Mafia World's Smallest Mafia - Endgame - 5/11/19

[Isaac the Investigator]

I think it was pretty unfair how checking Kyriaki showed as Mafia, especially as you gave her no indication that that would happen

However, I think having a Cop in this setup in general is unbalanced, as if Kyriaki had shown up as town, then Mafia would have been screwed

 

[ExLight]

Yikes. GG.

I personally think that the "Non-town" result would've been more appropriate since there was no indication of a Miller-esque passive to her role PM as well. Hyper Majority also didn't really leave space for discussion of the possibility of her not being scum.

Just some feedback, since this was the first game you hosted iirc: it needed a little more organization and details. The role PMs were kinda lackluster and there wasn't much patience while explaining some stuff to some of the newer players. I kinda wondered at some point if you'd had given a larger game the same treatment.

I hope this was a useful game for you to learn a few things about being a host, and I also look forward to see you hosting more games soon.

 

[Contrainer]

I didn't know what to do
TBH I just read MafiaWiki and misinterpreted it

 

[heretoplaymafia]

setup is kinda wonky and random, ngl

hosting was alright it did have the problems of miscommunication though and from personal experience survivor usually flipped as town so thats that

town was very passive d1, are towns always this passive here

regardless it was a learning experience for both me and the host

 

[ExLight]

town was very passive d1, are towns always this passive here

From what I've seen depends a lot of the players involved.
I've been in, uuh, 4 mafias? And in some they were really aggressive and in some they were really passive.

 

[Isaac the Investigator]

town was very passive d1, are towns always this passive here

Towns here tend to not do much early on, they typically wait for night results

 

[heretoplaymafia]

Towns here tend to not do much early on, they typically wait for night results

that kinda sucks