• All content from the former Roleplaying Games forum has been merged into the Writers' Workshop forum. You can find more information in this thread.

    We hope to see you roleplaying away soon!
  • The World Beyond Restructure is now finished! Check out the update here!
  • It's time for the Writer's Workshop Summer event: our second themed one-shot competition! Check out the sign-up thread here!
  • Hey everyone! Bulbagarden is hosting its first Bulbaleague Conference Pokemon Showdown Tournament! Check out this thread to get the full details!
  • Hey everyone! The Writer's Workshop is hosting an exciting event, Trainers of Fanfiction! It's a community event focused around your characters!

Mafia Archie Sonic Mafia, Endgame: TBA (4/8/20)

Brutally Honest
Joined
Nov 6, 2018
Messages
2,726
Reaction score
1,088
I thought it was permanently 48 hour days now...

Vote: TheCapsFan
Vote: Shorten Phases for the rest of the game :p
 
Petals For Armor
Joined
Jun 25, 2011
Messages
7,697
Reaction score
2,408
Have fun being played by Human” and then goes attacking me saying I’m the last scum once they notice their case on them isn’t convincing anyone ok then
Dude I’ve been trying to push my case on Human since Day 2 and no one’s even given it a second thought. Ya bet your ass that i’m tired of trying.
 
Petals For Armor
Joined
Jun 25, 2011
Messages
7,697
Reaction score
2,408
the game becomes a lot harder if thecapsfan isn't scum, and i've already tested the waters with mido and everyone's actions line up - mido might be
dude

mido is not scum

she was copchecked town

the chance for her to be godfather is SO low





I really don't understand the paranoia over the protection claims?

There is no Doctor in the game, thus, alternative roles who fill in the niche with their own limitations make sense balance-wise.
There is no active killing role in the game, thus, having THREE alternative roles who fill the niche of doctor, regardless of their limitations, makes NO sense balance wise.
 
Joined
May 30, 2012
Messages
19,621
Reaction score
3,289
There is no Doctor in the game, thus, alternative roles who fill in the niche with their own limitations make sense balance-wise.
I think it’s because when you et doing the base of it, we have three protection claims and we had a BP. Mine is basically a modified singer, then we have lovers and then we have a JOAT who had a doc protect. Add in bomb and even in a bastard game it’s just crazy how hard it is for mafia to kill town. If last mafia is roleblcoker then they could roleblock one and try to hit the overs but they’d have to get lucky and hit the liver not protected. It was even more absurd with Pikas fake PGO claim.

Anywaus I realized this morning I didn’t clarify why I chose caps for my vote currently.

He didn’t really seem to suspect pika day two or try to do much towards him really. Until I came in and then suddenly he’s all gungho about it. It looks like mafia trying to hide behind town to lynch a PGO.

Also he kept mentioning Piko and wanting to hear more from him, but then drops off wanting to hear more from him whilehe keeps mentioning Tood who he notably avoids voting.

And I’m now wondering if Fapika is mafia because caps just called them piko several times.Slip? Confusing scumbuds? Or just honest mistake because the two have way too similar avatars and names?
 
Petals For Armor
Joined
Jun 25, 2011
Messages
7,697
Reaction score
2,408
And I’m now wondering if Fapika is mafia because caps just called them piko several times.Slip? Confusing scumbuds? Or just honest mistake because the two have way too similar avatars and names?
honest mistake. I couldn’t figure out what to call them (settled on Pika2) until halfway through my post, didn’t even realize I had accidentally called Pika “Piko” in that post until you mentioned it just now.
 
King of Luxray
Joined
Sep 19, 2011
Messages
5,054
Reaction score
1,665
dude

mido is not scum

she was copchecked town

the chance for her to be godfather is SO low
I think I meant to say Mido might be Silver.

I think it's fair because with less Mafia the chances of GF increases. It happened a few times with the GF being checked N1. I don't think Mido is Mafia anyway.

There is no active killing role in the game, thus, having THREE alternative roles who fill the niche of doctor, regardless of their limitations, makes NO sense balance wise.
There's a Rookie claim that upon their death would result in the death of another Town member, and then there are the Lovers, and two Indeps, and Mafia is confirmed to have a Redirector. Babysitter dying equals two deaths. Even the vig's 1x bulletproof was situational, which can go to Town too. Town's Ascetic guarantees a player that can't be protected too.

I think it’s because when you et doing the base of it, we have three protection claims and we had a BP. Mine is basically a modified singer, then we have lovers and then we have a JOAT who had a doc protect. Add in bomb and even in a bastard game it’s just crazy how hard it is for mafia to kill town. If last mafia is roleblcoker then they could roleblock one and try to hit the overs but they’d have to get lucky and hit the liver not protected. It was even more absurd with Pikas fake PGO claim.

Anyways, I realized this morning I didn’t clarify why I chose caps for my vote currently.

He didn’t really seem to suspect pika day two or try to do much towards him really. Until I came in and then suddenly he’s all gungho about it. It looks like mafia trying to hide behind town to lynch a PGO.

Also he kept mentioning Piko and wanting to hear more from him, but then drops off wanting to hear more from him whilehe keeps mentioning Tood who he notably avoids voting.

And I’m now wondering if Fapika is mafia because caps just called them piko several times.Slip? Confusing scumbuds? Or just honest mistake because the two have way too similar avatars and names?
Nah I think it is a genuine mistake - similar usernames and profile pics. I think it happened to me once here.
 
Joined
May 30, 2012
Messages
19,621
Reaction score
3,289
Nah I think it is a genuine mistake - similar usernames and profile pics. I think it happened to me once here.
I think you’ve done it a few times, so it was more a paranoia thought as I was typing. Seriously one of them needs to change soemthong -_-
 
jelly fish
Joined
Apr 16, 2016
Messages
492
Reaction score
196
no, I'm scumreading because a billion of nonsensical actions fatima pulled and them bailing out as soon as someone pressured them the slightest which is just hollywood mafia 2

and I don't like their target claim
Fatima was kinda suspected the entire game though? sure, he was kinda believed in by some (bc too scummy to be scum), but is that that similar to hollywood mafia 2? genuine question because I didn't look at that game.

Dude I’ve been trying to push my case on Human since Day 2 and no one’s even given it a second thought. Ya bet your ass that i’m tired of trying.
You flip-flopped between Pika being scum and Human being scum.

the chance for her to be godfather is SO low
Has it never happened before?

Vote: TheCapsFan

based on flimsy claim & previous actions.

I really don't think Human is scum since he voted two scum out, and yeah maybe he's done that before as scum, but he's also tried to solve the game in various ways. He could have easily pushed to vote me out when I claimed Loved, but he didn't.

What character would go with babysitter again?
 
Dumb and Numb
Joined
Apr 5, 2016
Messages
2,822
Reaction score
773
Fatima was kinda suspected the entire game though? sure, he was kinda believed in by some (bc too scummy to be scum), but is that that similar to hollywood mafia 2? genuine question because I didn't look at that game
lol, I’m calling this game Hollywood Mafia 2
in Hollywood Mafia I kept asking them to give me some self meta so I knew what I was working with and got a bit suspicious of HD and Mido defending Fatima and then he bailed out outta nowhere exactly like here

I even made a deja vu commentary right when it happened because it was almost literally the same thing
 
Night 5: TBA New
Standing Out
Joined
Dec 9, 2015
Messages
9,317
Reaction score
5,548
Night 5: TBA

End-Phase Votals:
TheCapsFan (6):
HumanDawn, ExLight, Midorikawa, ZinnLav, Space, Pika_pika42
ExLight (1): TheCapsFan
Not voting (1): Jinjo

<FT to be added later>

TheCapsFan was lynched. They were Monkey Khan, a Bomb aligned with the Freedom Fighters.
Hi there TheCapsFan, you are Ken “Monkey” Khan.


Though you were raised in a village of pacifists, you rejected their ideals as The Great War continued to spread and consume more and more of the planet. Unfortunately, your fears later came to fruition as the warlord Julian Kintobor (who would later come to be known as Ivo Robotnik), arrived at your village to use you as test subjects for his cyborg technology. The only one strong enough to survive the process, you were granted increased strength and combat ability, but Kintobor got more than he bargained for when you proved strong enough to resist his orders. This caused him to seal you away for years, before being discovered by Sonic and Sally. After a brief misunderstanding with Sonic, you became an ally of the Freedom Fighters.

You are a Bomb. You’re a powerful fighter, and even if you can’t stop your own death, you can be damn sure you’ll take your attacker down with you. As such, if you are night killed then your killer will die with you.

You are aligned with the Freedom Fighters and win once all hostile forces have been eliminated.

It is now Night 5. Due to my own schedule Night 5 will only last 23.5 hours.
Countdown timer
 
Last edited:
Dumb and Numb
Joined
Apr 5, 2016
Messages
2,822
Reaction score
773
I know I kinda expected one or two unusual characters but
who the fuck is thisssss

honestly I wouldn’t’ve considered Bomb even if that character had been hinted anywhere
this prolly shows it might be dangerous to tunnel on flavor :surppika:

._. ...

Wow... I feel really ashamed of this...
pretty much everyone agreed on that lynch, so we all are
oof

I’ll try starting sketching some theories here

we should maybe start coordinating some stuff to make sure the lovers get through the next day phase so we have a smaller PoE
 
King of Luxray
Joined
Sep 19, 2011
Messages
5,054
Reaction score
1,665
Ugh, with Monkey Khan dying there my theory of all the Town characters being in the OP is thrown down the drain...

Where I'm floating right now:

Town
^
l (Jinjo
l Space)
l ZinnLav
l Midorikawa
l ExLight
l Pika_Pika42
v
Mafia

And the last two were voters on the Pikochu wagon... :/

If there's two Mafia left, I think it's either Midorikawa / Pika_Pika42 or Midorikawa / ExLight. I doubt it's ExLight / Pika_Pika42 with how ExLight has been against the Fatima slot for a long while now.

@ExLight @Pika_pika42

How should we handle our claims in this mess? With ExLight's claim that's harder to do considering his death leads to the death of the target too...

We are 7 players now, right? Assuming there might be two Mafia, and ExLight targets one of the Lovers, and ExLight dies alongside the Lovers, then we would be 4 players left and with two Mafia, then Mafia would win by parity.

@Lone_Garurumon

Could this be the *last* phase of the game assuming no modkills?
 
King of Luxray
Joined
Sep 19, 2011
Messages
5,054
Reaction score
1,665
If there's two Mafia left, I think it's either Midorikawa / Pika_Pika42 or Midorikawa / ExLight. I doubt it's ExLight / Pika_Pika42 with how ExLight has been against the Fatima slot for a long while now.
Actually, in this scenario, it would actually be better to lynch Mido...???

Unless I'm legitimately digging my grave here thinking about ZinnLav being Jack/Shard so much, ZinnLav shouldn't be Mafia.

I'll need to look into Midorikawa's and ExLight's interactions this game. Most I remember is them Town reading each other, which sounds like a really unscum thing to do, so maybe it's really Pika_Pika42?
 
Dumb and Numb
Joined
Apr 5, 2016
Messages
2,822
Reaction score
773
How should we handle our claims in this mess? With ExLight's claim that's harder to do considering his death leads to the death of the target too...
if Pika is telling the truth he could Bodyguard me, which would prevent me from dying probably? Then both you and me can protect one lover each

If scum still has strongman then we’ll lose lovers anyway although I don’t know if strongman would hit the bodyguard or me so it’s the difference between 2 or 3 kills
 
King of Luxray
Joined
Sep 19, 2011
Messages
5,054
Reaction score
1,665
I know I kinda expected one or two unusual characters but
who the fuck is thisssss

honestly I wouldn’t’ve considered Bomb even if that character had been hinted anywhere
this prolly shows it might be dangerous to tunnel on flavor :surppika:


pretty much everyone agreed on that lynch, so we all are
oof

I’ll try starting sketching some theories here

we should maybe start coordinating some stuff to make sure the lovers get through the next day phase so we have a smaller PoE
I can choose to target Space, and Pika_Pika42 can agree to bodyguard Jinjo, but then we leave Midorikawa/ZinnLav open, and even ourselves. Your role is the trickiest because if you target town and you get nk'd, the target dies too.
 
Top