-
Hey Trainers! Be sure to check out Corsola Beach, our newest section on the forums, in partnership with our friends at Corsola Cove! At the Beach, you can discuss the competitive side of the games, post your favorite Pokemon memes, and connect with other Pokemon creators!
-
Due to the recent changes with Twitter's API, it is no longer possible for Bulbagarden forum users to login via their Twitter account. If you signed up to Bulbagarden via Twitter and do not have another way to login, please contact us here with your Twitter username so that we can get you sorted.
Mafia Tiger & Bunny Mafia ~ HEROES WIN ~ 12/5
- Thread starter Nytie
- Start date
- Status
Majestic-Six
Goddess go with you
- Joined
- Sep 21, 2013
- Messages
- 1,992
- Reaction score
- 10
Re: Tiger & Bunny Mafia ~ Day 1: Begin ~ 11/7
I'm not voting yet I'm gonna wait a bit longer.
I'm not voting yet I'm gonna wait a bit longer.
Zima
dunno y u gotta pain 2nyt
- Joined
- Jul 16, 2011
- Messages
- 4,553
- Reaction score
- 12
Re: Tiger & Bunny Mafia ~ Day 1: Begin ~ 11/7
Vote: No Lynch
We'll likely lose a townie if we vote.
I love you, too.
Vote: No Lynch
We'll likely lose a townie if we vote.
GliscorMan
URPG!
- Joined
- Jun 7, 2010
- Messages
- 3,004
- Reaction score
- 1
Re: Tiger & Bunny Mafia ~ Day 1: Begin ~ 11/7
No, no, guys. You misunderstand the point of D1!
@_Q2; We vote D1 here as a custom.
But regardless of custom, just voting No Lynch gets us nowhere. After the first death, we can begin to mess with suspicious patterns and such, and until then we do not lynch. We do, however, tie up the votes/vote No Lynch at the very end of the phase.
Or at least that's what I like to see done, because that way we compromise getting information vs not putting ourselves at a disadvantage.
No, no, guys. You misunderstand the point of D1!
@_Q2; We vote D1 here as a custom.
But regardless of custom, just voting No Lynch gets us nowhere. After the first death, we can begin to mess with suspicious patterns and such, and until then we do not lynch. We do, however, tie up the votes/vote No Lynch at the very end of the phase.
Or at least that's what I like to see done, because that way we compromise getting information vs not putting ourselves at a disadvantage.
- Joined
- Jul 12, 2011
- Messages
- 14,622
- Reaction score
- 4,574
Re: Tiger & Bunny Mafia ~ Day 1: Begin ~ 11/7
For once I'm going to change my play-style a bit and postpone voting until I find reasonable reasons to vote
For once I'm going to change my play-style a bit and postpone voting until I find reasonable reasons to vote
Re: Tiger & Bunny Mafia ~ Day 1: Begin ~ 11/7
I'm used to Day 1 being a day where voting isn't allowed, so I guess this is going to be new to me. If it comes to the point where I have to, then I'll do so, but for now...
Vote: No Lynch
Because I still don't really understand the point of Day 1 voting if there is no basis for it. I feel like Day 1 is usually just a lot of omgus and nothing else, really.
I'm used to Day 1 being a day where voting isn't allowed, so I guess this is going to be new to me. If it comes to the point where I have to, then I'll do so, but for now...
Vote: No Lynch
Because I still don't really understand the point of Day 1 voting if there is no basis for it. I feel like Day 1 is usually just a lot of omgus and nothing else, really.
Zima
dunno y u gotta pain 2nyt
- Joined
- Jul 16, 2011
- Messages
- 4,553
- Reaction score
- 12
Re: Tiger & Bunny Mafia ~ Day 1: Begin ~ 11/7
What if we lose the cop or something? We might as well have a vanilla townie tell us they're vanilla and have them lynched if we want to lynch a town member so badly.
I mean, the cop could check someone and start an alliance or tell someone somebody's mafia if we don't lynch today. We're in total darkness as to who is what right now.
What if we lose the cop or something? We might as well have a vanilla townie tell us they're vanilla and have them lynched if we want to lynch a town member so badly.
I mean, the cop could check someone and start an alliance or tell someone somebody's mafia if we don't lynch today. We're in total darkness as to who is what right now.
harryheart
New Member
- Joined
- May 2, 2009
- Messages
- 633
- Reaction score
- 1
- Joined
- Oct 18, 2011
- Messages
- 5,558
- Reaction score
- 1,821
- Pronouns
- She/Her
- Any
Re: Tiger & Bunny Mafia ~ Day 1: Begin ~ 11/7
There's a lot of potential for little to come out of the night phase, though. If the cop checks mafia, that's great and hopefully they'd be able to find a way to communicate that safely in-thread, but if they check town which is statistically more likely, we'd really be in the exact same position as we are now for the purposes of finding scum here. And early night kills in particular are hard to judge who might've had a hand in them.
@harryheart
You've posted since the lynch vs. no lynch discussion started, and have still kept your vote on Zima after seeing her response (since you've directly quoted it). Do you think a lynch (and thus perhaps your vote on Zima) would be more beneficial than a no lynch?
There's a lot of potential for little to come out of the night phase, though. If the cop checks mafia, that's great and hopefully they'd be able to find a way to communicate that safely in-thread, but if they check town which is statistically more likely, we'd really be in the exact same position as we are now for the purposes of finding scum here. And early night kills in particular are hard to judge who might've had a hand in them.
@harryheart
You've posted since the lynch vs. no lynch discussion started, and have still kept your vote on Zima after seeing her response (since you've directly quoted it). Do you think a lynch (and thus perhaps your vote on Zima) would be more beneficial than a no lynch?
harryheart
New Member
- Joined
- May 2, 2009
- Messages
- 633
- Reaction score
- 1
Re: Tiger & Bunny Mafia ~ Day 1: Begin ~ 11/7
I think a lynch would be more beneficial, yes! I never used to think that, but I've seen how much more effective the next few phases are after a Day 1 lynch in some games, so I do stand by that as a general principle now. However, I wouldn't say a definite lynch on @Zima; because, to be fair, she's done nothing to suggest Mafia yet, but there's also no-one else that seems suspicious to this point so my vote stands.
I think a lynch would be more beneficial, yes! I never used to think that, but I've seen how much more effective the next few phases are after a Day 1 lynch in some games, so I do stand by that as a general principle now. However, I wouldn't say a definite lynch on @Zima; because, to be fair, she's done nothing to suggest Mafia yet, but there's also no-one else that seems suspicious to this point so my vote stands.
CrackFox
Mutha'uckas
- Joined
- May 20, 2009
- Messages
- 6,299
- Reaction score
- 27
Re: Tiger & Bunny Mafia ~ Day 1: Begin ~ 11/7
For a while I was against random D1 lynches because the majority of the time, they always lead to innocent deaths, however it's definitely true that not lynching is basically stagnating. The first night kill wont offer much insight if any, into people's mindsets so we'll be in the same situation the next day phase, sooner or later we're gonna have to take a shot in the dark. In theory i'd like to see someone lynched but I have no preference as to who it is (obviously not myself because that would make me sad :/)
I also don't think a vanilla should offer themselves up, that wouldn't help us anyway and no matter what your role, you should fight to save yourself regardless. I'd hope that if the votes were being placed on a player with an important role, they'd have the insight to try and stop it by whatever means they can. Claiming to a person they trust the most would be better than just letting yourself be lynched. Hopefully that wont happen and with the amount of people voting for a no lynch, looks like it's gonna carry through.
For a while I was against random D1 lynches because the majority of the time, they always lead to innocent deaths, however it's definitely true that not lynching is basically stagnating. The first night kill wont offer much insight if any, into people's mindsets so we'll be in the same situation the next day phase, sooner or later we're gonna have to take a shot in the dark. In theory i'd like to see someone lynched but I have no preference as to who it is (obviously not myself because that would make me sad :/)
I also don't think a vanilla should offer themselves up, that wouldn't help us anyway and no matter what your role, you should fight to save yourself regardless. I'd hope that if the votes were being placed on a player with an important role, they'd have the insight to try and stop it by whatever means they can. Claiming to a person they trust the most would be better than just letting yourself be lynched. Hopefully that wont happen and with the amount of people voting for a no lynch, looks like it's gonna carry through.
Elysion
Syaoran is the sweetest
- Joined
- Jun 30, 2013
- Messages
- 388
- Reaction score
- 2
Re: Tiger & Bunny Mafia ~ Day 1: Begin ~ 11/7
I don't think there's anything wrong with voting no lynch day 1, but I don't think its always bad to vote for someone day 1 either. Its just that it can be a little difficult since its day 1. :I
Dark Kyriaki - mentioning that you're going ti change your playstyle sounds a bit iffy to me. If you said that you were just going to postpone your vote that would have been good enough.I'm just weird I guess.
I don't think there's anything wrong with voting no lynch day 1, but I don't think its always bad to vote for someone day 1 either. Its just that it can be a little difficult since its day 1. :I
Dark Kyriaki - mentioning that you're going ti change your playstyle sounds a bit iffy to me. If you said that you were just going to postpone your vote that would have been good enough.
- Joined
- Jul 12, 2011
- Messages
- 14,622
- Reaction score
- 4,574
Re: Tiger & Bunny Mafia ~ Day 1: Begin ~ 11/7
I only mentioned just in case people find it suspicious if I'm not acting as usual. If you go look at previous games, you'll see that in nearly every game I was joke-voting the host (or voting early as possible to generate conversations). Changing my playstyle; not doing that in this game because I figured there was no need for unnecessary actions from me. In fact, I'll be more careful with placing votes in voting phases.
I only mentioned just in case people find it suspicious if I'm not acting as usual. If you go look at previous games, you'll see that in nearly every game I was joke-voting the host (or voting early as possible to generate conversations). Changing my playstyle; not doing that in this game because I figured there was no need for unnecessary actions from me. In fact, I'll be more careful with placing votes in voting phases.
Heartilly
shooting star
- Joined
- Oct 25, 2011
- Messages
- 1,833
- Reaction score
- 0
Re: Tiger & Bunny Mafia ~ Day 1: Begin ~ 11/7
Although I'm certainly not against it, I'm not exactly for a Day 1 lynch either. Sure, it can of course cause some discussion for the coming phase, but I think it might be wiser to wait to see what the night phase has in store for us. Nightkills don't always give information, but Day 1 lynches don't always either, so I'm just not going to vote for now (unless something comes up).
Although I'm certainly not against it, I'm not exactly for a Day 1 lynch either. Sure, it can of course cause some discussion for the coming phase, but I think it might be wiser to wait to see what the night phase has in store for us. Nightkills don't always give information, but Day 1 lynches don't always either, so I'm just not going to vote for now (unless something comes up).
- Joined
- Nov 9, 2011
- Messages
- 7,835
- Reaction score
- 447
Re: Tiger & Bunny Mafia ~ Day 1: Begin ~ 11/7
Quite honestly, voting a no lynch for day 1 is usually a bad idea. Not saying it always is, but most of the time it is. The night kill provides usually little to no information and day 2 will then go on just like day 1 and we can't risk that forever.
We could potentially hit the cop but that's a very low chance and risking another phase of no development just for that "what if" doesn't seem like a very good idea to me.
Quite honestly, voting a no lynch for day 1 is usually a bad idea. Not saying it always is, but most of the time it is. The night kill provides usually little to no information and day 2 will then go on just like day 1 and we can't risk that forever.
We could potentially hit the cop but that's a very low chance and risking another phase of no development just for that "what if" doesn't seem like a very good idea to me.
GliscorMan
URPG!
- Joined
- Jun 7, 2010
- Messages
- 3,004
- Reaction score
- 1
Re: Tiger & Bunny Mafia ~ Day 1: Begin ~ 11/7
Vote: Buoy
Your no-lynch vote strikes me as the most odd out of all of them, because of your usual play style; you aren't usually the one who decides to follow this sort of move.
Explanation?
Vote: Buoy
Your no-lynch vote strikes me as the most odd out of all of them, because of your usual play style; you aren't usually the one who decides to follow this sort of move.
Explanation?
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
- Locked
