- Joined
- Mar 14, 2011
- Messages
- 1,377
- Reaction score
- 1,069
- Thread starter
- #21
The top three selling titles of all time feature none of those three, and the majority of Pokémon fans are not discussing the games on the platforms you refer to. You have no quantitative evidence to back up your claim, and you're far better off treating it as your own subjective or anecdotal view - which, of course, you are perfectly entitled to.
By your logic, Ruby and Sapphire are better games than Emerald, and Diamond and Pearl are better games than Platinum? There are games that objectively have higher quality features and gameplay, despite sales numbers. We all know new generations historically sell the most and third versions/remakes don't because a lot of people view these to be just "the same game, but different" than games they already own, that doesn't mean they don't objectively have more content than the games that sold higher. Also, HGSS is considered better than GSC, but by your logic, GS are the best Johto games? You can't use sales numbers to determine the best games, only the most profitable/highest-grossing games.