Should Kanto reappear in Generation V?

[Midnight Blue]

Kanto has been in every generation. Everyone know why it has. But should it reappear again in Generation v?

 

[Battaman]

Since I believe they will remake Emerald and Yellow/Blue(FRLG), instead of RS, yes.

 

[The Pig King]

I'd like to see Kanto appear in some sort of spin-off game. It'd be interesting to see more spin-offs taking place in regions from the main series.

 

[Kaguya]

If you mean a remake version.. Then no..

 

[Lugnut]

I like Kanto, but I really would rather see new regions for Gen V. All of the generations that featured Kanto have already been remade once, and I actually don't think it would be best to see them again for a long time. Lets get Gen III remakes before getting another Gen I.

 

[System Error]

It'd be cool if it was like Liberty City in GTA:SA - you go there for a brief period/mission, but that's it. It's not fully in the game, just a part of it. But hey, that's clearly just a wish and not a fact or even speculation.

 

[Envoy]

Should it? No. Will it? Probably.

 

[Iteru]

Hopefully not.
It might be the original region but it's just boring now.

 

[Giovanni Ketchum]

Hopefully yes.

Nintendo should probably know how much dissapointing FireRed/LeafGreen was, and they should re-remake it AGAIN!!

With more new features, more challenges, DIFFERENT dialogue ( weather you're playing as RED or BLUE.) And that's about it. n_n

Besides, RED was my first game since 1998 and I still adore the Kanto region because it will always be my favorite and the best region ever.

 

[SalamenceCommander]

Yes. It would be awesome to see another remake of my favorite region so far.

 

[Blazaking]

It'd be cool if it was like Liberty City in GTA:SA - you go there for a brief period/mission, but that's it. It's not fully in the game, just a part of it. But hey, that's clearly just a wish and not a fact or even speculation.

I like this idea! Giving it a cameo in the game would be cool.

 

[Soulweaver]

Depends on what kind of platform Gen V lands on. If the battles are still in 2D and the world has a fixed camera point, no, I don't want another (F)R(L)G.

If it's going to be a generation with more real 3D gameplay, then I'd say it is OK (though that doesn't mean that I would buy that game; I never bought FRLG either).

Spin-off in Kanto or Kanto as a part of totally new main series game would be the best option

 

[Glaciachan]

I'm gonna say no on that one. I think Kanto is a bit overated, frankly. Just an opinion, though.

 

[Trainer Yusuf]

Should? No. Will? YES.

 

[Geechisu]

Kanto is a bit overplayed. Unless it's all-out remakes of the entire games in one epic one, no, it shouldn't. Of course, my idea will probably never be made, since R/S/E was enough gang wars for Nintendo. No Rockets vs. Galactics, no matter how amazing that would be.

 

[The Outrage]

Watch, they'll fit it into an RSE remake :/

 

[AndyPKMN]

I voted yes, but not in a remake. I think it's about time that Pokemon transitioned to doing pure sequels, as in Gen II, rather than an endless cycle of remakes. As I see it, the Gen I remakes were only due to the recent obsolescence of the Gen I and II games, and the Gen II remakes a generation later were an obvious extension of that. But unless Game Freak completely redesigns the data structure of individual Pokemon again, I think next generation should include expanded sequels a la Gold and Silver, featuring both old regions like Hoenn or Kanto and completely new regions.

 

[Iteru]

Watch, they'll fit it into an RSE remake :/

Either that or something similar to the Sevii Islands.
*prays for latter*

 

[Glaciachan]

I voted yes, but not in a remake. I think it's about time that Pokemon transitioned to doing pure sequels, as in Gen II, rather than an endless cycle of remakes. As I see it, the Gen I remakes were only due to the recent obsolescence of the Gen I and II games, and the Gen II remakes a generation later were an obvious extension of that. But unless Game Freak completely redesigns the data structure of individual Pokemon again, I think next generation should include expanded sequels a la Gold and Silver, featuring both old regions like Hoenn or Kanto and completely new regions.

I totally agree with that. A sequel to DPPt, for example, would be awesome.

 

[Our Wasted Years]

Yes it should :3