• Due to the recent changes with Twitter's API, it is no longer possible for Bulbagarden forum users to login via their Twitter account. If you signed up to Bulbagarden via Twitter and do not have another way to login, please contact us here with your Twitter username so that we can get you sorted.
  • Pronoun field selections have been updated! To ensure they show up correctly, please reselect your preferred option(s) in the Account details page. Click here for more information.

Mafia Pokémon Colosseum Mafia - Endgame - Town Victory, The Shadow Pokémon Plan Succeeds, Orre Belongs to Cipher!

TheCapsFan

C'est Comme Ça
Joined
Jun 25, 2011
Messages
9,369
Reaction score
3,635
I disagree! I don’t usually crap post this much do I? (Not that that’s part of town or mafia alignment in my case)
I was mostly referring to the whole "i'm mafia" schtick. nothing so far has really stood out as something that you couldn't fake and when that happens most of the time I'm just like "i'll figure it out later"
 

Max1996

Silver Guardian of the Sea
Joined
Mar 24, 2014
Messages
42,756
Reaction score
37,014
Pronouns
  1. He/Him
Why would being wary about lovers claiming be suspicious?

Why not?
1. I did not say I found that suspicious, I think that gives them Town points.
2. Because claiming Lovers, if that is in this game, has the risk of telling Mafia "Hey, look, easy double kill right here!"
 

Mint Elv

I thank you ever so much!
Joined
May 30, 2012
Messages
20,173
Reaction score
3,615
Pronouns
she_her
1. I did not say I found that suspicious, I think that gives them Town points.
2. Because claiming Lovers, if that is in this game, has the risk of telling Mafia "Hey, look, easy double kill right here!"
Yet you were fine when Emmy was rolefishing. What makes them and exclusion?
 

Emmy

Double Trouble~
Joined
Sep 8, 2019
Messages
1,636
Reaction score
3,569
Yet you were fine when Emmy was rolefishing. What makes them and exclusion?
I object to this remark, I was not "rolefishing", merely suggesting a potential tactic to help minimize a potential mislynching on Day 1. :|
 

RavenRaziel98

Yeah baby, I am the lizard king!
Joined
Oct 13, 2021
Messages
848
Reaction score
673
Pronouns
he_him
What about the way DW reacted makes you feel like it comes from a town mindset? Personally I think that it's weird that DW reacted that way because it should be very clear to them why HD was doing that, IMO
Maybe my approach was to simple minded, but assuming that what was said about Max1996 being an easy mislynch is true, I could see how it may look like an attempt to built a low-effort case (I hope this makes sense in a way, it's a kinda hard to explain), so I guess it could be considered something like mostly a gut feeling.
 

alana

New Member
Joined
Feb 14, 2023
Messages
15
Reaction score
9
nah


"I don't trust Mint Elv as much because of what was said about them."

What specifically was said about them that makes you not share my town lean?

ye about raven

true about dawning

yeah they are really meh but atm max bothers me a bit more

Timeaus... sounds familiar and I remember them having a good grasp about the game.

We may be mistaken on what counts as role madness here. I say role madness is bastard roles that really change the game, or hide info.

An unexplained vote can be used to put attention on a player and in a way put attention to other Townies who might come to the same conclusion based on the same content. It's a way to see if the minds of other players mesh with yours. I could say the reason why and somebody else could be like "oh yeah human bro man i deffo agree let's lynch this baby" but it's a bit more likely to be Mafia just bandwagoning on me.

"Max is a known easy mislynch" "low-hanging fruit" - man you're right I should try have tried harder to mislynch Max on that post other than telling others to figure it out themselves! If Max is Town and can just be mislynched on that then... wooooooooow you really do not give him enough credit!
I've seen Scum!MintElv pulling almost reckless stunts, she plays mind games (one time there was a situation where she was left with two town and she managed to make one of them support her vote against a townie even though she was repeatedly sus-ed before) she will bus without questioning or second thoughts if she considers it necessary.
 

TheCapsFan

C'est Comme Ça
Joined
Jun 25, 2011
Messages
9,369
Reaction score
3,635
Maybe my approach was to simple minded, but assuming that what was said about Max1996 being an easy mislynch is true, I could see how it may look like an attempt to built a low-effort case (I hope this makes sense in a way, it's a kinda hard to explain), so I guess it could be considered something like mostly a gut feeling.
yeah, i get you.

although what Dawning said about HD trying to artificially build a case is possible, personally, if a player is scummy, i have no problem eliminating them (especially on day 1) regardless of whether or not they’re an “easy elim”

maybe dawning is different, but that still begs the question to dawning as “why do you think this is fabricated & max isn’t just scum”
 

alana

New Member
Joined
Feb 14, 2023
Messages
15
Reaction score
9
Mint Elv - typical play from them so far
DawningWinds - unsure, it feels like the vote on me is towny, but it could also easily be faked. that sums up my thoughts on dawning so far: not bad, but not out of their scum range by any means.
Max1996 - regardless of whether or not they got their players mixed up I don't like that they immediately jumped in to defend Emmy without being prompted
RavenRaziel98 - nothing of note so far
TheCapsFan - town
HumanDawn - typical play from them so far
gentlefeather - i like their vibe, feels like they've got guts which I like, would like to see more from them in the way of actual scumhunting tho
Minish - minish please come play :(
alana - thought the reads were pretty good, weird that they didn't comment on me tho
Emmy - rolefishing was pingy, but honestly on a reread not that much of a big deal
Dragondg - props for getting right into the thick of it with a vote, but not enough to tell if this sheep is dyed red or green

damn my opinions on pretty much everyone can be summed up by ¯\(ツ)
I mean i could have commented on who i knew in the game but mostly i dont have a read on you

...reads? most of my reads were similar to HumanDawn's
 

alana

New Member
Joined
Feb 14, 2023
Messages
15
Reaction score
9
Good Morning time for my half asleep post yay!!!

What reasoning? I voted so many people so idk who this refers to.

If we were a scum team you’d be on the lynching block already :)

Also :bulbaWave:

They’re suspicious, you’ve rechecked to see why, and you still can’t remember? This sounds more like “I agree with the big name players to try to blend in.”

Why do you have to choose someone to unvote? Am I the only one that has stuck out to you? Have you reread the thread?

Why would being wary about lovers claiming be suspicious?

Why not?

What does glib mean? This is the second time I’ve seen it.

Also unusual by whose standards? How many?
no, as in 'i rechecked their posts multiple times' and still nothing about them stuck out to me despite them being here
 

alana

New Member
Joined
Feb 14, 2023
Messages
15
Reaction score
9
my reads, most to least suspicious
gentlefeather
dragondg
Max

MintElv
Jinjo=Minish

DawningWinds

Emmy
Raven
HumanDawn
 

TheCapsFan

C'est Comme Ça
Joined
Jun 25, 2011
Messages
9,369
Reaction score
3,635
I mean i could have commented on who i knew in the game but mostly i dont have a read on you

...reads? most of my reads were similar to HumanDawn's
yeah I know most of them are similar on paper, i guess it's more of a vibe as to why I like the post? specifically bc I mindmeld with the read on Dawning, and I thought the sentiment for the last three were good too. like "i've gone back and checked and they've posted but I can't remember any impact they have, so potential cwac there." I also like that you're vocally wary about Mint Elv.

idk, it's really nothing alignment indicative, but it's a good intro imo
 

Mint Elv

I thank you ever so much!
Joined
May 30, 2012
Messages
20,173
Reaction score
3,615
Pronouns
she_her
I object to this remark, I was not "rolefishing", merely suggesting a potential tactic to help minimize a potential mislynching on Day 1. :|
Anytime you ask someone to claim it’s rolefishing if there is not a reason such as being on the chopping block.

my reads, most to least suspicious
gentlefeather
dragondg
Max

MintElv
Jinjo=Minish

DawningWinds

Emmy
Raven
HumanDawn
Why don’t you vote your suspicions?
 

Rainbow Cloud

"I've got to fly higher"
Joined
Jul 12, 2011
Messages
18,324
Reaction score
8,069

Emmy

Double Trouble~
Joined
Sep 8, 2019
Messages
1,636
Reaction score
3,569
Wait, "Mid-Phase"? Does this mean Day 1 has ended and TheCapsFan has been lynched already?
 

Rainbow Cloud

"I've got to fly higher"
Joined
Jul 12, 2011
Messages
18,324
Reaction score
8,069
Wait, "Mid-Phase"? Does this mean Day 1 has ended and TheCapsFan has been lynched already?
It's just the halfway point through day 1, the vote totals are the current ones at the moment and aren't final.
 
Top Bottom