Waiter, there's a ______ in my soup

[Kharixi]

No, it's just a mirror.

Waiter, the Elements of Harmony are in my soup!

 

[TouyaShiro]

Thought you were a fan of rhythm games. I dunno the actual context pls no kill

Waiter, there's an iron fist in my soup!

 

[Time Breaker]

Be penitent! (Another reference no one will get)

I dunno the actual context pls no kill

Do me a favor and never will to find out. =D

Waiter, Commeson is in my soup!

 

[Kharixi]

...er, I thought that's what you ordered...?

Waiter, there's a ring in my soup!

 

[RagnorokX]

Will you marry me, milady?

Waiter, there's a potential misunderstanding of prior statement in my soup!

 

[indigohex]

What statement?

Waiter, there's a ticket to Indigohex Bulbagarden Forum Members Salute to Magikarp special. And it's at 7:30 tonight.

 

[Chidamari Sketch]

I'm sorry; it's expired by now.

Waiter, there's Cthulhu in my soup

 

[Maniacal Engineer]

Goodness, it's almost 11pm. I must have missed it. Oh well.
I'll get Eric Cartman. He can control Cthulhu.

Waiter there's a pair of sunglasses in my soup.

 

[Max1996]

This day must be...*puts them on*...soup-er for you, sir.
YEAAAAAHHHHHH!

Waiter, there is a Passimian in my soup!

 

[Maniacal Engineer]

That's odd. I thought this was Moon Version.

Waiter, there's a traffic jam in my soup.

 

[Wispy Willow]

Sir, some kid just dropped some jam and some toy cars in your soup while you were away. I don't know why those two items were specificly dropped in your soup, but the universe works in mysterious ways.

Waiter, there's an odd pea in my soup.

 

[Kirby4ever]

We ran out of fresh peas......

Waiter, there's a creeper in my soup!!!!! D:

 

[Kharixi]

We wanted to make our soup... SIZZLING!

Waiter, there's a beach in my soup!

 

[Max1996]

Do you enjoy our Sand Special?

Waiter, there is a baseball bat in my soup!

 

[Kharixi]

It got a home run.

Waiter, my soup is offsides!

 

[RagnorokX]

What? Oh true, there are 7 soups here and only 2 there.

Waiter, there's a power hungry immortal time-stopping vampire in my soup!

 

[Max1996]

I'll look for a stake.

Waiter, there is a steak in my soup!

 

[RagnorokX]

Ah, do you like our steak soup special?

Waiter, there's a drowning greninja in my soup, however that works SMASH BROS!

 

[TouyaShiro]

He's just getting used to his body. Plus, he's a ninja, not an athlete.

Waiter, there's an edgehog in my soup!

 

[Chidamari Sketch]

Ow the edge, hope it doesn't use guns and bad vehicles...

Waiter, there's Rise of Lyric in my soup.