• 4chan is an 18+ website, and as such we do not want to expose our underage users to that site.

    You may post screen shots and text from 4chan, but direct linking to the site or its archival sites is not allowed.

    Thanks.

  • To keep up with the hype driven by Sword and Shield's release, we are taking applications for new moderators in our Current Events: Sword and Shield as well as Anime and Manga sections.

    For more information, see this thread.We hope you all consider joining our team!
  • We hope you're enjoying Sword and Shield so far! So that everyone can enjoy it and not be spoiled, please keep the all story spoilers and any images from the games in the appropriate sections or in spoiler tags until January 3rd.

    Since spoiler tags are not allowed in signatures, please do not put images from the games in your signature either. You can list the names of new Pokémon if you want to list your team in your signature.

SPOILERS Regional Dex Discussion

Well-Known Member
Joined
Apr 8, 2015
Messages
1,334
Reaction score
1,732
Nope it is not. Raichu is Raichu; whether it's Alolan or not. We now have a usually-full-staged Pokémon (Linoone) who happens to evolve only in its regional form.

It would be somewhat comparable if Alolan Raichu, and Alolan Raichu alone, could evolve again.

Obstagoon is a completely new species; a new dex entry. Alolan Raichu was just a variant on the regular one, more comparable to Galarian Weezing.
Alolan Raichu is a regional variant. Regional evolutions are entirely new evolutions only available for regional forms.
I think they meant that Alolan Raichu (and by extension, Exeggutor & Marowak) are cross-gen evos in that their pre-evolutions could never evolve into those forms until Gen 7. They're branch-evos, but in this case they're forms instead.

Of course the difference between those three & Galarian Zigzagoon line is Linoone gets an evolution added on top of it.
 
Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 10, 2016
Messages
1,042
Reaction score
2,115
I think they meant that Alolan Raichu (and by extension, Exeggutor & Marowak) are cross-gen evos in that their pre-evolutions could never evolve into those forms until Gen 7. They're branch-evos, but in this case they're forms instead.

Of course the difference between those three & Galarian Zigzagoon line is Linoone gets an evolution added on top of it.
They're not "branch-evo's, but forms", they're just regional forms; nothing branched about it. What Oriden and I said earlier. Incomparable.
 
Well-Known Member
Joined
Apr 8, 2015
Messages
1,334
Reaction score
1,732
They're not "branch-evo's, but forms", they're just regional forms; nothing branched about it. What Oriden and I said earlier. Incomparable.
How exactly are they not branched, though? Yes, they're regional forms, but for those three Pokemon there's two different results when you evolve them: their Kantonian evolution or their Alolan evolution.

If that's not the definition of branched, then what is? Does Rockruff not count as branched even though it can evolve into two different results?
 
Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 10, 2016
Messages
1,042
Reaction score
2,115
How exactly are they not branched, though? Yes, they're regional forms, but for those three Pokemon there's two different results when you evolve them: their Kantonian evolution or their Alolan evolution.

If that's not the definition of branched, then what is? Does Rockruff not count as branched even though it can evolve into two different results?
It's not branched the way Rockruff's evo's are, as the region where you've captured the 'mon determines in what it will evolve; it's predestined, no choice whatsoever.
 
Eye of the Swan
Joined
Nov 29, 2012
Messages
3,101
Reaction score
4,881
Well, Exeggutor and Marowak could be considered an extreme variant of Wormadam formes, and vary greatly depending from the area where Cubone/Exeggcute evolve. In this case, rather than evolving in grass/caves/buildings, they need to evolve in completely different regions.
 
Now with Mega Evolution
Joined
Jun 28, 2013
Messages
4,784
Reaction score
4,467
This is all just semantics but personally I feel like if you consider Meowstic or Lycanroc as branched evos then the same would apply to Alolan Raichu, Alolan Exeggutor, and Alolan Marowak and vice versa. I myself think they’re alternate forms, though, not branched evolutions. Having the same name is the determining factor for me.
 
Here to ride the rumor train.
Joined
Aug 9, 2016
Messages
5,563
Reaction score
19,618
I think they meant that Alolan Raichu (and by extension, Exeggutor & Marowak) are cross-gen evos in that their pre-evolutions could never evolve into those forms until Gen 7. They're branch-evos, but in this case they're forms instead.

Of course the difference between those three & Galarian Zigzagoon line is Linoone gets an evolution added on top of it.
The thing is, what we mean when we say "regional evolution" is brand new evolutions for regional forms. This term came from the leaker who used it in that same context to refer to Farfetch'd new regional evolution. Alolan Raichu wasn't the first "regional evolution" in this context (or any context... Alolan Exeggutor says hi) because it was just a regional variant of an already existing pokemon, not a new evolution entirely.

Gotta remember that Regional Evolution isn't even an official term, it's only derived from that leak where it mentions Sirfetch'd. It's basically a fan term right now that happens to refer to the concept of new evolutions for only regional variants of old pokemon, of which Obstagoon is definitely the first that we've seen.

And nooo... Alolan Raichu, Exeggutor and Marowak really aren't branch evos, they're just different forms, for the same reasons that everyone else has been pointing out about Meowstic and Lycanroc.
 
Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 9, 2016
Messages
4,051
Reaction score
6,832
I still think regional evolutions is still a broader term. By that I mean not just regional variants get evolutions, but I feel regular pokemon can also get regional evolutions. Like farfetch'd. They can only evolve in a certain region.
 
Well-Known Member
Joined
Apr 8, 2015
Messages
1,334
Reaction score
1,732
It's not branched the way Rockruff's evo's are, as the region where you've captured the 'mon determines in what it will evolve; it's predestined, no choice whatsoever.
The region the Pokemon is captured in has never mattered. You can evolve a Pikachu/etc from Kanto, Johto, etc. into their Alolan variants, vice versa as well - you can evolve the ones caught/bred in Alola into their Kantonian counterparts.

This is all just semantics but personally I feel like if you consider Meowstic or Lycanroc as branched evos then the same would apply to Alolan Raichu, Alolan Exeggutor, and Alolan Marowak and vice versa. I myself think they’re alternate forms, though, not branched evolutions. Having the same name is the determining factor for me.
I'd argue they're all essentially branched-evos considering there's at least two different options for each of those, though Espurr itself doesn't get a choice unlike Rockruff, Pikachu, Exeggcute, Cubone since its evolution path is decided on gender.

The thing is, what we mean when we say "regional evolution" is brand new evolutions for regional forms. This term came from the leaker who used it in that same context to refer to Farfetch'd new regional evolution. Alolan Raichu wasn't the first "regional evolution" in this context (or any context... Alolan Exeggutor says hi) because it was just a regional variant of an already existing pokemon, not a new evolution entirely.

Gotta remember that Regional Evolution isn't even an official term, it's only derived from that leak where it mentions Sirfetch'd. It's basically a fan term right now that happens to refer to the concept of new evolutions for only regional variants of old pokemon, of which Obstagoon is definitely the first that we've seen.

And nooo... Alolan Raichu, Exeggutor and Marowak really aren't branch evos, they're just different forms, for the same reasons that everyone else has been pointing out about Meowstic and Lycanroc.
I know that, I'm not saying A-Raichu is the first regional evolution, it's not at all. I was just saying that maybe they meant it's a cross-gen evo.

Also why exactly aren't the four considered branch-evos when they fit in with the term? Any Pikachu can essentially evolve into Kantonian or Alolan. It's just in this case, all four evolution choices are forms, but it doesn't change that they're all different evolution choices for those Pokemon.
 
Now with Mega Evolution
Joined
Jun 28, 2013
Messages
4,784
Reaction score
4,467
I'd argue they're all essentially branched-evos considering there's at least two different options for each of those, though Espurr itself doesn't get a choice unlike Rockruff, Pikachu, Exeggcute, Cubone since its evolution path is decided on gender.
Honestly I feel like either opinion is totally valid. I just personally define a branched evo based on having different species names rather than evolution method. I see where you’re coming from, though.
 
Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 10, 2016
Messages
1,042
Reaction score
2,115
The region the Pokemon is captured in has never mattered. You can evolve a Pikachu/etc from Kanto, Johto, etc. into their Alolan variants, vice versa as well - you can evolve the ones caught/bred in Alola into their Kantonian counterparts.



I'd argue they're all essentially branched-evos considering there's at least two different options for each of those, though Espurr itself doesn't get a choice unlike Rockruff, Pikachu, Exeggcute, Cubone since its evolution path is decided on gender.



I know that, I'm not saying A-Raichu is the first regional evolution, it's not at all. I was just saying that maybe they meant it's a cross-gen evo.

Also why exactly aren't the four considered branch-evos when they fit in with the term? Any Pikachu can essentially evolve into Kantonian or Alolan. It's just in this case, all four evolution choices are forms, but it doesn't change that they're all different evolution choices for those Pokemon.
Pretty sure a Pikachu caught in Alola can't evolve into a normal Raichu; it's not a branched line, it's a region-specific line. And it's not a new 'species' (as in, dex-entry), so it doesn't hold up.
 
debates about Rugrats canon
Joined
Oct 18, 2012
Messages
5,909
Reaction score
15,422
Pretty sure a Pikachu caught in Alola can't evolve into a normal Raichu; it's not a branched line, it's a region-specific line. And it's not a new 'species' (as in, dex-entry), so it doesn't hold up.
It can if you take it to Ultra Space.

For what it's worth though, I don't really think of Raichu/Exeggutor/Marowak as "branch evos" per se. The context surrounding them is clearly different from, say, Politoed.
 
Well-Known Member
Joined
Dec 12, 2016
Messages
3,359
Reaction score
9,546
Also why exactly aren't the four considered branch-evos when they fit in with the term?
As a fan term, whether or not they're considered branched depends on the person, but I'd personally argue that a branched evolution is specifically about the fact that a Pokemon can evolve into two different Pokemon. A form difference in a Pokemon doesn't qualify as a separate Pokemon, according to the PokeDex.

A better example of the counterargument IMO would be Vivillion. Spewpa can evolve into 18 different forms of Vivillion depending on the region set for the game. And, like Lycanroc, Meowstic, or Alolan forms, Vivillion's form can't be changed. Despite this, nobody seems to put Vivillion in the category of branched evolutions, because it's still the same Pokemon, just in a different form.
 
Here to ride the rumor train.
Joined
Aug 9, 2016
Messages
5,563
Reaction score
19,618
Really don't want to bother with the branched evo argument because I guess it is a personal thing but I do believe that it is simpler to consider branched evolutions as being entirely different pokemon rather than different forms of the same pokemon, or else, like TechSkylander1518 TechSkylander1518 pointed out, every form of Vivillon could be considered a branch. And if alternate forms are a branch, then what about regional variants for every member of a line? They're not branching, but they're not a separate species either. It's simpler to consider variants as being an alternate version or subspecies of the same pokemon rather than being a branched evo. A branch implies going off in a different direction and Pikachu evolving into Alolan Raichu isn't going in a different direction in the way that Gloom evolving into Bellossom does- it's still going the Raichu path, just a different version of Raichu.

Plus this whole branched evo argument is really falling away from the original point that brought this up, which was "why is everyone acting like Obstagoon is the first regional evolution instead of Alolan Raichu?" and that's because the term "regional evolution" is being used to refer to entirely new evolutions that are unique to a region's variants, not regional variants of old evolutions. Alolan Raichu is just a new form of an old pokemon, not a new evolution, therefor it isn't the first example of this "regional evolution" concept in the way that it is currently being used.

Bottom line- we're borrowing the phrase from the leak and we don't have a better term for "new cross-gen evolutions exclusive to regional variants."
 
Well-Known Member
Joined
Apr 8, 2015
Messages
1,334
Reaction score
1,732
I still think regional evolutions is still a broader term. By that I mean not just regional variants get evolutions, but I feel regular pokemon can also get regional evolutions. Like farfetch'd. They can only evolve in a certain region.
Meant to respond to this earlier, but this tweet suggests original variants wouldn't gain any additions to their evolutions lines - only Galarian variants would.

View: https://twitter.com/Pokemon/status/1159097737431748609?s=19
 
Here to ride the rumor train.
Joined
Aug 9, 2016
Messages
5,563
Reaction score
19,618
Meant to respond to this earlier, but this tweet suggests original variants wouldn't gain any additions to their evolutions lines - only Galarian variants would.
I don't think that totally rules out non-variants getting regional evolutions too, it just emphasizes that some evolutions are only available for their regional variant lines.
 
Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 9, 2016
Messages
4,051
Reaction score
6,832
Meant to respond to this earlier, but this tweet suggests original variants wouldn't gain any additions to their evolutions lines - only Galarian variants would.

View: https://twitter.com/Pokemon/status/1159097737431748609?s=19
Honestly that sounds like the case. But when I think about it. Regional evolutions sounds the smartest way of getting away with cross gen evos. Back in gen 4 almost all the cross gens evolved fro items or move that haven't been learned previous. With this, they don't have to rely on stuff like that no more
 
Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 10, 2016
Messages
1,042
Reaction score
2,115
I really think the Galar dex needs to have around 600 'mons to be "acceptable".
 
Top