GliscorMan
URPG!
- Joined
- Jun 7, 2010
- Messages
- 3,004
- Reaction score
- 1
Re: Lord of the Rings Mafia -- August 2nd -- Day 3 -- To Isengard!
I'm going to make this perfectly clear. Beck does not have a secondary role. This was him coming full to claim to me. He has told me that his role is 100% identical to Forgotten's claimed role.
My decision to lynch Forgotten has absolutely nothing to do with this, however. There are several other things at play here. These things come together, and make it our best option to lynch Forgotten. It will clear up a large portion of my confusion. I do not know whether or not Forgotten is scum. I have no certainty of that matter. However, the situation and conditions that have been brought forth have forced me to make a decision, and those conditions (which are more extensive than just Beck vs Forgotten) hinge on what he flips. I chose him because he is, in my opinion, the most likely to flip Mafia. If he does, yay. We have a clear and we lynched a scum. Conversely, if he flips Town, I've actually bagged two Mafia members, at the price of losing the would-be confirmed. The same works for Beck, though admittedly slightly different, but I deem that Forgotten is, again, most likely to flip Mafia based on the information I have. So I want to lynch him because I think we have the highest chance of not losing a Townie in this witchhunt.
For the record, only one other person is aware of the full extent of what's going on. Even the people I've trusted with pieces of information don't have all of it. To those of you who express undue worry at me accidentally sharing information "with the wrong people", I simply tell you this: nobody (save the one person, who will be taking over for me behind the scenes) knows enough to leak any critical information to the Mafia. Even if everyone I've so far shared pieces of info with came together and willingly gave their info to the Mafia, the Mafia would still know less about the roles than the person I've set up.
I find it worrisome that many experienced people appear to be trying to sow discontent and discomfort, and question whether their motives are as pure as they'd like us to believe.
I'm going to make this perfectly clear. Beck does not have a secondary role. This was him coming full to claim to me. He has told me that his role is 100% identical to Forgotten's claimed role.
My decision to lynch Forgotten has absolutely nothing to do with this, however. There are several other things at play here. These things come together, and make it our best option to lynch Forgotten. It will clear up a large portion of my confusion. I do not know whether or not Forgotten is scum. I have no certainty of that matter. However, the situation and conditions that have been brought forth have forced me to make a decision, and those conditions (which are more extensive than just Beck vs Forgotten) hinge on what he flips. I chose him because he is, in my opinion, the most likely to flip Mafia. If he does, yay. We have a clear and we lynched a scum. Conversely, if he flips Town, I've actually bagged two Mafia members, at the price of losing the would-be confirmed. The same works for Beck, though admittedly slightly different, but I deem that Forgotten is, again, most likely to flip Mafia based on the information I have. So I want to lynch him because I think we have the highest chance of not losing a Townie in this witchhunt.
For the record, only one other person is aware of the full extent of what's going on. Even the people I've trusted with pieces of information don't have all of it. To those of you who express undue worry at me accidentally sharing information "with the wrong people", I simply tell you this: nobody (save the one person, who will be taking over for me behind the scenes) knows enough to leak any critical information to the Mafia. Even if everyone I've so far shared pieces of info with came together and willingly gave their info to the Mafia, the Mafia would still know less about the roles than the person I've set up.
I find it worrisome that many experienced people appear to be trying to sow discontent and discomfort, and question whether their motives are as pure as they'd like us to believe.