- Jun 9, 2012
- Reaction score
Good luck ISOing... Nothing
i’m riding my towncred.
I think this bottom part is plausible.Again an argument I could see working if both wagons are town, in fact it is best play to be unsure on both if you are wrong for both, but knowing the other wagon is scum makes me paranoid. It could be that scum!Raven actually wanted a No Lynch, not bus Piko but also not have me flip yet, so a case on me can be made again the next day, any No Lynch is a free +1 for scum at the cost of having to act it right for just a bit longer. But Minish showed up and ruined it.
What I mostly get from this is that scum Raven and scum Minish together is not likely.
sigh this is why I didn't want to share my tinfoil. Please do not use the tinfoil meta read that I already said I think is pretty unfair to use in this instance.Minish is included because Snowy has a meta of subbing out when scum and Minish has a meta of bussing when scum.
I mean...I guess her rebuttal will just be "WIFOM" lol
I do like this idea, not necessarily with the voting but I agree that I want to see other players introduce cases tomorrow.What we NEED for maximum info is Mido Minish LICH etc to be FIRST in suggesting cases tomorrow (especially Mido who is high active too). It should not be Caps or I guiding them.
Have them all commit on each other.
@TheCapsFan what do you think on this? If you or I suggest something first it will just be too easy for low active scum to follow the flow, be it mislynch or bus. What if we let them all do the first/second votes and actually open up our cards last?
This. So much this.I think it's incredibly unlikely that all these players are town and that there are exactly two scum between Elie, Gentlefeather, Lich, and Jamie. Aka I definitely think there was scum involved in the voting yesterday. So we have to kinda figure out which of the above five is more suspicious based on what they had done. The ISOs will help, but at first glance I think Zexy and Minish look the best, which leaves us with Raven, Mido, and ExLight.
To be fair, the plan did change later, because the three major players we are looking at did interact a lot with each other.I do like this idea, not necessarily with the voting but I agree that I want to see other players introduce cases tomorrow.
Playing all sides except the "Piko could be scum" side. In fact he still kinda seems on the Piko town side based on the first post.This post just feels like it is playing all sides. Also this is like the third post of pointing out something about Zexy. It looks like he’s fueling the flames without being the one that would have to take the blame.
There was about 20 minutes between the post referenced in the above quote and this one. That is a really quick turnaround. The only real indication we could see that he is progressing somewhere on Piko would be him saying "I'm reading D1." And my case was based on a post from D2. He didn't respond to my case really at all, just came out with this after the fact.What I don’t like about this is I don’t think we saw Light say much against Piko, and I think there was more against Zexy. Which makes this one seem like he’s covering all bases.
In a positive or negative way?The choice of the word vehemently in contingency with zexy’s name is interesting to note.
He did say that "he was torn" but he didn't give any indication as to why he was torn, this is true. Looking at the ISO makes this look pretty bad.Again he‘s hardly mentioned Piko in a negative light vs how much he’s brought up Zexy excluding answering my direct questions. So this honestly looks like it comes out of nowhere. There was the small bit about talking about mechanics, and Piko s read on him, but he hasn’t really expressed any belief that screams “Piko could be mafia” or any intent to lynch him.
The part about Piko being defensive was kind of a new idea.His explanation of the cases to Minish. The first we see of him being against Piko with anything more than a vote or “I’ll vote him”
Not really sure that Piko's fate was necessarily sealed at that point because I don't think you were moving off Zexy regardless of you seeing the case on Piko. It does read like a defense of Raven though.The last post I quoted looks like a defense of Raven since it was in response to Zexy calling the unvote scummy. Whether he unvote or switched wagons, Pikos fate was sealed, and was more likely to die over Zexy since I had mentioned seeing the case on Piko. This means that Piko would have been the better lynch for mafia at that point, and they were better off lynching him.