Would you rather catch...

[toastghost]

ditto, eternatus is way overdesigned

wailord or cetitan

 

[helperman]

i think cetitan?

eternamax eternatus or origin form giratina

 

[toastghost]

origin form giratina, eternamax eternatus looks silly, not in the good way

suicune or vaporeon

 

[guzmania]

suicune, johto mon make me feel nostalgic in a way i can't describe (and hell, i didn't even grow up with johto)

gardevoir or gallade?

 

[BigDocFan]

Gallade

Slugma or Growlithe?

 

[Chidamari Sketch]

Slugma.

Torterra or Great Tusk

 

[guzmania]

great tusk

moltres or ho-oh

 

[Pigrider09]

Moltres bien

Ferroseed or scizor?

 

[toastghost]

scizor

skarmory or celesteela

 

[guzmania]

scizor
oh great i get ninja'd and then my internet blips out. skarmory

raticate or maushold

 

[Coolsteph]

Raticate. Raticate may be too simple and uninspired, but Maushold looks like a Sanrio character and is a little disturbing.

Terakion or Heatran?

 

[Chidamari Sketch]

Heatran. It's not very characteristic of me to choose something from Gen 4 over Gen 5 but I just resent Terrakion and the entire Legendary group it's associated with.

Crawdaunt or Sharpedo.

 

[guzmania]

Sharpedo for sure

Quagsire or Clodsire?

 

[Pigrider09]

Giggity!

Meowth or Meowstic (either form)

 

[KerfishSea]

Meowstic (Female)
It just looks cuter. and has a better shiny

Pawmo or Morpeko

 

[guzmania]

pawmo. it shall eventually be pawmot which is scientifically proven to be the third best pikaclone (fourth if you count mimikyu)

rhyperior, magmortar, or electivire?

 

[helperman]

Magmortar

Darkrai or yveltal

 

[KOT0NE]

darkrai !!!dreams r cool 2 think about so the concept is veeery interesting 2 me

espeon or umbreon

 

[Die-Hard Dragon Devotee]

Umbreon. I almost always prefer Dark types over Psychic types.

Feraligatr or Krookodile?

 

[KerfishSea]

Krookodile

I love Feraligatr but Krookodile looks way cooler. I've used it a few times its amazing ..I dont like its shiny tho.