- Joined
- Mar 14, 2011
- Messages
- 1,377
- Reaction score
- 1,069
This is actually a two-part question.
Part I:
Did both of the aforementioned trainers officially beat Red? Did just Ethan, and not Nate? If they both did canonically (which I believe they did) who is better? If the PWT is canon, would that make Nate the best trainer in the world, because he can (and most likely does) beat everybody Ethan and Red have beaten + Brendan and Lucas, PLUS Hilbert via the main game? Is Nate the best trainer ever or will this title forever be exclusive to Red.
Part II:
Due to the PWT, doesn't that technically mean Red can (and most likely will) beat almost every Champion in the game as well? Think of it, how many times does one play through the Champions tournament to battle each and every Champion? At least three times, probably more, this means every time you play through it, so does Red, technically, granted he won't always make it to the final round but he usually wins his first and second matches, assuming he isn't unlucky enough to battle Nate right away, but it's possible to beat Nate too. So Red can also beat everyone you beat, at least in the people contained in the Champions Tournament. But this also means that Blue, Lance, Steven, Wallace, Cynthia, and Alder can also beat any of the other seven Champions, so the question to this part is, who is the best trainer? Does Red prevail, or does Nate prevail canonically, or do you think it would be someone else?
Part I:
Did both of the aforementioned trainers officially beat Red? Did just Ethan, and not Nate? If they both did canonically (which I believe they did) who is better? If the PWT is canon, would that make Nate the best trainer in the world, because he can (and most likely does) beat everybody Ethan and Red have beaten + Brendan and Lucas, PLUS Hilbert via the main game? Is Nate the best trainer ever or will this title forever be exclusive to Red.
Part II:
Due to the PWT, doesn't that technically mean Red can (and most likely will) beat almost every Champion in the game as well? Think of it, how many times does one play through the Champions tournament to battle each and every Champion? At least three times, probably more, this means every time you play through it, so does Red, technically, granted he won't always make it to the final round but he usually wins his first and second matches, assuming he isn't unlucky enough to battle Nate right away, but it's possible to beat Nate too. So Red can also beat everyone you beat, at least in the people contained in the Champions Tournament. But this also means that Blue, Lance, Steven, Wallace, Cynthia, and Alder can also beat any of the other seven Champions, so the question to this part is, who is the best trainer? Does Red prevail, or does Nate prevail canonically, or do you think it would be someone else?