• Hey Trainers! Be sure to check out Corsola Beach, our newest section on the forums, in partnership with our friends at Corsola Cove! At the Beach, you can discuss the competitive side of the games, post your favorite Pokemon memes, and connect with other Pokemon creators!
  • Due to the recent changes with Twitter's API, it is no longer possible for Bulbagarden forum users to login via their Twitter account. If you signed up to Bulbagarden via Twitter and do not have another way to login, please contact us here with your Twitter username so that we can get you sorted.

Review League

@diamondpearl876 All accurate

Love and Other Nightmares

Review - 2
One chapter - 1
250 words - 1

Total - 4

some rise by sin

Review - 2
Two chapters - 2
500 words - 2
Speedy review (24hrs) - 4
Monthly bonus - 2

Total - 12

Land of the Roses

Review - 2
Five chapters - 5
500 words - 2
Monthly bonus - 2

Total - 11

Liberation of Pokémon

Review - 2
One chapter - 1
Speedy review (24hrs) - 4

Total - 7

Dungeons and Dragonite

Review - 2
One chapter (?) - 1 (I refer to chapter one in order to illustrate a point about chapter two. Whether that counts as one or two chapters mentioned isn't for me to decide)
250 words - 1
Speedy review (24hrs) - 4

Total - 8
 
Last edited:
@Beth Pavell Yep, checks out. Regarding the D&D review, I'm a bit leery of granting a point based on that, personally. Total: 42 points.
 
ayy long time no see are you ready to get ur hands created lol

Quite a few of these reviews are on the shorter side (under 250 words), so if you feel like some of them don't really count, let me know and I'll remove them from this list.

PMD: Hands of Creation - Chapter 4
base - 2
chapters - 1
speedy bonus (24h) - 4

(same fic, all of these are) - Chapter 5
base - 2
chapters - 1
speedy bonus (24h) - 4

Chapter 6
base - 2
chapters - 1
speedy bonus (24h) - 4

Chapter 7
base - 2
chapters - 1
speedy bonus (24h) - 4

Chapter 8
base - 2
chapters - 1
250+ words - 1
speedy bonus (24h) - 4

Chapter 9
base - 2
chapters - 1
speedy bonus (48h) - 2

Chapter 10
base - 2
chapters - 1
speedy bonus (24h) - 4

Chapter 11
base - 2
chapters - 1
250+ words - 1
speedy bonus (24h) - 4

Special Episode 1
base - 2
chapters - 1

Chapter 12
base - 2
chapters - 1
speedy bonus (24h) - 4

Chapter 13
base - 2
chapters - 1
speedy bonus (48h) - 2

Chapter 14
base - 2
chapters - 1
speedy bonus (24h) - 4

Chapter 15
base - 2
chapters - 1
speedy bonus (24h) - 4

total - 85

I'd like to claim a review for 40 points on the newly revised Chapter 3 of Hunter, Haunted, please. The fic is rated mature, but this chapter is basically teen as it only includes strong language (no slurs), implicit violence and minor themes of depression. I don't really have a specific aspect I want to get looked at, but if I had to choose something, it'd be on if the prose and how the exposition was handled. Thanks!
 
I have neglected to log my reviews here for... months, I think. I neeeeeed to stop procrastinating. Here's... everything.

Note, for Amby's fic, I'm taking into account that at the time when I made all but the last review, it was NOT in the archives, so it doesn't get those associated bonus points.

Pokémon Mystery Dungeon: Guiding Light (Vol. 1) Chapter 1 + prologue (just gonna count that as 1 point) +1
Base + 2
250 + 1

Pokémon Mystery Dungeon: Guiding Light (Vol. 1) Chapter 2 +1
Base + 2
250 + 1

Pokémon Mystery Dungeon: Guiding Light (Vol. 1) Episode 2 (+2 chpapters)
Base +2
750 +3

Pokémon Mystery Dungeon: Delta Dossiers chapter 1 +1
Base +2
750 +3
Super speedy +4

Pokémon Mystery Dungeon: Guiding Light (Vol. 1) Episode 3 +2
Base +2
750 +3

Pokémon Mystery Dungeon: Guiding Light (Vol. 1) Episode 4 +3
Base +2
500 +2

Pokémon Mystery Dungeon: Guiding Light (Vol. 1) Special Episode 1 +3
Base +2
500 +2

Pokémon Mystery Dungeon: Delta Dossiers +1
Base +2
500 +2

Pokémon Mystery Dungeon: Guiding Light (Vol. 1) Episode 5 +3
Base +2
750 +3
Archives +2

The horrible total:+58 (Not sure which ones had a different word count, but I'll take it)
Past total: 38
Final total: 96
 
Last edited:
@canisaries: Looks like you miscounted a 24hr review as a 48hr one - +2 points

@namohysip: can you please be clearer about chapters you're claiming for in the future? 58 in total, some of the wordcounts didn't come out as expected.

Now for mine:

Land of the Roses

Review - 2
One chapter - 1
Speedy review (24hrs) - 4

Total - 7

Land of the Roses

Review - 2
One chapter - 1
250 words - 1
Speedy Review (24hrs) - 4

Total - 8
 
cashing in my spoopy spree

guidance - 4
Review - 2
Chapters (1) - 1
Words (373) - 1

Snowfall - 4
Review - 2
Chapters (1) - 1
Words (382) - 1

Multiple Dimensionality Redux - 5
Review - 2
Chapters (2) - 2
Words (369) - 1

A Journey of Different Heroes - 6
Review - 2
Chapters (1) - 1
Words (752) - 3

Pokemon Mystery Dungeon: Guiding Light (Vol 2) - 8
Review - 2
Chapters (1) - 1
Words (367) - 1
Super Duper Speedy - 4

Pletora's Story - 4
Review - 2
Chapters (1) - 1
Words (291) - 1

Orre: The Desert. - 5
Review - 2
Chapters (2) - 2
Words (328) - 1

The Deprogramming - 5
Review - 2
Chapters (1) - 1
Words (571) - 2

Flying in the Dark - 5
Review - 2
Chapters (1) - 1
Words (512) - 2

Phantom Project - 5
Review - 2
Chapters (1) - 1
Words (543) - 2

Snowfall - 4
Review - 2
Chapters (1) - 1
Words (326) - 1

The Creations - 4
Review - 2
Chapters (1) - 1
Words (315) - 1

Pokemon Mystery Dungeon: Hands of Creation - 4
Review - 2
Chapters (1) - 1
Words (295) - 1

----
(below this line = not spoopy)

The Creations - 8
Review - 2
Chapters (1)
Words (254) - 1
Super Duper Speedy - 4
 
Last edited:
@Beth Pavell Adds up and checks out, added to the scoreboard. 11 points away from 1000...

My own:

The Long Walk
2 points for review
4 points for 1071 words
1 point for Chapter 21
Total: 7 Points

Hunter, Haunted
2 points for review
2 points for 564 words
10 points for purchased review
Total: 14 Points
 
Last edited:
Been awfully quiet around here... So much so that I've been able to slack on counting points!

@Beth Pavell, all checks out. That brings you to over 1000 review league points! Congratulations on this milestone!

@unrepentantAuthor Apologies for getting to this so late, but yours checks out as well.

@UselessBytes Our first claimed points for the review exchange, hooray! The points check out.
 
Kanto: There and Back Again - 34 pts
Review (2) - 2
Chapters (7) - 7
Words (2,209) - 8
Secret Santa (x2) - 17

Echoes in the Dark - 8 pts
Review (2) - 2
Chapters (1) - 1
Words (461) - 1
Secret Santa (x2) - 4

kid a - 4 pts
Review (2) - 2
Chapters (1) - 1
Words (345) - 1

Seasoned - 8 pts
Review (2) - 2
Chapters (1) - 1
Words (292) - 1
Super Duper Speedy (24 hours) - 4
 
Please note: The thread is from 2 years ago.
Please take the age of this thread into consideration in writing your reply. Depending on what exactly you wanted to say, you may want to consider if it would be better to post a new thread instead.

Similar threads

Welkamo
  • Sticky
GAME: Review League 2: Electric Pikachu
Replies
19
Views
2K
Cavespider_17
Cavespider_17
lisianthus
lisia's workshop one-review-a-day challenge blog!! (requests... OPEN!)
Replies
8
Views
621
Cavespider_17
Cavespider_17
Cavespider_17
Cave's Bulbagarden's Fiction Review Thread
Replies
6
Views
480
Cavespider_17
Cavespider_17
UxieLover1994
How points work in HOME?
Replies
0
Views
122
UxieLover1994
UxieLover1994
Archaic
  • Locked
Pokémon Scarlet and Violet's Ranked Battles Season 17 has begun, running through to April 30th
Replies
0
Views
2K
Archaic
Archaic
Back
Top Bottom