My Starter Pokemon Tier List

[Phosphene]

So I decided to make tier lists for the first and second stages of the starters. Here's a link to my final evo post.

Spoiler: Second stages

S: Quilava, Servine, Dewott, Raboot
A: Ivysaur, Grotle, Prinplup, Dartrix
B: Charmeleon, Wartortle, Bayleaf, Croconaw, Grovyle, Monferno, Braxien, Frogadier
C: Combusken, Marshtomp, Torracat, Brionne, Thwakey
D: Pignite, Quilladin, Drizzile

Favorite

• Overall: Dewott
• Grass: Servine
• Fire: Quilava
• Water: Dewott

Least favorite

• Overall: Quilladin
• Grass: Quilladin
• Fire: Pignite
• Water: Drizzile

Spoiler: First stages

S: Cyndaquil, Totodile, Treecko, Mudkip, Turtwig, Piplup, Snivy, Oshawott, Sobble
A: Bulbasaur, Froakie, Rowlet, Litleo, Popplio, Scorbunny
B: Charmander, Squirtle, Torchic, Fennekin
C: Chikorita, Chimchar, Tepig, Chespin, Grookey

Favorite

• Overall: Mudkip
• Grass: Turtwig
• Fire: Cyndaquil
• Water: Mudkip

Least favorite

• Overall: Grookey
• Grass: Grookey
• Fire: Chimchar
• Water: Squirtle

Greatest fall from grace: Sobble (S --> D --> D)
Greatest rise to grace: Chespin (C --> D --> S)
Most consistent Pokemon: Snivy, Oshawott (S --> S --> S)

 

[RK9]

 

[Kyuu-Tales]

Oh, this seems like fun! I think I'll have a go.

Spoiler: Basic Stages

S - Cyndaquil, Treecko, Fennekin, Rowlet
A - Charmander, Chikorita, Torchic, Turtwig, Oshawott, Scorbunny
B - Bulbasaur, Totodile, Mudkip, Piplup, Snivy, Tepig, Litten, Grookey
C - Squirtle, Chimchar, Chespin, Froakie, Popplio, Sobble

Spoiler: Middle Stages

S - Quilava, Grovyle, Dewott, Braixen
A - Ivysaur, Wartortle, Bayleaf, Monferno, Servine, Frogadier, Torracat, Thwackey, Raboot
B - Charmeleon, Marshtomp, Grotle, Dartrix
C - Croconaw, Combusken, Prinplup, Pignite, Quilladin, Brionne, Drizzile

Spoiler: Final Stages

S - Typhlosion, Samurott, Delphox, Greninja
A - Charizard, Meganium, Sceptile, Blaziken, Torterra, Empoleon, Serperior, Chesnaught, Decidueye, Cinderace, Inteleon
B - Venusaur, Blastoise, Feraligatr, Swampert, Infernape, Emboar, Rillaboom
C - Incineroar, Primarina

 

[Tood]

Spoiler: First stages:

S - Piplup, Torchic, Rowlet
A - Mudkip, Treecko, Sobble, Scorbunny
B - Chikorita, Charmander, Froakie, Squirtle
C - Snivy, Totodile, Turtwig, Bulbasaur
D - Chespin, Grookey, Tepig. Popplio
F - Oshawott, Cyndaquil, Chimchar, Fennekin, Litten

Spoiler: Middle stages:

S - Grovyle, Marshtomp, Combusken
A - Dartrix, Charmeleon, Bayleef, Drizzile
B - Wartortle, Quilava, Prinplup, Servine, Braixen
C - Raboot, Frogadier, Ivysaur
D - Croconaw, Grotle, Dewott, Pignite
F - Thwackey, Brionne, Monferno, Quilladin, Torracat

Spoiler: Final stages:

S - Empoleon
A - Sceptile, Blaziken, Greninja, Swampert, Charizard
B - Decidueye, Inteleon, Meganium, Torterra,
C - Serperior, Blastoise, Chesnaught, Feraligatr, Primarina
D - Delphox, Samurott, Infernape, Typhlosion, Venusaur
F - Emboar, Rillaboom, Cinderace, Incineroar

where S = love, A = like, B = okay, C = meh, D = mild dislike, F = dislike.

...it turns out I don't like a lot of the starters.

 

[GrookeyFan77]

Spoiler: Base Stage

S: Charmander,Treecko,Froakie
A+: Cyndaquil,Chimchar,Oshawott,Rowlet,Grookey
A: Bulbasaur,Squirtle,Chikorita,Torchic,Mudkip,Sobble
B: Totodile,Turtwig,Piplup,Snivy,Fennekin,Chespin,Litten,Scorbunny
C: Tepig,Popplio
D: None, I like the base stages.

Spoiler: Mid Stage

S: Charmeleon,Grovyle,Frogadier
A+: Quilava,Monferno,Dewott,Thwackey,Raboot
A: Ivysaur,Bayleef,Braixen,Torracat
B: Wartortle,Combusken,Marshtomp,Grotle,Servine,Drizzile
C: Croconaw,Prinplup,Dartix,Brionne
D: Pignite,Quilladin

Spoiler: Final Stage

S: Charizard,Sceptile,Greninja
A+: Typhlosion,Infernape,Samurott,Decidueye,Rillaboom
A: Venusaur,Blastoise,Blaziken,Swampert,Incineroar,Cinderace,Inteleon
B: Feraligatr,Torterra,Empoleon,Serpireor
C: Meganium,Emboar,Chesnaught,Primarina
D: Delphox

Spoiler: Explanation

S: Special tier for the Charizard, Sceptile and Greninja lines.
A+: Great but they aren't Charizard, Sceptile or Greninja.
A: Pretty solid mon! Not top tier tho.
B: Decent. Meh I guess.
C: Kinda boring lame lol
D: Why do you exist.

 

[EternalPokéFanGirl]

This was difficult, most of the starters are some of my favorites, just look at how many are in the S-Tier . In fact, I actually don't hate any of the starters.

Spoiler

 

[Phosphene]

Spoiler

 

[Aulos]

Here's mine, although there are plenty of them I don't have a solidified opinion over. I tried my best. Rest assured that the top and bottom are 100% accurate, though. Incineroar is an abomination.

 

[skywaffles]