• Hey Trainers! Be sure to check out Corsola Beach, our newest section on the forums, in partnership with our friends at Corsola Cove! At the Beach, you can discuss the competitive side of the games, post your favorite Pokemon memes, and connect with other Pokemon creators!
  • Due to the recent changes with Twitter's API, it is no longer possible for Bulbagarden forum users to login via their Twitter account. If you signed up to Bulbagarden via Twitter and do not have another way to login, please contact us here with your Twitter username so that we can get you sorted.

The War Room Awards 2016 - Voting Has Ended

Status
Not open for further replies.

Zexy

Quaxly Boy
Joined
Jun 9, 2012
Messages
26,897
Reaction score
10,027
Pronouns
  1. He/Him
  2. They/Them
Welcome to the 2016 annual War Room Awards! A time for looking back on the year and remembering all the games that have come and gone. We all have that one game that has stood out from the rest for one reason or another. We have players that we admire particularly in some way and/or a host we feel have gone the extra mile to make their game enjoyable. If you'd like to express your appreciation this is the time of year to do so. Before you nominate a fellow user in any of the catagories, please first read the rules outlined below. You have until August 15th to cast your votes.


Rules:

Voters must have participated in at least one of this season’s games.

Staff members are eligible to receive awards.

Voters are not permitted to vote for themselves or for a banned user.

You may not vote for best town/mafia performance if you were in that group in that game.

Voting will be public and in this thread only. Voters can only vote for one person per category.

Voters can give the reasoning behind their votes with a small explanation, but it's not mandatory. Voters must provide the title of the game or games which prompted their vote.

Two further awards - Best Player and Best Host - will be awarded to the person who accumulated the highest number of votes across the categories of the Player Tier and the Host Tier respectively. Should the winners of the Best Player Award and the Best Host Award win more than half the categories in their respective tier, they would solely win that respective award, and their other awards would go to the person that has garnered the second highest number of votes in those categories.

You are not required to vote in all categories. If you like you can vote in one or you can vote in them all. As long as you vote only once, in each.

With the exception of the Best Town Performance, Best Mafia Performance and Best Independent performance, which refer solely to Mafia games, all other categories in the Player and Host Tiers refer to both Mafia games and Non-Mafia games.

Only players whose first ever completed played mafia game was in this season are eligible for the Best New Player award.

Only hosts whose first ever completed hosted mafia game was in this season are eligible for the Best New Host award.

VOTING CATAGORIES

Town Tier
-Best Single Town Performance
-Best Single Mafia Performance
-Best New Player
-Best Independent Performance
-Most Sportsmanlike Conduct
-Most Entertaining Player
-Most Strategic Player
-Most Unlucky Player

Host Tier
-Best New Host
-Most Creative Host
-Most Entertaining Host
-Most Organized Host
-Fair Hosting Award
-Best flavor text
-Host of the Best Game (Mafia or Non-Mafia)

The War Room Tier
-Most friendly user
-Most committed user

Team Tier
-Best Town Team Performance
-Best Mafia Team Performance

List of Eligible Games from oldest to newest

MAFIA
Pokemon XY Mafia – Eye Gel
Random Messages Mafia – returnofmastercrazyhand + Zexy
Chaos Mafia – Doctor Floptopus
One Piece: Alabasta Mafia – Life
Twitchplayspokemon Mafia – returnofmastercrazyhand
Video Games Mafia – Molten Eevee + Zexy
Masters of the Whoniverse – Doctor Floptopus + Maniacal Engineer
Murder, She Wrote – Molten Eevee
Battle of Hogwarts – Kakashi Hatake
Christmas Mafia – Pinball Wizard + Sword Master
Fire Emblem Protagonist Mafia – returnofmastercrazyhand + TheCapsFan
My Little Pony: Friendship Is Mafia – Elieson
Fruit Bowl Mafia – Molten Eevee + Maniacal Engineer
Build-It! – Kakashi Hatake
Chess Mafia – Zexy
Super War Room Mafia Mafia –Elieson
Monty Python Mafia – Soaringdylan + leetic
Pokemon Generation I Mafia (2016) – Kakashi Hatake
Murder, She Wrote 2 – Molten Eevee
Paragon: Rise of New World Order – frozen.palisades +Elieson
It’s All About ME Mafia – Maniacal Engineer + Zexy
Everybody is Mafia Mafia 1.0 – Elieson
Murder, She Wrote 3 – Molten Eevee + Zexy
The 100 Mafia – DrumBeats
US Presidential Election 2016 Mafia – leetic
Corrupt?! Mafia – Kakashi Hatake + Zexy
MCH Multiverse Mafia – returnofmastercrazyhand + Elieson
True Lust: Intergalactic Battle of the Ships – frozen.palisades + Slife
Survival Game - Zexy
Everybody is Lazy Mafia 1.1 - Elieson

NON-MAFIA
Assasin In the Palace – Doctor Floptopus
Stab in the dark – Molten Eevee
Connect 4! – Enzap
Doctor Who Top Trumps – Doctor Floptopus
Doctor Floptopus’s Totally Bastard UK Politics Mafia-Style Game – Doctor Floptopus
Connect 4! Round 2 – Enzap
 
Town Tier
-Best Single Town Performance - Elieson
-Best Single Mafia Performance -
-Best New Player - Pikochu
-Best Independent Performance - JaggedJimmyJay - the 100
-Most Sportsmanlike Conduct - Zexy
-Most Entertaining Player - Elieson
-Most Strategic Player - Midorikawa
-Most Unlucky Player - Maniacal Engineer

Host Tier
-Best New Host - Calvin
-Most Creative Host - Calvin
-Most Entertaining Host - Maniacal Engineer
-Most Organized Host - Life
-Fair Hosting Award - Zexy
-Best flavor text - Maniacal Engineer
-Host of the Best Game (Mafia or Non-Mafia) - Elieson (SWRMM)

The War Room Tier
-Most friendly user - Zexy
-Most committed user -

Team Tier
-Best Town Team Performance - Super War Room Mafia Mafia
-Best Mafia Team Performance - Fruit Bowl Mafia

That's all I got for now
 
Last edited:
WELL SINCE I CANNOT OMNOMNOMINATE MYSELF FOR ANYTHING all I'd wanna nom myself for is like most committed or best town performance in Christmas Mafia or something...

Town Tier

-Best Single Town Performance • ___ •
-Best Single Mafia Performance • Midorikawa • For the returnsweep in 100 Mafia
+Best New Player • TheCapsFan • (Heck I thought he'd been playing for about 2 years. He's doing rather well for a novice to the game/concept of Mafia IMO)
+Best Independent Performance • Pikochu • (Fruit Bowl Mafia Survivor performance was pretty solid. Did exactly enough to dodge getting killed, and used his role as a fair threat to both factions)
+Most Sportsmanlike Conduct • Occam's Chainsaw • (After handling accusations of being a potential cheater during True Lust: Intergalactic Battle of the Ships , in the most respectful and honest way possible, during and after the game)
+Most Entertaining Player • Maniacal Engineer •
+Most Strategic Player • HumanDawn • (In my opinion, thus guy has some strange and unorthodox strats that serve an intended long-term purpose. While I can't say I find them to be super effective, next to me, I think he approaches things in what he assumes to be a very strategic way. I respect this, as I see myself in his playstyle.)
+Most Unlucky Player • Hellcrow • (for the hilariously accidental throwing Super War Room Mafia Mafia's scum-team when Sword Master didn't show up despite saying he was around to do post)

Host Tier
-Best New Host • ___ •
+Most Creative Host • Kakashi Hatake aka Calvin • (Overall, a fairly ambitious new host with creative setup [via Mechanics] ideas, notable Build-It!)
+Most Entertaining Host • Maniacal Engineer • (for It’s All About ME Mafia and all of its great flavor)
+Most Organized Host frozen.palisades(For her incredible coordination efforts in Paragon: Rise of New World Order, gathering people from more than 5 non-Bulba sites to both play and teach).
+Fair Hosting Award • frozen.palisades (For modkilling when it mattered, and enforcing post-limit rules very fairly in both True Lust: Intergalactic Battle of the Ships and Paragon: Rise of New World Order )
+Best flavor text •Maniacal Engineer• (for being very entertainingly written, from start to finish. In particular, It’s All About ME Mafia & Fruit Bowl Mafia)
-Host of the Best Game (Mafia or Non-Mafia) • ___ •

The War Room Tier
+Most friendly user Molten Eevee(Always like the Class Angel, afraid to push people unless there's no doubt at all)
-Most committed user • ___ •

Team Tier
-Best Town Team Performance • ___ •
-Best Mafia Team Performance • ___ •


I'll fill in the rest later, when I can focus more

*Updated on 8/9/16 [Added: Most Creative Host, Fair Hosting Award, Most Friendly User, removed Best Town Team Performance]
*Updated on 8/12/16 [Added: Best New Player, Most Strategic Player, Most Organized Host]
*Updated on 8/15/16 [Added: Best Single Mafia Performance]
 
Last edited:
Town Tier
-Best Single Town Performance Leetic in Fire Emblem mafia•
-Best Single Mafia Performance Leetic in fruit bowl mafia
-Best New Player TheCapsFan
-Best Independent Performance frozen_palisides in Fire Emblem Mafia
-Most Sportsmanlike Conduct Maniacal Engineer
-Most Entertaining Player Maniacal Engineer
-Most Strategic Player Elieson
-Most Unlucky Player Myself :(

Host Tier
-Best New Host Calvin ッ
-Most Creative Host Calvin ッ
-Most Entertaining Host Zexy
-Most Organized Host Elieson
-Fair Hosting Award Elieson
-Best flavor text Fruit Bowl mafia
-Host of the Best Game (Mafia or Non-Mafia) myself and zexy for random messages bias.

The War Room Tier
-Most friendly user Zexy
-Most committed user myself (after all, I keep playing despite my difficulties when doing so)

Team Tier
-Best Town Team Performance christmas mafia
-Best Mafia Team Performance fruit bowl mafia
EDIT: just noticed I can't vote myself, so uh, ignore those ones.
 
Last edited:
Town Tier
-Best Single Town Performance Elieson (Christmas Mafia)
-Best Single Mafia Performance DrumBeats (US Presidential Election 2016 Mafia)
-Best New Player TheCapsFan
-Best Independent Performance Pikochu (Fruit Bowl Mafia)
-Most Sportsmanlike Conduct
-Most Entertaining Player
-Most Strategic Player DrumBeats
-Most Unlucky Player

Host Tier
-Best New Host Calvin
-Most Creative Host Calvin
-Most Entertaining Host Maniacal Engineer
-Most Organized Host
-Fair Hosting Award DrumBeats
-Best flavor text Fruit Bowl Mafia
-Host of the Best Game (Mafia or Non-Mafia)

The War Room Tier
-Most friendly user
-Most committed user

Team Tier
-Best Town Team Performance
-Best Mafia Team Performance Build-it

I'll fill in the rest later
 
tfw people forgetting my biggest masterpiece thus far, Random messages.
it was my idea, and zexy helped it come alive more so than anything I have ever done minus maybe tpp mafia and the MCHverse mafia.
 
Town Tier
-Best Single Town Performance: Elieson for being the major factor for town winning Master of the Whoinverse
-Best Single Mafia Performance: Mid for turning around 100 Mafia after 3 scums were lost in 3 days. And for winning the game for Mafia on a large scale game. Honorable: leetic for Fruit Bowl Mafia, after two unlucky scum getting killed.
-Best New Player
-Best Independent Performance
-Most Sportsmanlike Conduct
-Most Entertaining Player: Elieson for the Dinosaur comics in Master of the Whoniverse
-Most Strategic Player
-Most Unlucky Player Zexy, for getting caught in my random Tracker check and Calvin lucky check on me in Murder She Wrote 2.

Host Tier
-Best New Host:
-Most Creative Host: Calvin for Build-It! Mafia.
-Most Entertaining Host: ME four puns. nuff said
-Most Organized Host: Eevee for hosting so many games and to the best of my knowledge, not making many mistakes
-Fair Hosting Award: Drumbeats for handling the 100 Mafia issue very well
-Best flavor text: ME for Fruit Bowl Mafia, Whoniverse, All about ME
-Host of the Best Game (Mafia or Non-Mafia)

The War Room Tier
-Most friendly user
-Most committed user

Team Tier
-Best Town Team Performance
-Best Mafia Team Performance: Super War Room Mafia Mafia for basically letting ME, RC and I destroy ourselves. Honorable Mention for "The 100" mafia.[/b]
 
Last edited:
Town Tier
-Best Single Town Performance - Elieson (Masters of the Whoniverse)
-Best Single Mafia Performance - Midorikawa (The 100 Mafia)
-Best New Player - TheCapsFan
-Best Independent Performance - Elementar (The 100 Mafia)
-Most Sportsmanlike Conduct - TheCapsFan
-Most Entertaining Player - Elieson
-Most Strategic Player - DrumBeats
-Most Unlucky Player - Hellcrow

Host Tier
-Best New Host - leetic
-Most Creative Host - Calvin
-Most Entertaining Host - Maniacal Engineer
-Most Organized Host - Elieson (for the spreadsheets!)
-Fair Hosting Award - DrumBeats
-Best flavor text - Maniacal Engineer
-Host of the Best Game (Mafia or Non-Mafia) - DrumBeats (The 100 Mafia)

The War Room Tier
-Most friendly user - Doctor Floptopus
-Most committed user - DrumBeats

Team Tier
-Best Town Team Performance - It's All About ME Mafia
-Best Mafia Team Performance - US Presidential Election 2016 Mafia

Was thinking of including special mentions... but they are way too many to mention. Apologies to those who haven't made it, I had lots of fun and saw lots of nice things this season but we are only voting for the best of the best here.

I'll edit in more later.
 
Town Tier
-Best Single Town Performance
-Best Single Mafia Performance - Drumbeats (US Presidential Mafia)
-Best New Player - TheCapsFan
-Best Independent Performance - JaggedJimmyJay (The 100 Mafia)
-Most Sportsmanlike Conduct - Zexy
-Most Entertaining Player - Maniacal Engineer
-Most Strategic Player - Drumbeats
-Most Unlucky Player

Host Tier
-Best New Host
-Most Creative Host - Maniacal Engineer
-Most Entertaining Host - Maniacal Engineer
-Most Organized Host - Elieson
-Fair Hosting Award - Drumbeats
-Best flavor text - Drumbeats (100 Mafia)
-Host of the Best Game (Mafia or Non-Mafia)

The War Room Tier
-Most friendly user - Zexy
-Most committed user - FinalArcadia

Team Tier
-Best Town Team Performance
-Best Mafia Team Performance - I would say that US Presidential Mafia was pretty good, but I was unfortunately in that team. The other guys did most of the work though.
 
Last edited:
Town Tier
-Best Single Town Performance - Zexy (Monty Python Mafia)
-Best Single Mafia Performance - Midorikawa (The 100 Mafia)
-Best New Player
-Best Independent Performance - JaggedJimmyJay (The 100 Mafia)
-Most Sportsmanlike Conduct - Maniacal Engineer (Specifically in Gen I mafia)
-Most Entertaining Player - MetalMarsh89 (In the one day he was in the 100 mafia, he made me laugh so much)
-Most Strategic Player - Zexy
-Most Unlucky Player - Leetic (Pokemon Gen 1 Mafia - with the fool "cop checking" him)

Host Tier
-Best New Host - Leetic
-Most Creative Host - Calvin
-Most Entertaining Host - Manicial Engineer
-Most Organized Host - Elieson
-Fair Hosting Award - Zexy
-Best flavor text - Maniacal Engineer
-Host of the Best Game (Mafia or Non-Mafia) - Elieson (Everybody is Mafia Mafia - Spaghetti one)

The War Room Tier
-Most friendly user - Aussie Eevee/Mighty Eevee/Molten Eevee
-Most committed user - Zexy

Team Tier
-Best Town Team Performance - It's All About ME Mafia
-Best Mafia Team Performance
 
@Elieson; Your True Lust town vote is invalid as you were part of it.

@Pikochu; Your frozen.palisades/Elieson vote for Best New Host is invalid. Only one player may be picked, not one game. Both of those players are ineligible anyway. We are talking about actual new hosts, not hosts new to TWR only.

You can check the rules for more detail.
 
@Pikochu; Your frozen.palisades/Elieson vote for Best New Host is invalid. Only one player may be picked, not one game. Both of those players are ineligible anyway. We are talking about actual new hosts, not hosts new to TWR only.

Fixed for the time being. I also fixed the other potential problematic vote.
 
Town Tier
-Best Single Town Performance: HumanDawn in Random Messages Mafia (might be bias bc this was my first game but I think it was p good)
-Best Single Mafia Performance: leetic in Fruit Bowl Mafia (this was something I could have never done on my own)
-Best New Player: leetic
-Best Independent Performance: frozen.palisades in Fire Emblem Protagonist Mafia
-Most Sportsmanlike Conduct: Zexy
-Most Entertaining Player: Midorikawa
-Most Strategic Player: FinalArcadia
-Most Unlucky Player: Maniacal Engineer

Host Tier
-Best New Host: AussieEevee
-Most Creative Host: Calvin/Kakashi
-Most Entertaining Host: Maniacal Engineer
-Most Organized Host: Elieson
-Fair Hosting Award: leetic
-Best flavor text: Maniacal Engineer
-Host of the Best Game (Mafia or Non-Mafia): Elieson - Everybody is Mafia Mafia (For introducing the single coolest variation of Mafia I've ever seen, and turning it into one epic collaboration.)

The War Room Tier
-Most friendly user: Calvin/Kakashi (Gah, you make me pick one? Ye moderator fiends.)
-Most committed user: DrumBeats (Just look at Pokemon Gen One Mafia. This guy's wallposts are legendary.)

Team Tier
-Best Town Team Performance: Everybody Is Mafia Mafia Random Messages Mafia (totally not sheeping Zexy on this one)
-Best Mafia Team Performance: Build-It

Subject to change.
 
Last edited:
Town Tier
-Best Single Town Performance
-Best Single Mafia Performance: Midorikawa (The 100 Mafia)
-Best New Player: TheCapsFan
-Best Independent Performance
-Most Sportsmanlike Conduct
-Most Entertaining Player
-Most Strategic Player
-Most Unlucky Player: Maniacal Engineer

Host Tier

-Best New Host: Calvin
-Most Creative Host: Calvin
-Most Entertaining Host
-Most Organized Host: Elieson
-Fair Hosting Award: Zexy
-Best flavor text: DrumBeats (The 100 Mafia)
-Host of the Best Game (Mafia or Non-Mafia): Elieson (Everybody is Mafia Mafia)

The War Room Tier
-Most friendly user: Maniacal Engineer
-Most committed user: Zexy

Team Tier
-Best Town Team Performance
-Best Mafia Team Performance

Will edit later, I probably need to look back at games I didn't play in to get a good handle on some of the other categories.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom