HumanDawn
Living the rich life
- Joined
- Sep 19, 2011
- Messages
- 7,713
- Reaction score
- 3,464
What are the odds that Snowy just didn't listen to Pikapika and mafia kill got blocked?
Well, a Bulletproof role died... So, we have the usual Doctor, and potentially other Town protection roles like Commuter and Jailer, but I feel the latter two are a bit more unlikely because we had a Bulletproof flip. It's still within the realm of possibility though.
That said, what do players think of Pika_Pika for outing that targetting him has a chance of potentially killing the player?
I'm going to put him as a top Town read for that because Mafia does not out roles that could potentially kill Town if they are targetted, especially so early. Considering the game's status as a bastard game, a PGO being in the game is much more likely.
Just been looking back over Jinjo's posts which I have to agree they are mostly just defensive or non relevant. In a lot of the posts she keeps taking about people using meta but isn't offering any reads or thoughts herself. She also didn't vote on day 1 which also makes it harder to draw conclusions.
Can see her posts being CWAC.
Vote: Jinjo
What are your current reads @Jinjo ?
Thoughts on TheCapsFan and PikaPika now?
Tbh I am not sure if scum tried to make a wagon against me. While I think me voting Ex was blown a bit out of proportion, I can see it could come across as suspicious to others.
If I had to pick the scummiest out of my voters, I would choose DawningWinds, they were inactive throughout D1 but only came and voted me, which looked like a case of sheeping.
Not sure. I warned the cop not to visit me because there was a lot of risk involved.
The possibilities are:
1) snowy checked me and died and mafia kill was blocked for some reason
2) snowy didn't check me and was killed by the mafia
3) a combination of both i.e. snowy checked me and was killed by the mafia
ok
why not vote them?
Here is my ISO on Jinjo:
I remember a lot of people saying that they thought this was a weird entrance. I didn't find it super weird.
Subtle townread of Snowy amidst mechanic discussion, nothing much here.
Defense after a vote, on their actions coming into the day abruptly.
All responding to open questions put in the thread, nothing much on other players.
I think this has already been mentioned before by FA but it is quite ironic that Jinjo defended her entrance on D1 by using her own meta, yet here she literally says "don't trust meta." It almost reads to me that at this point she wants a bit of town cred, so she says something that will appeal to a lot of players to make her look better.
Still nothing really said about other players, or any attempts to gamesolve, really.
Defending herself from a response to a response to a question she asked. nothing of note
So, here's where the argument falls a bit flat in my opinion. Jinjo seems pretty ticked by these accusations but going back and looking at her posts, I don't really see where she made any concrete reads about specific players. She mentions these defenses against FA as giving reads, but in reality they read as general mechanical statements that could be applied to any player in any situation in my opinion.
I'm unsure as to how to take this frustration/anger from Jinjo, though, they typically seem pretty collected.
This is about the only read on a player Jinjo gives all game and it feels OMGUS-y. And, if you're gonna use meta based on mafia!HD, in Champs he never really did any sheeping, that's why it took the town a while to find him, a lot of his votes were strategically placed and they were doing a lot of vote-hunting.
Oh wait, but I thought you were encouraging people not to use meta? But you already used meta, so I'll justify myself in using it here.
TLDR; Rereading her posts makes me feel a lot worse about her. She could really do with actively trying to gamesolve and give her thoughts about players. Enough for a vote, I think. [VOTE]: Jinjo
Jinjo using meta to self-defend herself while saying meta is bad is just... wow...
Fun fact about the championship game: The only vote I sheeped was the first one on my scum partner in Day 4. I might have sheeped another vote, but yeah. One Townie pointed out how I was making only unique cases being the first voter - and I just played dumb to them telling them "but why is that bad?".
@Midorikawa
heeeey guuurl, what'cya dooooin'??