Waiter, there's a ______ in my soup

[PokéSean]

Gee, hopefully it’s not attached to Caitlin shoe.

Waiter! Emily from AG081’s shoe is in my soup too!

 

[my imagination]

Meh, its not real. It can’t hurt you. goes away

Hey waiter, there’s pneumonoultramicroscopicsilicovolcanoconiosis in my soup! Help!!!

 

[DigitalGen6]

This looks like fun.

Waiter, there’s a Trauma Center 2: Gentle Breeze plays in my soup.

 

[toastghost]

that's just the song playing on the radio. no need to fear.

waiter, there's a tangled fog of pulsating yearning in the shape of a woman in my soup

 

[DigitalGen6]

That’s just our boss. He’s gonna fire us if we don’t do our jobs right.

Waiter, there’s a Volphied’s avatar in my soup.

 

[babypiratewithalisp2]

Waiter there's a sponge in my soup
SpongeBoB: Hey, stop drinking my pool!!

 

[DigitalGen6]

Waiter, there’s a talking cheese with brown pants in my soup!
(And thanks for reviving this- And thanks for not giving reason to what I said was in there before)

 

[PokéSean]

It’s SpongeBob in there.

Waiter! There’s a city bus in my soup.

 

[guzmania]

uhhh.... feel free to, like... call a tow truck or somethi- waitaminute, what are you doing with that soup in the first place? that's reserved for wailord customers only, human!
ooh, i swear, this is a daily thing with our newest hire. i'm going to need to have a long talk with him.

waiter, there's a dead cutiefly in my soup!

 

[toastghost]

just bring it to the pokemon center

waiter theres a wormhole in my soup

 

[guzmania]

can't you just beat it up? those are early-game enemies, i'm pretty sure you first encounter them in the prologue

waiter, there's a faintly glowing red orb in my soup!

 

[Maniacal Engineer]

That’s just an evil Matzo Ball. It’s fine.

Waiter, there’s a deck of cards in my soup.

 

[DigitalGen6]

Have fun playing with them. Don’t draw the joker card ^^ (should I lay off the smile precure? or…)

(Idk if I’ve done this before but…) Waiter, there’s a baby patrick in my soup.

 

[The Traveller]

That’s because we serve this soup as part of our St. Patrick’s Day special! (I know St. Patrick’s Day is over a month away but I wanted to try getting this thread up and running again.)

Pardon me, waiter, but there appears to be a Waddle Dee in my soup.

 

[DigitalGen6]

Looks like someone hasn’t seen SpongeBob season 5’s “goo goo gas” xD

And now the Waddle Dee has a home :O

Waiter, there’s a Ellee-chan in my soup. (And just in case you don’t know who that is, Google it)