• A new LGBTQ+ forum is now being trialed and there have been changes made to the Support and Advice forum. To read more about these updates, click here.
  • Hey Trainers! Be sure to check out Corsola Beach, our newest section on the forums, in partnership with our friends at Corsola Cove! At the Beach, you can discuss the competitive side of the games, post your favorite Pokemon memes, and connect with other Pokemon creators!
  • Due to the recent changes with Twitter's API, it is no longer possible for Bulbagarden forum users to login via their Twitter account. If you signed up to Bulbagarden via Twitter and do not have another way to login, please contact us here with your Twitter username so that we can get you sorted.

War Room Awards (2012)- VOTING OVER

Status
Not open for further replies.

Paperhorse

Well-Known Member
Joined
Dec 11, 2009
Messages
2,486
Reaction score
21
SOMETHING HAS HAPPENED!

Welcome to the 2nd annual War Room Awards! The staff and I are excited to celebrate your involvement in one of the best communities on Bulbagarden. For the past year, the War Room has grown considerably; players and hosts have done exceptional jobs making the games exciting and fun for everyone. All of you deserve to be recognized for your commitment to the War Room, as there would be no War Room without it.

Rules (Edited from Rayne’s)

NOTE: Make sure you read all rules carefully.

- All games nominated must be completed by the time the thread goes up (June 3rd, 2012).

- Games that are eligible to win an award must have started around last year’s awards (August 20th 2011).

- Eligible games are listed at the end of this post for your convenience.

- Voters must have participated in at least one game, which must be completed in order to be eligible for an award.

- Mintaka, Iteru, Hellion and Parmalee are ineligible to receive individual awards, but may receive a team award.

- Voters may not vote for themselves.

- Voting will be public and in the nominations thread only. Voters can only vote for one person per category.

- Voters can give the reasoning behind their votes with a small explanation, but it's not mandatory. Voters must provide the title of the game or games which prompted their vote.

- Two further awards - Best Player and Best Host - will be awarded to the person who accumulated the highest number of votes across the categories of the Player Tier and the Host Tier respectively. Should the winners of the Best Player Award and the Best Host Award win more than half the categories in their respective tier, they would solely win that respective award, and his other awards would go to the person that has garnered the second highest number of votes in those categories.

Categories

Player Tier

- Best Town Performance
- Best Mafia Performance
- Best Independent Performance
- Most Sportsmanlike Conduct
- Most Entertaining Player
- Most Strategic Player
- Most Promising Player

Team Tier

(Prizes that are won by multiple users for each.)

- Best Mafia Team Performance
- Best Town Team Performance

Host Tier

- Most Creative Host
- Most Entertaining Host
- Fair Hosting Award
- Best Flavor text
- Most Organized host
- Host of the Best Mafia Game
- Host of the Best Mafia Series
- Host of the Best Non-Mafia Game
- Most Promising Host

The War Room Tier

(This category is more general, rather it refers to both players and hosts, and participants in the war room as a whole.)

- Best Contributor in the Situation Room
- Most Friendly user
- Most Committed User

NOTE: With the exception of the Best Town Performance, Best Mafia Performance and Best Independent performance, which refer solely to Mafia games, all other categories in the Player and Host Tiers refer to both Mafia games and Non-Mafia games.

The Most Promising Player/Host award refers to new players of the War Room. Most Promising Player should be awarded to a person who is new in the past four months. Most Promising Host may be six or seven months, as it takes longer to host.

Voting will begin on Monday June 4th at 9:00 am EST. ALL VOTES PLACED BEFORE THIS TIME WON’T BE CONSIDERED.

Also, use this thread for VOTING ONLY. Any discussions on nominations please bring to the Situation Room. For example, if you are nominated, please don’t quote the person and thank them, just take it to the Situation Room.

Award Banners will be created by @Blazaking EX;

Voting will be open for two weeks, and will end on Monday, June 18th at 9:00 am EST

Good luck to all of you!

LIST OF COMPLETED MAFIA GAMES
(August 21st, 2011 ~ June 3rd 2012)


Plant VS Zombies Mafia by TFRoflcopter - July 12th 2011 ~ August 23rd 2011

Rabbit Doubt II by Phoenicks - August 14th, 2011 to August 25th, 2011

Bloodshed in Blackthorn (Pokemon Mafia) by PkmnFireRed - July 21st 2011 ~ August 25th 2011

A Different Kind of Mafia Game (ADKOM) by Derier44 - July17th 2011 ~ September 1st 2011

My Little Pony: Friendship is Mafia hosted by Parmalee and Rayne - August 7th 2011 ~ September 1st 2011

The Battle for White Forest by ~HollowTree~ - August 23rd 2011 to September 12th 2011

Simpsons Mafia by GengarEatBanana - August 19th 2011 ~ September 17th 2011

War Room Mafia 2 hosted by Mintaka - August 22nd 2011 to September 19th 2011

Jackie Chan Adventures Mafia by J J M - August 28th 2011 to September 28th 2011

Falconwing Mafia 3 by Ryuutakeshi - September 3rd 2011 to September 29th 2011

America's Next Top Model by Hellion - September 15th 2011 to October 7th 2011

Family Guy Mafia by PkmnFireRed - September 3rd 2011 to October 15th 2011

Inazuma Eleven Mafia by Neonsands - September 18th 2011 to October 15th 2011

Harry Potter and Deathly Hallows Mafia by Aestivate - October 10th 2011 to November 1st 2011

Salem Witch Trials by Master Mew October 6th 2011 to November 2nd 2011

Sonic the Hedgehog Mafia by Pichuboy - October 3rd 2011 to November 6th 2011

Roleless Mafia 2 by Parmalee - November 2nd 2011 to November 16th 2011

War Room Mafia 3 hosted by Mintaka - November 13th 2011 to November 24th 2011

Pokémon Anime Mafia: Kodomo ne! by Iteru - November 8th 2011 to December 4th 2011

Havendale Mafia by Zenax - November 17th 2011 to December 5th 2011

Super Street Fighter IV: Mafia Edition by Shinobu - November 9th 2011 to November 19th 2011

Jackie Chan Adventures Mafia 2 by J J M - November 29th 2011 ~ January 2nd 2012

Companions Quartet Mafia by Buoy - December 8th 2011 ~ January 13th 2012

Assassin's Creed Revelations Mafia by PkmnFireRed - December 6th 2011 ~ January 19th 2012

Homestar Runner Sockpuppet Action Mafia by The Hooded Claw - January 12th 2012 ~ January 22nd 2012

Hunger Games Mafia by PkmnHeartGold and PkmnSilver - January 5th 2012 ~ January 23rd 2012

Havendale Mafia 2 by Zenax - January 2nd 2012 ~ January 25th 2012

Werewolves Mafia by Hellion - January 30th 2012 ~ February 12th 2012

The Legend of Zelda:The Mafia by Tris79 - January 10th 2012 ~ February 16th 2012

LOST Mafia by Paperhorse and The Man With No Name - January 30th 2012 ~ February 18th 2012

Hitchhikers Guide to the Galaxy Mafia by Soulmaster - February 3rd 2012 ~ February 25th 2012

Jackie Chan Adventures Mafia III by J J M - February 4th 2012 to March 4th 2012

Yu-Gi-Oh 5D's Mafia: Signers VS Dark Signers by Nytie - February 12th 2012 ~ March 4th 2012

MCF Huntsville Mafia by Mintaka - March 4th 2012 ~ March 15th 2012

Sailor Moon Mafia by PkmnSilver - February 18th 2012 ~ March 16th 2012

Brockback Mafia by Croag - February 25th 2012 ~ March 16th 2012

BTD5 Mafia~The Second Round by No Lynch - February 20th 2012 ~ March 25th 2012

Police Mafia by Sharpshooter★ - March 22nd 2012 ~ March 30th 2012

Pokémon Ranger: Guardian Signs Mafia by Hitomi - March 5th 2012 ~ March 31st 2012

Pokemon Mafia by Wasteland - March 13th 2012 ~ April 1st 2012

Disney Princesses Mafia by Aestivate - March 16th 2012 ~ April 5th 2012

My Little Pony: Friendship is Mafia 2 by Parmalee and Mintaka - March 16th 2012 ~ April 9th 2012

Twilight Mafia by Paperhorse - April 11th 2012 ~ April 23rd 2012

Catching Fire Mafia by PkmnHeartGold and PkmnSilver - April 7th 2012 ~ April 23rd 2012

Supernatural Mafia by Zenax - March 16th 2012 ~ April 24th 2012

Magic of Gardonia by Beck - April 6th 2012 ~ April 25th 2012

Looney Toons Mafia by Parmalee - April 25th 2012 ~ May 6th 2012

Pokemon Mystery Dungeon Mafia by PkmnHeartGold - April 28th 2012 ~ May 10th 2012

FUS RO MAFIA! - A Skyrim Mafia by PkmnFireRed - March 29th 2012 ~ May 10th 2012

Disgaea: Hour Of Darkness Mafia by Flonne - May 8th 2012 ~ May 14th 2012

Pokémon Ranger: Shadows of Almia Mafia by Hitomi - May 9th 2012 ~ May 29th 2012

The Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask Mafia by Feralize and PkmnSoulSilver - May 19th 2012 ~ May 27th 2012

Hydra Mafia by Zenax - May 16th 2012 ~ May 30th 2012

Town Vs. Mafia by Mintaka and J J M - May 22nd ~ June 2nd 2012


LIST OF COMPLETED NON-MAFIA GAMES
(August 21st, 2011 ~ June 3rd, 2012)


BMGf Indian (Card Game) by Mintaka - August 26th 2011 ~ September 2nd 2011

Death Note - The Game by ghaskan - August 25 2011 to October 1st 2011

War Room Mystery Murder by Hellion - November 4th 2011 to November 19th 2011

♦ CONSPIRACY ♠ by Master Mew - February 25th 2012 ~ March 8th 2012

TOTAL DRAMA-AS POKéMON! by The Hooded Claw - March 18th 2012 ~ April 19th 2012
 
Last edited:
Re: War Room Awards (2012)- Voting starts Mon, June 4th!

I'll edit this later.

Player Tier

- Best Town Performance
- Best Mafia Performance
- Best Independent Performance : Feralize and Baron Dante for their performance in hydra mafia
- Most Sportsmanlike Conduct
- Most Entertaining Player
- Most Strategic Player
- Most Promising Player

Team Tier

- Best Mafia Team Performance
- Best Town Team Performance

Host Tier

- Most Creative Host: Zenax for his Hydra mafia. Interesting concept with unique, seldom seen roles that made the game definitely interesting and fun to play.

- Most Entertaining Host: This was difficult to choose but I'll vote Zenax. He knows how to host a mafia game so that it's entertaining and enjoyable to all.
- Fair Hosting Award
- Best Flavor text: Hitomi for her Shadows of Almia mafia. She was ably to write thrilling and fun flavor text even if nothing remarkable happened during the phase that ended.
- Most Organized host
- Host of the Best Mafia Game
- Host of the Best Mafia Series JJM Jackie Chan series
- Host of the Best Non-Mafia Game
- Most Promising Host:Feralize.

The War Room Tier


- Best Contributor in the Situation Room
- Most Friendly user
- Most Committed User
 
Last edited:
Re: War Room Awards (2012)- Voting starts Mon, June 4th!

will also edit later when I've decided. also votes are subject to change.

Player Tier

- Best Town Performance: Paperhorse in Havendale Mafia 2
- Best Mafia Performance
- Best Independent Performance: Neonsands in Town vs Mafia.
- Most Sportsmanlike Conduct: Paperhorse
- Most Entertaining Player: Flonne
- Most Strategic Player: Zenax
- Most Promising Player: Joltik

Team Tier

- Best Mafia Team Performance
- Best Town Team Performance: Havendale Mafia 2

Host Tier

- Most Creative Host: Zenax for Hydra Mafia.
- Most Entertaining Host
- Fair Hosting Award
- Best Flavor text
- Most Organized host
- Host of the Best Mafia Game: Zenax for Havendale Mafia 2.
- Host of the Best Mafia Series: Zenax for Havendale Mafia.
- Host of the Best Non-Mafia Game
- Most Promising Host: Flonne

The War Room Tier

- Best Contributor in the Situation Room
- Most Friendly user
- Most Committed User
 
Last edited:
Re: War Room Awards (2012)- Voting starts Mon, June 4th!

Player Tier
- Best Town Performance: Flame_ in Havendale Mafia I. (too bad I killed him ;p)
- Best Mafia Performance: Zenax in Jackie Chan Adventures Mafia II.
- Best Independent Performance: TFSpock in Havendale Mafia II.
- Most Sportsmanlike Conduct: Paperhorse in Hydra Mafia.
- Most Entertaining Player: UM ER HM
- Most Strategic Player: Aestivate. No specific mafia game, really.
- Most Promising Player: In Soviet Russia. No specific game, either, I guess.

Team Tier
- Best Mafia Team Performance: Mafia team in Havendale Mafia I. (SERIOUSLY. DERIER44 AND ITERU WERE GREAT.)
- Best Town Team Performance: Town members in Havendale Mafia II.

Host Tier
- Most Creative Host: J J M for Jackie Chan Adventures Mafia (all three).
- Most Entertaining Host: NONE OF YOU ENTERTAIN ME
- Fair Hosting Award: I would like this award to go to anyone who has ever hosted a mafia game, with the exception of Feng (who hasn't hosted one in WR, though; BUT HE'S STILL SUPER BIASED). I would like to believe that anyone who has hosted a mafia game has hosted it fairly.
- Best Flavour Text: Paperhorse in LOST Mafia.
- Most Organised Host: SIGH
- Host of the Best Mafia Game: I LOVE YOU ALL. I COULDN'T PICK ONE.
- Host of the Best Mafia Series: Zenax for Havendale Mafia.
- Host of the Best Non-Mafia Game: um er lemme think :l
- Most Promising Host: UM

The War Room Tier
- Best Contributor in the Situation Room: Paperhorse.
- Most Friendly User: Croag.
- Most Committed User: PkmnFireRed.
 
Last edited:
Re: War Room Awards (2012)- Voting starts Mon, June 4th!

I'll edit in my votes.

Player Tier

- Best Town Performance
- Best Mafia Performance: Master Mew in Jackie Chan Adventures Mafia III
- Best Independent Performance
- Most Sportsmanlike Conduct
- Most Entertaining Player: Flonne
- Most Strategic Player
- Most Promising Player: Zenax

Team Tier

- Best Mafia Team Performance
- Best Town Team Performance

Host Tier

- Most Creative Host: J J M in Jackie Chan Adventures Mafia III
- Most Entertaining Host: Flonne
- Fair Hosting Award: Feralize
- Best Flavor text
- Most Organized host
- Host of the Best Mafia Game
- Host of the Best Mafia Series
- Host of the Best Non-Mafia Game
- Most Promising Host: Feralize

The War Room Tier

- Best Contributor in the Situation Room
- Most Friendly user: Shiny Celebi (PkmnSilver)
- Most Committed User
 
Last edited:
Re: War Room Awards (2012)- Voting starts Mon, June 4th!

Will edit in votes.

Player Tier

- Best Town Performance: Hitomi (Hydra Mafia)
- Best Mafia Performance:
- Best Independent Performance:
- Most Sportsmanlike Conduct: HilbertCressLover (Any game where shes vigkilled/killed Night 1)
- Most Entertaining Player: In Soviet Russia (Meme Mafia, The Situation Room, others)
- Most Strategic Player:
- Most Promising Player: FinalArcadia (Majora's Mask Mafia)

Team Tier

(Prizes that are won by multiple users for each.)

- Best Mafia Team Performance: Phoenix Wright Mafia (In Soviet Russia, The Puppetmaster, NfiNity, Exor)
- Best Town Team Performance: Shadows Of Almia Mafia

Host Tier

- Most Creative Host: Zenax (Hydra Mafia)
- Most Entertaining Host: Zenax (Hydra Mafia)
- Fair Hosting Award: Feralize (Pokemon Mystery Dungeon Mafia)
- Best Flavor text: Hitomi (Shadows Of Almia Mafia)
- Most Organized Host:
- Host of the Best Mafia Game: Feralize (Pokemon Mystery Dungeon Mafia)
- Host of the Best Mafia Series: J J M (Jackie Chan Series; just read them, and they looked amazing!)
- Host of the Best Non-Mafia Game:
- Most Promising Host: Feralize (Pokemon Mystery Dungeon Mafia, Majora's Mask Mafia)

The War Room Tier

(This category is more general, rather it refers to both players and hosts, and participants in the war room as a whole.)

- Best Contributor in the Situation Room:
- Most Friendly user: In Soviet Russia (The Situation Room, various)
- Most Committed User:
 
Last edited:
Re: War Room Awards (2012)- Voting starts Mon, June 4th!

Will Edit the rest in later

Player Tier

- Best Town Performance- Neonsands in TvM (I think it was him)
- Best Mafia Performance- Zenax in Yu-Gi-Oh 5Ds
- Best Independent Performance
- Most Sportsmanlike Conduct
- Most Entertaining Player
- Most Strategic Player- Zenax
- Most Promising Player- Flonne

Team Tier

(Prizes that are won by multiple users for each.)

- Best Mafia Team Performance
- Best Town Team Performance- Shadows of Almia (Mafia on Every Lynch and no Town lynchees :))

Host Tier

- Most Creative Host
- Most Entertaining Host
- Fair Hosting Award
- Best Flavor text- Hitomi Shadows of Almia
- Most Organized host
- Host of the Best Mafia Game
- Host of the Best Mafia Series- J J M JCA, The only game of a series I have been in.
- Host of the Best Non-Mafia Game
- Most Promising Host- Hitomi

The War Room Tier

(This category is more general, rather it refers to both players and hosts, and participants in the war room as a whole.)

- Best Contributor in the Situation Room-
- Most Friendly user- Paperhorse. For some reason all the friendlyness from you hasn't really been shown to me but you are still friendly. and the only one I could think of
- Most Committed User- Zenax
 
Last edited:
Re: War Room Awards (2012)- Voting starts Mon, June 4th!

Best Town Performance
- Best Mafia Performance-
- Best Independent Performance
- Most Sportsmanlike Conduct-Nytie
- Most Entertaining Player-Nfinity
- Most Strategic Player-
- Most Promising Player-Nfinity

Team Tier

- Best Mafia Team Performance-
- Best Town Team Performance-

Host Tier

- Most Creative Host
- Most Entertaining Host-Nytie
- Fair Hosting Award
- Best Flavor text-
- Most Organized host
- Host of the Best Mafia Game
- Host of the Best Mafia Series
- Host of the Best Non-Mafia Game
- Most Promising Host-Beck

The War Room Tier

- Best Contributor in the Situation Room
- Most Friendly user-Nytie
- Most Committed User-PkmnFireRed

I'll edit these later.
 
Last edited:
Re: War Room Awards (2012)- Voting starts Mon, June 4th!

Player Tier

- Best Town Performance: @Paperhorse; (Havendale Mafia 2) – She used a combination of strategy and insanity to figure out who was mafia (“He visited my profile, he must be mafia!1!!”) and was a vital part of the town in this game.
- Best Mafia Performance: @Sourcandy; (My Little Pony: Friendship is Mafia) - She always does a great job at playing mafia, and I thought here she really showed her skills.
- Best Independent Performance: @PichuBoy; (Havendale Mafia 2) – He almost managed to win this game until we convinced Buoy his lover was evil managed to vote him out, and he did a fantastic job fooling us all.
- Most Sportsmanlike Conduct: @Croag; – She always walks away from a game with a great attitude and even feels bad playing as mafia because she doesn’t like lying to people. xD
- Most Entertaining Player: @Buoy; – I don’t know what it is with this child, but everything he says makes me laugh.
- Most Strategic Player: @Aestivate; – She’s phenomenal at using logic, and she’s aggressive enough to where determining if she’s mafia or not is difficult, which usually works to her advantage.
- Most Promising Player: @Meron; – She hasn’t played in a while, but in her first few games, she did a wonderful job of helping the town win, such as in LOST Mafia (and she convinced The Man in Black to vote for me as the last mafia member in Supernatural Mafia >:I).

Team Tier

- Best Mafia Team Performance:
- Best Town Team Performance: Havendale Mafia 2 – I thought we worked well as a team here and had a lot of fun within our alliance. We also won in the end, but working with crazy teammates was far more rewarding. xD

Host Tier

- Most Creative Host: @Ryuutakeshi; (Falconwing Mafia 3) – Everything in this game originated from this child’s head. I don’t know how much more creative you can get than that. :p
- Most Entertaining Host: @Aestivate; (Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Mafia) – She was really into the theme and had a lot of fun with it, especially when writing the flavor text whenever her favorite characters died (which was probably more painful than fun actually).
- Fair Hosting Award: @Zenax; (Supernatural Mafia) – Even if I asked him to not make me anybody important and he made me mafia anyway (>:I), he did a good job of balancing the roles, which is proven by how close the win between town and mafia was in the end.
- Best Flavor text: @Paperhorse; & @The Man In Black; (LOST Mafia) – They included hints in the flavor text to help both sides, which aided the town in winning (even if I was the only one who read it…and because Paperhorse scolded me for saying I didn’t…xD).
- Most Organized Host: @Rayne*; & @Parmalee; [ineligible] (My Little Pony: Friendship is Mafia) – Both hosts updated on time every phase and were very clear about each role’s power, allowing the game to run smoothly.
- Host of the Best Mafia Game: @Zenax; (Havendale Mafia 2) – There’s a reason most of my nominations spur from this game. I have to say this is one of the best games I’ve played in The War Room because both my alliances and the mechanics of the game were enjoyable.
- Host of the Best Mafia Series: @J J M; (Jackie Chan Adventures Mafia) – I only played in his first game for a little bit because school worked enraptured me, but the concepts were creative and interesting, and I’ve heard many good things about the sequels from friends who played in them.
- Host of the Best Non-Mafia Game:
- Most Promising Host: @Zenax; Both his games I played were interesting, fun, and fair. I signed up for some games just because he was hosting them (even if I was buried in school work :p).

The War Room Tier

- Best Contributor in the Situation Room: @Hitomi; – She brings a playful attitude and has a nice presence in the thread.
- Most Friendly user: @Paperhorse; – She has a genuine concern for all players and does her best to make sure everyone’s having fun.
- Most Committed User: @Neonsands; jl;afjdofds THIS ONE IS SO HARD TO PICK. I decided to go with Neonsands because he loves playing, and he even mentioned once he feels obligated to join all games taking sign ups.

Will edit in the rest later.
 
Last edited:
Re: War Room Awards (2012)- Voting starts Mon, June 4th!

I'll edit this gradually.

Player Tier

- Best Town Performance- Paperhorse in Havendale 2 Mafia
- Best Mafia Performance- Zenax in 5Ds
- Best Independent Performance- @Feralize and @Baron Dante in Hydra Mafia
- Most Sportsmanlike Conduct
- Most Entertaining Player
- Most Strategic Player- @Sourcandy in most mafias I've been in with her.
- Most Promising Player- @Russia* You just recently joined and have been a great player as town, especially in PMD Mafia.

Team Tier

(Prizes that are won by multiple users for each.)

- Best Mafia Team Performance: Family Guy Mafia for a flawless victory and abusing my roles xD
- Best Town Team Performance: Havendale II Mafia (The town quickly united and everyone worked together very well to pick apart mafia and in the end PichuBoy)

Host Tier

- Most Creative Host- Zenax for Havendale series. He made up everything for this game himself, which is amazing.
- Most Entertaining Host- @The Puppetmaster and Paperhorse for hiding hilarious innuendos in role PMs xD
- Fair Hosting Award
- Best Flavor text- Zenax in Hydra Mafia (The flavor text was very entertaining, though I sadly wasn't the most active in this one.)
- Most Organized host
- Host of the Best Mafia Game- @Nytie for 5Ds Mafia. I loved this game, even if there were a few too many mafia roles.
- Host of the Best Mafia Series- Tough choice, but @J J M for Jackie Chan series. Havendale series is a close second.
- Host of the Best Non-Mafia Game- [MENTION]Hellion[/MENTION] for the War Room Mystery, even though he's not eligible.
- Most Promising Host- Flonne from Disgaea Mafia. (The roles were great and the game was entertaining, we just got extremely lucky as town.)

The War Room Tier

(This category is more general, rather it refers to both players and hosts, and participants in the war room as a whole.)

- Best Contributor in the Situation Room
- Most Friendly user- Paperhorse, she's always friendly and recently got me into Skype xD
- Most Committed User- Sourcandy, as long as I've been here, Sourcandy has been active and always contributes to most games she's in.
 
Last edited:
Re: War Room Awards (2012)- Voting starts Mon, June 4th!

Thanks for the votes, guys. Just a reminder, you may edit votes as long as it's during the voting period. :)

Also, please only post if you have at least one category with a nonimation. You may enter in others later but a post with no nominations could very well just be posted later with some. Nominations are not judged depending on the order we read them so reserving posts is not necessary.
 
Re: War Room Awards (2012)- Voting starts Mon, June 4th!

I have to go through all of the old games again, so this is subject to change, but I'll keep editing it :p

NONE OF THIS IS SET IN STONE; MY MIND WILL PROBABLY KEEP CHANGING.

SERIOUSLY DO NOT TAKE ANY OF THESE NOMINATIONS IN GRANITE UNTIL THE VERY LAST DAY LOL


Categories

Player Tier

- Best Town Performance - Paperhorse in Havendale 2. Legit. And I quote, "HE VISITED MY USER PROFILE PAGE! HE MUST BE MAFIA!"
She was right.
- Best Mafia Performance - Zenax in 5D's
- Best Independent Performance - Mijzelffan in JCA3
- Most Sportsmanlike Conduct - The Puppetmaster - no one is more gracious in defeat or humble in a victory
- Most Entertaining Player - Buoy
- Most Strategic Player - Sourcandy. 2 quirky 4 me
- Most Promising Player - Final Arcadia

Team Tier

(Prizes that are won by multiple users for each.)

- Best Mafia Team Performance - all of the games that I think were best played by mafia I've played in, hurr - the Mafia team in Drumbeats' Family Guy Mafia leading to an utterly flawless mafia victory with Sourcandy's death + revival and the clever use of Laterose's role to kill + revive Flame all as mafia. Our numbers grew and we didn't lose anyone, so we ended up having two more mafia players plus an ally in Zenax.
- Best Town Team Performance - all of the games that I think were best played by town I've played in, hurrr - havendale 2 town

Host Tier

- Most Creative Host - JJM srsly hao doez 1 shot web with all of the twists and turns he adds to his mafia games
- Most Entertaining Host - Drumbeats - his roles are always new and exciting and often through a really fun curveball to the players.
- Fair Hosting Award -
- Best Flavor text -
- Most Organized host - Feralize
- Host of the Best Mafia Game - Ryuutakeshi (Falconwing 3 still stands out as a sore thumb in my mind as being one of the best games I've ever played)
- Host of the Best Mafia Series - JJM
- Host of the Best Non-Mafia Game
- Most Promising Host - Hitomi - she hasn't been around in the WR for all of that long but her games that she's hosted have been utterly impeccable.

The War Room Tier

(This category is more general, rather it refers to both players and hosts, and participants in the war room as a whole.)

- Best Contributor in the Situation Room
- Most Friendly user
- Most Committed User
 
Last edited:
Re: War Room Awards (2012)- Voting starts Mon, June 4th!

Will edit all of the other nominations in when I think of someone.

Player Tier
- Best Town Performance:
- Best Mafia Performance: @Ryuutakeshi in Christmas Mafia. 'Nuff said.
- Best Independent Performance: @Neonsands in TvM Mafia. Even though he wasn't allied with the Town, he single-handedly rallied them all by getting their trust and collecting all the roleclaims and then working out who was mafia and who wasn't. Even when he wasn't sure of them, using the different players' roles, he checked multiple suspicious people simultaneously so as to weed the mafioso out as quickly as possible. Really, the mafia didn't stand a chance.
- Most Sportsmanlike Conduct: @Paperhorse in general. She's always supporting all the other players and acts nice to everyone. And if she had made a wrong decision (which happens rarely xD), she always says sorry which is completely unnecessary but it's still a very sweet thing to do. ^^
- Most Entertaining Player:
- Most Strategic Player: @Neonsands in general.
- Most Promising Player:

Team Tier
- Best Mafia Team Performance:
- Best Town Team Performance:

Host Tier
- Most Creative Host: @PkmnFireRed; in general. Seriously, how do you come up with those crazy abilities and mechanics for every role? Whenever I try to come up with a fitting ability for a role, it's really difficult but you come up with seemingly random and yet so awesome ones and make it seem easy. I would love to be able to come up with roles like yours. ;_;
- Most Entertaining Host:
- Fair Hosting Award:
- Best Flavour Text:
- Most Organised Host: @Rayne* & @Parmalee for My Little Pony: Friendship is Mafia. Seriously there was so many random roles and role mechanics (how could anyone keep track of Pinkie Pie's many "abilities"?) but they were prepared for everything. They had an idea of what each and every role does way before the game started and didn't come up with it on the fly during the game.
- Host of the Best Mafia Game:
- Host of the Best Mafia Series: @Zenax for Havendale Mafia.
- Host of the Best Non-Mafia Game: @ghaskan for Death Note.
- Most Promising Host: @Hitomi. While I haven't played in any of her games, based on everyone's opinions and the few bits I've read of the flavor text and roles, she does a pretty good job with the role abilities and flavor text. The fact that she isn't a veteran to the section makes it all the more impressive.

The War Room Tier
- Best Contributor in the Situation Room:
- Most Friendly User:
- Most Committed User: This was a tough category since pretty much everyone's so committed. But if I had to pick, it'll be @Flonne. Since she's almost always active and she is in the running for becoming the official vote tallier for the section. xD Seriously, what would hosts do without her service. ;_;
 
Last edited:
Re: War Room Awards (2012)- Voting starts Mon, June 4th!

Player Tier

- Best Town Performance:
- Best Mafia Performance:
- Best Independent Performance:
- Most Sportsmanlike Conduct:
- Most Entertaining Player:
- Most Strategic Player:
- Most Promising Player:

Team Tier

- Best Mafia Team Performance:
- Best Town Team Performance:

Host Tier

- Most Creative Host: Ryuutakeshi for the Falconwing Mafia series
- Most Entertaining Host:
- Fair Hosting Award:
- Best Flavor text: Ryuutakeshi
- Most Organized host:
- Host of the Best Mafia Game:Aestivate for Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Mafia
- Host of the Best Mafia Series: Zenax for Havendale Mafia series
- Host of the Best Non-Mafia Game:
- Most Promising Host:Feralize

The War Room Tier

- Best Contributor in the Situation Room:
- Most Friendly user:
- Most Committed User:

I'll edit in more votes later.
 
Last edited:
Re: War Room Awards (2012)- Place your votes!

As Mintaka pointed out earlier, DO NOT reserve posts with no nominations on it, as it is unnecessary. You may have a post with at least one nomination on it, and edit it in your others later, but posts with no nominations is unacceptable. This is your last warning.
 
Re: War Room Awards (2012)- Place your votes!

Player Tier

- Best Town Performance - Hitomi and Mr. Fahrenheit in Hydra mafia (they were one entity). They really did a great job as town leaders, sniffing out the mafia, but they caught the arsonist just one phase too late.
- Best Mafia Performance -
- Best Independent Performance -
- Most Sportsmanlike Conduct - Paperhorse. She never shows distaste when killed, she's always respectful even to regular users, and she's so cheerful.
- Most Entertaining Player - Buoy. We've had our moments of disagreement, but in the end we can get along. And he's hilarious.
- Most Strategic Player - Zenax. Probably the most skilled at catching mafia of us all.
- Most Promising Player - FinalArcadia. Still learning, but she catches on quickly and is constantly learning new skills to become a more effective player.

Team Tier

(Prizes that are won by multiple users for each.)

- Best Mafia Team Performance
- Best Town Team Performance - Shadows of Almia Mafia. Sure, some inactives won, but most of the town did put in a great deal of effort and we even got the last mafioso to surrender :D

Host Tier

- Most Creative Host - Zenax for Hydra Mafia.
- Most Entertaining Host
- Fair Hosting Award
- Best Flavor text - Hitomi for her Pokemon Ranger games.
- Most Organized host - Lavender Frost. Since she taught me to host, her organizational skills really impacted me. There is never confusion when she hosts. Everything has always been kept orderly and explained thoroughly.
- Host of the Best Mafia Game
- Host of the Best Mafia Series - Hitomi's Pokemon Ranger series.
- Host of the Best Non-Mafia Game
- Most Promising Host - Russia*. I thoroughly enjoyed Disgaea Mafia despite the mafia's utter failure xD

The War Room Tier

(This category is more general, rather it refers to both players and hosts, and participants in the war room as a whole.)

- Best Contributor in the Situation Room - Russia*. She always livens up conversations and even has to drag her off-topicness from games to there xD it's never a dull day when she's around.
- Most Friendly user -
- Most Committed User - Drum Beats. He's never inactive, and truly gives every game his all.
 
Last edited:
Re: War Room Awards (2012)- Place your votes!

Player Tier

- Best Town Performance:Aestivate in 5D's
- Best Mafia Performance:Zenax in 5D's
- Best Independent Performance
- Most Sportsmanlike Conduct:
- Most Entertaining Player:Nytie
- Most Strategic Player:Zenax no game in specific
- Most Promising Player

Team Tier

(Prizes that are won by multiple users for each.)

- Best Mafia Team Performance:5D's mafia
- Best Town Team Performance:pokemon Ranger Shadows of Almia mafia.

Host Tier

- Most Creative Host:Zenax Hydra mafia
- Most Entertaining Host:Nytie
- Fair Hosting Award
- Best Flavor text:Zenax Hydra mafia Seroiusly,a Blue Eyes Ultimite Dragon juggling chainsaws?
- Most Organized host
- Host of the Best Mafia Game:Hitomi for GS mafia
- Host of the Best Mafia Series:Hitomi for Pokemon Ranger mafias
- Host of the Best Non-Mafia Game:ghaskan for Death Note
- Most Promising Host:Hitomi

The War Room Tier

(This category is more general, rather it refers to both players and hosts, and participants in the war room as a whole.)

- Best Contributor in the Situation Room:
- Most Friendly user
- Most Committed User:paperhorse

Also you forgot Minority Rule on the list of games.
 
Last edited:
Re: War Room Awards (2012)- Place your votes!

Most Strategic Player definitely has to be Hellion.

And the rest, I dunno.
 
Re: War Room Awards (2012)- Place your votes!

I've only played two games thus far, but since I got the mention, I figured I really should contribute at least a little in the voting here. ^_^

And I've been nominated? I'm honestly (pleasantly) surprised... Thanks!

Player Tier

- Best Town Performance
- Best Mafia Performance
- Best Independent Performance
- Most Sportsmanlike Conduct - Flonne, for continuing to contribute even while being silenced (through the liking of posts), and for always seeming to be friendly and helpful.
- Most Entertaining Player - Zenax, since his interrogations of other players and amazing talent for analyzing the game was entertaining to me even before I joined a game.
- Most Strategic Player - Zenax, because even before I started playing in the War Room, I saw his strategies in other games, and he always seems so on-top of what is going on, and getting to the bottom of things that don't quite add up.
- Most Promising Player - In Soviet Russia, because she seemed to have a very interesting play style (even though I mistook you for mafia, sorry!) that I'm interested to see in the future.

Team Tier

(Prizes that are won by multiple users for each.)

- Best Mafia Team Performance
- Best Town Team Performance

Host Tier

- Most Creative Host
- Most Entertaining Host
- Fair Hosting Award
- Best Flavor text
- Most Organized host
- Host of the Best Mafia Game
- Host of the Best Mafia Series
- Host of the Best Non-Mafia Game
- Most Promising Host

The War Room Tier

(This category is more general, rather it refers to both players and hosts, and participants in the war room as a whole.)

- Best Contributor in the Situation Room
- Most Friendly user
- Most Committed User
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom