Mafia Monty Python Mafia - And There Was Much Rejoicing (TOWN VICTORY)

[Zexy]

In my opinion, @leetic, Role PMs should never confirm anything about the set up other than a player's own role.

Something that I have struggled with in my own games though.

As much as I loved being clear because of it, I have to agree.

I don't remember any of your games giving roles out that much. MSW had the roleblockable NK shenanigans and VGM had Framer/Stongman (but giving out the existence of Cop and Doctor isn't really important).

I seriously wanna read and realize how I was not killed all this time. You could strongman me or just do it after Ryuu's death...

 

[DrumBeats]

For certain roles though I feel like including it is a balance thing.

For Ninja, I believe that including it is fine. It benefits the mafia until the ninja dies, because it allows them to know what they are up against, confirming a tracker and a watcher to be present.

For strongman, I would only say it makes the kill penetrate kill protection. Revealing the doctor and seraph combo could have been very dangerous to the mafia if the strongman died early

 

[Zexy]

That's because of Seraph existing, not because the mafia knew about it or could circumvent it.
It's Seraph itself that is a problem.
ALSO, mafia had no clue what Seraph really was until it was killed. They knew it was protection, but what kind?

 

[mariowie]

Okay congratulation town, I am out

 

[Zexy]

Also, ME, why did you breadcrumb exactly which roles the mafia had left in your PMs?

 

[Maniacal Engineer]

Also, ME, why did you breadcrumb exactly which roles the mafia had left in your PMs?

Because you should have figured it out, even if I hadn't told you. It was pretty damn obvious to anyone paying attention. You'd already been roleblocked, and claimed so in-thread, and with some many protective roles, Mafia needed some way to deal with them.
I would have figured it out easily as Town, so I guessed you had already figured it out.

 

[Zexy]

Because you should have figured it out, even if I hadn't told you. It was pretty damn obvious to anyone paying attention. You'd already been roleblocked, and claimed so in-thread, and with some many protective roles, Mafia needed some way to deal with them.
I would have figured it out easily as Town, so I guessed you had already figured it out.

I had figured out the Roleblocker of course, but I was stuck thinking there were 3 mafia and 2 protection roles still isn't enough of a proof to guarantee the existence of Strongman.

 

[Maniacal Engineer]

I also enjoy breadcrumbing...
Also, you had mentioned the possibility of a third protective role in our PMs. Since I was supposed to be Town and didn't know any better, three protective roles and no way for scum to counteract them is a little much.

 

[Zexy]

Random thing I remembered now.

In order to bait Freesia into claiming back then, I "claimed" to her. My claim was... Tucker If things went really wrong, I would say I accidentally typed that name instead of Tracker. But had Freesia told you in the QT, you could've figured out my role because it was intentionally 'crumby.

 

[mariowie]

Well atleast I got my wish of lynching Ryuu, sad that I didn't see anything of the last day phase because of the stretching of the night.

 

[Snowy]

As much as I loved being clear because of it, I have to agree.

I don't remember any of your games giving roles out that much. MSW had the roleblockable NK shenanigans and VGM had Framer/Stongman (but giving out the existence of Cop and Doctor isn't really important).

I seriously wanna read and realize how I was not killed all this time. You could strongman me or just do it after Ryuu's death...

I was actually referring to the PMs that confirm too much of the set up.. I overcompensated. Does anyone remember a certain Serial killer without any possible way to win?

 

[Falconwing]

Wooooo! Town win! Congrats team.

This was a fun game, even though personally I was playing way too safe. Probably would have been more effective if I had 't been so paranoid. That's what happens first time I play the doc, I guess. I'll try to step it up next time.

 

[TheCapsFan]

Wooooo! Town win! Congrats team.

This was a fun game, even though personally I was playing way too safe. Probably would have been more effective if I had 't been so paranoid. That's what happens first time I play the doc, I guess. I'll try to step it up next time.

I think you played really well as Doc (especially considering it was your first time after a long break!), I'm just surprised you weren't fearkilled by the Mafia tbh. If I were mafia, you would have been my first target.

 

[ReturnofMCH]

Too bad that wouldn't have worked while I was alive
I protected ryuu night 1 because I somehow guessed he had a power role

 

[mariowie]

Too bad that wouldn't have worked while I was alive
I protected ryuu night 1 because I somehow guessed he had a power role

I feel somewhat happy now that I decided to kill you first : )

 

[ReturnofMCH]

I feel somewhat happy now that I decided to kill you first : )

Oh my god
You killed IGN
You bastard!
references FTW

 

[Snowy]

You killed IGN

well, we keep trying to anyway...

 

[ReturnofMCH]

well, we keep trying to anyway...

Keep in mind while there reviews are shit most of the time
They make better articles and reviews than gamespot at least

 

[Slife]

And that's game! Well done town! Looks like that paranoia was uncalled for after all haha. I guess sometimes things actually are as they seem.

It was cool to see Elie as scum for the first time. I wish I could say I figured it out by my own merit, but I scanned him Night 1 so all that was left was to clinch the lynch on him.
N2 scan was on Drum who was bus-driven with Zexy by AE.
N3 scan was town!ME but he died the same night.
N4 scan was supposed to be on Kakashi according to our OC alliance chat(s), but I privately switched it to Ryu because I still had doubts about him. Ironically that was the wrong call to make but it didn't matter in the end because I died that night. Having both the Seraph and Doctor was surprising indeed, which was partly why I was suspicious of Ryu. Sorry about that buddy

Overall a great game, and thanks to the hosts for hosting!