- Joined
- Dec 19, 2011
- Messages
- 23,818
- Reaction score
- 13,934
...huh? I won? But I died.
What did you think of the game itself?
it was fairly interesting up until I died, then everything got boring
What Suggestions do you have to improve upon?
it did seem slightly town sided. I'm surprised the mafia won. Yes, I do acknowledge your efforts to balance it. I'd be surprised if the water absorb mons weren't there intentionally to make us think suicune was the third mafia, instead of raikou, and skarmory/zubat being there as additional flying-types potentially could have made it slightly harder to locate ho-oh and lugia. I also liked that there wasn't a real cop until day 3. The town also lacked a reliable lynch. But even with all that, the type effectiveness system was effectively able to be used too similarly to cop checks, something I don't think the town or I took advantage of well enough. So despite all the balancing efforts it still seemed slightly town sided to me.
What do you think of the roles made?
did anyone besides zexy actually evolve at any point? I think if you're going to implement an evolution system, the process of evolving should be much quicker. Besides that, I don't see any real problems...I was gonna say a lot of the roles were pretty dull, but that's probably just a consequence of that questionable evolution system. And ignoring said dull roles, you actually had a good amount of creativity going on. Nothing as creative as a recoil cop, tho...
Is there anything not mentioned you would like to comment on?
damn you, darth
Last of all... Generation III mafia, do you dig it?
damn straight. You better make sableye a role. And cacturne. And sharpedo. And swalot.
What did you think of the game itself?
it was fairly interesting up until I died, then everything got boring
What Suggestions do you have to improve upon?
it did seem slightly town sided. I'm surprised the mafia won. Yes, I do acknowledge your efforts to balance it. I'd be surprised if the water absorb mons weren't there intentionally to make us think suicune was the third mafia, instead of raikou, and skarmory/zubat being there as additional flying-types potentially could have made it slightly harder to locate ho-oh and lugia. I also liked that there wasn't a real cop until day 3. The town also lacked a reliable lynch. But even with all that, the type effectiveness system was effectively able to be used too similarly to cop checks, something I don't think the town or I took advantage of well enough. So despite all the balancing efforts it still seemed slightly town sided to me.
What do you think of the roles made?
did anyone besides zexy actually evolve at any point? I think if you're going to implement an evolution system, the process of evolving should be much quicker. Besides that, I don't see any real problems...I was gonna say a lot of the roles were pretty dull, but that's probably just a consequence of that questionable evolution system. And ignoring said dull roles, you actually had a good amount of creativity going on. Nothing as creative as a recoil cop, tho...
Is there anything not mentioned you would like to comment on?
damn you, darth
Last of all... Generation III mafia, do you dig it?
damn straight. You better make sableye a role. And cacturne. And sharpedo. And swalot.