The 2013 War Room Awards

[Zenax]

Welcome to the third annual War Room Awards! A year has passed since the second edition, during which time friendships were put to the test in battles of wit, lies and backstabbing. Many users were shot, lynched, burned, crushed, drowned, thrown down buildings, buried alive, and blasted off again. Despite this, the War Room stayed a great community, and now is your chance to reward the users for their contributions and performances in the section.

Rules (make sure you read carefully):

Spoiler

— All games nominated must be completed by the time the thread goes up (August 2nd, 2013).

— Games that are eligible to win an award must have started around last year’s awards (June 4th, 2012).

— Eligible games are listed at the end of this post for your convenience.

— Voters must have participated in at least one game, which must be completed in order to be eligible for an award.

— Parma, Paperhorse and Zenax are ineligible to receive individual awards, but may receive a team award. Froakie, Feralize, Master Mew and Mintaka may be nominated.

— Voters may not vote for themselves or for a banned user.

— Voting will be public and in the nominations thread only. Voters can only vote for one person per category.

— Voters can give the reasoning behind their votes with a small explanation, but it's not mandatory. Voters must provide the title of the game or games which prompted their vote.

— Two further awards - Best Player and Best Host - will be awarded to the person who accumulated the highest number of votes across the categories of the Player Tier and the Host Tier respectively. Should the winners of the Best Player Award and the Best Host Award win more than half the categories in their respective tier, they would solely win that respective award, and their other awards would go to the person that has garnered the second highest number of votes in those categories.

— The voting period of two weeks will end on August 16th.

Here are the categories in which you may vote:

Town Tier

-Best Town Performance
-Best Mafia Performance
-Best Independent Performance
-Most Sportsmanlike Conduct
-Most Entertaining Player
-Most Strategic Player

Host Tier

-Most Creative Host
-Most Entertaining Host
-Most Organized Host
-Fair Hosting Award
-Best flavor text
-Host of the Best Mafia Game

The War Room Tier

-Most friendly user
-Most committed user

Team Tier

-Best Town Team Performance
-Best Mafia Team Performance

LIST OF COMPLETED MAFIA GAMES
[June 4, 2012 - August 2nd, 2013]

Spoiler

Super-Effective Mafia by Buoy - May 26, 2012 to June 8, 2012

Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney Mafia by Akuraito - June 2, 2012 to June 13, 2012

Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood Mafia by Setra and Parma - May 21, 2012 to June 20, 2012

Pokémon Generation I Mafia by The Puppetmaster and Paperhorse - June 2, 2012 to June 21, 2012

BTD Mini Mafia by No Lynch - May 31, 2012 to June 22, 2012

Kirby Mafia by Tris79 - June 7, 2012 to July 8, 2012

Layton Mafia by Joltik - June 9, 2012 to July 11, 2012

Mafia Mafia by Soulmaster - June 4, 2012 to July 12, 2012

American Revolution Mafia by Hitomi - June 23, 2012 to July 15, 2012

Meme Mafia by DrumBeats - May 31, 2012 to July 15, 2012

Axis Powers Hetalia Mafia by Akuraito - July 11, 2012 to July 20, 2012

Star Trek (2009) Mafia by Luminosity and TheMissingno. - July 12, 2012 to July 23, 2012

Post Restriction Mafia by Aestivate - June 23, 2012 to July 27, 2012

Fire Emblem: The Sacred Stones Mafia by Feralize - July 9, 2012 to July 28, 2012

The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword Mafia by Neosquid and Mijzelffan - July 16, 2012 to August 4, 2012

The Battle of the Test Tube by Mr. Fahrenheit - July 22, 2012 to August 11, 2012

Warrior Cats Mafia by Catspring - July 24, 2012 to August 15, 2012

Havendale Mafia 3 by Zenax - July 23, 2012 to August 18, 2012

Ape Escape Mafia by Neonsands - July 15, 2012 to August 19, 2012

Yu-Gi-Oh! Zexal Mafia by FinalArcadia and Fushimi - July 24, 2012 to August 19, 2012

War Room Mafia BYOB by Mintaka - August 4, 2012 to August 21, 2012

Skullgirls Mafia by Shinobu - August 15, 2012 to August 31, 2012

Legend of Korra Mafia by DrumBeats - August 20, 2012 to September 3, 2012

Tales of the Abyss Mafia by Greece - August 16, 2012 to September 13, 2012

Music Mafia by Feralize - September 3, 2012 to September 14, 2012

Kid Icarus: Uprising Mafia by Mijzelffan - August 12, 2012 to September 16, 2012

Mafia of the Mages by Ryuutakeshi - August 21, 2012 to September 20, 2012

Star Wars Mafia by TheMissingno. - August 20, 2012 to October 2, 2012

Betrayal Knows My Name Mafia by Fushimi - August 31, 2012 to October 1, 2012

Super Effective Mafia II by Buoy September 15, 2012 to October 6, 2012

Advance Wars Mafia by FairyGaga - September 14, 2012 to October 8, 2012

Mini Mafia by Zenax - October 1, 2012 to October 13, 2012

Legendary Pokemon Mafia by Joltik - September 18, 2012 to October 13, 2012

The IT Crowd Mafia by CrackFox - October 4, 2012 to October 21, 2012

Pokemon GSC - HGSS Style Mafia by Dark Kyriaki - October 7, 2012 to October 31, 2012

Oakwood Mafia by Catspring - October 13, 2012 to November 6, 2012

War Room Party by Mintaka - October 22, 2012 to November 8, 2012

Make-A-Mafia by KidBeano - October 10, 2012 to November 11, 2012

Pokemon Best Wishes! Mafia by HumanDawn - October 10, 2012 to November 10, 2012

Nameless Mafia by Parma - October 17, 2012 to November 14, 2012

Yu-Gi-Oh! All-Stars Mafia by FinalArcadia - October 31, 2012 to November 16, 2012

Yu-Gi-Oh! GX Mafia by Momoka - November 11, 2012 to November 27, 2012

Choose Your Flavor Mafia by Master Mew - November 15, 2012 to November 29, 2012

Bleach Mafia by jokool - November 7, 2012 to December 6, 2012

My Little Pony: Mafia is Magic - November 12, 2012 to December 10, 2012

Witchhunt by Phoenicks and Feralize - November 9, 2012 to December 15, 2012

Pokemon RSE-Hoenn Mafia by Dark Kyriaki - November 29, 2012 to December 16, 2012

Super Smash Bros Mafia by FairyGaga - December 7th 2012 to December 21, 2012

U.S. Elections Mafia by Master Mew - December 2, 2012 to January 1, 2013

OTP Mafia by Paperhorse and Zenax - December 22, 2012 to January 6, 2013

Puella Magi Madoka Mafia by Catspring - December 28, 2012 to January 12, 2013

Pokemon DPPt - Sinnoh Mafia by Dark Kyriaki - December 16, 2012 to January 17, 2013

Star Trek: The Next Generation Mafia by Soulmaster - December 10, 2012 to January 24, 2013

Trouble in Newbieville by Master Mew - January 4, 2013 to January 26, 2013

Atelier Arland Mafia by FinalArcadia - January 5, 2013 to February 1, 2013

Bionicle Mask of Mafia by Neon Borealis and Phoenicks - January 7, 2013 to February 4, 2013

Pokemon Best Wishes! Season 2 Mafia by HumanDawn - January 27, 2013 to February 7, 2013

Black Dagger Brotherhood Mafia by Harpy - January 25, 2013 to February 18, 2013

Vampire Knight Mafia by Momoka - February 1, 2013 to February 24, 2013

Fire Emblem: Radiant Dawn Mafia by DrumBeats - January 17, 2013 to February 27, 2013

Fire and Ice Mafia by Paperhorse and Phoenicks - February 9, 2013 to February 26, 2013

Pokemon Movie Mafia by Dark Kyriaki - February 19, 2013 to March 8, 2013

Star Trek: The Original Series Mafia by Soulmaster - February 19, 2013 to March 11, 2013

House, M.D. by Master Mew and Paperhorse - February 27, 2013 to March 13, 2013

Homestuck Mafia, Act 1 by Sollux Captor and Phoenicks - February 27, 2013 to March 21, 2013

Phoenicks Wright: Justice For All Mafia by Akuraito and HumanDawn - February 25, 2013 to March 27, 2013

Harvest Moon: Back to Nature Mafia by CrackFox - March 18, 2013 to March 31, 2013

Intro to Mafia: Cats of the War Room by Feralize - March 8, 2013 to April 4, 2013

Doctor Who Mafia by Froakie and Oswin - March 31, 2013 to April 16, 2013

Lion King Mafia by Fushimi - March 27, 2013 to April 18, 2013

Werewolf by Phoenicks and Feliciano - March 28, 2013 to May 8, 2013

Monster Mafia by m0ckingbird20 and HumanDawn - April 2, 2013 to May 10, 2013

Pokemon Bishounen Mafia by Dark Kyriaki - April 19, 2013 to May 15, 2013

Bible Mafia by Master Mew - March 28, 2013 to May 20, 2013

The Room Mafia: Johnny's Revenge by HumanDawn - May 14, 2013 to May 24, 2013

The Walking Dead Mafia by Paperhorse and CrackFox - April 26, 2013 to May 31, 2013

Let's Kill Bowser! Mafia by Setra - May 11, 2013 to June 3, 2013

Eeveelution Mafia by Harpy and Zima - June 4, 2013 to June 15, 2013

Pokemon BW: Unova All-Star Mafia by Dark Kyriaki - June 10, 2013 to June 26, 2013

Animal Crossing: New War by Miss Mew - June 19, 2013 to July 9, 2013

Mafia Wars: The Scum Menace by Parma, Paperhorse and Zenax - June 13, 2013 to July 25, 2013

 

[HumanDawn]

How do we vote?

 

[Buoy]

How do we vote?

Make a post in this thread with all the categories you wish to vote for someone in, and then you make your nominations with the categories you listed. Like this:

Player Tier
-Best Town Performance: [user] in [game]
-Best Mafia Performance: [user] in [game]

Host Tier
-Most Creative Host: [user] for [game]
-Most Entertaining Host: [user] for [game]

You can list as many or as little categories as you like, but you can only make one nomination for each category. If there's a category you don't want to nominate anyone for, or if you can't think of anyone to nominate for it, just leave it out. You don't have to vote in every category. You don't even have to vote in an entire tier of categories, if you don't want to. If you don't want to vote for any category in the 'host tier', then just leave the tier out. It's completely up to you how many nominations you make, although you can only make one nomination in any given category. If you're still confused about how to vote, it's best to wait for someone else to post their votes so you can see how it's done.

sorry if this didn't make much sense, i'm sooo tired

 

[Almonds]

There were a lot of fun mafia games that I played in - I can't just pick one for nomination ;_;

 

[Mr. Fahrenheit]

I am going to edit this later.

Town Tier

-Best Town Performance
-Best Mafia Performance: Phoenicks for War Room Mafia – BYOB
-Best Independent Performance
-Most Sportsmanlike Conduct
-Most Entertaining Player
-Most Strategic Player

Host Tier

-Most Creative Host
-Most Entertaining Host
-Most Organized Host
-Fair Hosting Award
-Best flavor text: There have been many excellent flavor text but I think that the best flavor text goes to Hitomi for American revolution mafia. She did excellent job with entertaining and educating flavor text troughout the whole game.
-Host of the Best Mafia Game

The War Room Tier

-Most friendly user
-Most committed user

Team Tier

-Best Town Team Performance
-Best Mafia Team Performance

 

[Buoy]

Town Tier
-Best Mafia Performance: TheMissingno. in the IT Crowd Mafia.
-Best Independent Performance: Hitomi in Post Restriction Mafia.
-Most Sportsmanlike Conduct: Froakie.
-Most Entertaining Player: jda95 (he made me vote for him >:{{{ hes not even funny).
-Most Strategic Player: PichuBoy.

Host Tier
-Most Creative Host: PichuBoy for Make-A-Mafia.
-Most Entertaining Host: Aestivate for Post Restriction Mafia.
-Most Organized Host: FairyGaga.
-Fair Hosting Award: FairyGaga. (no game in particular, he's just a really consistent and solid host, judging by every game i've played of his)
-Best Flavour Text: Hitomi for American Revolution Mafia.
-Host of the Best Mafia Game: Aestivate for Post Restriction Mafia.

The War Room Tier
-Most friendly user: FinalArcadia.
-Most committed user: Mintaka.

Team Tier
-Best Town Team Performance: ummm

[i left out 'best town performance' and 'best mafia team performance' bc i couldnt think of anything for them >>>:]

 

[CrackFox]

There's only really a few catagories I can vote for with conviction. They are as follows:

Town Tier
-Best Mafia Performance: Yatagarasu in the Walking Dead Mafia.
-Most Strategic Player: Mijzelffan in Make-a-Mafia

Host Tier
-Most Creative Host: Pichuboy for Make-A-Mafia.
-Most Entertaining Host: HumanDawn
-Host of the Best Mafia Game: Akuraito and HumanDawn for Phoenicks Wright: Justice For All Mafia

The War Room Tier
-Most friendly user: Zima
-Most committed user: Master Mew

(Most of the usernames have probably changed)

 

[Neon Borealis]

I'll edit this later.

Town Tier
-Best Town Performance.
-Best Mafia Performance
-Best Independent Performance
-Most Sportsmanlike Conduct
-Most Entertaining Player
-Most Strategic Player

Host Tier
-Most Creative Host.- Mijzelffan for Kid Icarus Mafia,
-Most Entertaining Host
-Most Organized Host
-Fair Hosting Award
-Best flavor text
-Host of the Best Mafia Game

The War Room Tier
-Most friendly user
-Most committed user.- Harpy

Team Tier
-Best Town Team Performance.- Legend of Korra mafia (you guys simply destroyed us that time).
-Best Mafia Team Performance

 

[Zima]

Town Tier

-Best Town Performance -
-Best Mafia Performance - Ariana for The Walking Dead Mafia
-Best Independent Performance -
-Most Sportsmanlike Conduct -
-Most Entertaining Player - Buoy (Pretty much all games)
-Most Strategic Player - Mijzelffan (Pretty much all games)

Host Tier

-Most Creative Host -
-Most Entertaining Host -
-Most Organized Host -
-Fair Hosting Award - Phoenicks and Feliciano for Werewolf.
-Best flavor text - Hitomi's American Revolution Mafia.
-Host of the Best Mafia Game - Drumbeats for Meme Mafia

The War Room Tier

-Most friendly user - HumanDawn
-Most committed user - Harpy

Team Tier

-Best Town Team Performance -
-Best Mafia Team Performance - Bible Mafia

(These will be incredibly difficult for me to decide on, so I'll just leave this here for now.)

 

[Feenie]

Town Tier

-Best Town Performance
-Best Mafia Performance Fushimi for Atelier Arland Mafia
-Best Independent Performance
-Most Sportsmanlike Conduct
-Most Entertaining Player
-Most Strategic Player

Host Tier

-Most Creative Host
-Most Entertaining Host
-Most Organized Host
-Fair Hosting Award
-Best flavor text
-Host of the Best Mafia Game Akuraito and HumanDawn for Phoenicks Wright: Justice For All Mafia

The War Room Tier

-Most friendly user Dark Kyriaki
-Most committed user

Team Tier

-Best Town Team Performance
-Best Mafia Team Performance

 

[Almonds]

I will edit this later




Town Tier

-Best Town Performance
-Best Mafia Performance - Harpy in The Walking Dead Mafia.
-Best Independent Performance
-Most Sportsmanlike Conduct
-Most Entertaining Player
-Most Strategic Player

Host Tier

-Most Creative Host -
-Most Entertaining Host - jokool from Bleach Mafia.
-Most Organized Host
-Fair Hosting Award - FinalArcadia from Yu-Gi-Oh All-Stars Mafia
-Best flavor text - HumanDawn from Pokemon Best Wishes! Mafia
-Host of the Best Mafia Game

The War Room Tier

-Most friendly user
-Most committed user - Harpy

Team Tier

-Best Town Team Performance
-Best Mafia Team Performance

 

[HumanDawn]

Town Tier

Best Town Performance - Buoy in Mafia Wars: A Scum Menace (or almost every game)
Best Mafia Performance - Fushimi in Atelier Arland Mafia
Best Independent Performance - JJM in Pokemon Best Wishes! Mafia
Most Sportsmanlike Conduct - FinalArcadia (Every Game)
Most Entertaining Player - Buoy (Every Game)
Most Strategic Player - Buoy (Every Game)

Host Tier

Most Creative Host - Mijzelffan for Kid Icarus Mafia
Most Entertaining Host - DrumBeats for Meme Mafia
Most Organized Host - Master Mew (All games, but specifically Trouble in NewbieVille)
Fair Hosting Award - FairyGaga(All games)
Best flavor text - FinalArcadia for Yu-Gi-Oh! All Stars Mafia
Host of the Best Mafia Game - FinalArcadia for Yu-Gi-Oh! All Stars Mafia

The War Room Tier

Most friendly user - Nobody yet.
Most committed user - Harpy (Every Game)

Team Tier

Best Town Team Performance - Legend Of Korra Mafia by DrumBeats
Best Mafia Team Performance - Phoenicks and Master Mew in Nameless Mafia by Parma

 

[Gaga]

I don't think I've been active enough for more than the following categories:

Town Tier

Best Mafia Performance - TheMissingno. in IT Crowd Mafia (I was his awed mafia buddy, after all)
Most Entertaining Player - Buoy (generally)
Most Strategic Player - TheMissingno. (generally)

Host Tier

Most Creative Host - Mijzelffan for Kid Icarus Mafia
Most Organized Host - Master Mew for U.S. Election Mafia
Best flavor text - FinalArcadia for Atelier Arland Mafia
Host of the Best Mafia Game - Neosquid (Mijzelffan also hosted) for Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword Mafia

The War Room Tier

Most friendly user - Dark Kyriaki
Most committed user - Harpy

 

[Elysion]

Town Tier

-Best Town Performance - HumanDawn in Yu-Gi-Oh! All Stars Mafia
-Best Mafia Performance - TheMissingno. in The IT Crowd Mafia
-Best Independent Performance -
-Most Sportsmanlike Conduct - FinalArcadia(any game)
-Most Entertaining Player - Buoy(any game)
-Most Strategic Player - Buoy(any game)

Host Tier

-Most Creative Host - HumanDawn and m0ckingbird20 in Monster Mafia
-Most Entertaining Host - HumanDawn for his BW Mafias
-Most Organized Host -
-Fair Hosting Award - FinalArcadia for Yu-Gi-Oh! All Stars
-Best flavor text - Catspring's Oakwood Mafia
-Host of the Best Mafia Game - FinalArcadia's Yu-Gi-Oh! All Stars

The War Room Tier

-Most friendly user - Fushimi
-Most committed user - Harpy

Team Tier

-Best Town Team Performance -
-Best Mafia Team Performance -

I will update this.

 

[J J M]

Town Tier

-Best Town Performance
-Best Mafia Performance
-Best Independent Performance
-Most Sportsmanlike Conduct : FinalArcadia in general.
-Most Entertaining Player : Master Mew in general.
-Most Strategic Player

Host Tier

-Most Creative Host
-Most Entertaining Host : DrumBeats for Meme Mafia. God I loved all the appropriate memes and hair-pullingly frustrating roles.
-Most Organized Host : Phoenicks in general. His games always have complex rules and mechanics yet he manages to organize everything and pull it off well.
-Fair Hosting Award
-Best flavor text
-Host of the Best Mafia Game

The War Room Tier

-Most friendly user
-Most committed user : Master Mew in general for all the effort he's put into the games he's hosted and played.

Team Tier

-Best Town Team Performance
-Best Mafia Team Performance

I haven't played a lot of other games this time so I don't really know much about all the recent games.

 

[Midorikawa]

Votes May Change


Town Tier

-Best Town Performance-HumanDawn for All Stars Mafia
-Best Mafia Performance-Fushimi for Atelier Mafia
-Best Independent Performance-Insanish Danish in Elections Mafia
-Most Sportsmanlike Conduct-Master Mew (All Mafias)
-Most Entertaining Player-HumanDawn (All Mafias)
-Most Strategic Player-FinalArcadia (Several Mafias)

Host Tier

-Most Creative Host-Mijzelffan for Kid Icarus Mafia
-Most Entertaining Host-HumanDawn (All his mafias)
-Most Organized Host-FairyGaga (All Games)
-Fair Hosting Award-Master Mew for Elections mafia
-Best flavor text-HumanDawn (All Mafias)
-Host of the Best Mafia Game-Crackfox for TWD Mafia


The War Room Tier

-Most friendly user-Zima
-Most committed user-Master Mew (All Games)

Team Tier

-Best Town Team Performance-Doctor Who Mafia
-Best Mafia Team Performance-

 

[Zenax]

Quick clarification to the team tier vote, since it wasn't explained clearly in the rules. You may not vote for a best town team or best mafia team if you were part of said team, as that would be like voting for yourself.

 

[FinalArcadia]

Still rereading through old games, so I'll be editing the remaining categories soon (and maybe editing others):

Town Tier

-Best Town Performance – HumanDawn (Yu-Gi-Oh! All-Stars Mafia)
-Best Mafia Performance
-Best Independent Performance – Harpy (Mafia Wars)
-Most Sportsmanlike Conduct – m0ckingbird20 (in general)
-Most Entertaining Player – Buoy (in general)
-Most Strategic Player – Buoy (in general)

Host Tier

-Most Creative Host – Aestivate (Post Restriction Mafia)
-Most Entertaining Host – HumanDawn (in general)
-Most Organized Host – FairyGaga (in general)
-Fair Hosting Award – Master Mew (Bible Mafia)
-Best flavor text - Catspring (Oakwood Mafia)
-Host of the Best Mafia Game – Akuraito and HumanDawn (Phoenicks Wright: Justice For All Mafia)

The War Room Tier

-Most friendly user – Dark Kyriaki
-Most committed user - Harpy

Team Tier

-Best Town Team Performance –
-Best Mafia Team Performance – Nameless Mafia

 

[Mijzelffan]

I would've mentioned everyone that's allowed to vote again but I was on vacation during most of the awards :/

Town Tier

-Best Town Performance
-Best Mafia Performance
-Best Independent Performance -themissingno. in KI:U mafia
-Most Sportsmanlike Conduct
-Most Entertaining Player -themissingno. in general
-Most Strategic Player -phoenicks in general

Host Tier

-Most Creative Host
-Most Entertaining Host
-Most Organized Host -Mintaka in general
-Fair Hosting Award -master mew's election mafia, giving it all up for a fool win.
-Best flavor text -crackfox for twd mafia
-Host of the Best Mafia Game -buoy's super effective mafias

The War Room Tier

-Most friendly user -zima
-Most committed user

Team Tier

-Best Town Team Performance
-Best Mafia Team Performance

 

[Peachy]

Town Tier

-Best Town Performance-
-Best Mafia Performance- Ariana (TWD Mafia)
-Best Independent Performance-Zima in Meme Mafia
-Most Sportsmanlike Conduct-Master Mew (All Mafias)
-Most Entertaining Player-Buoy (All Mafias)
-Most Strategic Player-FinalArcadia (Several Mafias)

Host Tier

-Most Creative Host-Aestivate (Post Restriction Mafia)
-Most Entertaining Host- HumanDawn (All his mafias)
-Most Organized Host- Mijzelffan (All Games)
-Fair Hosting Award- Master Mew for Bible Mafia
-Best flavor text- HumanDawn (All Mafias)
-Host of the Best Mafia Game- Neosquid and Mijzelffan for Skyward Sword Mafia


The War Room Tier

-Most friendly user-Zima
-Most committed user- Harpy

Team Tier

-Best Town Team Performance - Doctor Who Mafia
-Best Mafia Team Performance - Bible Mafia