Everything except Ski was reasonable enough, that should have been out since toast said sunny. I mostly wanted to guide spy to think Beach tbh, but the other parks were not a bad idea either.
That was my thought process when I asked the question, sunny did expel Ski from my mind. Mido following up with what animals made me lose Beach. Then it's a 50/50 between water and the other two parks.
To be fair, I was not sure what I was doing first time I randed spy either. Which is why "trying to understand the game" felt like a decent first answerYou assume I know what I’m doing.
Of course I wanted to convince you guys it was Claire.
It was either restaurant or cafe. I’m guessing cafe cause
Also isn’t it against the rules to lie since we are supposed to be acting our roles?
Too many gambitting players this game. I think removing gambits would make it a bit more fair.
You cannot make "no gambits" a rule. No loophole abuse is a thing, OK, but despite Raven suggesting lying, we did not have to tell any lies before round ended anyway...
I was trying to catch people out, that's why. This is my first time playing the game so sorry if I played it wrong.
Yeah, I know. I was trying to be careful with all my answers because if I answer a bit wrong then people would sus me.
The first time I used that question was to see if Claire knew we were indoors and the second one was spy me trying to cross potential locations off the list.
That is the problem, even if it is spy asking this kind of question, and town is trying to be honest, if the answer that should be given is ambiguous anyway, spy has not much info to gain either... These are the kinds of questions/answers that make everything more subjective, having to consider "does Jamie know music is art?" or "do airports have different rulings for pets in other countries?" in making voting/location decisions may not exactly be in the spirit of the game
Without doubt. Also I can not un-bold this without weirdly breaking the quotes.
That for once (despite kinda glitching the game) I did something smart for a change and other than usually, I'm quite happy with my overall performance (I wish I would perform similarly well in Mafia).
Complete talking ban, I feel like restrictions like Don't state if/when/who you voted and similar things could work well enough.
I will play again.
See above ^^
The one we talked about on Discord recently, you know, the one where you'ld probably need to change the name XD
good
Just wanted to post this minor correction, Codenames was my first one back but I meant first completed one since returning.
Thank you for hosting!First of all thankyou everyone for playing!
I will say I think this game can work on a forum setting, I do disagree with Zexy's point there but agree with the other things he mentioned that it might need a little bit of work. I think it can be done, just gotta figure out how. I think Spyfall 1 was a really good idea of how well this game can work. Regardless of the above anyways:
I do hope you guys enjoyed playing, I will be ending at the original five rounds as stated for now, and then for any (possible) future iterations we can figure out making the games a bit longer, some changes etc. I'd be more than happy to host again in the future if required, but I think as a collective we should think of possible changes. I understand I'm hosting the game but I've always valued player input as it's extremely valuable, even if its negative really. So with that I have some questions below
Would you play this game again?
What's one thing you liked, if anything?
What is something you disliked, if anything?
If you were to play again, what do you think could be changed and / or improved for a more fun experience?
Now this one is non game related, just guaging interest. Are there any board games you might like to see on a forum setting?
Again huge thanks for playing, even though it was short and quick, this was my first non mafia game back so nice to see people interested in it regardless! I'm happy to answer any questions and take part in any discussions until we archive this. Thanks again everyone
1. yeah
This is a sentiment I can also relate to very well after two losses (that did involve me mislynching you too, sorry).
Secret Authoritarian Leader? xD
Yes
I think it’s fun asking questions and trying to answers questions to gain more information.
Round four. That round was not fun especially as they started discussing lying and stuff.
I think leaving it at just asking questions is nice. Also ban lying because it doesn’t benefit anyone honestly since it becomes hard to tell who the spy is if everyone is lying.
Clue could work. Maybe Life.
I don't think the people of South Dildo were leading figures in a massacre that cost millions of people their lives, also it was originally Calvin's idea to rename it for bulba (although I encourage this procedure because it may look like romantization of this person to the uninformed War Room visitor)This is a sentiment I can also relate to very well after two losses (that did involve me mislynching you too, sorry).
Secret Authoritarian Leader? xD
Also ironic such concern comes from the person who submitted a certain remote location in Canada as an answer for a comp
I appreciate the input and I'm glad you enjoyed, but I don't quite get this.
Oooh, I wouldn't know how to make it work but I like this idea!
Aye, I do love Zexy's name for it though ahahaha.
The level of discussion allowed, the voting process, the amount of locations and ratio of people can all be flexible. I agree the nature of what questions should be asked is not to be policed.
