Nightwing101
Member
- Joined
- May 16, 2017
- Messages
- 265
- Reaction score
- 92
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Joke vote. NAIDidn’t work for me too...weird.
VOTE: Jinjo
I like this one. IT has a good point, and is productive.This is one of these "I don't like it but it's useful" posts, which doesn't end up making sense in the end. Also didn't like how you had to point out how voting the host is unproductive. Sure it is unproductive but almost everything isn't really productive in D1, and a vote like that is harmless.
Unvote: Jinjo
Vote: swarla
Nothing wrong with this. Solid opinions, and elaboration.H-how did you know?!
I just wanted to see your reaction and see if you would get defensive. That would have been great but...your reaction is so passive and genuine :C The game was full of joke posts, so I wanted to make things serious, even if I didn’t have the greatest logic
No...what? I meant that swarla says “I don’t like joke votes but they provoke reactions” which to me, reactions are useful since it’s the only thing we have for D1. Not the host thing. I still stand by my point that although voting the host is unproductive there’s no need to point it out, especially when it’s obviously a joke vote.
You are right about two things though...I was trying too hard to get actual serious conversation and looking back, Swarla really wasn’t trying to throw any shade of suspicion against Nightwing. Also liked their reply.
Unvote: swarla
100% agree, felt the same way.
Good points.I’m not really liking Feenie at the moment...
Well you said it yourself that my vote was random, so it’s obviously a joke vote.
I don’t quite get your logic here. Do you think scum would prompt you to vote for them?
Why are you focusing on me so much? You mentioned Seth’s vote on Jinjo at least 3 times now. I find it strange how you are completely avoiding talking about how Midorikawa random voted HumanDawn. We did literally the same thing. Also really dislike your vote on Max here
You also have Nightwing voting for the host, which if I recall correctly you said you didn’t like. Kind of gave him a pass though.
And of course your main point about CheffOfGames, which wasn’t really a bad one, I also didn’t like how he had to mention “hey look! I’m Town everyone!”. Still, you abandoned this idea pretty quickly.
Impatient.@Midorikawa the day phase is going to end soon and not only are you still sticking with the HD joke vote, but you also disappeared.
@Rainbow Cloud you’ve been awfully quiet this game
Seth sees no problem with it
I was going to wait Feenie respond to what I said but it’s been a while and she still hasn’t responded. Therefore, I shall
Vote: Feenie
Quite a bit of helping and defending Max. Mafia could do this to make themselves look better with the defense "hey I'm town because I'm protecting town." Granted that's not enough reason to say something is wrong.I don’t think Max is scum...I’m using meta here but having played with him as scum recently, his scum persona is way too different.
I really didn’t like the OMGUS tho...
So Max, let’s say HD voted you with flimsy reasoning. You just did the same thing.
I’m going to assume Max is an independent for now. Max can you try to defend yourself better? What did you find about HD suspicious and how is it flimsy reasoning?
I liked Midorikawa’s post, but it’s not enough to make any judgements for now.
And finally, although My suspicions against Feenie aren’t 100% gone, I think it’s better to keep her alive for now.
Unvote: Feenie
Need to say something else. Officer Snake doesn’t speak at all. You know Red in the Pokémon video games? “...” Yep, that’s him. That’s dangerous, even if he’s town. Keep an eye out for him.
An "I told you so" and a martyr comment. This is so fake and hypocritical. He hardly did anything to truly help Max, and the whole acknowledging that he didn't is so fake. It's also unnecessary since it comes after an "I told you so." There are ways to do it that are genuine, but his isn't.RIP Max. I knew it.
That said, I made a mistake too, should have voted someone.
I also felt Nightwing's posts were kind of iffy, but she questioned all of you. That's something productive. Something necessary too.
HumanDawn, Midorikawa and Feenie. You all got some explaining to do.
Feenie started the Max wagon, with an OMGUS too. Voted Max for questioning her. How did I miss this?!
HumanDawn, your reasoning for voting Max is very weak. You voted him because he was avoidant, yet he asked which question to disregard. You didn't like the fact he didn't answer both questions.
And of course Midorikawa...joke votes in the beginning of the day, doesn't appear until much later almost at the end of the day, votes Max because of OMGUS on HD, but ignores Feenie's OMGUS on Max. Amazing. You said Max and CheffOfGames were buddy-buddy? I see more buddy-buddy in you and Feenie.
Let's see if that's true. Tomorrow either you or Feenie have my vote.
swarla is the towniest right now.
No because mafia never are.True, true...what an easy target, am I right?
Oh look he changed on Nightwing again. Funny considering his previous post called her productive. Saying what she did was needed is calling her productive, and yet now she isn't. And now it's question instead of questions. He just keeps changing on her.I already explained this. It was Day 1, and some time had passed. No actual good posts have been made. I tried to find something to kick off the “serious” phase. So you can see how my arguments weren’t really all that good, since all we had then was the joke votes.
You misunderstood me. I did not say Nightwing’s Day 1 posts were productive. They weren’t. But in N1 she asked you, Midorikawa and Feenie what were your thoughts on the myslynch. THAT’s what was necessary.
What is there to say? He already replied to you. I can’t keep track of them all. Besides, I don’t recall you answering Nightwing’s question either.
You guys should lay off HD for now at least. Feenie and Midorikawa are much more alarming. HD at least had a reason to vote for him, though it was weak. While the other two:
Midorikawa: votes Max for OMGUS, but ignores Feenie’s OMGUS on Max, speaking of which...
Feenie: OMGUS on Max, her reason being “he questioned me”
More comments on inactivity. Yet he doesn't talk about snake despite mentioning him earlier.Not sure I like this HD...there are like 4+ potential scum lurkers. Why jd?
Rainbow Cloud is also experienced and they haven’t posted much.
Heck, where did CheffOfGames go?
THERE IT IS!!! The magic words mafia love to use to look more town. "I said this." "I said this so you can't say this." It's scummy with no point. It has no conviction and is just fake.I did say I made a mistake in not voting. I also said in D1 that l do not think Max is scum.
Why not state what was your reason for voting Max then? Because it looks like an OMGUS to me. You said his questions AND his vote bothered you, because they almost prompt you to vote for him. (Which wasn’t the case)
Look mentions jd. Not snake or any other inactive though.If there isn’t anything to gain, why did you quote me and say “you didn’t answer me here”
After re-reading your post...that’s fair enough HD. ~Half of the players are inactive which really doesn’t help. He is probably going to reply though, @jdthebud any thoughts?
Vote: Feenie
NOthing wrong here.Catching up on the thread right now, since you went ahead and claimed Feenie, do you know for sure if dragon/demon/god figure are the mafia in this game?
Unvote: Feenie
EDIT: NEVERMIND, so you are the flying pumpkin who shoots lasers out of its ass. (This is an actual role in mafia)
Again with mentioning inactives. Finally brings up our newbie Renato, but again no snake.@Renato_Sinclair you too Renato, it would be really helpful if you posted your reads here. Who do you think is town? Who do you think is mafia?
@CheffOfGames can I get your thoughts on what has been happening recently ?
Well he didn't make it obvious that he suspected Human, but after Max died he did make his opinions on me and Feenie clear. So that part is fine.I believe Mido when she says that someone roleblocked her. Tbh I’m glad to know that I’m getting more towny vibes from my 3 original suspects. (HD Feenie and Midorikawa) especially Feenie. Of course this doesn’t mean they’re 100% town, but it’s nice anyway
@Midorikawa but...I like my avatar tho :c
That being said I’m completely out of leads to be honest. Renato at least tried to make a post, but nothing came out of it. Officer Snake a man of few words.
Many people have said that they like jd’s recent posts. I can’t say I do. He asked me why I voted for Feenie, even tho I explained that part, and then he himself proceeds to vote for her with no explanation. Apparently it was a “pressure vote” even though you said you found her the most suspicious. Then he votes Officer Snake. I don’t much of a problem with this but Officer Snake is unreadable and if he’s town he’s an easy target for mafia to pick on.
Another 180 on Snake.I also played with him before when he was a pretty much confirmed townie, and he still didn’t say much. I agree on the part that that he surely must have something to say.
Defending NIghtwing again. And trying to lynch RC solely based on activity.Hey guys, I found a decent candidate for the lynch! @HumanDawn ideas can happen in the most unlikely of places
@HumanDawn @Midorikawa Don’t you think that Nightwing’s inexperience might be the reason for this?
I think i’d rather lynch Rainbow Cloud. They’re usually much more active and they haven’t really scumread anyone since the beginning of the game, despite having more than 3 posts.
Nothing wrong with this.Never heard of this either
Now he's neutral on Snake. And defending Nightwing again.Well wanted to hear your thoughts but yes, I’m not sold that Nightwing is scum.
I’m posting this on my phone with 3G and away from home, which is why I took so long to post.
Two of their posts were made after I called them out. Another thing is that he seems sneaky to me, always appearing at only certain times. Add to the fact that he comes back and makes his D2 vote when the phase is about to end. What does he do? Joins a wagon, and votes Officer Snake without giving his thoughts on the game. Gives me the impression he’s trying to take him out of the game. Now I’m not sure Officer Snake is town, but if he is he would be an easy target for the mafia
Vote: Rainbow Cloud
Something feels off about this. It's so defensive....why would the Town roleblocker even listen to you? You’re far from a confirmed townie. More importantly, why exactly do you believe targeting HD is a bad idea? You said that Max was acting buddy buddy with Cheff. Looking at this, it makes you look pretty hypocritical
Answer me this, so the town roleblocker shouldn’t have targeted anyone?
Please tell me that I'm not the only who sees how blatantly contradicting this post is. He's against lynching based on inactivity, yet that is his reason for going after RC.I made a mistake. In that post, I meant you voted Officer Snake without giving thoughts on his claim. Look, I know where you’re coming from but how many myslynches can we afford? Lynching someone as an “inactive” is a high risk thing. You know Officer Snake is always like that.
Don’t care. I’d rather lynch Officer Snake than Nightwing, and if by the end of the day the votes are tied i’ll guarantee there’s a lynch and vote for Officer Snake because knowing what he will flip will give me more info about you. I’m not sure about you. I’m not townreading you to be honest.
Now that I think about it, Officer Snake’s claim doesn’t really help him. Nobody has even heard of that role lol
Funny how he was all for HD plenty and against me and Feenie. And he hasn't said anything since me at this point since I came out with the roleblock. Yet his townreads are Feenie who claimed so she makes sense, and Swarla...who he still hasn't given reason for believing to be town. More interesting is the Snake thing. He's still contradicting himself on snake. He's made no sense on him at all during the game, and he continues to do so.I tend to not associate people as scum “yep, they’re scum buddies!” until we actually find someone who is scum. So no...
Also i wasn’t implying Officer Snake was town. He is unreadable. I’m just saying that he’s an easy target and scum may join his wagon.
Listen honestly, I barely have any townreads, and that’s probably something bad. The only one for now is Feenie and swarla, a little bit. I found things I disagree with almost everyone’s posts. I was kinda reckless...
Unvote: Rainbow Cloud
Forget everything I said against you.
Vote: Officer Snake
Seeing what he flips will give me some information to work with.
Again with the "it's a strange role so it can't be real." Actually note this normal role comment.So they should wait until the cop,doc and tracker claim to make sure they don’t hit cop? In this game you rely on your theories, not on evidence because 90% of the time you’re not gonna have them.
If they are a temporary roleblocker then sure I agree
WIFOM. Besides, I’ve seen them doing it. Or, you know, could be just a newbie slip.
We know there’s Roleblocker, Seraph Knight,cop ... all normal roles. The chances of a sudden custom role being added is low. And I don’t recall him ever explaining what the role does, even though HD and I quoted him.
NAIMidorikawa what is it with you and “Becaise” xD
"My role isn't normal but because I haven't heard of or seen a role like Snake's because nothing of the kind has appeared in any of the games I've played, he must be lying." So his logic was because he lacked the experience, Snake must have been lying. This was after I actually said what the role could be because EXPERIENCE allows one to judge just by names. Yet he ignored that and judged based solely on his own experience, when anyone should always judge based on the games collective experience. Not once did he ask for other's thoughts and kept judging and ignoring.Lol I know the feel
What? ...no...
I myself have a role with a few “abormal” qualities. It’s just that Officer Snake’s role, is one I’ve never heard off. Heck, it’s been over a year I didn’t play mafia and I don’t recall ever being in a game where there’s even a role that boosts others, so this role is one I’m not familiar with.
What do you mean?
Yeah guys I’ve added two scumreads on my scumlist but I’m just gonna add and not explain why they are scum.
Midorikawa is supposed to be a townread for me at this point but her posts don’t help.
Townreads are Feenie, HD and Jinjo(or CheffOfGames).
Obviously because of the flip, I’m more willing to believe you @HumanDawn when you say Nightwing may be scum. I also don’t like their vote when the phase was about to end. I’m gonna be honest with you though, I don’t trust Midorikawa one bit. jd and RC are also potential scum
It was mainly going to help me read HD better. He’s been kind of avoiding Officer Snake for whatever reason. He voted you because apparently “we can’t let potential scum lurk” but ignored Officer Snake. Basically, if Officer Snake flipped scum, I would suspect HD the most.
jd if I may ask...why exactly do you think Officer Snake claiming makes your pressure vote “successful”?
Oh look Nightwing Defense. And trying to get people to go after me and RC. His reasoning, well for RC its inactivity. For me its...Idk. He never explained.She does have a point. I’m not sure Nightwing, honestly I’m very confused, and although you’ve made some mistakes, they were completely normal for a beginner or someone new in mafia. I’m not really convinced you’re scum.
ARGHHH this is giving me a headache.
Everyone who’s town, think with me:
Everyone’s been focusing on scum on Snake’s wagon, but my theory is that both Nightwing and Snake were town, so there’s one scum in each wagon. I’m very confused right now because there are many possibilities and I may be getting paranoid but I will update my thoughts soon.
The first line feels forced. The second feels fake. And does that comment about being 1x doc disturb anyone else?Why would you play selflessly in mafia? This isnt a game of sympathy. Your doc claim was actually fine but the Fool Miller...? You were going to get lynched today anyway so why
I’m glad I was wrong
Following the flow.Eh, I’m not buying it Nightwing.
Vote: Nightwing101
I don’t have much to say, HumanDawn made a great point. We haven’t really seen roles that are “wow, so bastard!”. Gotta say tho, if Nightwing actually has this 1x Doc Miller Fool, this May be the most op role ever lmao
Thanks.@Midorikawa Glad to hear that your mom is doing better.
Also, I agree about looking at others besides Nightwing, and whatever Nightwing actually flips as should tell us a lot too. Looking forward to your analysis.
For me, I am beginning to have a bad feeling about HD, though maybe that's paranoia because he's still alive and I always think he's mafia until proven otherwise.
Doesn't mean we can't pressure with questions and dig for more information. What use is there sitting on hands?I agree that this phase is awfully one-sided, but it's so one-sided I doubt a counter wagon would bring in any pressure on anybody.
And if I'm telling the truth?Seth is scummy. If nightwing turns up mafia, then I think that will confirm that he's mafia. He's given no reason to believe he's town.
You subbed in for Cheff, right? You've been essentially cleared from my ability, so by association - I really can't be brought up in this otherwise it would mean that you would have to be considered a suspect as well.Jinjo said:I died on Night 1 and the only players I could think of who would want to kill me are JD, HD, and Feenie since they are the only players I have played Mafia the most with and I'm pretty sure one of them is Mafia.
Normally I'd be against a 'claim game', but since we're getting closer toward the end - and may not even make it to another day phase from the sounds of it - I'd say that's a good idea.Seth Rollins said:If we manage to survive tomorrow, how about we claim roles?
I did try HumanDawn, I really did.
I hope your mum gets better Mido. It's great she's back home!
Also Feenie, I hope you feel better soon!
This may be the last phase in the game.
If we manage to survive tomorrow, how about we claim roles?
sweatsHumanDawn said:you better not screw it
no pressure tho