Okay, I have five extra Pokemon. Meet me back in there to trade the giveaway Pokemon. Thanks for the Chikorita! I'm trading you some starter Pokemon, so promise me that you'll keep these five extra Pokemon.
I received the chikorita in a giveaway a while back (Tag3r) so I'm not able to nickname it. As far as I know it's legit. I haven't heard anything otherwise. It's up to you if you still want to trade or not but unfortunately I don't have any other shiny Johto starters.