• All content from the former Roleplaying Games forum has been merged into the Writers' Workshop forum. You can find more information in this thread.

    We hope to see you roleplaying away soon!
  • The World Beyond Restructure is now finished! Check out the update here!
  • The 2020 staff drive for Bulbagarden is now live! If you're interested in joining the Bulbagarden staff team (whether it be forums, social media, or more!) then you're encouraged to apply!
  • Hey everyone! The Writer's Workshop is hosting an exciting event, Trainers of Fanfiction! It's a community event focused around your characters!

Advanceshipping General Discussion

Vick+Pkmn=WIN!
Joined
Oct 6, 2010
Messages
492
Reaction score
0
Re: AdvanceShipping Nation

But unlike with Kris who was exclusive to Crystal and thus not as significant as May who has appeared in RS and E and has been a main character in the anime for a period of 4 years and some cameos. There is little need to replace her.

May's best chance at making a cameo is RSEmakes. Without that, she may not appear again.
she might at the end of best wishes or something like that, but all we can do now is hop that she does.
 
ORE... SANJOU!
Joined
Dec 7, 2010
Messages
28
Reaction score
0
Re: AdvanceShipping Nation

I was looking for the manga adaptation of Temple Of The Sea, but couldn't find it. Is it even anywhere on the internet?

What kind of advice would you think Ash's friends (all of them up to this point) would give Ash and/or May regarding their relationship?
 
NCIS Special Agent
Joined
Oct 19, 2008
Messages
3,594
Reaction score
134
Re: AdvanceShipping Nation

I was looking for the manga adaptation of Temple Of The Sea, but couldn't find it. Is it even anywhere on the internet?

What kind of advice would you think Ash's friends (all of them up to this point) would give Ash and/or May regarding their relationship?
I have a copy of Temple of the Sea, so it's out there.

I doubt Misty would give advice to foster an Ash/May relationship. Brock's advice would be thoroughly useless, so it doesn't matter.

...Actually, I can't think of anything else.
 
Pokemon & CoD Fan
Joined
Sep 13, 2009
Messages
2,488
Reaction score
4
Re: AdvanceShipping Nation

What kind of advice would you think Ash's friends (all of them up to this point) would give Ash and/or May regarding their relationship?

Misty: Considering she still has her crush on Ash, I think she'd be too crushed to give anything.

Brock: I don't know. Maybe he'd tell Ash to stay with May so he won't have to live the lonely life that he does? lol

Tracey: Tracey might give them advice to always be honest with each other.

Max: I don't think he'd know anything about romance at that point...

Dawn: Being a girl herself, she'd give Ash advice on how to please girls and maybe give him various tips for different things.

Iris: She'd tell both of them to live and have fun since life is short. Iris seems like a person to tell them that, honestly.

Dento: He'd assure Ash and May that they can call him up if they have relationship problems. And is it bad that I think that Dento would give Ash fashion advice for dates...?

I have a copy of Temple of the Sea, so it's out there.
You do? Does the manga adaptation retain the same amount of ASness and/or awesomeness as the actual movie? I was thinking about buying it...
 
NCIS Special Agent
Joined
Oct 19, 2008
Messages
3,594
Reaction score
134
Re: AdvanceShipping Nation

You do? Does the manga adaptation retain the same amount of ASness and/or awesomeness as the actual movie? I was thinking about buying it...
Let's see...*currently flipping through it*...they omit the Luvdisc scene, so that's one less hint. When Ash puts May and the Pokes in the capsule, we don't see the same facial expressions. We do see May worried about Ash after the Sea Temple rises from its near-Poseidon Adventure. Overall, the manga has less ADV than the movie.
 
Last edited:
ORE... SANJOU!
Joined
Dec 7, 2010
Messages
28
Reaction score
0
Re: AdvanceShipping Nation

You still haven't answered where I could find it and read it for free.
 
ever so slightly
Joined
Apr 30, 2010
Messages
4,349
Reaction score
420
Re: AdvanceShipping Nation

am i still welcomed here? xD

Been off the ADV thread for a while. What's happening?^^
 
Got Pokemon Black!!
Joined
Nov 3, 2010
Messages
152
Reaction score
1
Re: AdvanceShipping Nation

Morru Magnum, everyone is always welcomed here! Not much has been going on... Now for the topic...

What kind of advice would you think Ash's friends (all of them up to this point) would give Ash and/or May regarding their relationship?

I think Dawn would give Ash some advice about girls in general, Brock would give Ash the WRONG advice, and Max would probably give advice on what May likes to do in her spare time(since May is Max's sister). I think Misty would give Ash some advice on being mature.
 
I am Kamina-Sama
Joined
Oct 27, 2009
Messages
381
Reaction score
1
Re: AdvanceShipping Nation

What kind of advice would you think Ash's friends (all of them up to this point) would give Ash and/or May regarding their relationship?

Ash

Oak+Delia: proably will give Ash "The Talk" and Delia would Tell Ash some of the thing his father did whenh they were dating

Gary: proably tell Ash to try and come off cool and to try and "Be The Man"

Pikachu: Pika pikachu-translation-Just be yourself man

Misty: proabaly won't be must use due to her being compatishon

Sensible Brock: try and be with her always so he doesn't end up like him -sad and alone (Awww:bawl:)

"Lovey duvy" Brock: proably won't give any good advice really- except a few date ideas

Richie: proably some practicle ideas and a few things to do or say ect

Professor Ivy: take her to the Orange islands for a holiday *gives romantic locations on a map to him*

Tracey:be honest with eachother or somthing like that proabably

Proffesor Elm: yeah proabably not much use except giving some nice places in Johto really

Professor Birch: yet again proably not much help except locations

Norman: Be good to her-or else *good advice to me :scared:*

Max: a few things May likes to do or a few places she likes to go

*non-CS* Drew: woo her with Roses

*CS* Drew: not much help

Harley: buy her some clothes

Scott: Take her to a resort or somewhere fancy

Professor Rowan: Just be yourself and be true to her and see where it goes

"Non- relationship looking" Dawn: tell him some stuff that girls generally like to do and try to help as well

"Crush" Dawn: not much use

Barry: Fine her *lol*

Paul: Not much use

I'll do Mays later
 
Whispers in the dark...
Joined
Sep 26, 2009
Messages
4,438
Reaction score
6
Re: AdvanceShipping Nation

What kind of advice would you think Ash's friends (all of them up to this point) would give Ash and/or May regarding their relationship?

All of them: Damn Ash, I thought you were gay. Don't mess this up
 
ORE... SANJOU!
Joined
Dec 7, 2010
Messages
28
Reaction score
0
Re: AdvanceShipping Nation

Forget about getting advice from Ash's friends, here's a better, and a whole lot funnier(imo), topic:
If Ash and/or May could understand them, what would be the advice their Pokemon(at least the ones who you think would have interest) would give?:-D
 
Last edited:
Joined
Jul 31, 2010
Messages
368
Reaction score
0
Re: AdvanceShipping Nation

What kind of advice would you think Ash's friends (all of them up to this point) would give Ash and/or May regarding their relationship?

brock,misty,iris,drew,ritchie,shooti,Barry, and paul won't be of much help.

gary:would give advice to ash on how to woo may(since gary is a cowboy casanova)

dawn:she'll tell ash,find out what she likes most, and set up a romatic date that she'll like. she'd also help ash with this even though if she was secretly jealous.

tracey, delia, oak, professor ivy, dento, and professor araragi would give ash some relationship advice.

harley, and solidad would help ash buy gifts for her especially clothes.
 
NCIS Special Agent
Joined
Oct 19, 2008
Messages
3,594
Reaction score
134
Re: AdvanceShipping Nation

Forget about getting advice from Ash's friends, here's a better, and a whole lot funnier(imo), topic:
If Ash and/or May could understand them, what would be the advice their Pokemon(at least the ones who you think would have interest) would give?:-D
I wouldn't expect much from Ash's Pokemon regarding love advice, considering what Oak said about Pokemon gaining traits from their trainers. I would imagine most of Ash's Pokemon inheriting his cluelessness regarding love. The only exception would be Sceptile, and look how his attempt at romance turned out.

As for May's Pokemon...actually, none of them have shown much inclination to love, except maybe Bulbasaur. If Ash's Bulba feels the same way, they might try leading by example. "Okay, Ash and May, watch how we do it. Got it? Now you try it."
 
Face it, I'm cute
Joined
Jul 14, 2008
Messages
815
Reaction score
0
Re: AdvanceShipping Nation

I don't want to be a jerk, but they may replace May with another girl like they did with Crystal and HG/SS. Lets just hope that doesn't happen when they make R/S/E sometime in 2011- 2012.
Merry Christmas and a happy new year to you all...
Well i don't know if anyone else has notice but i believe that the writers are getting sick of making new charathers. like Kenny he went missing for about 40 episodes and didn't even pass the 1st round of the grand festival and same goes with Nando. Zoey came from a decent rival to Dawn's bff and comes back after she goes missing for awhile. we never saw Nando battle and he didn't last in the grand festival for long either. Lyra might never make another camo again. maybe same goes with Angie. Conway hardly showed up and i think wasn't the best rival for Ash. Barry was decent.

So doesn't anyone see this that the writers are getting tried of making new charathers, making them last for at least 5 episodes and making them have a good childhood background and good closer. thats a lot of work now that you add all the characters they introduced since the show started.

So i believe there is a bigger chance that May WON'T BE REPLACED. i mean whats the point making a new charather for only a few episodes and never to be seen again? pointless if they do this with May. and plus the uproar of the fans will be huge, like with the Lyra and Kris issue when Kris was replaced when HG/SS was remade.
 
Last edited:
Got Pokemon Black!!
Joined
Nov 3, 2010
Messages
152
Reaction score
1
Re: AdvanceShipping Nation

Well i don't know if anyone else has notice but i believe that the writers are getting sick of making new charathers. like Kenny he went missing for about 40 episodes and didn't even pass the 1st round of the grand festival and same goes with Nando. Zoey came from a decent rival to Dawn's bff and comes back after she goes missing for awhile. we never saw Nando battle and he didn't last in the grand festival for long either. Lyra might never make another camo again. maybe same goes with Angie. Conway hardly showed up and i think wasn't the best rival for Ash. Barry was decent.

So doesn't anyone see this that the writers are getting tried of making new charathers, making them last for at least 5 episodes and making them have a good childhood background and good closer. thats a lot of work now that you add all the characters they introduced since the show started.

So i believe there is a bigger chance that May WON'T BE REPLACED. i mean whats the point making a new charather for only a few episodes and never to be seen again? pointless if they do this with May. and plus the uproar of the fans will be huge, like with the Lyra and Kris issue when Kris was replaced when HG/SS was remade.
Yeah, I did not notice that...
I guess we will find out if May's replaced, won't we?
 
追放されたバカ
Joined
Dec 11, 2010
Messages
38
Reaction score
0
Re: AdvanceShipping Nation

Well i don't know if anyone else has notice but i believe that the writers are getting sick of making new charathers. like Kenny he went missing for about 40 episodes and didn't even pass the 1st round of the grand festival and same goes with Nando. Zoey came from a decent rival to Dawn's bff and comes back after she goes missing for awhile. we never saw Nando battle and he didn't last in the grand festival for long either. Lyra might never make another camo again. maybe same goes with Angie. Conway hardly showed up and i think wasn't the best rival for Ash. Barry was decent.

So doesn't anyone see this that the writers are getting tried of making new charathers, making them last for at least 5 episodes and making them have a good childhood background and good closer. thats a lot of work now that you add all the characters they introduced since the show started.

So i believe there is a bigger chance that May WON'T BE REPLACED. i mean whats the point making a new charather for only a few episodes and never to be seen again? pointless if they do this with May. and plus the uproar of the fans will be huge, like with the Lyra and Kris issue when Kris was replaced when HG/SS was remade.
Kris was first introduced in Crystal, while HeartGold and SoulSilver are remakes of Gold and Silver, games which do not feature female protagonists. In contrast, May is featured in Ruby, Sapphire, and Emerald, in addition to being a well-established character in the show. There is no reason to believe that she will be replaced in future R/S remakes.

Actually, if they replace any protagonist, it would be Brendan, as he has only made three cameos in M06/M09/M11 and has no important role in the show. However, Brendan is awesome and if they replaced him I would be absolutely outraged.
 
Pokemon & CoD Fan
Joined
Sep 13, 2009
Messages
2,488
Reaction score
4
Re: AdvanceShipping Nation

Let's see...*currently flipping through it*...they omit the Luvdisc scene, so that's one less hint. When Ash puts May and the Pokes in the capsule, we don't see the same facial expressions. We do see May worried about Ash after the Sea Temple rises from its near-Poseidon Adventure. Overall, the manga has less ADV than the movie.
... :(

Well i don't know if anyone else has notice but i believe that the writers are getting sick of making new charathers. like Kenny he went missing for about 40 episodes and didn't even pass the 1st round of the grand festival and same goes with Nando. Zoey came from a decent rival to Dawn's bff and comes back after she goes missing for awhile. we never saw Nando battle and he didn't last in the grand festival for long either. Lyra might never make another camo again. maybe same goes with Angie. Conway hardly showed up and i think wasn't the best rival for Ash. Barry was decent.

So doesn't anyone see this that the writers are getting tried of making new charathers, making them last for at least 5 episodes and making them have a good childhood background and good closer. thats a lot of work now that you add all the characters they introduced since the show started.

So i believe there is a bigger chance that May WON'T BE REPLACED. i mean whats the point making a new charather for only a few episodes and never to be seen again? pointless if they do this with May. and plus the uproar of the fans will be huge, like with the Lyra and Kris issue when Kris was replaced when HG/SS was remade.
The writers don't make new characters for the games. The writer's make new characters for the anime, lol. They won't have a say in who's in what game remake. That's up to GameFreak and the Pokemon game developers. Even then, May has an extremely high chance of staying because:

Kris was first introduced in Crystal, while HeartGold and SoulSilver are remakes of Gold and Silver, games which do not feature female protagonists. In contrast, May is featured in Ruby, Sapphire, and Emerald, in addition to being a well-established character in the show. There is no reason to believe that she will be replaced in future R/S remakes.
So we don't need to worry about May never reappearing. ;)
 
Top