Whispers In The Dark by Skillet, quickly followed by Awake and Alive.
The Best of Atreyu, currently at "Lip Gloss & Black".
I can't believe I bought this album on a whim like this. I haven't heard a single song by Atreyu front-to-back, and all I know of them is previews on iTunes and Allmusic.
I lucked out this time, though. I dig.