• Hey Trainers! Be sure to check out Corsola Beach, our newest section on the forums, in partnership with our friends at Corsola Cove! At the Beach, you can discuss the competitive side of the games, post your favorite Pokemon memes, and connect with other Pokemon creators!
  • Due to the recent changes with Twitter's API, it is no longer possible for Bulbagarden forum users to login via their Twitter account. If you signed up to Bulbagarden via Twitter and do not have another way to login, please contact us here with your Twitter username so that we can get you sorted.

Review League

I present reviews for the following:

Canis' Seiren: base 2, wordcount 1, chapters 1, awards fic 2: 6 total.

Amby's Guiding Light: base 2, wordcount 3, chapters 1, awards fic 2: 8 total.

Beth's Kanto: TaBA: base 2, wordcount 4, chapters 1, awards fic 2: 9 total.

Additionally, I'd like to claim the 2 extra points from my previous review of Seiren as it was an awards fic and I forgot about the bonus.

Total: 25.
 
It's been a wee-while. Awards review spam
Vivarium: 9 (Base + 1 + 500 + judged + monthly)
D&D: 10 (Base + 2 + 500 + judged + monthly)
Restarting: 11 (Base + 1 + 500 + archive? + judged + monthly)
Kanto: TABA: 12 (Base + 3 chapters + 750 words +judged + monthly)
Different Eyes: 17 (Base + 5 + 1500 + judged + monthly)
Specta: 19 (Base + 7 + 1500 + judged + monthly)

Total: 77
I note now that Restarting is in the Archive. I am not sure if it was there when I posted the review or not, so feel free to remove 2 points from that list.
 
Love and Other Nightmares

Review - 2
One chapter - 1
250 words - 1
September challenge - 2

Total - 6

The Alola Pokédex

Review - 2
Six chapters - 6
September challenge - 2
Speedy review (48hrs) - 2

Total - 12

Land of the Roses

Review - 2
One chapter - 1
Speedy review (48hrs) - 2

Total - 5

Star Performer

Review - 2
Three chapters - 3
500 words - 2
Speedy review (48hrs) - 2

Total - 9
 
Gonna sneak in my purchase of a beta request worth 40 points right here. I'll post further details in the Review League Beta Contributions conversation once it's cleared, and then what I'm looking for the most when I'm all set up with a reader.

Point tallying will happen shortly, folks! I was just about to do it myself and noticed that mine still haven't been tabbed up. I don't want my points to slip into the void and can't officiate for my own, sooo...
 
put me in coach

Phantom Project - 8 pts
Review - 2 pts
Words (827) - 3 pts
September Theme (Awards) - 2 pts
Chapters (1) - 1 pt

Pokemon Mystery Dungeon: Guiding Light - 11 pts
Review - 2 pts
Chapters (1) - 1 pt
Words (701) - 2 pts
September Theme (Awards) - 2 pts
Super Duper Speedy - 4 pts

Different Eyes - 13 pts
Review - 2 pts
Chapters (2) - 2 pts
Words (1791) - 7 pts
September Theme (Awards) - 2 pts

Star Performer - 7 pts
Review - 2 pts
Chapters (3) - 3 pts
Words (582) - 2 pts

Pletora's Story - 7 pts
Review - 2 pts
Chapters (1) - 1 pt
Words (305) - 1 pt
Super Duper Speedy - 4 pts

Guidance - 14 pts
Review - 2 pts
Chapters (6) - 6 pts
Words (1191) - 4 pts
September Theme (Awards) - 2 pts

Guiding Light (again) - 13 pts
Review - 2 pts
Chapters (1) - 1 pt
Words (872) - 3 pts
September Theme (Awards) - 2 pts
Super Duper Speedy - 4 pts
Review Game - 2 pts
 
Last edited:
Don't mind me, just posting reviews.

Pokemon Mystery Dungeon: Hands of Creation
+2 - Base
+1 - 1 chapter
+1 - 490-ish words
+4 - Super speedy
Total: +8

Pokemon Mystery Dungeon: Hands of Creation
+2 - Base
+1 - 1 chapter
+3 - 750 words
+4 - Super speedy
Total: +10

Pokémon Mystery Dungeon: Delta Dossiers
+2 - Base
+1 - 1 part
+3 - 750 words
+4 - Super speedy
Total: +10

Pokemon Mystery Dungeon: Hands of Creation
+2 - Base
+1 - 1 chapter
+2 - 690 words
+4 - Super speedy
Total: +9

Flying in the Dark
+2 - Base
+1 - 1 part
+1 - 420 words
+2 - Review game entry
Total: +6

guidance
+2 - Base
+1 - 1 part
+2 - 510 words
+2 - September bonus (in the awards... again)
+4 - Super speedy
Total: +11

Running total: 614
Lifetime total: 844
 
@kintsugi - found a couple of small discrepancies, but otherwise fine.
@Ambyssin - likewise, I think your wordcounter might be reading the emojis weirdly or something
@unrepentantAuthor - those ten points added

And now for mine:

Pokémon Mystery Dungeon: Guiding Light

Review - 2
One chapter - 1
500 words - 2
Monthly bonus - 2

Total - 8

Love and Other Nightmares

Review - 2
One chapter - 1
250 words - 1
Monthly bonus - 2

Total - 6

some rise by sin

Review - 2
One chapter - 1
500 words - 2
Review game - 2
Speedy review (24hrs) - 4
Monthly bonus - 2

Total - 13

EDIT: Vision of Spark

Review - 2
One chapter - 1
500 words - 2
Speedy review (24hrs) - 4

Total - 9

I'd also like to claim +10pts for having beta-read Land of the Roses
 
Last edited:
Beth's KTABA: 2 base, 1 for one chapter, 2 for wordcount, 2 for an awards fic. 7 total.

Damn it, I could have gotten super speedy if I wasn't so insanely busy lately. Ah, well.
 
I'd like to inquire into commissioning one or two "character art" prizes. Do we have a one redemption at a time policy? At 60 points a pop, I can afford a couple.

At least one of the sketches, if not both, will be anthro characters. I mention this mostly as a caution to prospective volunteers who don't really do that sort of thing. @canisaries, you busy? ;P
 
I'm back.

Review League Round Up

Different Eyes
2 Points for Review
5 Points for 5 chapters
5 Points for 1471 word review
2 Points for Monthly challenge
Total: 14 Points

Pokemon Mystery Dungeon Guiding Light
2 Points for Review
12 Points for 3127 word Review
4 Points for Monthly Challenge and because I reviewed it for the awards.
2 Points for Review within 48 hours
Total: 20 Points

Pokemon Mystery Dungeon Guiding LIght
2 Points for Review
1 Point for 314 word review
4 Points for speed review
4 Points for Monthly Challenge and cause I reviewed it for the awards.
Total: 11 Points

Pokemon Mystery Dungeon Guiding Light
2 Points for Review
2 Points for 569 word review
2 Points for speedy review
4 Points for Monthly Challenge and cause I reviewed it for the awards.
Total: 10 Points

Pokemon Mystery Dungeon Guiding Light
2 Points for Review
1 Point for 346 word review
4 Points for speedy review
4 Points for Monthly Challenge and cause I reviewed it for the awards.
Total: 11 Points

Pokemon Mystery Dungeon Hands of Creation
2 Points for Review
4 Points for Speedy Review
Total: 6 Points

Love and Other Nightmares
2 Points for Review
8 Points for 2115 Word Review
4 Points for Monthly Challenge and cause I reviewed it for the awards.
Total: 14 Points

Guidance
2 Points for Review
7 Points for 1916 Word review
4 Points for Monthly Challenge and cause I reviewed it for the awards.
Total: 13 Points

You know, I realized I never cashed these in.

Spectra
2 Points for Review
6 Points for 1735 word review
3 Points for three chapters
Total: 12 Points

Spectra
2 Points for Review
2 Points for 601 Review
Total: 4 Points

The Deprogramming
2 Points for Review
5 Points for 1552 word review
2 Points for Monthly Challenge
3 Points for 3 Chapters
Total: 12 Points

Land of the Roses
2 Points for Review
2 Points for 709 Review
2 Points for Monthly Challenge
Total: 6 Points

Star Performer
2 Points for Review
2 Points for Monthly Challenge
9 Points for 2467 word review
10 Points for 10 Chapters
Total: 23 Points

Unpredictable
2 Points for Review
1 Point for 358 Chapter Review
Total: 3 Points

Holy shit, I didn't cash these either.

Hunter Haunted
2 Points for Review
1 Point for 354 word Review
Total: 3 Points

Hunter Haunted
2 Points for Review
1 Point for 279 Word review
Total: 3 Points

Hunter Haunted
2 Points for Review
1 Point for 445 word review
2 Points for Monthly Challenge (?) I mean it was in august so I don't know if it counts.
Total 3 Points without the challenge and 5 If we count the challenge.

Total Amount: 165 (without counting Hunter Haunted's last review for this month's challenge)

Total Overall: 571 Points
 
@Beth Pavell That's 46 all added up!
@unrepentantAuthor I'll put you down for one right now at 60 points, net total -53 points
@Flaze god damn. Good work, certainly, but maybe you wanna split these up in the future? :p

However, there's a lot of point discrepancies on yours, though:
A lot of these have +4 claimed for monthly challenge and because you were a judge in the awards. The monthly challenge part has no cap on it so those would be +2. However, the other +2 from being a judge can only be claimed on the judging feedback (this one for Guiding Light).

There's also a lot of speedy claims that don't line up as well: this one had a +2 speedy claim, but it's just your awards judging; true, it was posted shortly after Amby published another chapter, but I couldn't see any obvious references to the new chapter, so I won't be counting that. This one had a +4 speedy claim when it only qualified for +2. This one is nine minutes after the cut off for speedy bonuses, but screw it, it's nine minutes. This one only qualifies for +2 as well. There's also Land of the Roses and Star Performer not being in the awards, so -2 on those as well. I'll give you the +2 on the Haunter Haunted one, though.

All said and done, your new total is 154.

Eat that, Mrs. Meyers, saying I'd never be good at numbers and detail.
 
Last edited:
Pokemon Mystery Dungeon Guiding Light Volume 2
2 Points for Review
2 Points for 697 word review
4 Points for Speedy Review
Since this is Volume 2 and is a different thread I don't think I can get bonus for the monthly challenge
Total:8 Points

Guidance
2 Points for Review
2 Points for Review
2 Points for Monthly Bonus...okay, I know that it's been almost an hour since the month ended, but, does it still count?
Total: 6 Points
 
Please note: The thread is from 2 years ago.
Please take the age of this thread into consideration in writing your reply. Depending on what exactly you wanted to say, you may want to consider if it would be better to post a new thread instead.

Similar threads

Welkamo
  • Sticky
GAME: Review League 2: Electric Pikachu
Replies
19
Views
2K
Cavespider_17
Cavespider_17
lisianthus
lisia's workshop one-review-a-day challenge blog!! (requests... OPEN!)
Replies
8
Views
621
Cavespider_17
Cavespider_17
Cavespider_17
Cave's Bulbagarden's Fiction Review Thread
Replies
6
Views
480
Cavespider_17
Cavespider_17
UxieLover1994
How points work in HOME?
Replies
0
Views
122
UxieLover1994
UxieLover1994
Archaic
  • Locked
Pokémon Scarlet and Violet's Ranked Battles Season 17 has begun, running through to April 30th
Replies
0
Views
2K
Archaic
Archaic
Back
Top Bottom