So X and Y have been out for a week now and I've been having a lot of discussions across other threads arguing the finer points of different gens. Is Gen 3 the worst or is it Gen 6, is Gen 4 over rated, did Gen 5s Pokes suck etc etc etc.
So I thought why not create a thread?
In addition to completing the poll above picking your favourite Gen, this thread is more about ranking all the Gens. Put your fave of the 6 at the top, and least fave last, you can include spin offs in your decision, but count them as part of the Gen, so Colloseum and XD are apart of Gen 3. (Gen 3 fans this will help you greatly)
So for me it's:
#1 Gen 1 (duh)
#2 Gen 5 (no main console tie in hurt this gen, but even then it wouldn't top Gen 1)
#3 Gen 4 (only beats Gen 2 as it has Gen 2 remakes as well as the main DPPT)
#4 Gen 2 (I really love Johto, it's my favourite region, I loved visiting Kanto, but the Gen itself was really short and they put Johto pokes too late in the game)
#5 Gen 3 (Colloseum and XD do give it a boost but for me personally, it still doesn't top Gen 2.)
#6 Gen 6 (I know it's not finished yet, but I think I've seen enough, a rehashed Z version, and remake of my 5th ranked Gen aren't going to boost this gen up)
Post your rankings below. If you think it's too early to rate Gen 6 then you can just omit this one.
So I thought why not create a thread?
In addition to completing the poll above picking your favourite Gen, this thread is more about ranking all the Gens. Put your fave of the 6 at the top, and least fave last, you can include spin offs in your decision, but count them as part of the Gen, so Colloseum and XD are apart of Gen 3. (Gen 3 fans this will help you greatly)
So for me it's:
#1 Gen 1 (duh)
#2 Gen 5 (no main console tie in hurt this gen, but even then it wouldn't top Gen 1)
#3 Gen 4 (only beats Gen 2 as it has Gen 2 remakes as well as the main DPPT)
#4 Gen 2 (I really love Johto, it's my favourite region, I loved visiting Kanto, but the Gen itself was really short and they put Johto pokes too late in the game)
#5 Gen 3 (Colloseum and XD do give it a boost but for me personally, it still doesn't top Gen 2.)
#6 Gen 6 (I know it's not finished yet, but I think I've seen enough, a rehashed Z version, and remake of my 5th ranked Gen aren't going to boost this gen up)
Post your rankings below. If you think it's too early to rate Gen 6 then you can just omit this one.