• To keep up with the hype driven by Sword and Shield's release, we are taking applications for new moderators in our Current Events: Sword and Shield as well as Anime and Manga sections.

    For more information, see this thread.We hope you all consider joining our team!
  • We hope you're enjoying Sword and Shield so far! So that everyone can enjoy it and not be spoiled, please keep the all story spoilers and any images from the games in the appropriate sections or in spoiler tags until January 3rd.

    Since spoiler tags are not allowed in signatures, please do not put images from the games in your signature either. You can list the names of new Pokémon if you want to list your team in your signature.

Notice: The Round Table

Sith Puppy
Joined
Dec 6, 2016
Messages
3,856
Reaction score
2,313
Greetings Knights of the Round Table!

Over the last few months it has come to our attention that quite a lot of people have problems making reads in mafia games, especially the newcomers. Upon inspection we noticed that this topic isn't disucssed in our Player Guide.

So what are reads? Although everyone has their own style to it, it comes down to sharing your thoughts on the progress of the game and a participating player. You could also combine all those thought to form a reads list. Well, that's my view on it at least. There isn't really a clear definition of a "read". To each their own.

And that's where you, the player, comes in! We would like to expand this guide with your input.
Share us your thoughts on what reads and a reads list are to you and tell us what you think should be added to the guide. If enough interest pops up to help out with making the addition we might move it to our guide volunteer chat as well.:)
 
Vee Vee Eeeeveee!
Joined
Oct 16, 2013
Messages
7,881
Reaction score
2,497
I think the only real way to improve the ability to read is via experience.

We need more mentor games.
 
Joined
Nov 18, 2014
Messages
30,664
Reaction score
16,118
Unfortunately, we don't have the infrastructure to run the mentor games, at the moment. Too many mentees and not enough mentors.

And, while developing reads does take experience, that isn't to say that there aren't tips for developing reads that new or newer players could use.
 
Vee Vee Eeeeveee!
Joined
Oct 16, 2013
Messages
7,881
Reaction score
2,497
Unfortunately, we don't have the infrastructure to run the mentor games, at the moment. Too many mentees and not enough mentors.
How many people do we have that would be willing to be mentors?

EDIT: This is an open question, not just to ME.
 
Joined
Nov 18, 2014
Messages
30,664
Reaction score
16,118
Preferably a 1:1 ratio for mentors to mentees. Theoretically, the same mentor could be used for the entire mafia faction, but that's it. Each townie needs to have a mentor that knows as much about the game as they do, so 1:1 ratio must be maintained.
There's also the slight issue that some of us, who may have been willing/able to be mentors before might not be able to do so now, but I'll figure out my own availability in the near future.
 
Merry Chrysalis
Joined
Nov 20, 2016
Messages
37,038
Reaction score
40,393
Okay, I've got an idea. We could have a sort of "role bank," if you will, for hosts to store roles from all their different games. There could be a big, comprehensive list of roles used in TWR, as well as a personal role bank thread for hosts who want one. There, hosts can store info on either only their most unique roles, or everything from whatever they've hosted, down to the most humdrum vanilla role. Roles can be categorized by game, alignment, alphabetically, etc.

So...thoughts?
 
Just some random guy on a random site
Joined
Dec 6, 2016
Messages
2,091
Reaction score
684
I like the idea and could see use for it when creating games, but how would you want to do that? Would you want to make a thread where you can put your roles or maybe make something outside of the forum on Google Drive for example? Or maybe something like MafiaScum does?

I would think we could also create a "Power Scale" for how strong a Town/Mafia role is compared to others to make the game somewhat balanced (strong town/negative mafia roles could have positive numbers while negative town/strong mafia roles would have negative numbers, then the total should be around 0 to make it balanced)
 
Merry Chrysalis
Joined
Nov 20, 2016
Messages
37,038
Reaction score
40,393
I was thinking along the line of seperate threads.

I could see your power scale being a cool idea for the main role bank. We could also list some checks against any roles that have either excessive negative or positive power, as well as good pairings for weaker roles?
 
Just some random guy on a random site
Joined
Dec 6, 2016
Messages
2,091
Reaction score
684
I was thinking along the line of seperate threads.
So like a subsubsection where you can create a new thread per role with room for comments and 1 thread comparing all roles? That could work.
I could see your power scale being a cool idea for the main role bank. We could also list some checks against any roles that have either excessive negative or positive power, as well as good pairings for weaker roles?
If what I put above would get done that could be done in the comparing thread, I really start to like this idea more and more now :p
 
Vee Vee Eeeeveee!
Joined
Oct 16, 2013
Messages
7,881
Reaction score
2,497
Separate threads isn't a good idea.

I think one combined thread, with one of the moderators that is willing to manage it. Roles, custom or common, that have been used by 2 or more hosts go into the moderator's post, while everyone may post their own list of custom roles in their own post within this thread.

Each role listing must follow strict information guidelines (as posted by the moderator) as to help people when chosing if they want to use that role in their game.

The thread would also be strictly no talking. Use TSR for that.

Just my two copper anyway.
 
Merry Chrysalis
Joined
Nov 20, 2016
Messages
37,038
Reaction score
40,393
So like a subsubsection where you can create a new thread per role with room for comments and 1 thread comparing all roles? That could work.
I wasn't really thinking a thread for each role, just 1 big TWR compilation plus host-specific lists for hosts that want to make them. But we could also have a place for that.
 
Joined
Nov 18, 2014
Messages
30,664
Reaction score
16,118
I don't like the idea of Host specific role banks being separate threads.
Y'all are absolutely welcome to make Role banks for yourselves from the roles you've used in the past, but creating new threads just for a single host's role bank gets cluttered very quickly.
Using the OP of a thread as a collective role bank and having hosts post their own "role banks" or additions to the collective role bank in the thread is a good idea, though. Keeps everything contained and nice and neat.
 
Merry Chrysalis
Joined
Nov 20, 2016
Messages
37,038
Reaction score
40,393
Makes sense, I suppose.

What should be the standing for roles hosts have used on other forums? My suggestion is they need to at least have hosted one TWR game to include those in their personal banks, and they need to actually use 'em in a TWR game to get them added to the main compilation.
 
Just some random guy on a random site
Joined
Dec 6, 2016
Messages
2,091
Reaction score
684
I think that as long as you can link to the reveal of the role it is okay to have them in your own bank, but indeed for the TWR bank it would have to be used in TWR
 
Just some random guy on a random site
Joined
Dec 6, 2016
Messages
2,091
Reaction score
684
So the idea for "TWRole Bank" at the moment is one thread where you can keep your own role bank from games in TWR and outside and a list of roles with what they do in the OP with comparisons between the roles and the discussion to be in TSR?

I think that the list of all roles will get large very fast and that TSR would be flooded by the discussion. We might just want to keep TSR from flooding by having Mafia Philosophy be the place to discuss roles.
And we would of course also need people to manage it, I myself would be willing to help with this and we would need to have at least 1 Moderator on board to help.
 
Sith Puppy
Joined
Dec 6, 2016
Messages
3,856
Reaction score
2,313
I think we should only use 1 thread for this. The OP as collective roles of evreything that has been used in TWR. People can post their own list in the thread as well possibly, but I mainly want discussion to stay in that thread.

I would think we could also create a "Power Scale" for how strong a Town/Mafia role is compared to others to make the game somewhat balanced (strong town/negative mafia roles could have positive numbers while negative town/strong mafia roles would have negative numbers, then the total should be around 0 to make it balanced)
A scale is hard to make as power of a role is largly tied to interaction with other roles.

I'm willing to mod this project if needed.:)
 
The Paragon of Torna
Joined
May 9, 2015
Messages
5,828
Reaction score
2,993
Personal banks can be threadmarked for easier navigation if you like. I'm also willing to mod it.
 
Sith Puppy
Joined
Dec 6, 2016
Messages
3,856
Reaction score
2,313
I think that thread would work best if it didn't have discussion in it... Just served as an actual database of roles.

We have two other threads (TSR and the philospy (sp) ones) that we can discuss the roles in.
Gotta agree with AussieEevee on this one, Darth. Mafia Philosophy exists for a reason.
So what if someone wants to ask to add a role to the op?

Personal banks can be threadmarked for easier navigation if you like. I'm also willing to mod it.
So every post then.
 
Top