mine, and at some point in the past year I realized, holy shit, i'm finally here, and that was a wild experience in itself. True to form I immediately forgot to make an actual gallery for all of these because I am the worst and instead kept them in a private document so I could oggle at them in my own free time; if I've lost your link, please accept my apologies and also maybe let me know?

wow it's
a r t
(spoilers for the entire fic, probably)
N_Truth.jpg

[by WildBoots FFN | AO3 | Instagram | Tumblr]
---

boldore_wm.jpg

[by WildBoots FFN | AO3 | Instagram | Tumblr]
---

image0.jpg

[by kyeugh FFN | Tumblr]
---

unknown.png

[by An Author's Pen FFN | AO3]
---

Gardening_Sword.png

[by An Author's Pen FFN | AO3]
---

unknown.png

[by An Author's Pen FFN | AO3]
---

unknown.png

[by An Author's Pen FFN | AO3]
---

unknown.png

[by An Author's Pen FFN | AO3]
---

unknown.png

[by An Author's Pen FFN | AO3]
---

unknown.png

[by An Author's Pen FFN | AO3]
---

unknown.png

[by An Author's Pen FFN | AO3]
---

unknown.png

[by An Author's Pen FFN | AO3]
---

unknown.png

[by Chibi Pika FFN | DA | Twitter | Tumblr]
---

image0.png

[by HelloYellow17 FFN | Tumblr]
---

image0.png

[by HelloYellow17 FFN | Tumblr]
---

Carnel_paint.jpg

[by Panoramic Vacuum / Wolflyn Tumblr | AO3 | FFN]
QnBcDvA.png

uREL8Z3.png

[by sun / finersun | Twitter]

and, a little something from my muse to yours:

Me0k1OZ.jpg


My most sincere thanks to WildBoots and Pen, who stuck on this train for 17 months of oops-too-real, provided incredible beta work, and generated more engaged discussion about the implications of ferris wheels than I thought was possible. Without them this story would be far more messy, confusing, and typo-ridden than it is, and my life would contain roughly 40% fewer shitposts.

And of course, enormous thanks to anyone who’s read up to this author’s note. In a very unsubtle way this story is about inspiration and legacy, communication and conversation. It isn’t my way of fixing the world, or myself, or really anything consequential at all—but in a year spent quarantined and online, this story means a lot to me, and in no small way it’s trying to be from me and my muse to you and yours, so to find it read and heard means the world.
 
Last edited:
All right you. Even though you actually did participate in the review challenge thereby ruining the punchline I had in mind. Yet still, I am finishing with a massive twofold bang. I pushed myself to the absolute limit, reading this over the course of the whole challenge, and succeeded. Let's do some reading, pick this back up, and go all the way to the end of this thing, because I am COURAGEOUS!! (and a little crazy)

C2
- Protect shattering is the worst trope
- Good thing N wasn't using Stealth Rock here, because that is just poison. Also make your own Studio Ghibli joke here.
- Second person from a fricking Rotom. I'm surprised though, there's no Pokemon language in here given a Pokemon is the viewpoint.
- Interesting interpretation of Alder leaving a lot of collateral. I imagine the custodians hate him.
- With how crazy Alder is, maybe N's accusations have merit.
- Man imagine commercial breaks and then coming back to the battle being over
- Truth/ideals coming up.
- How coincidental the whole thing had cut to commercial during this time.
- Rotom thinking about lightning
- BAH GAWD KANG WE GOT INTERFERENCE IN HERE SOMEBODY STOP THE DAMN MATCH
- Pokemon cameramen, so unreliable. Shaking my smh...
- You know with how much of a sociopath Ghetsis is I don't buy that he'd nickname his Pokemon since that gives them an identity beyond the tools he sees them as
- Ohhhh, plot twist, Ghetsis was the one battling. Didn't see that coming, and was obfuscated by just calling him Harmonica.
- Wait now I'm confused. Alder was down to his last Pokemon, now he's suddenly using more?
- How much can it take to open one door?
- Meh, Ghetsis isn't anywhere near as convincing as N. Also heh, the commentator falling right into the trap instead of treating it as an emergency
- Oh there's the Poke-speak.
- I guess N failed to awaken his dragon here??
- Ded

C3
- More Poke-perspectives I see.
- I do like the concept of Pokemon not knowing other species' names that humans have given, and in fact would use it myself if ever going wild Pokemon persepctive.
- Hm, going to Cheren and his wanting to fill the Pokedex, I guess.
- I also like the concept of trainer nicknames not lining up with what a Pokemon wants to be called, would use that myself, and am surprised it doesn't get used as often
- Ahh, I kinda figured he caught one of N's Pokemon, but I was thinking it didn't line up with plot.
- Interesting that you had Cheren choose the one weak to the protagonist's starter here.
- Shoutouts to IVs making someone selectively catch
- Man this Boldore is going to have one bad time when he finds out how he has to evolve. I hope Cheren finds someone to tradeback
- That feel when caring about inanimate rocks. And that freakier feel when they answer you
- WILLLLLMAAAA
- Being not with the protagonist is suffering
- So I guess this Liepard isn't he first of N's Pokemon Cheren's grabbed
- Human/Pokemon communcation is pain
- Well this a cynical way for Pokemon to talk about trainers
- And verifying Ghetsis claims from the last chapter, the fuck???
- Fucked up.

C4
- Ahh, I see it now, we're going full Pokemon perspective except for the first chapter. Hey! Why didn't N get an icon for his chapter!?
- It's sometimes hard to tell what's a Fakemon and what's not from disciples of lowercase
- Let there be light, with electricity, because I guess batteries are unreliable
- Man, that feel when Hilda didn't catch anything until after Striaton. One way to avoid being given a monkey, I guess.
- What a flowery title.
- Of course the electric type would be swayed by the electric god.
- I guess N can brainwash even Pokemon
- A bit of Poke-racism with hating on being raised in a cage
- It is neat if almost a little bit corny how the Pokemon talk in elemental terms
- Interesting to think about how Pokemon sometimes don't get a choice in their trainer
- Why does a Zebstrika need to clop in order to light itself up??? Unless they're separate things, in which case, I think the Flash would also be just as telling of their position
- Wow ordering an attack on a human, this is serious. But given how serious a threat he posed and how he won, maybe it was legit
- Well I guess this explains how N failed. Makes more sense that Reshiram!N would fail, actually.
- Untranslatable words are fun. Although that said now that it's absolutely clear that it is one, those are usually italicized.
- N has been judged, and Amara is the executioner, I suppose.
- I guess this explains how N randomly has a fossil Pokemon.
- Glad at least some of the Pokemon are seeing how warped this is instead of all of them being easily brainwashed or hating everything
- Seeing right through the illusion. Like the concept that it'd be imperfect
- Interesting use of Defeatist
- Sponsorship??? I guess in this world, Britain took over and pushed their ways on everyone?

C5
- Hello? Moe's Tavern? Yeah uh, Mina Burr! Phone for Mina Burr?
- In a world where for equity's sake, the plural of trainer is also trainer
- Ever had your mom take away your video games? Try having her take away your Pokemon, permanently.
- It's kind of awkward to see them calling their trainer Trainer. Also that feel when that can get capitalized
- Interesting to think about the consequences of releasing. If only there were people willing to take abused Pokemon in, huh?
- I mean the King/Queen vs. King endgame would beg to differ on having no pawns. This is some Code Geass level of chess logic here. Well, maybe not that bad.
- I wonder if females always take lead just to keep the chess metaphor these Pokes somehow know about alive
- Ah so adoption's an options after all
- I guess that partially answers my question, not thinking of the King as the leader to protect
- And enter N
- Many years before wanderer’s birth <- Missing word
- This is certainly not the story in game
- Well there's Trainer's problem, he was ignoring type disadvantage
- You know it's a shitty world of a kintsugi fic when Pokemon violently turning on their trainers is a common occurance
- The trainer got maimed by his own Pokemon and he somehow survived and got arrested? Yup. This is a kintsugi fic all right.
- Aww, the Bisharp does something nice
- That feel though when a trainer falls from grace and becomes and abusive shit...
- I mean certain humans do wear helms, but I guess this Bisharp is uncultured
- Wow the kid punched hard enough to break Pokemon bones?!
- Oh, the Bisharp rescued Trainer. That makes more sense.
- That feel when Pokedexes are pretty much government spy cams.
- Hey, a way to communicate!! More need to think about this, really.
- And the Bisharp finds something else, something that doesn't involve fighting.
- Hee, being confused over tea.

C6
- And I see we're over to someone unidentified given the lack of a thing at the top of the chapter. But it does seem tentatively to be Ghetsis' Hydreigon.
- Ah, that might explain the nickname a little. Respect might do it, but I still think it's out of character
- And then the dragon met the fairy and got beaten into submission, the end
- Very interesting and unique relationship between trainer and Pokemon here. Maybe Ghetsis and his Hydreigon were made for each other considering he has the same opinion on N
- I guess N finds it hard to accept sacrifice
- Yes, this thing very much takes after Ghetsis
- Interesting twist, laying clear Ghetsis' real intentions to N directly
- Man, Zahh- even gives the same kinds of speeches as Ghetsis. Not so different indeed
- You know this far in I have to question, how long has this been going on and if Pokemon hated it for so long why hasn't revolution ever happen? Who even set the so-called rules?
- Moving goalposts. This story isn't going to end well.
- I like to think that he's pretending fairies simply don't exist when he's alluding to their weaknesses
- Yup, I knew it. Just took what she wanted by force once she realized the fix was in
- The truth will set you free, as they say.
- I do like this. A sad truth is, nonviolent protest rarely amounts to anything. You need something a lot worse than words to make true change happen in most cases.
- Interesting concept. N better fitting the hero of ideals, even though they're grooming him to be one of truth.
- Oof, that is a sad and painful question indeed
- Awww, hugs

C7
- Hm, and here I thought it was the LAPD, not the NYPD, who were infamous for police brutality. She was standing down.
- Wow going to jail for accidentally cutting a gas line or something
- I guess the gas suddenly doesn't exist when the cop goes to arrest her?
- Oh, a Plasma member
- I have no idea what to make of the Gym Leader running the city and letting open challenges happen everywhere besides "kintsugi fic"
- Man, Cheren getting arrested??
- So uh is she propping herself up as a kidnapper instead of a thief?
- Tying to a stick hypothetical again
- Ohhh I guess the cops were the ones doing the gassing. This is uh way worse than tear gas.
- And the police get slapped down. I feel you're kinda getting political with this, but...
- The problem with names like those, of course, are that they put pressure on the owner to live up to them. For all you've done I'm surprised that hasn't come up in the fic - maybe not yet, at least.
- There's N coming up again, and more of his Pokemon
- With all the licensing stuff and limitations, I feel it's injecting a lot of buruecracy into the world. It's interesting to think about, but going too far you can see just how much real world stuff doesn't work with the Pokemon world...
- Plus, bred moves??? Dude, that's just common to find in the games these days. It's not so illogical for Pokemon to just end up with eggs moves from being in the wild
- The ever lawful dog who does what he's told.

C8
- Okay, listening to Kirby music as I read this. Good background music to counteract something so cynical.
- It can be a bit funky adjusting to the differing terms different Pokemon use, like Leader/Follower here, but I like it. Gives each species their own identity, rather than typical PMD humans in Pokemon form even leaving aside when that's literally the case
- Ahh, the fossil. Thought it was Hilda for the briefest of moments because of Thunderlegs, but the others (and gender) don't line up. But I guess the fossil is going to explain the other fossil of N's
- Rushing river, yup. There it is.
- Also I guess Hilda is involved after all. And I guess since there's communication, this was N after getting the turtle, sometime in Chargestone Cave
- Huh, I guess this Joltik had some other random trainer who was able to understand Pokemon too.
- Based N, happily willing to introduce Pokemon to good trainers
- Things I like, certain species of Pokemon just not using names for themselves.
- I'm guessing Leader/Follower here are the two gears? Or is it N/Klink?
- And he will walk a million miles and he will walk a million more...
- Not everything would take flashing the teeth to mean not upset!
- Huh, and so dropping an intruiging twist: Hilda also wants to change the world.
- I like how the untranslatable word problem actually comes up with N.
- This Klink has an adorable speech pattern
- Ahh, so Leader/Follower is the two separate pieces. Which is interesting, since this thing's consciousness seems to be of a third party.
- Ah, numerals to the power of themselves.
- Interesting take on the Yin/Yang becoming Leader/Follower, even though in terms of their power it doesn't really make too much sense. And we haven't even factored in Kyurem yet.
- Ooo, an explanation for why he has a random Klingklang at the end. Although ironically for all he's presented as good, N doesn't seem to understand that a Pokemon might want to willingly help. Goes back to not understanding sacrifice.

C9
And reading this one with a...somethingache after eating KFC.

- Archen though, this one is definitely going to be telling
- Man, these N and Hilda interactions seem great
- Huh, challenger sending out Pokemon first?
- Well this is not creepy at all, the fossils calling out to each other by serial numbers
- BACK TO THE LAB AGAIN????
- Again, like the idea that understanding a Pokemon language isn't so simple, given all the different accents, dialects, and terminology
- Hilda seems surprisingly tolerant of N even if she doesn't trust him as far as she can throw him. If this wasn't a fic of yours, I could definitely see it going in a romance direction, or even a romcom
- And they just let the Tirtouga escape???
- I kind of do wonder, random thoughtcrafting even though you seem to just be ignoring anything from beyond BW in this plot: would the living fossils on the Crown Tundra speak modern? What about things like Relicanth that have been around forever?
- A dragon friend he would like? Oh no...
- Wonder how Tirtouga comes to evolve, if not through experience?
- I like to imagine Hilda just sitting there bitterly the whole time while N listens in on the fascinating story that takes half an hour to tell.
- Huh, the Great Dragon? Definitely doesn't seem to be either of the two Unovan dragons, until later shows it was all three together
- Either way, this dragon seems kind of a jerk to flood the world. Shades of the Wind Waker
- When N is hesitating to ask a question - N who doesn't know human interaction very well - you know it's going to be a juicy one.
- Yup, that's a juicy one. So juicy she gets defensive.
- Hilda is certainly this super hot blooded character who would fit in your average world, but not in this world!

C10
- I thought that was a Veilstone myth, though, and was more one against senseless killing
- A lot of old myths tend to make no sense
- Man Pokemon myths are pretty brutal, at least this one is
- Her revenge? Seems like she was more being a whimsical bitch to me, since the young boy never did anything to wrong her
- That feel when Zoroark knows about human burn degrees
- Welp here comes G-Cis
- Hasn't this Zoroark ever heard of ape does not hunt ape?
- I'd like to think it would be far harder to fool a nose than the eyes...and yup, a couple bits later there it is
- Oh the guy is actually named Blue? That's confusing since canon characters
- Now we remeet the Liepard from before, and Rhea too
- Pokemon to Pokemon trust, I suppose
- There's something amusing about turning berry names into compound words. Although I imagine it wouldn't work nice with all of them
- Man if they have a deragotry name for Zoroarks, wonder how bad actual skinchanger Ditto gets called
- Guess Plasma is a worldwide cult movement given there's protests in Hoenn too
- Kobo, Kobo, Kobo. This fox is obsessed.
- Aha, tying in to N
- But what if Pokemon never tell lies is in itself a lie? Huh???
- Was wondering if Bianca would ever show up
- Interesting way to add on to her convincing herself to give up
- The orb itself was boobytrapped!
- Oh dear, we have an identity for this thing now, N's Zorua's pissed off brother. Explains things.
- Hm well that didn't go as poorly as I thought, although man still stuck up. I guess N has doubts too though

C11
- And Iris all of a sudden? Well the last character I was expecting to show up here.
- Meh, coffee
- I guess this immediately preceeds the previous chapter
- Well I suppose Iris would be another person able to understand Pokemon, albeit maybe only dragons
- Hmhmhm, this Fraxure is familiar with Juniper
- That feel when Gym Leaders get sources to scout trainers' teams in advance
- The Fellowship of the Juniper, evidentally
- Corrin? Corn? An idiot royal from a seemingly nameless continent full of bad writing?
- Seems the Unova League was steeped in family tradition wherein only the rich and privileged could be involved.
- I do like the subtle implication that given Cheren later in canon, the League challenge is used to get new Gym Leaders
- Iris being concerned with how people dress is kind of amusing. And thinking how someone dresses is how they are...hasn't she ever met a contradiction who dresses like a bum but carries themselves well?
- I guess like N, these two are firmly on the side of Truth
- I'm guessing Fraxure's idea of human battles is basically a courtroom. I misread that intent but it's still a funny mental image of it thinking they fight with words
- Hey, I was only half joking, but it seems the League was indeed rigged all along.
- Suddenly breaking to mention that the next chapter is slightly concurrant!! Kind of sticks out, actually
- Debate about class difference. I should've seen it coming.
- Nativity debates too. Jeez.
- Iris accusing Hilda of being involved in Pokemon Liberation, when she herself is involved. Maybe it was the halfheartness. Actually, would make sense for some of the leaders to be involved.
- Hm, with that sudden rock throwing erupting into chaos, gotta wonder if it was intentional sabotage to start a riot
- I wonder what the cops would do if they pulled out Pokemon immune to tear gas and turned violent
- Heroic sacrifice!!
- Well! Drayden's kind of an ass. No wonder Iris joined Team Plasma.
- I like the idea behind the various meanings of We. But who is we?

C12
- I guess Noah was American. That seems such an American thing to do, actually.
- Yeah, we are suddenly getting biblical here. Or planning on breaking the walls down.
- The second Emolga is pretty hilarious when you put it into writing
- The eternal, everlasting carnival...
- It seems there's no apparent language for Solosis, at least not presented to the reader yet
- The Pansage? But he should have a Pansear.
- Is a bit weird for her to be using game mechanics talk like a build given this world has otherwise stayed away form those
- Man instead of ferris wheeling with a cute guy or hot guy or that one girl, she's riding with her cell Pokemon.
- Odd changeup from the games where Elesa is fourth and she uses it, but I do like acknowledgements of Gym Trainers being able to adjust their power level
- Heh, tying this into the Zoroarks
- Oh, I guess N is at the ferris wheel. From context this happened after the initial reveal there.
- Ah, so Solosis does have a language. I'm sure there are some voiceless ones out there. I mean, there are in the games.
- There's that semantic argument about liberation again. I don't get what they were going for with that insistant terminology.
- Man if this N wasn't a pure ball of kindness, asking what they'd want him to know about Hilda would be a fantastic villain line
- And just when it looks like things might work out, bam. Who would've thought a reporter would've been the one to fuck everything up?
- There's hot blooded Hilda, forcing N to make a choice.
- He isn't even trying. She's almost making him look bad. While maybe making herself look bad, if this wasn't a crazy psychotic world that accepted this.
- Suddenly, flashbacks and flashforwards. Wonder if N was somehow responsible.
- I was confused but it seems to be an evolution? Even though that normally requires a stone? Or maybe the Solosis line are simply weird like that. Might make sense given they're splitting cells.
- And the premonition of doom.

C13
- And I am reading this one hungry but not able to eat for another half hour, yet wanting to kill half an hour. So let's murder it with a Munny chapter, cha-ching. Funky intro.
- Hey, at least they get a dream smoke umbellical cord, Bianca!
- Neat connection with the spirit of the moon, since they evolve with Moon Stones
- I always like hinting at different appearances for Pokemon rather than all uniform
- I have a funny mental image now of all Pokemon reading the Pokedex and being all "what the FUCK" and going to see whoever made the dex entries
- Shoutouts to Darkrai
- Her Cheren, pretty funny misconception
- Somebody found an early Leaf Stone. Actually I think you can get one in the forest?
- INSTEAD OF AIMING WHERE HE WAS, YOU SHOULD'VE AIMED WHERE HE WAS GOING TO BE! MWAHAHAHAHAHAHA
- That feel when Pokemon use the smelly Imperial system!!
- And suddenly, kidnapping by Rhea. And don't you forget it's kidnapping.
- One chirp, two chirp, red chirp, blue chirp.
- I guess this Munna has a small - sensible - range of knowledge given it doesn't know about Chansey. Does make sense it may know about Darkrai
- Hee, having to explain potions. I guess Bianca never used one? Explanation a little later but I'd like to think some for the road would be important
- Wow, Bianca has a stalker. And I guess Bianca really did never use any healing items
- I like the small allusion to N speaking quickly.
- N being respectful as always. Too pure for a kintsugi world.
- Sudden change in tongue. I wonder how he trained himself to speak like that, since some conflections are just too hard to do so.
- Hee, making Rhea rethink her position with some mist?
- Oh it seems Bianca took the insulting words to heart eventually.
- Living yet benign dreamcatchers. The archnemesis of Drowzee. Shoutouts to Munny.

C14
- You were made to protect.An <- Aha! Was wondering if I'd find a typo during my speedreading, and did! Missing space!
- I see we got an oldtimer here
- I think this is my favorite identification among Pokemon yet, simply numbers. And making sense for them to be numbers here too since they're the five statues
- OOoo story time!
- Going back to the old myth about the flood. Is guardians of the winds/earth supposed to be about Tornadus/Landorus? Also this one aged well with the new one if so.
- I guess in this world, it's all but confirmed now that the Original Dragon was the true creator. Makes me wonder the nature of Arceus then.
- Stormdancer, pirouetting? Nice way to identify it's Meloetta without actually saying so. Same way for Aria and voice.
- Oh dear, the Hydreigon. And wow, wasn't expecting this conversation to turn so uncouth.
- N, a voice who can hear the voiceless. He is in a way the voice of the voiceless. In other words, he's raging against the machine.
- Well at least the Sigilyph isn't a prejudiced one
- There goes Pokemon never tell lies again. If that's true, I imagine they like to twist things and tell half or technical truths.
- Even in death, Meloetta is smooth.
- You know, random musings just now. Humans are being put on the EVILLL pedestal, but as evident from Zoroarks or Ghetsis' Hydreigon, territorial disputes and cruelty aren't unknown among them either.
- Hm, an interesting bit: back then, humans and Pokemon indeed could simply understand each other, until the war and Meloetta's throat got ripped out Mortal Kombat style. Intrigue!
- Shoutouts to black and white. And shoutouts to the main theme of change and the difficulty of it.
- Oho, this puts Sigilyph in an interesting position. They were made by humans. Never mind their purpose for a second, but that means they owe their existences to them. And throw in the questions being posed and...
- Give some insight into how N's heart wavers. He's asking for an ideal, even though he later becomes a hero of Truth
- Hm, an intriguing alternate ending with a different result. Given Sigilyph's history and my own conspiracy theorying/refusal to accept Pokemon are pure balls of pureness, I'm willing to bet the war thing was spread by antihuman extremists, or that the murder did happen but it happened after Meloetta had already lost her gift of Voice.
- Yeah, it's looking more likely like Pokemon aren't as pure as N thinks. Plus with all the bigotry, they might make things like this up. Since these two versions of the stories came from Pokemon and can contradict each other, somebody has to be lying.
- never her whol self <- Two typos, one chapter? Or something stylistic?
- But what ever happened to Kyurem? Besides mentions of ice, it has been noticeably absent.
- Capital letters are very important in some languages.
- It is very true that the world can only change through sacrifice. Eat the rich
- Ooo, now we're getting spicy. Stormdancer being all of these other Pokemon from the myths being told so far.

C15
- Well some Pokemon need to go through a capable or the internet to evolve, so of course they need humans to reach their full potential!!
- Hm, I wonder, did this Conk just run the hell away when it was all growed up?
- Some call him Tim.
- This dude thinking a freshly caught Pokemon is going to win him a Gym Battle. That only works on Lt. Surge!!
- Ahh, I guess the Conk's human willingly let him go. There's really all kinds in this world.
- Man imagine if Tim was illiterate. Sure would fit this world.
- Tim's Timburr is about to find out that not all humans are nice. Although a lot don't seem to realize the opposite
- Oh so it's this clown mentioned before. Also my god, his name is Tim Burr. I wouldn't want to be him on the playground, that's for sure. No wonder he's a bitter bully.
- Huh, must be some of that league bias to have the challenger go first
- What a kind Watchog, helping a fellow Poke out.
- I wonder if Lenora knows her Pokemon took a dive because that was really obvious
- Man, she fights brutal though.
- Huh, wasn't expecting him to actually win. But then again, he seems a natural borne warrior with lots of training.
- I get the feeling this Timburr simply didn't know what battle was going to entail.
- Oh hey, wasn't expecting the BLITZ to show up here. I guess it makes sense that in a full nurse setting...where simple moves are used on step above machines...there would be cross trainer Poke mingling
- Not much to say on this conversation, it's an interesting one that shows philosophical differences though
- Welp, and just when things were going well, the asshole turns out to be an asshole in a twist ending - although maybe not so much of a twist given the earlier chapter. Timburr pulled through and won and Tim Burr still beats it up!!

C16
- Ooo, I can already see where this one is going. A Purrloin who wants to join Hilda, but then joins N in the first battle against him instead.
- Oof, shot down. Kind of the opposite of what Plasma is rallying against, this is humans rejecting Pokemon who want to train them. But perhaps no different?
- Huh, y'know, I'm surprised buying Pokemon only came up now and so briefly. You'd think it'd be a more contentious issue.
- Yup, there N is. Also this Purrloin has the most adorable way of getting attention
- Her attempts to get him to notice her kind of come across as comical.
- She is surprisingly nonplussed at him being able to understand her.
- Ah, so this is Tourmaline's backstory
- Dorky N is adorkable, not knowing how to battle.
- Hilda starts attacking without seeing if N is ready. Consistent.
- Shoutouts to vine hammerspace
- Well that is quite the violent way to use Slam
- Heh, funny end to that scene, back with that annoying Pidove
- Music, huh? Wonder if the Meloetta stuff is coming up again? Certainly know Cheren is going to pop up.
- N being so friendly, even if he prolly comes across as weird.
- Hey, a little bit of B2W2 acknowledgement in Roxie
- Interesting scene, although I do get a funny mental image of the trainers going "uh wtf" when their Pokes try to sing
- Huh, so in this world, Hilda does become interested in Plasma. I mean there were signs of that, before she goes her own way in later chapters
- Interesting contrast to the previous chapter. Here the Pokemon feels humiliated by the trainer.
- With this scene about talking about the Pidove she beat up I am randomly remembering this cat we sort of adopted when I was little who killed a pretty sizeable bird and brought it back home to share. Dropped it right on the doorstep. We later found out it had a tattoo and returned it.
- Rejected again, oof. But, in this case, she seems to realize he's not the right fit. So it's more of an amiable breakup, I guess.
- And although this chapter ends with her pondering N's ways and drifting to sleep, we know she ends up with Cheren. Who I guess isn't showing up here after all.

C17
- Back to the present now I see.
- YOU SHOULD HAVE LISTENED
- Watching everything in reverse I guess does hadve a certain charm to it
- "Grats on winning, now what kind of world will you make"
- Hey maybe if he went this path, that's how the PMD world got started. But it seems he won't
- At least he didn't play shoji. Then he'd be asking why defeating someone could make you force them to fight for you
- Forgoing truth and ideals, for a path of understanding...
- Ahh, interesting twist, it does sometimes take a major event to steel resolve
- And Hilda's back on her feet and suddenly talking philosophical history. I guess we never saw her side of the story much
- Only now does the question come up to N that Pokemon chose to partner with humans for good reason. To think.
- SIIIIIIING
O?
- And the twist, a new world is shaped, one where humans and Pokemon have a chance to live as better equals, and N has...ascended to a higher plane of existence. Sacrifice.
- They say he's alive, but lost his Voice. Whatever happened, he probably got Gainexed.
- And the role of making sure this crapsack world doesn't crumble to pieces under everything else falls onto one person. Good lord, they're doomed.
- With the storm being brought up at the end, it makes me wonder how it happened in the first place. Hmhmhm...

Okay, blitzed through. So let's summarize my thoughts.

Now I made the joke about this being a kintsugi fic several times, but that actually is tied into the biggest issue I saw. This world you've created has a lot more problems than people mistreating Pokemon or not giving them a say in the matter. When you see things like police brutality, the attitude towards good television, the formal hierarchal nature of the Unovan League and its sponsorships, or the tangled web of bureaucracy for trainers - people not being able to give Pokemon a choice almost ends up taking a backseat at times. The world has a lot further to go than this one issue being solved, and it's doubtful they can overcome it.

In the afterword, you went on what's basically a huge rant against the Unovan games' - indeed - black and white storytelling that leaves no room for misinterpretation or compromise, no room for a third option in the matter. And yeah, you're most certainly right - can't quite have deep morality in a game that is effectively a power fantasy in some regards, it instead ends up more about might being right. However, there's a difference therein between your fic and B&W. The latter is super optimistic and idealistic, and the former is pessimistic and crapsack. They're at such extremes that it kind of removes any moral grayness. Just like how change and the logic behind it is insane in B&W, the world in envy of eden is so bad that change has to happen. In an unusual sense, that same dichotomy is there, coming down to complacency in a broken system vs working to fix it. It's difficult to see N as anything but a hero here, dragging people kicking and screaming into progress no matter how painful change might be - and in the end his doubts leading to making the ultimate sacrifice. If that was your point though, well done! I'd say if you were to write it again though, it would probably be best to downtone if not at least downplay the rest of the world's issues besides the human/Pokemon relationship - it would be more streamlined, you'd have more room to explore things like Pokemon trading/buying that never came up, and the ending would certainly be more hopeful with far less for the world to overcome.

That aside, there's a lot more good than there is bad here. You do a lot to make each species of Pokemon feel distinct, rather than having them all be mostly the same as PMD fics often do. You built up an intriguing world and even though you went a little far in other places, the world you made did a lot to give credence to the other side of the issue. What's more, it's clear there's many different opinions from the human and Pokemon side of things. The world indeed, is not black and white.

I'm also a big fan of the style. I like experimental/different styles of writing, and it doesn't get much different than second person and being told backwards. Add in the different species of Pokemon being different, and even individual chapters are really unique! You also did a good job of reworking N and Hilda's characters in particular to make the former more humane and the latter more flawed. Some of the philosophical questions posed are good ones for Pokemon, even though it really exposes how much the concept can crumble if you think about it too hard. And hey, major plus, it wasn't horribly unbearably dark!

About the only other problem I had was the holes from canon to the story - from the minor and silly like the fairy type to Kyurem seemingly just not existing - but this is as much a good thing. It makes one ask questions. Even if it seems sometimes you simply yeeted anything that didn't fit your vision. It's not a bad thing to exclude some of the things: the opposite extreme is trying to cram in the whole legendary pantheon and we all know how that goes. It was different is what I'm saying!

Finally, the ending was solid. It was a good answer as to how to solve the issue posed in Black and White without leaning to one or the other extreme. And hey, an ending that could be happyish is certainly better than most of your fics! We get enough depression out of the real world anyway. All in all, while this story has some flaws that stick out, I overall liked it and felt it was worth my time. Even if I did only do it to meme in your face when it seemed you were going to be a CHICKEN.
 
Okay. Long time coming on this, but what's new. I think I've re-read the first six-ish chapters of this four or five times now, and I finally got around to actually reading the rest of the fic too. We have already talked at length about all sorts of things pertaining to this story, so I'll try not to repeat too much. I definitely think that reading it once the whole thing was posted was the way to go. This story relies pretty heavily on remembering and understanding the themes and events of previous chapters, otherwise the whole thing starts to come apart at the seams. And it's also kind of impossible to really judge it until knowing the end.

I guess I'll start with the reverse chronological format then since that's related. In most stories you only really need to have a vague idea of the events that got you to where you are now in order to understand and appreciate the story on its own merits. For this, the actual events that happened in previous chapters are mostly irrelevant. You need to recall and understand the ideas from the earlier chapters in order for the story to continue to make sense. You've said your intent with this style is instead of "where is this going to go?" it's "how did we get here?" This ultimately means readers have to be constantly conscious of where these characters and concepts are going (that is, what they have already read) otherwise they completely lose the thread of the story. In most stories, if I left for a while and came back, I could reread a couple earlier chapters to get a reminder of how we got to the current point I'm at, and they will inherently offer hints at things that happened in even earlier chapters in the way of references and simple causality (eg: Senori's a Furret? Oh right, he evolved!). If I came back to this after a few months and picked up on Chapter 7, rereading Chapter 6 would provide no reminders about what happened in Chapters 1-5. And this matters because what is actually happening at any given moment in this story is less important than what it's trying to say. Tourmaline looking for a trainer isn't the point, the point is how looking for a trainer led to her realizing battling is stupid and joining Plasma (which ultimately got her shunted to Cheren, a "powerful trainer"). But if you forgot what she becomes then it loses its impact.

So that was super ramble-y and didn't even get to any of the actual feedback that I really wanted to give on the reverse chronological storytelling, but what I'm really trying to say here is that this story requires a huge IQ to understand benefits a lot from paying close attention and reading start to finish before making judgements. Also it's the ultimate in "it'll make sense later" justifications.

Now for some actual feedback rather than just word vomit. I have mixed feelings about telling the story backwards. At first it didn't seem to add anything at all. This isn't Memento. It's not like there's a mystery that will be solved by knowing the beginning after seeing the end. In fact, it made the beginning kind of boring, despite the fact that climactic events were happening. I didn't care about the characters (because I never got to be a part of their journey/development), and I felt like I didn't really need to understand how and why we got here. I already knew how. I've played B&W before, and references and causality filled in the gaps. And I already knew why. These characters were pretty clear in their motivations. But over time I started to come around. It's about where those motivations came from, and why they are resorting to the actions they are.

Then I read Chapter 16, which is mostly just about a little concert in the park. And that's when I really got it. This was the simple, sweet way that N had originally tried to get his point across. It was the beginning of his arc, which ultimately resulted in him/his people resorting to some awful things. But also, more importantly, it was a very simple example of the world he wanted to bring about. Despite all the conflict on the horizon, despite all the terrible things people and Pokemon were going to eventually do to each other, here was a collection of trainers and Pokemon and Plasma alike, sitting around and enjoying a Minccino singing a love song. The whole point of the story, including why it had been told in this order, hit me like a train. And then in the last chapter:

“In our struggles we have forgotten how we were once one, how we once stood for a world that could be beautiful because of its flaws, not despite them”
This line just straight up said what I had realized only a few thousand words before. Specifically "we have forgotten." If the story had been told any other way, this whole arc would have felt different. So yeah, I came around on it I think. I still feel like I had trouble connecting to any of the characters due to not being able to follow them through their journeys, but I suppose that's not really the point. Makes me glad I'm not trying to do a "Characters" score for the awards or something lol.

Speaking of characters, let's talk about language. Telling each chapter from a different perspective was a very "you" move. Although it kinda got in the the way of me becoming really emotionally connected to any of the individual characters, it added a lot to the story. A story like this deserves a multitude of opinions, perspectives, and subjective ideas, which different POVs does really well. And then the fact that the end of the story involved literally giving Pokemon voices made the whole thing come together. But yeah, language. I loved how each narrator had their own distinct voice and narrative style. Informed not only by their character but also by their species. It was always fun to see how different Pokemon interacted with and saw the world. The trouble comes with legibility or lack thereof. For the most part I was able to discern what was going on, which characters were being referenced, what Pokemon the narrator was looking at. But I can't help but admit that it did add a layer of complexity to an already hard to follow format (not to mention your penchant for heavily metaphoric language). The biggest offender here was Chapter 10 for me. I read it twice in a row and I still wasn't able to parse what was going on. Like I understood the events of the chapter, but I still have no idea what exactly the "gift" was or "different faces" or why Inari's brother was different when he returned. Or even where he went or what he did. Like N was raised by them? Briefly? Maybe? And Kodo took him back to civilization? But decided to always be an illusion? For reasons I still don't get? I don't know. Maybe it makes sense for a Zoroark's narration to be full of illusory metaphors which may or may not be true. None of the philosophical character stuff made much sense to me. Getting confused by all that really made the chapter fall flat for me.

Me for the entire story: Wait so if Reshiram gives N the power to make a truthy world where humans and Pokemon are separate, why can't Hilda just use Zekrom to make an ideal world
Me at the end: oh lmao

Chapter 6 doesn't have a little pixel icon. Don't know if that's on purpose. Also the little 'n' at the end of Chapter 8 doesn't have a link.

“See, they know each other!” N exclaims, cutting into your thoughts.

“Who?” Hilda’s probably a little less confused than you, which at the moment makes her very bewildered. “N, what’s going on?”
Is Hilda supposed to be dumb or is this just to drive home how she actively refuses to see Pokemon as people? Like later in the story (and therefore earlier in the timeline) she seems much more understanding/accepting of the fact that N can talk to Pokemon. What happened? Like this behavior would make more sense later on, but at this point in her journey I gotta believe she's used to this with N.

The cylinder lodges between the chinks in its reddish armor, and then it begins seeping burning-hot gas while the scolipede shrieks in pain, bucking around wildly.
A group of five—three humans, a liepard, a scolipede—goes past on the sidewalk across the street, their shouts muffled by the cars.
I really liked these small connections to previous chapters. But this one makes me wonder if this:

That’s the tricky part, you decide now that you’re no longer in the back room next to the venipede who hissed as an audino dabbed salve on his burnt thorax
-should be a Scolipede instead? Although I may be getting my locations mixed up (I'm gonna be real I don't remember all the different Unova cities).

Is she afraid she’ll betray you like Elesa? You could never do that to her.
I think some words are mixed up here. I don't really understand what it's saying. Elesa betrayed Jericho? Hilda betrayed Elesa? Or is 'Elesa' simply referring to the gym battle (which we didn't see so I'm still struggling to connect the dots)?

followed by some enormous, floating, rainbow bird that you’ve never seen before
Ah, Ho-oh’s here.

at this point correcting her would be terribly rude and you don’t want to bother her.
same

The Rhea motions with her head.
Is this supposed to be a psychic thing? She hasn’t actually introduced herself as Rhea at this point.

“My Lord N!”
You can take Plasma out of the goofy costumes, but the idea of these pseudo-anarchist Pokémon liberators referring to their leader as “my lord” will still be hilarious to me.

“She says that your trainer battles with you until you faint a lot.”
This almost implies that it stops being as abusive if you win? Like losing battles is the real problem and is why Bianca was targeted? Team Plasma's really over here like "git gud nerd"

You float closer to Rhea
Only time it’s not “the Rhea” but I dunno if that's on purpose.

just like every other time she’s asked you to protect her
It’s implied a few times in this chapter that Bianca has been giving Munny her nightmares on purpose, but we never really see any evidence of that (and it sounds like a weird thing for Bianca to do given how she doesn’t seem to fully understand how this stuff functions until reading the dex entry).

And then she’s already sweeping away, muttering under her breath, just a child how could they possibly—
The use of italics instead of quotation marks feels incorrect here, but I can't say for sure.

You know he wooed your mother by stacking stones taller than the oldest pine tree until they formed a spire in her craggly image, with his twin concrete columns at the base.
furiously scribbles notes

that comes from our ancient word for alone. The translation is imperfect,
Italics spill over here.
 
Last edited:
All right you. Even though you actually did participate in the review challenge thereby ruining the punchline I had in mind. Yet still, I am finishing with a massive twofold bang. I pushed myself to the absolute limit, reading this over the course of the whole challenge, and succeeded. Let's do some reading, pick this back up, and go all the way to the end of this thing, because I am COURAGEOUS!! (and a little crazy)
[...]
Even if I did only do it to meme in your face when it seemed you were going to be a CHICKEN.
Thank you for stopping by; I really appreciate it. In my old age I really was stupid enough to believe that "post in this thread to declare your intent to enter, or be a chicken" + [posting a chicken] -> [declaring intent to enter], but I'm well-aware of how little sense that actually makes. Regardless of the reasons that brought you here though, I'm both impressed and flattered that you took the time to read this through to the end, and I'm sorry for the clouded intent caused by my poor communication.

And, on a broader point, I really respect your thoughts here and the time you took to write them all out. Of all my stories, this one is easily the most forceful and least subtle in making its spicy takes (and it's a pretty tight competition for that spot; my writing is often preachy at best and I know that), and historically it's ruffled some feathers--so as someone who often struggles to separate my personal views from objective criticism when trying to write reviews, I'm very appreciative of how you approached the story on its own terms despite the general mismatch with your own headcanons. From a purely learning standpoint on review-writing I learned a lot from reading this (in addition to the fact that it's a detailed review for my story), which I think is neat. Sorry it took me so long to finally do responses here.

[as a general note--the reaction notes per-chapter are super helpful + I'm still doing overall tweaks to the story. I haven't pushed those updates to the forums yet and I won't respond to each one to save you some time lol, but again, highly appreciated.]

C2 - Wait now I'm confused. Alder was down to his last Pokemon, now he's suddenly using more?
How much can it take to open one door?
  • In this setting there's a difference between [technical knockout] and [could feasibly, if compelled to, recover enough to try to save someone's life], but I agree that isn't super clear!
  • There's a few throwaway lines about how Ghetsis's cofagrigus is keeping things out with Trick Room, but given that that's in one line and also not the traditional use of Trick Room, I see how that's not really a natural conclusion. Going to mull on how to convey these two points better.

C3 - I do like the concept of Pokemon not knowing other species' names that humans have given, and in fact would use it myself if ever going wild Pokemon persepctive.
- Fair warning, having gone big on this, it does get really confusing for some readers and I find my writing has to get really telegraphy with the epithets as a result. Definitely fun to try, but god I wish sometimes I could just namedrop some species.
C3 - Interesting that you had Cheren choose the one weak to the protagonist's starter here.
tbh this was a mistake, but yeah, let's call it large-brained foreshadowing about the inverseness of the AU

C4 - Ahh, I see it now, we're going full Pokemon perspective except for the first chapter. Hey! Why didn't N get an icon for his chapter!?
  • A bit of Poke-racism with hating on being raised in a cage
  • Sponsorship??? I guess in this world, Britain took over and pushed their ways on everyone?
  • I forgot to find one
  • I find that people punch down a lot! Especially in a world where pokemon are dehumanized, I was interested in how they'd view themselves/each other as a result.
  • The sponsorship thing is something I've kicked around well before Galar tbh, what with the trend of professors singling out between one and three children to give super rare starters that aren't seen anywhere else, although I certainly borrowed a bit from Sw/Sh. It's definitely not hashed out in this fic or in canon, but I don't think it'd be super unrealistic that Galar and Unova in particular have some overlap in cultural values/economic systems.

C5 - You know it's a shitty world of a kintsugi fic when Pokemon violently turning on their trainers is a common occurance
This was actually an addition late in the story (like, late enough that there are versions that were published to Bulbagarden that don't have it)! I had several early readers express confusion that pokemon wouldn't just murder their trainers in this world since it's so shitty. Personally I'm not a huge fan of trainer murder (I just also an equal un-fan of pokemon murder), nor do I think it's really necessary that individuals have to resort to murder in order to validly show their discontent with their situation or whatever, but conceptually I think it's interesting to explore--since ultimately trainer murder via pokemon doesn't fix things systematically and is still pretty horrifying since it's usually kids getting beaned in gruesome ways. Though I think in this story pokemon murdering their trainers wouldn't be super common, which is why it only really happens in this one incident and everyone is pretty shocked and horrified.

C6 - Ah, that might explain the nickname a little. Respect might do it, but I still think it's out of character
  • You know this far in I have to question, how long has this been going on and if Pokemon hated it for so long why hasn't revolution ever happen? Who even set the so-called rules?
  • I like to think that he's pretending fairies simply don't exist when he's alluding to their weaknesses
  • Ghetsis is definitely not in-character in this fic, and probably the most egregious of the changes I've made lol. I think "corrupting activist movements against their original intents" was still an interesting concept to explore, but this version of the story didn't really have much room for "AND THEN I, I MEAN TEAM PLASMA, SHALL KILL EVERYONE, I MEAN, PET THE NICE POKEMON". But Ghetsis's abject hamminess is like 1000% of his character and I get that, lmao; this is mostly just a guy who has a similar outfit to him and maybe liberated his pokemon.
  • Same reasons revolutions tend to happen relatively infrequently in human history compared to the amount of overall unpleasantness/hatred, I think. A more serious answer, though--I think people are usually optimistic that things will get better without bloodshed/burning everything to the ground; and those who aren't, tend to have limited resources and ability to organize the bloodshedening and the burnening. Drayden in BW2 implies that the introduction of pokeballs is relatively recent in Unova: "When I was little, Poké Balls didn't exist yet. Sometimes Pokémon would run away from awful Trainers who didn't try to understand them." -- 'would' being a word that's doing a weird amount of lifting here. So in this setting, where pokeballs were both recently invented and don't allow the pokemon to leave willingly, there's a ton of destabilization happening over the course of more or less one human generation, and a lot of volatile changes as a result. And again, this is all stemming from some personal beliefs on why revolutions happen and one (1) line of dialogue from the incredibly obscure Memory Link feature, so very much not clear in the fic as stands + something I'll tweak to address.
  • I didn't really have time to work in the reintroduction of fairies into this, but tbh, yeah, that sounds pretty accurate for this situation

C7 - Hm, and here I thought it was the LAPD, not the NYPD, who were infamous for police brutality. She was standing down.
  • I have no idea what to make of the Gym Leader running the city and letting open challenges happen everywhere besides "kintsugi fic"
  • So uh is she propping herself up as a kidnapper instead of a thief?
  • With all the licensing stuff and limitations, I feel it's injecting a lot of buruecracy into the world. It's interesting to think about, but going too far you can see just how much real world stuff doesn't work with the Pokemon world...
  • Depends who you ask tbh
  • This is admittedly a darker take, but at the same time Clay also does just yeet the drawbridge up to prevent anyone from getting into Driftveil because he's trying to stop crime, and then he has a bunch of kids go storm all the occupants of a warehouse to stop more crime (holding the player's right to challenge his gym hostage until they do so)--there's definitely light ways to interpret "if you meet a trainer's eyes you gotta battle", but gym leaders having an active role in their cities' social circles is a pretty common take I think! I just, yeah, run it to a dark extreme.
  • Honestly, yeah. Rhea isn't written with what I would say is effective rhetoric--she's earnest and well-intentioned but she's quite bad at changing minds. I didn't want to portray Plasma as completely flawless, and this kind of talking past each other is a pretty common shortcoming in these kinds of debates. In this case the point of "kidnapping is for people; theft is for property" is because she wants Cheren to see pokemon as people rather than property--but she fails quite spectacularly in changing hearts here, and he rips her apart for admitting to kidnapping lol.
  • It definitely doesn't work here! I admit the lighter interpretation of "let's just trust everyone to be nice and responsible when catching pokemon" is one that I have fond nostalgia for; it's just one that I think requires dramatically smarter protagonists/humans in general for society to survive more than half a generation. And I do love writing idiot protagonists, so here we are.

C8 - This Klink has an adorable speech pattern
  • Ooo, an explanation for why he has a random Klingklang at the end. Although ironically for all he's presented as good, N doesn't seem to understand that a Pokemon might want to willingly help. Goes back to not understanding sacrifice.
  • They talk in sentences that are six words long, yeah! Because, at least for this klink, each gear has six teeth and things need to line up with that. This was an incredibly stupid limitation to place upon myself but for once it didn't completely ruin me.
  • Imo a pretty major shortcoming of N, and one that I focused on a lot for this story, is his doubt. Which in this case, like you say, fuels his inability to understand and accept pokemon willingly putting themselves in his hands.

C9 - I kind of do wonder, random thoughtcrafting even though you seem to just be ignoring anything from beyond BW in this plot: would the living fossils on the Crown Tundra speak modern? What about things like Relicanth that have been around forever?
  • I like to imagine Hilda just sitting there bitterly the whole time while N listens in on the fascinating story that takes half an hour to tell.
  • Lmao, my thoughtcrafting on fossil pokemon is actually super thin (how long ago were they around? was it millions of years ago, meaning that it makes actually zero sense that this one would believe that the world was created by a really big dragon ten thousand years ago?). Depends on how they got to the Crown Tundra though! I think if, like relincanth, they'd been hanging around for a while and were social with other creatures, they'd probably have the chance to pick up the modern dialects. Conversely I also think there'd probably be several ocean dialects alone and it's not unlikely that relincanth/deep dwellers would probably have their own and rarely interact with the surface--there's a reason there's no water episode here.

C10 - I thought that was a Veilstone myth, though, and was more one against senseless killing
  • But what if Pokemon never tell lies is in itself a lie? Huh???
  • This chapter definitely has some revisions pending to tie the myths and main plot together--like you say, the morals don't really work out.
  • Honestly that's pretty true--personally I think that that line is not compatible with a world in which pokemon behave as people and make their own choices/morality. And in this case, objectively I think N's phrasing this poorly. But someone saying "pokemon wouldn't lie about their condition and we should trust them when they speak instead of just guessing what we think is happening" and then promptly having that get shortened to "pokemon wouldn't lie" via media bits and going viral isn't entirely unlikely.

C11 - Iris being concerned with how people dress is kind of amusing. And thinking how someone dresses is how they are...hasn't she ever met a contradiction who dresses like a bum but carries themselves well?
- I definitely think she has, and she was also once one of those people--she just found that the society that she operates in doesn't look too kindly on that kind of contradiction.

C12
  • There's that semantic argument about liberation again. I don't get what they were going for with that insistant terminology.
  • I was confused but it seems to be an evolution? Even though that normally requires a stone? Or maybe the Solosis line are simply weird like that. Might make sense given they're splitting cells.
  • I think the closest analogue would be the difference in people who think that freeing slaves is liberating them from their masters vs the people who think that freeing slaves is stealing them from their masters. It's definitely a charged argument and one that makes trainers defensive, which is on the long list of why I think Plasma didn't have much traction with that phrase here.
  • I think solosis line is just a level evolution actually! For once I didn't just bend canon to my absolute will.

C14 - Hm, an intriguing alternate ending with a different result. Given Sigilyph's history and my own conspiracy theorying/refusal to accept Pokemon are pure balls of pureness, I'm willing to bet the war thing was spread by antihuman extremists, or that the murder did happen but it happened after Meloetta had already lost her gift of Voice.
  • It is very true that the world can only change through sacrifice. Eat the rich
  • Ooo, now we're getting spicy. Stormdancer being all of these other Pokemon from the myths being told so far.
  • I like myths as storytelling tools for more or less this reason, as they're good at making the literal kind of metaphorical, but also the actual literal events get lost. Pokemon trying to steal Meloetta's voice is totally on the table here--the myth only says "king". N makes an assumption about the king being human, but that's certainly not the only one.
  • there's no eat emoji but lol
  • This chapter is more or less trying to be a dramatic climax in a story where I literally hamstrung the ability to have dramatic climaxes through obfuscatingly ass-backwards storytelling, so I'm glad that it lands well.

C16 - With this scene about talking about the Pidove she beat up I am randomly remembering this cat we sort of adopted when I was little who killed a pretty sizeable bird and brought it back home to share. Dropped it right on the doorstep. We later found out it had a tattoo and returned it.
- This is incredible.

Just like how change and the logic behind it is insane in B&W, the world in envy of eden is so bad that change has to happen. In an unusual sense, that same dichotomy is there, coming down to complacency in a broken system vs working to fix it. It's difficult to see N as anything but a hero here, dragging people kicking and screaming into progress no matter how painful change might be - and in the end his doubts leading to making the ultimate sacrifice. If that was your point though, well done! I'd say if you were to write it again though, it would probably be best to downtone if not at least downplay the rest of the world's issues besides the human/Pokemon relationship - it would be more streamlined, you'd have more room to explore things like Pokemon trading/buying that never came up, and the ending would certainly be more hopeful with far less for the world to overcome.
I think, and this does boil a bit down to intent/"if that was your point"--I think a story of "is it a bad idea to buy/trade pokemon without their consent", at least in the way that I would immediately interpret it, would end pretty quickly with "yeah, that's trafficking". I could probably swing it as a oneshot or trust it to someone else with less extreme worldbuilding takes instead, but for me the story would be pretty short and even more one-sided. I was interested if there were ways to have characters who aren't objectively doing things that are bad (or at least wouldn't be considered bad in a generous fanfic/fandom setting), yet still be at moral odds with each other. I think people tend to receive Hilda/Cheren/Bianca/the miscellaneous human takes here as pretty ambiguously evil, but truthfully I think they're just people doing what they were told was okay. They have no way of communicating with their pokemon and literally cannot be privy to most of the sentiments expressed in these chapters, and they aren't really given information to make things right. It doesn't make them right of course, but I think I could probably do a rewrite of this story from Hilda/Cheren/Bianca's perspective instead, and have that pass off as pretty traditional trainerfic (with a lot of pokemon thoughts and motivations omitted/not translated, and Plasma just flapping around their hands about "liberation" and "kidnapping" without the fic ever getting to the roots of personhood).

It's definitely not my most subtle work though, and "make everyone less comically stupid/oblivious/evil" is pretty high on my rewrite priorities, since it does lead to a pretty telegraphed moral like you say.

Again, thanks for your review. Really appreciated hearing your thoughts here, and I'm glad that it ended up being enjoyable to you! Hope you enjoyed your KFC.
 
I am here once more.

(Side note: got a bit jumbled while reading. This tab kept scrolling up randomly when I clicked to a different tab, and so I kind of got lost in terms of where I last left off. All good now. I am no longer lost. Or should I say... there are no synonyms that start with n.)

I need to go north.
Am I gonna cry

This seems to get Ico’s attention once more. {Ambrella,} he corrects.

{My name is Tourmaline,} says Tourmaline, looking firmly at you. {Cheren calls me what he wants. He will call you what he wants as well. Best decide now which one you want to keep.}
I like it when fics explore Pokémon nicknames, and the difference between a name given by a parent and one given by a Trainer, and what each one means to a Pokémon.

{Cheren caught many boldore before he found you. If he’s kept you around this long it probably means you’re strong in the ways he wants.} There’s something infecting Tourmaline’s voice now. It reminds you of rot. {Ico says he’s … particular like that, with those of us he chooses to keep.}
Something something game mechanics something something themes of power something something this line hits and I can't pinpoint an academic/logical reason why. Sometimes my brain just latches onto

Her skin, too, is like nothing you’ve ever seen. It’s fur-clad like the webspinners, but where they were golden, she is like a gemstone. One of your kind was born different; the rocks of his body were not the bold colors of ore and gold, but were a deep, vibrant—you aren’t sure what word to use for the color. It is between clear sky and blood. That is her color.
Shiny Pokémon???

The biotites let you speak to the earth. Inside each crystal is the potential for great strength, but you must be careful with it. Use the power too callously and the earth may punish you for it. She doesn’t do it directly, no: she lets you take as much from her as you want. But if you take too much, she will forsake her structure and collapse on top of you. You ask for the earth’s help as a last resort; otherwise, you solve your problems without her help.
Rock religion good (or is it more rock spirituality?)

You don’t want to. Your last human understood that, so this one will as well. You let a fraction of the power flood through you; your biotites glow a faint orange. One of the baby rocks glows in response, calling to you, listening to you call back.

Yes, it certainly feels like granite. {Pardon me,} you tell the rock.

The rock hums back and moves where you ask it to.
Ahhhhhh omgomg omg I need to know about this last human and what happened to them.

“Vaselva! Leaf Blade!”
Where did this quote go why did it quote here why did I quote this and where did it go where did it goooooo

“Hilda’s off to challenge the Elite Four. We’re a long way from being ready for the League,” he says at last.
...Oh no. This reverse chronological order makes certain things hit different.

{How can we fix this?} you ask instead, gesturing wide with your shoulders, which are still healing from where the zebstrika lanced a hole six inches deep with a bolt of lightning. You saw Cheren’s tears and his frustration after your loss, even when he tried to make sure no one was watching. He hurt too, in a language that had no words. And you could see it, as clear as the dwebble’s shell. It makes you sad to look at, but it doesn’t make him right.

{You don’t.}

That’s not a good answer. Rocks are patient. Sometimes they take a hundred years to move. But even if it takes them a century, they still move. {We have to.}
An interesting thing brought up in this chapter: throughout this fic, we see a lot of Pokémon and human communicating—or rather, the failure for them to communicate. But here, we see a failure of Pokémon and Pokémon communication. (I almost went into a rambling here, but then I realized I was speaking on midnight brain thoughts and probably made zero sense).

You expect laughter, like Maxis. But Tourmaline stays quiet. In a soft voice, she says, {My last human felt like you do. She couldn’t hear my spoken words, but she could hear the unspoken ones. She and I worked together to free pokémon like you. Like me.} Her tail coils tightly around her feet, hugging herself close. {I will go back to her one day. She was a good human. But until then—Cheren is a necessary evil. I dream of clawing his face off at night, but I also know he is not the worst trainer in Unova. Some of the trainers we rescued pokémon from were truly vile. Cheren is merely a fool. If I stay with him I cannot be caught by someone else.}
:oops::oops::oops:

They are not opposites. You learned that as a young blitzle. They are two halves of the same whole. There is no single moment when the thunderstorm ceases to exist and the white clouds return. They are one cycle, joined to one another as firmly as your hooves meet your legs.
It's easy to see the Legendaries of each game as opposites, but in actuality they feel more like this, more like interconnected aspects. Because the land needs the sea, and both need the sky. The natural order follows life and destruction. Red and Blue are... colours.

they do shed not rain, but ice.
The "do" feels a bit weird here

He told you this back in Mistralton, before you speared his sigilyph with a bolt of lightning and sent her tumbling to the earth. Things could be different. He understood what Hilda strove to protect, but he sought a different world. Pokémon no longer had to be strong in order to protect humans. You no longer had to put your body on the line to keep Hilda safe from the storm. Humans had grown past the time where they needed their siblings to risk themselves; what humans asked for now was mere entertainment and pleasure.
Ooooh seeing the trainer/mon dynamic as protected/protector is interesting.

The death is brutal, but it only lasts a few moments. Hilda, in seeking kindness, made that suffering last for months.
Same "where did this go", but also in general, oof. Hilda seems to have good intentions, but she either doesn't understand her Pokémon or chooses not to, and if she did speak to her Pokémon, maybe things would have turned out differently.

But humans pick the strongest. If you grit your teeth through a broken leg, if you remain impassive through a barrage of flames, you are more desirable. You become their rock. Strength will protect you from liepard and make you vulnerable to human hunters instead.
This... ouch...

A PARTIAL TRUTH IS NO BETTER THAN A LIE.

You shudder, and the klinklang and N do as well.

The stone falls, inert and silent, into N’s outstretched hand.

You exhale. He was judged and he fell short. Of course he was. What else could he be?
Partial truth???? PARTIAL TRUTH????? Omg

You look at Reylin with betrayal twisting your stomach. He wasn’t even part of the team. He barely spoke. When he fought, he gave up when the pain was too much. But when the chance to flee appears, he doesn’t even hesitate to leave you behind.

Anger floods through you now. You can’t show the hurt, not without appearing weak to Hilda, so you let it out the only way you know how, the only way that’ll still show you’re still strong. Another bolt of electricity lances from your mane. You aim for the archeops without Hilda even having to tell you; N can’t get off the tower without wings.
I have a feeling we're getting a Reylin POV chapter, but also I just hhhhhh themes of communication and how not even teammates communicate

I guess like... coming out of this chapter, communication. Like, how well characters communicate their feelings and opinions and justifications, how well they understand each other, and what the best way of communication even is. Like, how well does N even understand Pokémon? He can speak with them, he can see their pain, but he doesn't really seem able to see why a Pokémon would want to stay with humans, no matter how good or not good that reason is. He only sees why Pokémon and humans should be separate. Is that his "partial truth"? He can only see part of the bigger picture? Guess we'll see in later chapters.

Oh yeah and last night I wrote a whole thing about communication between Pokémon, but I realized it probably made zero sense because I was speaking on "Torchic go to sleep" brian. But screw it. Take the thing:

Okay so like something something there are predator-prey dynamics, but Pokémon sometimes work together as well, but that's not easy if you don't speak the same language, so at the very least, there have to be pidgins between different species.

Because like, it's possible that certain mons can't make certain sounds because no mouth/different mouth (this is the one part that stuck out to me reading Star Wars books for kids: Chewbacca can understand Basic, but Wookies can't make the sounds that are required to speak Basic), so like... hm... pidgin would have to have sounds common between the two mons. Well, it's possible to be able to understand a language without speaking it—but that relies on both parties knowing both languages on a level of speaking and being able to speak their native language.

And like, Water types live around Water types, and Route 1 mons live around Route 1 mons. So, like, would a Caterpie be able to speak with a Quagsire? Are Pokémon societies globalized on the level than human societies are? How does the training system affect Pokémon language?

But also, that's imposing human views on language onto Pokémon. Also, you're making no sense Torchic.


But yeah, good stuff so far. Makes me think a lot about Pokémon rights in a way that I think will help with writing and stuff. Very good stuff.
 
Throws Cecilia's non-existent helmet at you: Oh hai, Kin didn't see you there messing around with this helmet that should belong to Cecilia. Bit weird to be here, especially since well it's concluded and you're usually my most frequent reviewer behind SE and Nori (somehow). So figure with the review event, I'll pay you back a bit by reviewing this since I've been waiting to read this a bit. This will be a review of End and Nominal, the prologue and Chapter 1.

First off, N is a wonderful character to get into the headspace of since he thinks so differently then most people, regardless of what people think he may have (I think a common theory is that he is on the spectrum) due to his upbringing among Pokémon and Ghetsis being father of the year....at the Razzies. Plus with his ability to speak with Pokémon, he can effectively Double Speak every conversation like he was a Orwellian creation instead of a Pokémon character. I've always wanted to work with N and always considered doing a one-shot in Orre: The Desert of all things where my character encounters him with no clue of who he is, so reading this could be the trigger I need to throw him into the desert.

Now, actual stuff. Love that the prologue is at the end, The Beginning is always at The End they say or The End is truly the beginning. Like how it shows that in the end N "wins" which I presumes is when he defeated Alder unless I misunderstood and N actually wins in this fic (then oh shit, N watch then Ghetsis will murder you). I do love how he realized his victory was pretty much hollow since what does he accomplish in the end? Though I'm iffy on the Pokémon never lie part, since we have had Pokémon straight up lie in other media and considering Ghost-Types fluctuating lore and N being able to communicate with them, I do believe we should be wary about this statement.

The first real chapter was honestly not expecting us to start at Relic Castle. But I do find it interesting that we start here especially since he already has Reshiram, so him recounting the tales now is something unless we are starting backwards and ending at the beginning which is noir (the genre not the anime), not something I would expect. Though Hilda being there, Chuggaaconroy's Let's Play kinda ruin the name for me thanks to his impressions of Hilbert and Hilda (plus his Garbordor named Hilbert stealing the show) so it kinda takes some seriousness out of it for me but I'll push through it! Like I said before it N's abilities basically let him have two conversations or even double speak basically to people and Pokémon, which he does here with Hilda and her Serperior with him talking more to the latter than the former. Do like how Pokémon speech is slightly different from the normal text thanks to the brackets. Though the surprise change to second person really got me, it's a dynamic move to make and it really works in the mind of Vaselva. Almost confused it for N in a quick moment when I realized wait no, that's wrong.

Anyways, I really like these first two parts of the greater story and will be looking forward to reading the rest when I get a chance. Thank you for the good read and I'll see you around the Discord.
 
Okay so it turns out that maybe multitasking while reading was a mistake, because my laptop kept doing weird scrolly stuff and I thought I was okay but whoops I skipped two chapters. At times like this, I’m glad the little sprites are there, or I probably would have never figured it out.

Okay Hydreigon chapter first and Bisharp chapter later:

The angle you took with Ghetsis’s Hydregion is interesting. What’s unique about Ghetsis is that he’s the only villain whose Pokémon know the move Frustration—so the assumption can be made that he abuses his Pokémon. But here, that lack of friendship… points? Stats? Is explained by a lack of respect. Zahhak is only here because Ghetsis gives them what they want: power and bloodshed. In turn, Ghetsis gets an intimidating ally. It’s a transactional relationship with nothing deeper, and honestly it really works.

Zahhak’s different perspective on things really plays into N’s ambitions well. They can challenge N’s plans in a way that few really can. And the subversive tale they tell really highlights a running theme of… subversiveness. Words are fun. But it’s like, Zahhak has a very different and unconventional way of looking at things, which helps to call up questions and solutions in other characters. It’s a good dynamic. It’s good stuff.
 
"Torchic needs to catch up on the chapters they missed" part two

Okay I have a few disjointed thoughts so I'll get typo stuff out of the way first:
but the man sounds snide when adds
missing a "he" after "when"

Trainer was a bad pretender at being a Queen.
The wording of this is a tad odd. Maybe "Trainer was bad at pretending to be a Queen"?

{It’s what I wanted him to do for me,} you said quietly.
...Fuck I might cry.

With that being said: holy shit this is my favourite chapter. First of all, I love violent characters who learn peace. I love characters from abusive circumstances who learn peace. But also... this whole story up until now has been about humans and Pokémon failing to communicate, either intentionally or by circumstances they can't control, and that miscommunication leads to pain. But here... Trainer didn't listen to his Pokémon, and that caused everyone around him to suffer. Bisharp and Mina cannot speak each other's languages, but... they take the time to be patient with each other to not speak, but understand. It's just... fuck I love this chapter. I only want good things for Bisharp and Mina.
 
Hi, I need you to know two things.

The first is, I read this at midnight, it is now 2 am and I need to get up in the morning but I am so glad I took the time to read this. Honestly speechless.

Second, because it is 2 am I will return from my enclosure to give me thoughts in proper full form at a later date.

Okay but my first thoughts are— I am thoroughly inspired reading this. Your word choices and form are something to be envied, I am OBSESSED with your choice in format and the chronological order of events/writing. I can feel the love you put into this series, it really shows, and that is beautiful.

holy shit

ok in-depth thoughts later just know I’m obsessed
 
Hey there! I'm back for more. I'm very sorry for my tardiness.

I was going to read through everything at once, because as Aether said, I feel like this story benefits more from reading it all through before formulating thoughts, rather than reading and reviewing chapter by chapter. A lot of themes and characters really only develop after you've seen them several times, and in the moment of a single chapter, the bigger picture isn't always immediately clear. The problem is I'm... very bad at reading through an entire longfic and then writing out all of my thoughts at once; I'm very much a chapter-by-chapter reviewer. This isn't a flaw with this story, though. It's a very personal preference... problem... thing. Maybe it's not a problem and more a "this is just how I read stuff".

That being said, three more chapters.

nonconformist

So like, Team Plasma takes/kidnaps/rescues Pokemon (depending on how one sees it) and asks them if they want to return to their trainers or stay with Team Plasma. It’s certainly better than just taking/kidnapping/rescuing them with no input from them, but if Trainers were to do the same after capturing Pokemon… would it be any better? Because yeah, you are giving them the choice, but you’ve already done the taking/kidnapping/rescuing, so the dynamic is kind of… different, I suppose? Like, it’s not a totally equal exchange, if that makes sense, Team Plasma or Trainer.

In an ideal world, humans would ask Pokemon what they want to do (battling and so on) before capturing them or taking them or adopting them off, rather than after. But the problem, the overarching problem, is that Pokemon and humans can’t communicate, or they don’t. From Lucky and Rhea’s exchange, where Rhea thinks that Lucky will help her when Lucky is actually saying know, it seems like humans (or most humans, maybe) can’t understand Pokemon. But I have hope that, in a better world, they could or would at least try. But this lack of communication is so ingrained in this society, with the regulations that treat sentient creatures like property, that the question becomes not “what would a better world look like” but rather “how do we make this world better”.

On a lighter note, I wonder how the egg move regulations apply in a region like Paldea, with the Mirror Herb.

nondeterministic

Not sure if I’ve said this before, but I think you were one of the main writers who got me into xenofic (alongside PeN, Cress, and a few others). Part of it is definitely in the lore/worldbuilding aspects, part of it is probably trying to make sense of how certain mons would act, part of it is maybe the neurodivergent part of me being interested in “atypical” viewpoints.

Anyway, the Klink line. Over the years, I went from “yeah I remember it because it’s just gears” to “I mean it’s not that bad it’ kind of silly” to “my silly my scrunkly”. Idk, I think I just really like object mons now. And object mons are especially interesting in a xeno context. Like, we have some idea of how animals like dogs and cats think and feel and act, but how would a living and/or sentient candle think or feel or act?

I like what you have here, especially the stuff about names. It makes sense for a machine part to have a… machine-like view on names. On some level, I find it a bit surprising that N doesn’t seem to fully understand that someone wouldn’t want a name, given his relationship with Pokemon, but it also makes sense. N’s/Team Plasma’s whole thing is that Pokemon are individuals like humans, that Pokemon deserve dignity and respect. And one of the ways that one can humanize/dehumanize someone is through names. It makes sense for someone like N to think that calling a Pokemon by their species name could be dehumanizing. To him, it’s like calling a person “you human” or something instead of their name. But to Klinklang, it’s not dehumanizing. (In a way, it reminds me of how certain trans people use it/its pronouns. Like, historically “it” has been used to dehumanize people, especially trans people, but if a trans person wishes to use those pronouns to describe itself, then who am I to judge?)

I am so, so close to going on more ramblings about the language of humanizing and dehumanizing, but I will restrain myself. For now.

I also like how Klingklang and Ferroseed/Ferrule are able to bond over being Steel types. I don’t know, I just think it’s neat. And it makes a lot of sense that they would have that kinship :)

I like the combined word syntax stuff (worldchange and biggear and the like). It makes sense both for a mon like Kling and for… idk a .exe sort of speech pattern, if that makes sense? Like file names? I can’t quite place a finger on it, but I like.

Admittedly, I’m a little confused as to Klingklang’s logic, and maybe that’s the point, and maybe I’m making the wrong interpretation, so here we go: It’s easier to see that a problem exists than it is to solve it, and it’s very difficult for an individual to solve a systemic problem (in this case, N sees the problem of Pokemon-human inequality, and he the individual/his group is trying to solve it, but that’s hard because this inequality is so ingrained in society that it’s not easy to solve). It takes a lot of people to change a system… but it’s hard to get a lot of people to work together or agree on the right solution.

nidifugous

More cool xeno stuff! It makes sense that a fossil mon would be confused with and overwhelmed by modern technology and lights and stuff.

Tirtouga in the bucket!!! Eeeeh that’s so cute that N is carrying Zara around in a bucket of water. And Zara and Reylin’s reunion is such a nice segway into some spicy fossil lore.

“and they have this odd way of conjugating without tenses that I don’t fully”
N gets cut off here, but I don’t really understand if he’s saying he doesn’t understand the tenses that Zara isn’t using? Because that wouldn’t make sense. So is it that he doesn’t understand why the tenses aren’t there?

The linguist in me is very intrigued by Pokemon languages! N mentions a sea dialect? Is that a sea dialect of Unovan/Galarian/English/whatever the characters are speaking? Because the way it’s a reply to Hilda’s question “do you speak all of the languages”, it implies that sea creatures speak a separate language from other mons (and so the dialects would probably be between different levels of the sea: deep sea, surface, etc.) Of course, I also say this as someone who hasn’t really fully grasped how Pokemon languages/Pokemon to human speech works in my own world, so let he who is without language sin cast the first language stone.
 
We all know things that start with n, but what about things that start with z and end with a (I said this as a topical joke but it turns out there are more words that fit this criteria than I thought)

I’ve come to realize that I’ve made a big shift from line by lines to general summarizing of thoughts with the occasional typo thing. Maybe it’s because of the nature of this fic, maybe it’s a general change in how I do things. But it does make it so I can get less hung up on the things I quoted/”why did I quote this what was I gonna say” and instead focus on my general thoughts on each chapter and expand on those. It’s a nice change. I like it.

nudum
I think back to the quote from the beginning: Pokémon don’t tell lies. What they do tell is a different story entirely. Paraphrased, perhaps.

Inari seems to think that humans always lie. N seems to think that Pokémon always tell the truth. But maybe they’re both telling the truth, or rather their truths, their stories. There’s a reason it’s called hi-story; because even history books leave out some information, for brevity or because that information wasn’t available yet or whatever. I’ve heard history described as being not what happened, but each historian’s testimony of what happened (or each witness’s testimony, in the case of primary sources). Neither Pokémon nor humans have the whole story, and so the truth can only be found when both stories are allowed to be seen by both groups. Balance. Greyyyyyyyyy
(I was also going to go into a ramble about how it’s important to not focus only on the bad of humanity while also not ignoring the bad of humanity, but that also culminates into “Balance. Greyyyyyyyyy”. I would make a joke about how we don’t get Grey, but instead Z-A, but I don’t know how to spin that into a good joke. And I already tried.)

necktie
corruption yayyyyyyyy

I joke. Kind of. Because here we see the systems in place with the League, how it’s driven by marketing a brand. And nepotism. People like Iris and the triplets are more success stories to market. But Iris is trying to use that success, or rather the cards she was dealt, to make change, real change that can help others and not just “the exceptions”.

The battle being paralleled with Iris and Hilda’s conversation was really neat to see. They both (at least I think) seem to be fighting for change: Iris in trying to help disenfranchised children have a chance at being Trainers, and Hilda getting trying to talk with Team Plasma, at least more than most people are.

And hey, more Pokémon and humans working together! Iris and Sienna are good. They have a kindred spirit, forged from shared struggles and triumphs.

“Because you of all people should know,” Iris replies stonily, “how it feels to have a pale man stroll into your life, rip off your tusks, and declare himself your king.”

It also makes this line hit different. Because N has declared himself liberator of Pokémon. And yeah, he is able to speak with Pokémon, but not once does a Pokémon speak up at the rallies, nor does N give them the chance. And he’s not doing this out of malice or a desire for fame or any other bad intention; it’s clear he believes in the cause he’s fighting for.

And Iris is also able to speak with Pokémon. Iris, Hilda, and N - as well as Sienna, Inari, Tourmaline, Lucky, and so on - all disagree on how change should and does happen, so while they’re all fighting for it, they’re also fighting with each other over their clashing truths and ideals, all believing they are in the right.

“Nonsense. You gave Sienna a run for her money; the two of us haven’t had a fight that close in weeks! Your Air Slash accuracy is really something.” Iris shrugs and takes another sip of coffee. To give herself time to think, you’re sure. It’s not like she enjoys it. “It’s not like Alder’s going anywhere anytime soon, you know? So if Drayden says I should wait, I’ll wait.”

- minor grammar thing, but the dialogue guys should be separate paragraphs.

noogenesis
Biblical allusionsssssssssssss

(I would probably love to do a Biblical analysis

Interesting how Jericho prefers being around multiple people, because then it’s harder to try and focus on each of the individual minds of people.

Reylin… ouch. Like yeah, even if he was allowed to or willing to leave Hilda and battling, where would he go? The modern world is so scary and foreign to him, he’d surely get lost in it. (Petition or fossil rehabilitation programs.)

If I’m interpreting this right… when Albieba died, Venant could only see the ideal world, and so now that Venant is “a part of” Jericho, so to speak, he can now also only see the ideal world. And hell yeah Vaselva name theme returns! She wants to be with Hilda, but she wants to be acknowledged by the name her mother gave her… but that means she also wants to know what that name was : (

In the end, it felt like the truth of the present and the ideal future each character wanted seemed to blend together in the heat of battle, as though it was hard to tell what would happen and what others wanted to happen. It was cool. Gives you a lot of mull over even after reading. I think it’s very easy to go down the “the future is what it is” with future predicting, but I think even in canon Pokémon, there’s this idea that the future can always be changed, and predictions are more so “what will happen if things keep going the way they are going now”, like A Christmas Carol, sort of. I feel like, with the last visual, both Hilda and N believe they are the “chosen one”, and they both want to reshape the world.

Perhaps it was in the way Elesa’s zestrika

missing b

nightmare
Skimmed over a bit of the explicit depictions of abuse for my own wellbeing, just as an fyi. I could have very well misread or misinterpreted something.

Bianca and Munny’s relationship is… complicated, imo. At first, it feels like Bianca is more of a naive pet owner than anything, telling Munny things she thinks are cool, but Munny would probably know. But it also seems like Bianca chose Munny specifically because of her dream-eating abilities, and Munny is internalizing those dreams. A lot of her thought process reflects the effects of abuse (blaming yourself for your shortcomings, downplaying the severity of the situation, etc.), but as far as I can see Bianca and Munny’s relationship isn’t abusive? Codependent. That’s it. Bianca treats Munny as a pet or maybe at most an emotional support animal, while Munny (being more sentient than an emotional support animal) seems like a full-on therapist. But the thing is that therapists have boundaries. They have their own support networks and time away from their clients. And they’re just that: clients. Munny is both super close to Bianca and super carrying of Bianca’s emotional burdens.

(Though during the N conversation, I was internally screaming at N and Rhea to maybe talk to Bianca about keeping your battle partners separate from your therapist, but I’ve accepted that this point is that she wouldn’t listen, that this story is about what happens when people don’t listen. So instead I began internally screaming at all of them to just talk ahhhhhhhhh)

Oh and Moon Goddess lore was really cool. Yummy like a good dream.

nocturne
I was right in my analysis of how different versions of the same story are needed to tell the whole picture hell yeah

I have a lot of thoughts after reading this, but at the same time I find it hard to put those thoughts into words. It's a weird paradox. Maybe it's that the thoughts are more vague apparitions rather than coherent words.

I have no idea how to word this, so forgive me if it’s jumbled, but how I interpret the meaning of the story of the Nocturne Lament is that humans got voice/strength, Pokémon got dance/power. Maybe in that sense, they are two parts of the same whole. Like the Original Dragon. Like Meloetta. Maybe they can exist without each other. Maybe they can’t.

You were made to protect.An obsidian knife
missing space

From that day forward she was never her whol self
“whol” should be “whole”


na-šāyad
Full disclosure: blood/realistic violence in Pokémon battles isn’t something I’m usually a fan of. I think one of the reasons why Pokémon appeals to me is specifically because of the lack of blood and realistic violence. However, it fits the tone and themes of this fic, especially with this chapter: a young Timburr entering a world he doesn’t fully understand, but one he feels he needs to enter because of tradition.

Petra is a much kinder trainer than Tim. It has me thinking of Pokémon as trainers again. After all, what is a trainer (in the basic sense) if not one who trains others?

you’re so bad at figuring out with the humans
this feels a bit strangely worded? I think it’s the “figuring out” that confuses me. It’s not wrong, I don’t think, but it does trip me up a bit.

The corded muscles of his arms stretched taught like stone
“taught” should be “taut”

nepeta
Fuck. I loved this chapter.

No arguments. No fighting. No bloodshed or injustice. (Well, there is injustice in the background). But for a moment, humans and Pokémon were able to be one, sharing music, as equals. And Tourmaline, who lived her life thinking she only had one path, was shown a world where she could follow that path, or countless more. Where Pokémon weren’t just battlers or tools. Ideal incarnate, after a chapter of the bitter truth.

also GRIMSLEY NO (this whole fic was actually an anti-gambling PSA)

and it’s shrill calls echo again.
“it’s” should be “its”

“if you’d like, you can seek out your own trainer until you found one who fit”
I think it should be “find one who fits” maybe? It feels a little better in my head, at least.

enharmonic
okay so admittedly I… got a little lost in the prose, especially near the end. I’m guessing this is also the end - as in, the chronological end, not just “the end of the order we’ve been told the story”, and I’m guessing N didn’t separate humans and Pokémon, but rather gave up his voice to Pokémon, so they could have a chance at equality. He was the only human who was willing to learn to speak with Pokémon (or one of the only, rather he was the main one to), and now humans will have to hear Pokémon, and it will be something they can’t easily ignore.

I like this ending better than a separation one. Because change isn’t something you can wish into existence; even if you can wish in a radical change like “Pokémon can speak to humans”, there’s still a “what now” after that. And maybe it would be easier to just separate humans and Pokémon, but it’s more tragic, more of a downer, because… well, we’ve seen in this fic several times that humans and Pokémon can exist in harmony, if they only take the time to listen. But if you separate them, that hope is lost.

final thoughts
God damn.

This fic changed me. It changed how I think about Pokemon/human relations, inspired me to try to explore worlds where humans and Pokemon can coexist as equals, gave me despair and hope and despair again and in the end... hope. Change is hard. Change is long and messy and difficult and hard, but it's worth it. Because the ideal can't be reached until you first acknowledge the truth, and the truth can't be changed if you can't imagine an ideal. At the start, I thought this fic would break me, but instead it rebuilds you into something better, something that can see a better future and how to find it. (Communication. Mostly.)

I think you did a good job at portraying the main players as not fully good or evil. They're trying to survive in the system, or break it, or fix it, or change it. They do good and bad, they have their beliefs and dreams and truths and ideals.

I think my biggest issue was that the prose could sometimes get lost in the sauce, where it could ramble a bit with no clear way of interpreting what was happening. And maybe that was intentional, because there are a lot of things here that require a bit of thought to parse out, a critical eye to see the bigger picture, but sometimes it could get a bit too tangled to know where to start. But that was a pretty rare occurence, and in general this fic was a lot of good philosophical food for thought.

Very good stuff. Very, very, very good stuff.
 
Back
Top Bottom