Pokémon Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl General Discussion

[PkmnTrainerV]

RE: all the artistic choices. I don’t know if it’s just me, or these artistic choices happen to kick in when they nearly cut the effort to execute the game in half or just allow them to copy paste their earlier work. How hard could have it been to add remixed music?

 

[PkmnTrainerV]

I am aware that there are people who don't like that you can't turn off the EXP. Share. Here's an idea: You don't HAVE to win every fight. I'm sure there will be trainers that you can skip. I don't really care as much. Also, I think Game Freak is doing this because they want kids to be able to have. Not everyone plays games for the challenge.

... What is easier? Giving back players an option they already used to have in the first place or literally have players skip and purposefully lose fights because they weren’t bothered enough to balance the game around the Exp. share?

It's a kid friendly game so they don't want to show a chemical plant because of pollution implications.

Well these are the same games that show graveyards and emotional child abuse?

I've seen a few news outlets claiming that BDSP will have "placeholder music" which requires a patch on release day. Personally though, I believe the MIDI-like soundtrack is an artistic choice designed to replicate the feel of the original games, much like the chibi art style.

I honestly don’t know. It’s a weird pattern of going to the choice that takes the least effort and calling it an artistic choice. Why not again, make it an optional mode like the earlier games?

My point here is the idea that everyone would be satisfied if it were still optional is simply wrong.

What? Let me give you two options. Having a light be switched on permanently, and giving you a light switch that you can use on your own free will. Which do you think will help more people?

 

[Kit Chan]

A link to the Cynthia case in question.

While I'm still a bit skeptical on BDSP's teams, I don't think this was coincidental. Cynthia's Platinum team is my favorite Champion team, even if battling them can be nightmarish, so I really hope this is an indication of what's to come in a couple weeks.

I'm unable to check as the website is blocking me and saying my browser is making odd behavior (firefox), but I seem to recall it being a licensed third party case. It could be the third party put the platinum team by mistake.

 

[FinnishPokéFan92]

Spoiler: New footage of important characters

 

[Kallyle]

Spoiler: New footage of important characters

Is there anything interesting in their dialogue? Or is it just the same DP dialogue? I can’t read Japanese. XD

 

[Sakuraa]

The Galactic commanders look so cute as 3D chibis

 

[colours]

The Galactic commanders look so cute as 3D chibis

the more i see the chibis in this game the more im starting to love it lmao they're all so adorable!!

 

[FinnishPokéFan92]

Spoiler: Commercial

 

[zoroarctic]

What? Let me give you two options. Having a light be switched on permanently, and giving you a light switch that you can use on your own free will. Which do you think will help more people?

Wouldn’t matter to those who don’t think the light should be there in the first place.

 

[Bolt Strike]

Spoiler: New footage of important characters

Spoiler

Mars looks a bit too happy in that clip for an antagonist. Chibi style really isn't doing that scene any favors.

 

[PkmnTrainerV]

Wouldn’t matter to those who don’t think the light should be there in the first place.

They can switch it off and pretend it doesn’t exist. Why remove options for everyone just because they don’t align with your taste? Just keep the Exp. All on if you want.

 

[KirbyBulba737]

They can switch it off and pretend it doesn’t exist. Why remove options for everyone just because they don’t align with your taste? Just keep the Exp. All on if you want.

It's the same for disability ramps: you can just use the stairs.

Mars looks a bit too happy in that clip for an antagonist. Chibi style really isn't doing that scene any favors.

We can't have all the antagonists be nihilistic stoic people, now can we? I for one welcome this.

 

[TechSkylander1518]

I'm pretty sure swiftfox isn't saying that he personally doesn't want the exp share toggle, but that he thinks that some people who criticize the lack of a toggle wouldn't necessarily be satisfied just by putting it back; that these people would think it shouldn't be included for fans who do want it. (The conversation traces back to his earlier comment that "Plenty of people were complaining about the EXP Share even when it was optional.")

But really, I think that's being a bit too pedantic- if someone wants to dictate how other people play a game when it doesn't affect their own gameplay, it's kind of a foregone conclusion that you can't make them happy. Alola might not be totally correct in saying "literally everyone" would be happy with the change, but I don't think a minority of players that logically can't be satisfied is really worth this much back-and-forth.

 

[Puddle]

I'm starting to have doubts about that MIDI trumpet being an artistic choice, because it doesn't really match up with the style of the other tracks we've heard. Maybe the wild and trainer battle themes weren't quite finished when they sent out the preview footage? The gym battle theme is sounding absolutely epic.

 

[Esserise]

Maybe the wild and trainer battle themes weren't quite finished when they sent out the preview footage?

That's kinda what I'd assumed. I think Shota Kageyama (the game's main composer) tweeted a while back saying that he's been really busy with multiple projects, too, so maybe BDSP's stuff took longer to get fully put together compared to the promotional videos? Just a theory.

At any rate, I guess "game footage not final" should be expanded to "game assets not final," although at any rate, I think it's unfortunate because those rough MIDI sounds left a bad impression for some.

 

[olivinelighthouse]

these are the same games that show graveyards and emotional child abuse?

They also implied that Pokemon ownership can be taken as slavery in BW, and Hoenn's plot is a commentary on political issues in Japan. We have yet to see whether Ainu and Japanese interaction will be touched on yet in PLA but I can't rule it out yet. Considering all this and that pollution/climate change are the problem of our century, Game Freak should have no problem with a brief allusion to chemical plants.

... Back to BDSP: I miss the days when games were released as finished packages, but if they're willing to patch in better audio, maybe that's promising for the prospect of some good DLC. I would not be adverse to it... as long as they give me my Battle Frontier.

 

[FinnishPokéFan92]

Spoiler: Another short Nintendo trailer

 

[wanderist]

On a slightly more wholesome note, it's kinda cute seeing the comments on Twitter saying they're excited for BDSP because they haven't played Sinnoh before and this will be their first experience with it. Reminds me of when I was young and HGSS was coming out and it was a 100% brand new game to me because I'd never played GSC. I had vaguely heard that it was a remake but didn't really care much, was just excited for a new game.

 

[FelipePR]

On a slightly more wholesome note, it's kinda cute seeing the comments on Twitter saying they're excited for BDSP because they haven't played Sinnoh before and this will be their first experience with it. Reminds me of when I was young and HGSS was coming out and it was a 100% brand new game to me because I'd never played GSC. I had vaguely heard that it was a remake but didn't really care much, was just excited for a new game.

I don't buy this "100% brand new game" story, Lol. Just before HGSS came out, I hadn't played G/S/C games either, at least not in their entirety. So just before the remake launched I played Pokémon Crystal, and then HGSS. And.... both, in their own way, were great game experiences. Actually, my favorite Pokémon Games.

View attachment 151853Source

She only had a Snover in DP. Case pretty much closed, except there could be an exception or two like Clair's Gyarados and Glacia's Froslass.

I also find the use of Chimchar funny because people keep saying that the absence of the evolved "Hisui" starters in Legends trailers is suspicious. It's par for the course.

, the graphic, as reproduced in the image above, looks way better than I expected.

 

[wanderist]

I don't buy this "100% brand new game" story, Lol. Just before HGSS came out, I hadn't played G/S/C games either, at least not in their entirety. So just before the remake launched I played Pokémon Crystal, and then HGSS. And.... both, in their own way, were great game experiences. Actually, my favorite Pokémon Games.

Nah, for me it really was. I had barely even heard of the originals, and didn't know of a way to play them anyway. I wasn't really on the internet all that much back then either, so I was kinda in the dark. It didn't even really occur to my 12-13 year old self to find out more about the originals or play them. I can't even remember how I heard about the games in the first place, it was either TV commercials or GameStop or something. I know it had to do with an ad for the pokewalker.

I actually still haven't played GSC to this day, nor do I really feel a need to with HGSS right there.