GastlyGibus
World's worst critic
- Joined
- Oct 27, 2013
- Messages
- 1,210
- Reaction score
- 97
Re: Ace Attorney: Dual Destinies Mafia - Night 2 - When I Am Dead, Then You Will Real
My suspicion is now directly on all those who voted Yato. More specifically, harryheart and Mijzelffan. FinalArcadia too, to an extent, but not as much as the first two.
With harryheart, I believe I already brought this up, but I'm going to bring it up again.
You pretty much just flat-out said that you were hesitant, and that you thought it might end badly, but you went and voted Yato anyways. What logical sense does that make? If you think something is going to end badly, you don't do it.
Now, for Mijzelffan, let's count the list of sins...
Lurks the thread for a while, then just comes in to place a vote with reasoning that makes my face hurt just reading it. Completely ignores the previous discussion regarding Zima and her activity, and simply takes Zima's posts at face value.
What is extremely irritating though is the "miller wouldn't be much of value lost." I mean, seriously?? I already said this, but I feel the need to reiterate: Losing town members is a bad thing, period. Doctor, Vanilla,ultimate miller mason with one copcheck and half a vigilante shot, I don't care what role a person is. If they're are town, they are worth keeping around. This is just so frustrating and absolutely screams scum to me.
Immediately puts the pressure on Lysandre because Lysandre didn't mindlessly follow the herd and actually had the gumption to think for himself. As if somehow it makes Lysandre suspicious that he didn't vote for Yato. I absolutely agree with Lysandre's reasoning 100%, and the fact that Mij pretty much tried to place suspicion on Lysandre for not voting Yato makes me even more wary.
Ad Hominem.
Since Mij can't defend their position logically (since it was pretty illogical to begin with) we then have this gem of a claim to save themselves. I'm sorry, but after the back and forth discussion we've had, and then we have this claim, and they won't even reveal whom they checked, just that "they were town," you'll forgive me if I call your bluff. It's a shaky claim at best, and it's blatantly false at worse.
Once again pretending that the miller is some kind of awful, evil role that must be lynched immediately or else the whole town might blow up...
... once again insisting that Yato is clearly the scummiest player alive and should be killed without remorse. Once again lacking any sort of sound argument against Yato.
So everyone, tell me again how that lynch against Yato was just such a wonderful idea. I'm all ears.
My suspicion is now directly on all those who voted Yato. More specifically, harryheart and Mijzelffan. FinalArcadia too, to an extent, but not as much as the first two.
With harryheart, I believe I already brought this up, but I'm going to bring it up again.
From what has been said and what I read, Zima did seem suspicious but as FinalArcadia; rightly said, in the Futurama mafia if that had happened with Setra/Flaze it would've been a bad choice. So I'm hesitant to go fro Yato as well solely based on what Zima did, but I do feel suspicions towards that and so will:
Vote: Yato
You pretty much just flat-out said that you were hesitant, and that you thought it might end badly, but you went and voted Yato anyways. What logical sense does that make? If you think something is going to end badly, you don't do it.
Now, for Mijzelffan, let's count the list of sins...
Crackfox is giving me mafia vibes but I won't use meta to make a case. I guess I'll vote Yato because zima was acting pretty weird and a miller wouldn't be much of value lost.
Lurks the thread for a while, then just comes in to place a vote with reasoning that makes my face hurt just reading it. Completely ignores the previous discussion regarding Zima and her activity, and simply takes Zima's posts at face value.
What is extremely irritating though is the "miller wouldn't be much of value lost." I mean, seriously?? I already said this, but I feel the need to reiterate: Losing town members is a bad thing, period. Doctor, Vanilla,
You seem awfully convinced there's gonna be a mislynch if we vote yato. Is there anything you know that we don't Lysandre? Zima (who is now yato) was suspicious, has a suspicious claim and I'd say has a high chance to be mafia based on that. On top of that, IF he turns out not to be mafia there is nothing of value lost. We're not lynching someone we know is innocent because their role is useless, we're lynching someone suspicious. And then if they turn out to be innocent then it doesn't matter much because the role they claimed is useless. You're trying to excuse anything fishy zima did just because she quit? That's not very smart, if everyone was like you mafia would just have to sub out the moment they're under fire and live on forever.
Immediately puts the pressure on Lysandre because Lysandre didn't mindlessly follow the herd and actually had the gumption to think for himself. As if somehow it makes Lysandre suspicious that he didn't vote for Yato. I absolutely agree with Lysandre's reasoning 100%, and the fact that Mij pretty much tried to place suspicion on Lysandre for not voting Yato makes me even more wary.
Only a foolish fool from a land of fools could think something so foolishly foolish, I grow tired of the foolish foolery of the foolish fools of this foolish country. -Franziska von Karma
Ad Hominem.
I'm the cop. Is outing myself like this risky? Yes but I'm already at risk so I can't make it much worse. Is outing myself smart? Still smarter than dying so the miller can live.
Since Mij can't defend their position logically (since it was pretty illogical to begin with) we then have this gem of a claim to save themselves. I'm sorry, but after the back and forth discussion we've had, and then we have this claim, and they won't even reveal whom they checked, just that "they were town," you'll forgive me if I call your bluff. It's a shaky claim at best, and it's blatantly false at worse.
Once again pretending that the miller is some kind of awful, evil role that must be lynched immediately or else the whole town might blow up...
I'd appreciate any unvotes and I'd appreciate any votes to yato even more.
... once again insisting that Yato is clearly the scummiest player alive and should be killed without remorse. Once again lacking any sort of sound argument against Yato.
So everyone, tell me again how that lynch against Yato was just such a wonderful idea. I'm all ears.
Last edited: