List elimination

Acrobatic Crobat

Bats aren't flying rats, but rats can fly too!
Joined
Sep 12, 2018
Messages
449
Reaction score
191
So, rules of this game are simple.
The first user posts a thematic list of some sort.
Then the next one deletes one entry from said list and gives a reason for deleting this particular entry.
Then the third one deletes yet another point.
The game continues until only one entry is left, at which point the user who deleted the second-to-last one creates a new list with a new theme.

For example, the first person gives a list of western elements:
  • Fire
  • Water
  • Wind
  • Earth
The second person replies:
  • Water
  • Wind
  • Earth
I delete fire due to its destructive power.

The third person then says:
  • Wind
  • Earth
I delete water, 'cause I can't swim.

Finally, the fourth user replies:
  • Wind
Earth is boring, so wind wins.
New list theme - [add a theme of your choice here]

So let's start with the list of starter Pokemon in the main series.
  • Bulbasaur
  • Charmander
  • Squirtle
  • Chikorita
  • Cyndaquil
  • Totodile
  • Treecko
  • Torchic
  • Mudkip
  • Turtwig
  • Chimchar
  • Piplup
  • Snivy
  • Tepig
  • Oshawott
  • Chespin
  • Fennekin
  • Froakie
  • Rowlet
  • Popplio
  • Litten
 

SoaringDylan

The Soaring Dragon
Joined
Nov 17, 2015
Messages
4,217
Reaction score
1,969
I remove Charmander because it's overrated :p
  • Bulbasaur
  • Squirtle
  • Chikorita
  • Cyndaquil
  • Totodile
  • Treecko
  • Torchic
  • Mudkip
  • Turtwig
  • Chimchar
  • Piplup
  • Snivy
  • Tepig
  • Oshawott
  • Chespin
  • Fennekin
  • Froakie
  • Rowlet
  • Popplio
 

DarthWolf

Sith Puppy
Joined
Dec 6, 2016
Messages
2,873
Reaction score
1,605
I heard you like mudkip... so I removed him :p
  • Bulbasaur
  • Squirtle
  • Chikorita
  • Cyndaquil
  • Totodile
  • Treecko
  • Torchic
  • Turtwig
  • Chimchar
  • Piplup
  • Snivy
  • Tepig
  • Oshawott
  • Chespin
  • Fennekin
  • Froakie
  • Rowlet
  • Popplio
 

Max1996

Wrestling Pokémon
Joined
Mar 24, 2014
Messages
25,940
Reaction score
21,338
Neutral towards all Gen 1 and 4 starters, but let's go in order. Bulbasaur's out.
  • Squirtle
  • Chikorita
  • Cyndaquil
  • Totodile
  • Treecko
  • Torchic
  • Turtwig
  • Chimchar
  • Piplup
  • Snivy
  • Tepig
  • Oshawott
  • Chespin
  • Fennekin
  • Froakie
  • Rowlet
  • Popplio
  • Litten
 

NMLewis

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 27, 2015
Messages
2,975
Reaction score
1,871
Turtwig's my least favourite starter, so that's that.
  • Squirtle
  • Chikorita
  • Cyndaquil
  • Totodile
  • Treecko
  • Torchic
  • Chimchar
  • Piplup
  • Snivy
  • Tepig
  • Oshawott
  • Chespin
  • Fennekin
  • Froakie
  • Rowlet
  • Popplio
  • Litten
 

Firox Zouru

"thank ya! time to eat apples"
Joined
Dec 12, 2012
Messages
13,434
Reaction score
5,919
Removed Torchic since its my least favorite of all starters
  • Squirtle
  • Chikorita
  • Cyndaquil
  • Totodile
  • Treecko
  • Chimchar
  • Piplup
  • Snivy
  • Tepig
  • Oshawott
  • Chespin
  • Fennekin
  • Froakie
  • Rowlet
  • Popplio
  • Litten
 

Max1996

Wrestling Pokémon
Joined
Mar 24, 2014
Messages
25,940
Reaction score
21,338
See post #4. See ya, Squirtle!
  • Chikorita
  • Cyndaquil
  • Totodile
  • Treecko
  • Chimchar
  • Piplup
  • Snivy
  • Tepig
  • Oshawott
  • Chespin
  • Fennekin
  • Froakie
  • Rowlet
  • Popplio
  • Litten
 

NMLewis

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 27, 2015
Messages
2,975
Reaction score
1,871
Litten is just... at the bottom of the current list. In more ways than one.
  • Chikorita
  • Cyndaquil
  • Totodile
  • Treecko
  • Chimchar
  • Piplup
  • Snivy
  • Tepig
  • Oshawott
  • Chespin
  • Fennekin
  • Froakie
  • Rowlet
  • Popplio
 

Max1996

Wrestling Pokémon
Joined
Mar 24, 2014
Messages
25,940
Reaction score
21,338
In Sinnoh now...away with Chimchar!
  • Chikorita
  • Cyndaquil
  • Totodile
  • Treecko
  • Piplup
  • Snivy
  • Tepig
  • Oshawott
  • Chespin
  • Fennekin
  • Froakie
  • Rowlet
  • Popplio
 

NMLewis

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 27, 2015
Messages
2,975
Reaction score
1,871
Sorry to Chespin, it's really only its middle stage that's a problem for me.
  • Chikorita
  • Cyndaquil
  • Totodile
  • Treecko
  • Piplup
  • Snivy
  • Tepig
  • Oshawott
  • Fennekin
  • Froakie
  • Rowlet
  • Popplio
 

Max1996

Wrestling Pokémon
Joined
Mar 24, 2014
Messages
25,940
Reaction score
21,338
PIPLUP Y U NO EVOLVE IN THE ANIME
  • Chikorita
  • Cyndaquil
  • Totodile
  • Treecko
  • Snivy
  • Tepig
  • Oshawott
  • Fennekin
  • Froakie
  • Rowlet
  • Popplio
 

NMLewis

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 27, 2015
Messages
2,975
Reaction score
1,871
Fennekin, you're good, but you got somewhat tainted for me somewhere along the line. Circumstances outside of your control, but... yeah.
  • Chikorita
  • Cyndaquil
  • Totodile
  • Treecko
  • Snivy
  • Tepig
  • Oshawott
  • Froakie
  • Rowlet
  • Popplio
 

Acrobatic Crobat

Bats aren't flying rats, but rats can fly too!
Joined
Sep 12, 2018
Messages
449
Reaction score
191
A bit too many grass types here, thus Treecko, being the only Hoenn starter left, gets eliminated.
  • Chikorita
  • Cyndaquil
  • Totodile
  • Snivy
  • Tepig
  • Froakie
  • Rowlet
  • Popplio
 

NMLewis

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 27, 2015
Messages
2,975
Reaction score
1,871
Rowlet should stay Grass/Flying IMO. So, regretfully, it's Rowlet.
  • Chikorita
  • Cyndaquil
  • Totodile
  • Snivy
  • Tepig
  • Froakie
  • Popplio
 

Max1996

Wrestling Pokémon
Joined
Mar 24, 2014
Messages
25,940
Reaction score
21,338
Sorry, Totodile, but you don't compare to Cyndaquil.
  • Chikorita
  • Cyndaquil
  • Snivy
  • Tepig
  • Froakie
  • Popplio
 

SoaringDylan

The Soaring Dragon
Joined
Nov 17, 2015
Messages
4,217
Reaction score
1,969
While water is my favorite typing, I'd prefer some other starter over Froakie.
  • Chikorita
  • Cyndaquil
  • Snivy
  • Tepig
 

Acrobatic Crobat

Bats aren't flying rats, but rats can fly too!
Joined
Sep 12, 2018
Messages
449
Reaction score
191
For being a smug little snake thing Snivy gets thrown away.

  • Chikorita
  • Cyndaquil
  • Tepig
 

Max1996

Wrestling Pokémon
Joined
Mar 24, 2014
Messages
25,940
Reaction score
21,338
Cyndaquil is the best Fire-Type starter left. Too bad, Tepig!
  • Chikorita
  • Cyndaquil
 

NMLewis

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 27, 2015
Messages
2,975
Reaction score
1,871
I had to. Chikorita's a fave!!! Sorry, Max.
  • Chikorita
Next theme is leaders of Hoenn.
  • Roxanne
  • Brawly
  • Wattson
  • Flannery
  • Norman
  • Winona
  • Liza
  • Tate
  • Wallace
  • Juan
 

Max1996

Wrestling Pokémon
Joined
Mar 24, 2014
Messages
25,940
Reaction score
21,338
  • Roxanne
  • Brawly
  • Wattson
  • Flannery
  • Norman
  • Winona
  • Liza
  • Tate
  • Wallace
You were in only one game, so out you go, Juan!
 
Top