Mafia Holiday Mafia 2017: Endgame: The Ghosts of Kwanzaas Past 15/1/18

[Maniacal Engineer]

I consider any role that is unfair to be bastard... As I stated in the post above yours, I was stopping scum from winning, and they had no way to kill me so...

Bulletproof Serial Killer is a standard role according to Mafia Scum, hence no bastard.

 

[Snowy]

Bulletproof Serial Killer is a standard role according to Mafia Scum, hence no bastard.

I just don't agree, Sorry.

Speaking of which, I'm curious what you thought of my fake claim.

 

[DarthWolf]

I was surprised no one linked the fruit laser to the SK, it was the most obvious role to be SK when everyone knew it was in the game.

 

[CheffOfGames]

I was surprised no one linked the fruit laser to the SK, it was the most obvious role to be SK when everyone knew it was in the game.

Exactly, which was why I kept focusing on AE with votes

 

[DarthWolf]

Exactly, which was why I kept focusing on AE with votes

You should also convince others of that then, tally up the votes on him.

 

[Snowy]

Exactly, which was why I kept focusing on AE with votes

To be fair (And my role was very unfair to your guys), town didn't want to lynch the SK because I was the only thing keeping them from outright losing AFAIK.

 

[DarthWolf]

At the point of of 2v2v1 they indeed couldn't lose Eevee. Mafia would have won then.

 

[Maniacal Engineer]

I just don't agree, Sorry.

Agree to disagree, then, but by my standards, this game was not bastard. Incidentally, AE, your BP would not have worked against the Town Strongman shot from the Present Giver. Furthermore, the idea behind making the SK Bulletproof is to help the SK and even the playing field a bit. As you said, SK has a notoriously difficult role to win with, and with a role like Hostage Taker in the game, in addition to the standard Doctor, which could prevent your kill from going through, it was the best way to balance things out, IMO. Given how the game turned out, I'd say it was reasonably balanced.

Speaking of which, I'm curious what you thought of my fake claim.

I'm frankly surprised and disappointed that nobody figured out you were the SK because of your claim.
A Pumpkin in a Winter Holiday themed game? After Jack Skellington had already flipped?

Still, I've been known to include the Pumpkin a time or two, so it seems to have, mostly, worked out.

 

[jdthebud]

Great game @Maniacal Engineer! A fitting send-off I would say.

I thought AE being SK was likely and even said as much. He was needed for town to survive though.

Also, I think it's perfect that my role survived to the end. Talk about being on the nose.

Thanks to @TheCapsFan, you da real MVP.

 

[DarthWolf]

Thanks to @TheCapsFan, you da real MVP.

Without even knowing it XD

 

[Maniacal Engineer]

Without even knowing it XD

See, this right here makes it even funnier.

 

[TheCapsFan]

That's crazy cool. That's all I have to say about that.

Congrats to town and to AE who might as well have won the game if I hadn't done the thing.

EDIT: I have one issue and it's a mechanics issue with the dead town voting thing. It's a great idea to keep dead players invested in the game but there's a PM limit of about 20 I think and if there are enough IOs/hosts then not all the dead people will be added to the graveyard chat. Aside from that it's awesome.

 

[Maniacal Engineer]

That's crazy cool. That's all I have to say about that.

Congrats to town and to AE who might as well have won the game if I hadn't done the thing.

EDIT: I have one issue and it's a mechanics issue with the dead town voting thing. It's a great idea to keep dead players invested in the game but there's a PM limit of about 20 I think and if there are enough IOs/hosts then not all the dead people will be added to the graveyard chat. Aside from that it's awesome.

In this instance, things like QT exist or the hosts could have a separate Graveyard for non-town entities.