- Joined
- Jan 1, 2014
- Messages
- 2,017
- Reaction score
- 1,771
It honestly sounds like you're letting your bitter feeling blind you to the possibility that the new main character can be good. If that's the opinion you have going in you won't like them no matter what. Try to be a bit more open minded. As for the formula that's always worked, it works until it doesn't. Family guy, the Simpsons, dragon ball, naruto, all of these shows ran 20+ years and see how after a while their characters become cardboard cutouts of their original selfs. Peter was a dumb but caring dad now he's staright up abusive, same with Homer but less extreme. The only anime I know of where the main Character didn't change to badly is one piece. It's good to let Ash go and be a champion instead of a constantly reset character who looks less and less like himself. People say this Ash is slightly OOC but that's because he became OOC when this was how he was originally. Plus now there's the chance to have him show up here and there like say Cynthia and show us some awesome battles that they never would have let him do before. Ash can still be involved as a champion character like Cynthia was or like Lance was.Loved the episode! Once again was I transported back to the pre-SM days. A shame it only happened at the very end of the show, because they felt the need to innovate in the last few years instead of sticking to the formula that worked for decades. If you have something that works, stick with it. The higher ups, especialy the writers and producers who came during SM, have just no idea how to manage this anime and now they will kill it instead of facing their own incompetence.
As a user said above, this episode proves there would be absolutely no problem keeping Ash around, as this episode proves that he can still lose battles. Having him battle gyms in Paldea woudn´t be a problem. He could have a rookie team of new Pokemon, like in previous seasons, where Pikachu is the only veteran and that would make any defeat believable, like it always did for previous seasons.
Each day I understand less the reason for retiring Ash. This episode proves that the so called formula can still keep going. No matter what the circunstances, the new series wil be formulaic as well, since they appear to want to follow an episodic format instead of a serial, as mentioned at the beginning of Journeys, s, why not keep the characters people already love around. It never stopped new viewers from joining during this 25 years, so why now? Honestely I feel petty, but I really wish this decision blows in their faces and they regret what they are doing to Ash and Team Rocket forevermore.
This isn´t a love letter to older fans. It´s anaesthesia so those fans don´t complain to much about the absulute insanity of their decision to retire Ash. Does anyone, after watching this episode, believe that they had no way to keep Ash around for generation 9? They can try to pull wool over my eyes, but I can see very well through their lies.
Some genius saw how terribily received Go was (just to clarify, I don´t mean to offend Go or his fans, I myself didn´t dislike him, I´m just expressing what appears to be the major opinion abou his character, especially in Japan) and concluded that the problem was Ash. I don´t even have words. Add the fact that the Ash storyline was actully well received (exept how out of nowhere this world tournament came), and you can´t find a sound reason for this decision. What people complained most about Ash was the lack of screentime his pokemon got outside batles. This problem coul easily be fixed by making the Team Rocket schemes of the week more frequent, like in older series (XY found the perfect balance with their appearance rate). As much as people like to complain and badmouth TR, their funny schemes were essencial to give these pokemenon much needed screentime and, above all, quirks and personality.
All very solvable situations, without the need to write off Ash. They are basically keeping everything people criticised about Journeys and taking everything people actually liked and use a new main character to see if it sticks. If this isn´t business incompetence and malpractice I don´t even know in wich world I live anymore. Getting rid of your golden goose who is stiil laying golden eggs after 25 years. Absolute insanity. I literrally never saw anything like this in my life.
Also the gym formula was getting old. Ash travels to a new gym across 10-15ish episodes. Encounters character of the day who needs help with X pokemon. Team rocket shows up for 1 maybe 2 episodes to steal said pokemon and by fighting alongside the pokemon to save it ash resolves the issue. Insert new team capture/evolution every 20ish episodes.
Ash makes it to the gym, like 6/10 times he loses on the first match and wins on the Rematch after training for a new move.
Companion character gets 3ish episodes to their arc.
Rinse and repeat.
So the formula did need changing up overall.