- Joined
- Jan 2, 2010
- Messages
- 7,282
- Reaction score
- 3,150
Re: A Sine of Things to Come
Chapter Three down
Technical Accuracy/Style
A lot of little minor errors, most of which I suspect are typos. Watch the capitalisation, especially on words that are also perfectly good in lowercase. A line break missed, let's see ... oh, yes, and "striped" rather than "stripped"
Story
The story continues well. It's a nice training sequence chapter overall. I quite like your take on the physics of electric pokémon. I wish I was in a position to make more sensible comments, but electrical physics is not my area of expertise. Regardless, it came across well, and you've hit a nice middle between the technical and the accessible in your writing. I especially like that the story continues to take a non-traditional approach. I'm kind of bored of an unusual premise leading straight into the standard forest-and-Rock Gym arc
Characters
Quite a good version of Blue here. Personally I hate the canon character's colour names, but what the hell, it's canon and I'm not going to complain much about it. Anyway, Blue comes across well - kind of spiky and rude, but not completely without reason. I appreciate that you highlight a Gym Leader's responsibilities - something zig-zagged in the canon where Leaders apparently can completely ignore their Gyms at times
Final Thoughts
Continues well. I would suggest having technical tidy up of the chapter, if only to make sure that future readers don't run into the same errors
Chapter Three down
Technical Accuracy/Style
A lot of little minor errors, most of which I suspect are typos. Watch the capitalisation, especially on words that are also perfectly good in lowercase. A line break missed, let's see ... oh, yes, and "striped" rather than "stripped"
Story
The story continues well. It's a nice training sequence chapter overall. I quite like your take on the physics of electric pokémon. I wish I was in a position to make more sensible comments, but electrical physics is not my area of expertise. Regardless, it came across well, and you've hit a nice middle between the technical and the accessible in your writing. I especially like that the story continues to take a non-traditional approach. I'm kind of bored of an unusual premise leading straight into the standard forest-and-Rock Gym arc
Characters
Quite a good version of Blue here. Personally I hate the canon character's colour names, but what the hell, it's canon and I'm not going to complain much about it. Anyway, Blue comes across well - kind of spiky and rude, but not completely without reason. I appreciate that you highlight a Gym Leader's responsibilities - something zig-zagged in the canon where Leaders apparently can completely ignore their Gyms at times
Final Thoughts
Continues well. I would suggest having technical tidy up of the chapter, if only to make sure that future readers don't run into the same errors