Mafia Prank War Mafia, A BMU Story: Endgame, Final Prank Foiled! Town Wins! (2/6/19)

[Max1996]

...ah, that takes me back to when I inadvertently kept myself up all night in the Tower with my dreaded garlic bread alarm clocks!

...Sounds delicious...

 

[MegaPod]

Hopefully MP can selfprotect and is smart enough to realise he is the next logical target.

Bahaha. Bahahahahaha. BAHAHAHAHAHAAAA

Lucky I was even smarter enough to realize you’d expect me to self protect, and that buying ME extra time to check the remaining suspects was worth the risk of getting killed myself, eh?

 

[Maniacal Engineer]

Very well reasoned, my friend.

 

[MegaPod]

Why, thank you!

 

[Snowy]

Did you enjoy the game?

I was extremely amused when I was NKed... and even more so reading the mafia chat. So sure, yeah I did.

What did you think of the balance?

Others are probably better suited but... two vanillas on towns side?

What did you think of the flavour text?

I sat on a woopie cushion?!!!!

If you could change one thing about this game, what would it be?

More players.

 

[Maniacal Engineer]

two vanillas on towns side

four passive roles on the town side altogether. 4/7 = 57%
one passive role on mafia. 1/2 = 50%

This wasn't a rolemadness game, and I think that town's two information and one protection role worked out pretty well.

 

[Snowy]

four passive roles on the town side altogether. 4/7 = 57%
one passive role on mafia. 1/2 = 50%

This wasn't a rolemadness game, and I think that town's two information and one protection role worked out pretty well.

And I don't agree.

 

[Maniacal Engineer]

AE, Town kicked butt this game, and Mafia's one active role was useless. If anything, that indicates that the setup wasn't pro-scum enough.

In reality, factoring in that Calvin was the Godfather, and not regular scum, a little more detective work would have needed to happen to whittle down PoE from Cheff, Eresh, Max, and Darth, but it could have been done using the roles at our disposal.

 

[DarthWolf]

Imagine if I stuck to my initial thoughts and killed MegaPod n1. Game changer right there

 

[DarthWolf]

CheffofGames likewise returned to his home. As he approached however, he noticed that his door was slightly ajar. Taking out his trusty frying pan, he slowly edged towards the door. Slowly opening it, he raised the pan in preparation for whoever he might find inside, and suddenly found himself soaking wet, with a bucket over his head.

Clearly you didn't use the frying pan correctly.

Spoiler: Correct way

 

[Snowy]

AE, Town kicked butt this game, and Mafia's one active role was useless. If anything, that indicates that the setup wasn't pro-scum enough.

That's irrelevant to the opinion that I have regarding the roles.

 

[Lone_Garurumon]

I put in the Vanillas because I didn't want Town going too overboard with power. It's easy to accidentally go overboard trying to give everybody a unique role, and the Vanillas help keep that in check. Believe me, I've learned that sometimes it's best to not make everyone a powerhouse.

 

[Snowy]

Curious but why did you choose two vanillas instead of one vanilla and a miller?

 

[Lone_Garurumon]

I figured Ascetic was already Miller-y enough. In the sense that Cop was 100% useless in soling their alignment.
Plus no Millers means no auto-clears when someone claims it first thing D1.

 

[DarthWolf]

I figured Ascetic was already Miller-y enough. In the sense that Cop was 100% useless in soling their alignment.
Plus no Millers means no auto-clears when someone claims it first thing D1.

I was considering it actually but I was the very first poster so doing it later seemed weird to me.

 

[DarthWolf]

That and i had an active role

 

[Maniacal Engineer]

That and i had an active role

You should have had Calvin claim Miller.