Mafia Chaos Mafia V: This Time it's Personal. Night 5: A Purr-fect Outcome

Petals For Armor
Joined
Jun 25, 2011
Messages
7,812
Reaction score
2,484
It’s because I’m on mobile, and whenever I select the fonts choices, my Google Chrome crashes. I will amend my posts to the superior font once I have access to my portable computer.

Why are you not voting Blight DarthWolf with me? Even if you didn’t agree with me, he is as good as any player to lynch at this point.
What a terrible shame, good sir. Sophisticated men like yourself should always have access to the proper methods of speaking in the most acceptable of tone! A shame, a shame.

But alas, you do promote the mightiest of points, my good man. I shall join you in your quest to rid this world of those terrible Blights. [VOTE]: DarthWolf
 
Minty fresh.
Joined
Oct 16, 2013
Messages
9,812
Reaction score
2,970
Is there a reason for the darth hate?
Not really. It's mostly just because he's ME's current "rival", I think.

But since I like to pick on DW, I'm fine with voting Darth off. Later.

In other news, Snowy's opening post about lynching the hosts pinged me, but I don't think it warrants a vote just yet. Nothing of note since, personally.
Do you have anything more to say on this? Do you agree? disagree? Think I'm crazy? all of the above?
 
looking forward
Joined
Aug 14, 2013
Messages
1,088
Reaction score
1,259
leviathan with gun < leviathan with grandkids

Is there usually an odd-night granny/pgo when there's also an even-night one?
 
i am ferdinand von aegir!
Joined
Apr 16, 2016
Messages
551
Reaction score
229
I don't really either, I guess with the role I had I wanted to get everything out in the open and I was a bit tired at that point so I decided claiming the name used in my role was important? I'm also not really sure why they used Granny instead of PGO, maybe because Even Night Granny just sounds better?
Why wouldn't you claim the name in the role? I'm not sure why you're defending the "granny" part seems like you've got something to hide. I'm not sure what but I'm going to keep an eye on you.

Good, good, just wanted it confirmed
Why?

leviathan with gun < leviathan with grandkids

Is there usually an odd-night granny/pgo when there's also an even-night one?
Have you seen this happen before or something? but I mean, anything's possible probably with this game
 
Petals For Armor
Joined
Jun 25, 2011
Messages
7,812
Reaction score
2,484
Do you have anything more to say on this? Do you agree? disagree? Think I'm crazy? all of the above?
Yeah I can elaborate on that. Personally I don't think that lynching the host is ever a good idea because lynching the host confirms that you will not be lynching mafia, since they are the hosts and therefore unaligned. So advocating for lynching the host is kinda anti-town.

Granted, this is Chaos Mafia. But it was just an odd entry for you, in my opinion.

I don’t. The other form hurts my eyes.
Aw c'mon Mido, don't you wanna have some fuuuuuuun?

Have you seen this happen before or something? but I mean, anything's possible probably with this game
I actually think I've played in a game with two town roles that were even/odd night targets. But I couldn't tell ya the game or the roles, I can't remember.

Aaaaanyway, @DarthWolf I'm waiting on your kingmaker claim. :U
 
Petals For Armor
Joined
Jun 25, 2011
Messages
7,812
Reaction score
2,484
Actually, that's a lie. I think it was an old PokeCommunity game where there were two cults, one recruited on odd nights, and the other on even.
 
looking forward
Joined
Aug 14, 2013
Messages
1,088
Reaction score
1,259
Have you seen this happen before or something? but I mean, anything's possible probably with this game
I've been in a games where there's been even night / odd night pair of players with the same active role. But I've only seen it with cops or doctors, so I was curious if anyone else has seen it with pgo

But yeah, this game is most certainly special, given the size and the context.
 
Brutally Honest
Joined
Nov 6, 2018
Messages
2,970
Reaction score
1,237
You'd rather it be unknown if we're actually playing a Bastard game? It helps to know that we can expect Bastard things, like the hosts being potential players or lying to us (we're all Squidward, we just don't know it)
 
i am ferdinand von aegir!
Joined
Apr 16, 2016
Messages
551
Reaction score
229
Yeah I can elaborate on that. Personally I don't think that lynching the host is ever a good idea because lynching the host confirms that you will not be lynching mafia, since they are the hosts and therefore unaligned. So advocating for lynching the host is kinda anti-town.
in other contexts I would agree, but wasn't this brought up because a previous Chaos Mafia had the hosts as mafia?

You'd rather it be unknown if we're actually playing a Bastard game? It helps to know that we can expect Bastard things, like the hosts being potential players or lying to us (we're all Squidward, we just don't know it)
No, that's fair.

out of curiosity, have all Chaos Mafias been bastard?
 
♡ ice reaper ♡
Joined
Oct 18, 2011
Messages
5,031
Reaction score
1,218
Yeah, I think the "lynching the hosts" thing as a way to start D1 would at best derail things, at worst get in the way of trying to actually find mafia. Maybe I'm just no fun lol, but it's not even something I personally would entertain right now, especially given how that's gone in past Chaos Mafia games.
Why wouldn't you claim the name in the role? I'm not sure why you're defending the "granny" part seems like you've got something to hide. I'm not sure what but I'm going to keep an eye on you.
He could have just as easily claimed PGO rather than granny specifically instead of drawing attention to it at all, with PGO being more widely used and all. I don't get what's sneaky there when I (and maybe others, I can't remember) commented on it being weird to use the granny terminology, it kinda makes sense to respond to that.
 
I'm a Girl
Joined
Mar 1, 2018
Messages
4,481
Reaction score
3,870
I have not played in the last Chaos Mafia and what made you guys want to vote the host? The host flipping mafia in the previous game I'm assuming this was an unexpected surprise mechanic which was not originally planned and the host decided to mess with the players?


Vote: CrystalOnix

Around an hour ago I saw him posting in the fun and games section and he is ignoring this game which I find suspicious.
 
All cards on the field are destroyed!
Joined
Jan 3, 2020
Messages
4,795
Reaction score
750
I'm not sure why you're defending the "granny" part seems like you've got something to hide.
FA questioned it, so I responded. Are you saying you wouldn't respond if someone questioned the fact that you wrote the name listed in your role PM in your claim?
 
Petals For Armor
Joined
Jun 25, 2011
Messages
7,812
Reaction score
2,484
in other contexts I would agree, but wasn't this brought up because a previous Chaos Mafia had the hosts as mafia?
As HD said,

Star Snowy, I believe that was a Role PM made in jest and not am actual requirement for a Star Victory.

We should focus our resources on lynching the Blight Darthwolf instead.
I suppose we could ask the creators themselves. @Magnificent Entertainer @Doctor Floptopus Was lynching the hosts a requirement for town to win the game in Chaos Mafia 4?

out of curiosity, have all Chaos Mafias been bastard?
They are bastard by the nature of the game, where roles and alignments are randomized such that traditionally town roles could end up as mafia roles and vice versa.

Vote: CrystalOnix

Around an hour ago I saw him posting in the fun and games section and he is ignoring this game which I find suspicious.
I hate when people use this as a strategy to try and find scum. It's a cop out.

People also used it against me in past games so maybe it's a bit of a personal vendetta

Anyway, I see no reason not to trust DawningWinds at this point in time. Good on him for being proactive, I suppose.
 
Madcap Entreprenuer
Joined
Nov 18, 2014
Messages
35,285
Reaction score
17,644
I suppose we could ask the creators themselves. @Magnificent Entertainer @Doctor Floptopus Was lynching the hosts a requirement for town to win the game in Chaos Mafia 4?
Technically, no. Didn't actually matter how we died, we just needed to be dead. Lynching would have worked. Vig shot or other night kills would have worked. Giving ME the Pineapple Pizza item would have worked.
 
Top