- Joined
- Aug 10, 2015
- Messages
- 3,769
- Reaction score
- 2,598
- Thread starter
- #21
Another book review! This one was originally posted on my LJ account on November 15th, 2017, though I only recently wrote the review and finished it in its entirety.
I give this simple but cute book about a girl and her dog...a 76/100.
Growing up, I never really liked reading. Actually, scratch that, I did like reading to an extent, but I hated having to analyze books for school assignments. Questions like "How does this chapter told in X's POV show about her character?" or "How will Y react to Z?" or "What does A and B say about C?" really stumped me, mostly because I didn't know what the word react meant, and partly because I just wanted to read without thinking too hard about them. I especially had trouble with it in middle school and high school, with stories such as Black Beauty, Lord of the Flies, and the one that especially traumatized me, Homer's Odyssey, giving me a lot of grief. I did recently decide to revisit one book I was made to read in middle school, Because of Winn-Dixie, and found that I like it. I remember seeing the movie in class once, and now that I've reread the book, I think it's time I give it a proper review, now that I'm actually able to comprehend and analyze books from a more critical eye as opposed to having so much trouble with it as a kid.
Since this is obviously a children's book, the premise is very simple and by the numbers: A young girl named Opal and her father, a preacher, recently moved to a new town. One day, when Opal is out running errands, she finds that a feral dog has decimated part of the grocery store she's in. She takes a liking to the dog, naming it Winn-Dixie, and decides to take him home. Winn-Dixie is quite a character, as he's always getting into trouble, from catching mice in the church to completely losing his mind when thunderstorms come around. But Opal and her new community love him anyway, flaws and all. The book is really about Opal, her father, and her new friends and acquaintances coming to appreciate Winn-Dixie and how he brings everyone together. Not a very original premise, but it can be done well, and for what it's worth, I do think it's serviceable enough here. If you're looking for something that'll blow you away or get your adrenaline pumping, you're in the wrong place. This book is a pure slice-of-life story, with many chapters focusing on mundane things, from Opal befriending a recovering alcoholic to Opal getting a job at the local pet store.
Much like The Wizard of Oz and Where The Mountain Meets The Moon, the prose is also very simple as well. It does make sense, as this is a book aimed at children, and is told from a ten year old's point of view, so while the prose is nothing to write home about, it's fairly realistic and doesn't go overboard nor does it feel so beige that it talks down to its audience or feel dull. Every chapter is short, only three or four pages long save for one near the end, so it's a fairly easy read. Plus, it gently touches on relatable issues such as loss, loneliness, missing parents, one's past wrongdoings, and reaching out to your community. They're only grazed at the surface level, but it doesn't sugarcoat the issues, but makes them relatable and easily understandable for kids, which is a rare feat to pull off. I think Winn-Dixie pulled it off here nicely.
The characters are serviceable, but nothing too note-worthy. Opal's a realistic lead: she's nice when she wants to be, but like a normal kid, she can lose her temper at times and get on someone's bad side. She gets into mischief, but she's still a sweet-natured, relatable kid who just wants friends and her family to be whole again. The other characters, while also decent in their own right, are pretty one dimensional. Several of them, such as a female classmate named Amanda Wilkinson or the mother of the rowdy boys in the neighborhood--who's only mentioned but never shows up on the page, don't get to do anything in the book other than say a few lines here and there. I would have liked to know more about Amanda, as I feel she was REALLY underutilized. We learn some things about some characters' backstories, but nothing that really dives deep into them. They're not unlikeable or anything, but at the same time, I can't help but feel that the characters had a lot of wasted potential that never got used.
But do I think it's a bad book? Not at all. Despite its mundane premise and slice-of-life take on said premise, it's still a very sweet, heartwarming, charming little book that I feel deserves the popularity that it gets. It's no masterpiece, but it wasn't trying to be one. It's just a cute little book about a girl and her dog, and sometimes, we need to sit back, relax, and enjoy a good book that makes people feel good, especially in these current trying times. I guess my main issues with it are that it's so short and that the characters, other than Opal, either don't develop or don't get to do anything. Plus, people who don't have a whole lot of patience might not gell with the book being purely slice-of-life, with nothing of note happening save for Opal and her father thinking Winn-Dixie got lost in a storm. That's literally it. I personally liked it well enough and I reread it from time to time, so who says sweet, pure slice-of-life books are bad?
Overall, if you want a quiet, charming, sweet little book that'll make you feel good or that you want to read to your kid, pick this one.
I give this simple but cute book about a girl and her dog...a 76/100.
Growing up, I never really liked reading. Actually, scratch that, I did like reading to an extent, but I hated having to analyze books for school assignments. Questions like "How does this chapter told in X's POV show about her character?" or "How will Y react to Z?" or "What does A and B say about C?" really stumped me, mostly because I didn't know what the word react meant, and partly because I just wanted to read without thinking too hard about them. I especially had trouble with it in middle school and high school, with stories such as Black Beauty, Lord of the Flies, and the one that especially traumatized me, Homer's Odyssey, giving me a lot of grief. I did recently decide to revisit one book I was made to read in middle school, Because of Winn-Dixie, and found that I like it. I remember seeing the movie in class once, and now that I've reread the book, I think it's time I give it a proper review, now that I'm actually able to comprehend and analyze books from a more critical eye as opposed to having so much trouble with it as a kid.
Since this is obviously a children's book, the premise is very simple and by the numbers: A young girl named Opal and her father, a preacher, recently moved to a new town. One day, when Opal is out running errands, she finds that a feral dog has decimated part of the grocery store she's in. She takes a liking to the dog, naming it Winn-Dixie, and decides to take him home. Winn-Dixie is quite a character, as he's always getting into trouble, from catching mice in the church to completely losing his mind when thunderstorms come around. But Opal and her new community love him anyway, flaws and all. The book is really about Opal, her father, and her new friends and acquaintances coming to appreciate Winn-Dixie and how he brings everyone together. Not a very original premise, but it can be done well, and for what it's worth, I do think it's serviceable enough here. If you're looking for something that'll blow you away or get your adrenaline pumping, you're in the wrong place. This book is a pure slice-of-life story, with many chapters focusing on mundane things, from Opal befriending a recovering alcoholic to Opal getting a job at the local pet store.
Much like The Wizard of Oz and Where The Mountain Meets The Moon, the prose is also very simple as well. It does make sense, as this is a book aimed at children, and is told from a ten year old's point of view, so while the prose is nothing to write home about, it's fairly realistic and doesn't go overboard nor does it feel so beige that it talks down to its audience or feel dull. Every chapter is short, only three or four pages long save for one near the end, so it's a fairly easy read. Plus, it gently touches on relatable issues such as loss, loneliness, missing parents, one's past wrongdoings, and reaching out to your community. They're only grazed at the surface level, but it doesn't sugarcoat the issues, but makes them relatable and easily understandable for kids, which is a rare feat to pull off. I think Winn-Dixie pulled it off here nicely.
The characters are serviceable, but nothing too note-worthy. Opal's a realistic lead: she's nice when she wants to be, but like a normal kid, she can lose her temper at times and get on someone's bad side. She gets into mischief, but she's still a sweet-natured, relatable kid who just wants friends and her family to be whole again. The other characters, while also decent in their own right, are pretty one dimensional. Several of them, such as a female classmate named Amanda Wilkinson or the mother of the rowdy boys in the neighborhood--who's only mentioned but never shows up on the page, don't get to do anything in the book other than say a few lines here and there. I would have liked to know more about Amanda, as I feel she was REALLY underutilized. We learn some things about some characters' backstories, but nothing that really dives deep into them. They're not unlikeable or anything, but at the same time, I can't help but feel that the characters had a lot of wasted potential that never got used.
But do I think it's a bad book? Not at all. Despite its mundane premise and slice-of-life take on said premise, it's still a very sweet, heartwarming, charming little book that I feel deserves the popularity that it gets. It's no masterpiece, but it wasn't trying to be one. It's just a cute little book about a girl and her dog, and sometimes, we need to sit back, relax, and enjoy a good book that makes people feel good, especially in these current trying times. I guess my main issues with it are that it's so short and that the characters, other than Opal, either don't develop or don't get to do anything. Plus, people who don't have a whole lot of patience might not gell with the book being purely slice-of-life, with nothing of note happening save for Opal and her father thinking Winn-Dixie got lost in a storm. That's literally it. I personally liked it well enough and I reread it from time to time, so who says sweet, pure slice-of-life books are bad?
Overall, if you want a quiet, charming, sweet little book that'll make you feel good or that you want to read to your kid, pick this one.