- Joined
- May 30, 2012
- Messages
- 21,720
- Reaction score
- 5,356
- Pronouns
- She/Her
Correction it is mylo.If scum is not lynched, this is the final phase of the game.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Correction it is mylo.If scum is not lynched, this is the final phase of the game.
I literally just told you why? Are you just ignoring that?Otherwise why would e refuse to claim.
Ok fair point, and if they dont then another player can notice those special claims if they have the game. I submitted my very first game, Star Wars Mafia.If scum got a role from it then they already know where to look for fake claims, there's no point in hiding it.
And then what? Next phase we have the same issue. It would just delay this problem of double claims. This is literally the best we got. We are certain there is scum in here. Don't delay it. What makes you doubt pika? His play is consistent with what he said before. jd has no alibi.It’s too difficult to tell which cop claim is legit at this moment. So it’s best to go for a different mafia member.
And they could be fake checks made to match his play.I literally just told you why? Are you just ignoring that?
Ok fair point, and if they dont then another player can notice those special claims if they have the game. I submitted my very first game, Star Wars Mafia.
And then what? Next phase we have the same issue. It would just delay this problem of double claims. This is literally the best we got. We are certain there is scum in here. Don't delay it. What makes you doubt pika? His play is consistent with what he said before. jd has no alibi.
It's LyLo, not MyLo. A tie results in a loss for Town.We’re at the point where hiding anything just harms town. This is probably mylo. It’s too difficult to tell which cop claim is legit at this moment. So it’s best to go for a different mafia member.
Can you say with confidence that Pika or jd is 100% mafiaIt's LyLo, not MyLo. A tie results in a loss for Town.
And I'm not sure if I agree with this strategy.
One of the scums just exposed themselves and you want to attempt to find another one with less than 18h remaining?
The entire Town+Lone has to vote this newly found scum, I afraid trying to do that would only spread the votes more easily and facilitate Mafia's win.
even if we focus on someone else I'm not sure we'd be able to tell whether they're 100% mafia or not eitherCan you say with confidence that Pika or jd is 100% mafia
It wouldn’t feel as rushed if Darth and snake weren’t hindering town effortseven if we focus on someone else I'm not sure we'd be able to tell whether they're 100% mafia or not either
especially if it's a rushed case
lmaoIgnore that part about jd in that last post. I realized I worded my last post badly and was going to clarify but work interrupted
(This is not reads, only hypothetical)lmao
I was like "how can one be 60% mafia"
sigh(This is not reads, only hypothetical)
Suppose at the beginning of the night, there are 7 living players. 2 are Bulletproof Cult Leaders with currently empty cults who can't target each other, or it will target a random player. One of the other 5 is jdthebud, who is currently Bulletproof Mafia. There are no other conversion mechanics. With this logic, there is a 40% chance jdthebud will be a Cultist at the start of the next day. Otherwise, he will remain Mafia. Using quantum law, one can deduce that the state of jdthebud at the start of the next day is 60% Mafia. Thank you for coming to my Ted Talk.
The dead should remain dead.(This is not reads, only hypothetical)
Suppose at the beginning of the night, there are 7 living players. 2 are Bulletproof Cult Leaders with currently empty cults who can't target each other, or it will target a random player. One of the other 5 is jdthebud, who is currently Bulletproof Mafia. There are no other conversion mechanics. With this logic, there is a 40% chance jdthebud will be a Cultist at the start of the next day. Otherwise, he will remain Mafia. Using quantum law, one can deduce that the state of jdthebud at the start of the next day is 60% Mafia. Thank you for coming to my Ted Talk.
I’m always 60% mafia.lmao
I was like "how can one be 60% mafia"
Thos helps.wait wait waitwaitWAIT
wtf
I was pretty sure you were softing Doctor or some other kind of manipulative/protective role:
Isn't that the opposite of an investigative role claim since they all return results even when redirected?
It was supposedly your second time getting roleblocked, if you suspected they had rolecopped you D1 why did you lie?
Correct, I lied about not getting a result, on the off chance that I hadn't been rolecopped, hoping scum would leave me alone the next night.wait wait waitwaitWAIT
wtf
I was pretty sure you were softing Doctor or some other kind of manipulative/protective role:
Isn't that the opposite of an investigative role claim since they all return results even when redirected?
It was supposedly your second time getting roleblocked, if you suspected they had rolecopped you D1 why did you lie?
There's no reason for me to CC someone when I could claim a different role from my game.
Why.
Why must you people do this.
Vote: jdthebud
He's the worst looking of the two before this point, and as Ex has just so graciously pointed out, directly contradicted his earlier statement.
I won't deny that Pika's targets are very convenient and reek of fakeclaim, but at least they're consistent with what he'd been doing before.
Really, this is weird! I was not expecting OC to vote for Pika here if Pika is scum...which makes me think this is an ploy by Darth, given his response to Officer after this vote:Vote: Pika_pika42
I'll go with jd for this one
Here's your scum team: Darth, Pika, and Officer Snake.Scumbud confirmed
What do you think of my theory above regarding the scum team being Darth, Officer Snake, and Pika?I’m always 60% mafia.
In seriousness I’m honestly having a large feeling that Darth is mafia.
He’s not actually down anything to help town, his refusal to claim, and also the fact that FA suspected him and suddenly she died.
Usually I think nothing of that type of thing but....imo a bit coincidental this time
He claimed to be roleblocked, but funnily enough he didn't say so on the previous day, did he? I highly doubt there is a mass roleblock, since before today I was the only one to claim being roleblocked.Also I think we can say there may have been a mass toleblocking last night phase since both cops claimed to be rolecopped.
Vote: jdthebud
Pika is at least consistent and I did double check.
I see what you did there, ME. Well played. Unlike me :vMegaPod paced around his room for a while, cursing his short fuse from earlier.
"I shouldn't have blown up on Max," he said.
Also do you guys really think that I would CC pika if I wasn't cop? Most people were townreading him before this.
Wait I can guess why. Most people were scum reading you before this whereas I was being town read but not as much as Mido, Ex or Darth. If you would have claimed any other role, chances were we would still Lynch you today.There's no reason for me to CC someone when I could claim a different role from my game.
I was just told my check failed, which could mostly be due to Roleblock but there could be some other reason like you are Ascetic or something? Were you specifically told you were Roleblocked?He claimed to be roleblocked, but funnily enough he didn't say so on the previous day, did he? I highly doubt there is a mass roleblock, since before today I was the only one to claim being roleblocked.