Mafia One Piece: Alabasta Mafia - ENDGAME - Baroque Works Win!!!

[Snowy]

Re: One Piece: Alabasta Mafia - Day 2: Over-doped

Spoiler

well, that was unexpected.
this is why I didn't vote for him. I had a gut feeling he would be a straw hat.

Not a bad read, but not sure if it's worthy of a vote. Got anything else to back this up?[/QUOTE]

His self-vote from Day 1 has him on my radar since then.

 

[Feenie]

Re: One Piece: Alabasta Mafia - Day 2: Over-doped

Human brings up a good point about the vanilla thing.

VOTE: Flopunny.

I can always take my vote off when/if Flopunny comes in with a defense, but right now this'll do.

Was very quick to point out that he didn't vote for Poke Man due to his "gut feeling". Trying to look town.

I don't see how that would try to make him look more town. Since we're all in the same boat as far as not knowing who is on what side, regardless of alignment, it's hard to win points for "looking town" there.

 

[CrackFox]

Re: One Piece: Alabasta Mafia - Day 2: Over-doped

Gonna hold off voting just yet. I would like to hear more from Flop though. I think it's very possible there are vanillas in the game so him soft claiming to be one is not worrying to me. Roles aren't everything. Flop is a good contributer and it would be a shame to lose him just because he doesn't have an active role. I'm a bit confused as to why Pyanda was chosen as the target? Maybe the mafia killer last night took lovandra's advice/opinion, whatever it was that they were allied with the town.

If lovandra really is allied with the mafia she helped to kill one of her own team there.

 

[Doctor Floptopus]

Re: One Piece: Alabasta Mafia - Day 2: Over-doped

So...
As far as I understand, you're voting me because you all assume I'm vanilla and I made a wrong assumption?
I guess it's probably for the best for me to confirm that I am in fact a vanilla. The way my role was worded made me assume I was vanilla, clearly I was mistaken.
As for being quiet, it's my 2nd week back in school so I'm swamped with homework.
I can safely guess that approximately 50% of my voters are my enemy.
I will Vote: jokool since I'm pretty sure he's not my alignment.

 

[ReturnofMCH]

Re: One Piece: Alabasta Mafia - Day 2: Over-doped

um... @AussieEevee; you do realize my first post was a joke vote, right?
I had a gut feeling he's town because I just did, I always have gut feelings first, irl, I react then think, it's how I roll IRL and in forums.

 

[Snowy]

Re: One Piece: Alabasta Mafia - Day 2: Over-doped

Was very quick to point out that he didn't vote for Poke Man due to his "gut feeling". Trying to look town.

I don't see how that would try to make him look more town. Since we're all in the same boat as far as not knowing who is on what side, regardless of alignment, it's hard to win points for "looking town" there.

Read what his post says again then.

 

[Snowy]

Re: One Piece: Alabasta Mafia - Day 2: Over-doped

Just looking back over everything, I think we have heard from everyone at least once except @Midorikawa;. Thoughts?

 

[HumanDawn]

Re: One Piece: Alabasta Mafia - Day 2: Over-doped

So...
As far as I understand, you're voting me because you all assume I'm vanilla and I made a wrong assumption?
I guess it's probably for the best for me to confirm that I am in fact a vanilla. The way my role was worded made me assume I was vanilla, clearly I was mistaken.
As for being quiet, it's my 2nd week back in school so I'm swamped with homework.
I can safely guess that approximately 50% of my voters are my enemy.
I will Vote: jokool since I'm pretty sure he's not my alignment.

I'm voting you because I assumed you were Vanilla due to your wrong assumption that this was a Vanilla game, which makes you the safest lynch in my eyes. So wait are you Vanilla or not? If you thought your role was Vanilla how did you assume wrong?

What do you think is jokool's alignment?

 

[ReturnofMCH]

Re: One Piece: Alabasta Mafia - Day 2: Over-doped

Was very quick to point out that he didn't vote for Poke Man due to his "gut feeling". Trying to look town.

I don't see how that would try to make him look more town. Since we're all in the same boat as far as not knowing who is on what side, regardless of alignment, it's hard to win points for "looking town" there.

Read what his post says again then.

how does Having a reactionary feeling make me scummy?

 

[Zexy]

Re: One Piece: Alabasta Mafia - Day 2: Over-doped

Well, @Flopunny; what Human said.
Are you vanilla or not? I don't get when you were mistaken and about what so I am still confused.
Also, are you SURE that jokool is the opposite alignment for some reason?
Same question goes to @FinalArcadia; were you SURE that Flop is the opposite alignment when you decided to go after her as the very first vote?

 

[FinalArcadia]

Re: One Piece: Alabasta Mafia - Day 2: Over-doped

Same question goes to @FinalArcadia; were you SURE that Flop is the opposite alignment when you decided to go after her as the very first vote?

I'm not sure at all actually. Flopunny's posts have left me with not much indication of alignment one way or another.

I figured that since we're back into even numbers between the two sides, might as well take a shot in the dark here, especially if they're only a vanilla. Plus, we hadn't heard much from Flopunny and I thought this could lead to more, which in turn could help figuring out Flop's alignment. Though as of now, I still don't have much clue as to Flopunny's alignment from the response they gave, but I am trying to figure out how to interpret the vote on jokool.

 

[Doctor Floptopus]

Re: One Piece: Alabasta Mafia - Day 2: Over-doped

So wait are you Vanilla or not? If you thought your role was Vanilla how did you assume wrong?

What do you think is jokool's alignment?

Oh DAMN what I meant to say there was that my PM made me assume it was a vanilla game.

I'm being deliberately ambiguous about my alignment, so I won't tell you which alignment I think jokool is either.
@Zexy; I would say I'm about 72.3% sure that jokool is the killer not on my team.

 

[Snowy]

Re: One Piece: Alabasta Mafia - Day 2: Over-doped

Was very quick to point out that he didn't vote for Poke Man due to his "gut feeling". Trying to look town.

I don't see how that would try to make him look more town. Since we're all in the same boat as far as not knowing who is on what side, regardless of alignment, it's hard to win points for "looking town" there.

Read what his post says again then.

how does Having a reactionary feeling make me scummy?

You were quite quick to point out that you weren't involved in the lynch.

 

[Flashranite]

Re: One Piece: Alabasta Mafia - Night 1: Cloudy & Overcast in Alabasta

Well, that's interesting. Town lynches town, so mafia NKs mafia... that makes us even again.

what makes you so sure that it was the Boroque Works kill that succeeded and not a Straw Hats kill?

 

[ReturnofMCH]

Re: One Piece: Alabasta Mafia - Day 2: Over-doped

that doesn't make me scummy either, as I just said I didn't vote for him, how quick I was doesn't matter.

 

[Snowy]

Re: One Piece: Alabasta Mafia - Night 1: Cloudy & Overcast in Alabasta

Well, that's interesting. Town lynches town, so mafia NKs mafia... that makes us even again.

what makes you so sure that it was the Boroque Works kill that succeeded and not a Straw Hats kill?

I assume you mean a vigilante? I suppose that is entirely possible. But that would mean that the doctor successfully protected the nightkill target.

 

[Flashranite]

Re: One Piece: Alabasta Mafia - Night 1: Cloudy & Overcast in Alabasta

Well, that's interesting. Town lynches town, so mafia NKs mafia... that makes us even again.

what makes you so sure that it was the Boroque Works kill that succeeded and not a Straw Hats kill?

I assume you mean a vigilante? I suppose that is entirely possible. But that would mean that the doctor successfully protected the nightkill target.

yeah, that is what I was meaning (regarding vig)

so, you think there is a doctor along with the enchantress?

 

[Snowy]

Re: One Piece: Alabasta Mafia - Night 1: Cloudy & Overcast in Alabasta

Well, that's interesting. Town lynches town, so mafia NKs mafia... that makes us even again.

what makes you so sure that it was the Boroque Works kill that succeeded and not a Straw Hats kill?

I assume you mean a vigilante? I suppose that is entirely possible. But that would mean that the doctor successfully protected the nightkill target.

yeah, that is what I was meaning (regarding vig)

so, you think there is a doctor along with the enchantress?

I would assume so, but I don't know. There was only one kill last night, and if you are right about the vig, then what happened to the NK? Logic points me to it being blocked by a doctor or similar role.

 

[Flashranite]

Re: One Piece: Alabasta Mafia - Night 1: Cloudy & Overcast in Alabasta

Well, that's interesting. Town lynches town, so mafia NKs mafia... that makes us even again.

what makes you so sure that it was the Boroque Works kill that succeeded and not a Straw Hats kill?

I assume you mean a vigilante? I suppose that is entirely possible. But that would mean that the doctor successfully protected the nightkill target.

yeah, that is what I was meaning (regarding vig)

so, you think there is a doctor along with the enchantress?

I would assume so, but I don't know. There was only one kill last night, and if you are right about the vig, then what happened to the NK? Logic points me to it being blocked by a doctor or similar role.

I think the set up is balanced, as in, both sides have equal amounts of power, overall. So, having a vig makes most sense to me. I am not sure if having 4 protective roles against kills would make things very interesting, so, I was actually thinking more that there must have been a roleblock or something, on one of the 2 killing roles.

 

[Snowy]

Re: One Piece: Alabasta Mafia - Night 1: Cloudy & Overcast in Alabasta

I think the set up is balanced, as in, both sides have equal amounts of power, overall. So, having a vig makes most sense to me. I am not sure if having 4 protective roles against kills would make things very interesting, so, I was actually thinking more that there must have been a roleblock or something, on one of the 2 killing roles.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but roleblocks don't effect the NK, do they? Or am i misunderstanding?