Minority Rule | Feedback & End : Tris79 won!

[Sharpshooter★]

Re: Minority Rule | Phase 1: Is this a mafia game?

It doesn't really matter because we just ran out f time
Maybe next time ...

Spoiler

1)@Hellion
2)@DrumBeats
3)@Smasher 101
4)@Aestivate
5)@Sourcandy
6)@Insanish Danish
7)@Argus Claydol
8)@Paperhorse
9)@Iteru
10)@Feralize
11)@Croag
12)@Karamazov
13)@Tsutarja
14)@Gotpika
15)@Zenax
16)@Soulmaster
17)@Kaustic
18)@Tris79
19)@Derier44

8 people voted for no, 7 people voted for yes, 4 didn't vote
Those four votes went to no

5 people will be asked to leave
The ones that will leave tonight are:

@Insanish Danish
@Paperhorse
@Soulmaster
@Derier44
@Kaustic

Maybe next time
But keep an eye here cuz I have something in mind for the final two and will need you help

The second question is : ...

Minimum minority is 8:6 and maximum is 13:1
Am I a girl?
As always only yes or no are acceptable, and it doesn't need to be the correct answer
Please PM the votes, and Sundays are hard for me to update, so the update will only happen tomorrow night (21:00 PM GMT-3)

 

[Paperhorse]

Re: Minority Rule | Phase 2: Am I a girl?

Oops. xD

Oh wow, it was so close anyway!

 

[Sharpshooter★]

Re: Minority Rule | Phase 2: Am I a girl?

Oh yeah, if you guys want
I can post who voted for what

 

[Hellion]

Re: Minority Rule | Phase 2: Am I a girl?

Oh yeah, if you guys want
I can post who voted for what

Sure thing Miss, that'd be great!

...

Did I vote he was a girl? Do I think she's a he? MIND GAMES! XD

 

[Sharpshooter★]

Re: Minority Rule | Phase 2: Am I a girl?

I'm neither a boy nor a girl
I'm a Sableye (or a Porygon)
But the votes are:

Yes

• Aestivate
• Tsutarja
• Iteru
• Karamazov
• Smasher 101
• Tris79
• Argus Claydol

No

• Insanish Danish
• Hellion
• Zenax
• Derier44
• Gotpika
• Sourcandy
• Paperhose
• DrumBeats

Copied directly from my secret HQ
Anybody not listed didn't vote

 

[Paperhorse]

Re: Minority Rule | Phase 2: Am I a girl?

^ I'm not a hose, I'm a horse :<

 

[Kaustic]

Re: Minority Rule | Phase 2: Am I a girl?

Not to nitpick, but the phase ended before 24 hours was up.

Nonetheless, my fault for being a derp and not casting my vote last night. XD

Good luck all.

 

[Sharpshooter★]

Re: Minority Rule | Phase 2: Am I a girl?

Spoiler

1)@Hellion
2)@DrumBeats
3)@Smasher 101
4)@Aestivate
5)@Sourcandy
6)@Insanish Danish
7)@Argus Claydol
8)@Paperhorse
9)@Iteru
10)@Feralize
11)@Croag
12)@Karamazov
13)@Tsutarja
14)@Gotpika
15)@Zenax
16)@Soulmaster
17)@Kaustic
18)@Tris79
19)@Derier44

Kaustic called me out privately for something i'm afraid he was right thus to make it up to you guys, last round shall be treated as a mock round (one that won't affect the game, just to make you guys get the hang of it) therefore making any elimination that has happened last round nulled
The deadline still stands though
Please vote now

 

[Sharpshooter★]

Re: Minority Rule | Phase 2: Am I a girl?

Spoiler

1)@Hellion
2)@DrumBeats
3)@Smasher 101
4)@Aestivate
5)@Sourcandy
6)@Insanish Danish
7)@Argus Claydol
8)@Paperhorse
9)@Iteru
10)@Feralize
11)@Croag
12)@Karamazov
13)@Tsutarja
14)@Gotpika
15)@Zenax
16)@Soulmaster
17)@Kaustic
18)@Tris79
19)@Derier44

And so the phase ended

Am I a girl?
6 voted for yes, 9 voted for no, 4 didn't vote
7 will be asked to leave, and they will be ...

12)@Karamazov
4)@Aestivate
9)@Iteru
16)@Soulmaster
15)@Zenax
10)@Feralize
1)@Hellion

Sorry guys, maybe next time
But keep an eye on the game, because I'll need you guys for the final two showdown
The new question is the opposite of this one
Am I a boy?
Vote, and feel free to contradict yourselves

The votes from this last phase

Spoiler

Yes

• Tris79
  
• Gotpika
  
• Argus Clayol
  
• Croag
  
• Kaustic
  
• Sourcandy
  

No

• Karamazov
  
• Hellion
  
• Zenax
  
• Tsutarja
  
• Smasher 101
  
• Paperhorse
  
• Feralize
  
• DrumBeats
  
• Iteru
  

 

[Soulmaster]

Re: Minority Rule | Phase 3: Am I a boy?

But since I didn't vote we have the minority right?
Sorry I couldn't be active I was at a Boy Scout Campout.

 

[Sharpshooter★]

Re: Minority Rule | Phase 2: Am I a girl?

Spoiler

1)@Hellion
2)@DrumBeats
3)@Smasher 101
4)@Aestivate
5)@Sourcandy
6)@Insanish Danish
7)@Argus Claydol
8)@Paperhorse
9)@Iteru
10)@Feralize
11)@Croag
12)@Karamazov
13)@Tsutarja
14)@Gotpika
15)@Zenax
16)@Soulmaster
17)@Kaustic
18)@Tris79
19)@Derier44

And so the phase ended

Am I a boy?
1 voted for yes, 4 voted for no, 7 didn't vote
(@Zenax Since you left last round your vote didn't count)
10 will be asked to leave, leaving us to the final two ...
Those that will leave us will be ...

Anybody left but Tris79 and Kaustic

Sorry guys, maybe next time
But keep an eye on the game, because I'll need you guys for the final two showdown

The new question is ...
Will Tris79 win?
But this time around the ones that will vote won't be the ones in the game, rather the ones out of the game will vote
If yes is minority, Tris wins
In no is minority, Kaustic wins

This is the desperation round, you may use any and whatever tricks you have up your sleeves to use.
(Including but not limited to getting people outside the game to vote)
Voting will proceed as always, may the best one win
The votes from this last phase

Spoiler

Yes

Zenax (Void due to leaving last round)
Tris79

No

Smasher 101
Tsutarja
Argus Claydol
Paperhorse

May the more desperate one wins

 

[Tris79]

Re: Minority Rule | Phase 2: Am I a girl?

(Including but not limited to getting people outside the game to vote)

Does this mean people outside the game can vote?

 

[Sharpshooter★]

Re: Minority Rule | Phase Final: Tris79(Yes) or Kaustic(No)?

You just quoted that, but yes
But, really keep that to a minimum otherwise it's popularity not strategy

 

[Soulmaster]

Re: Minority Rule | Phase Final: Tris79(Yes) or Kaustic(No)?

So is either one going to try to get either votes for either person because whoever has the better argument will get my vote in the favor they want.
So @Tris79 and @Kaustic tell me your argument.

 

[Kaustic]

Re: Minority Rule | Phase Final: Tris79(Yes) or Kaustic(No)?

So is either one going to try to get either votes for either person because whoever has the better argument will get my vote in the favor they want.
So @Tris79 and @Kaustic tell me your argument.

You should vote "Yes", because I have the feeling I'm the underdog and am going to be vote-bombed. XD

 

[Sharpshooter★]

Re: Minority Rule | Phase Final: Tris79(Yes) or Kaustic(No)?

One hour to go, final phase and I only got three votes ...
Really, you guys should work harder

 

[Sharpshooter★]

Re: Minority Rule | Phase Final: Tris79(Yes) or Kaustic(No)?

Players:
1)@Hellion
2)@DrumBeats
3)@Smasher 101
4)@Aestivate
5)@Sourcandy
6)@Insanish Danish
7)@Argus Claydol
8)@Paperhorse
9)@Iteru
10)@Feralize
11)@Croag
12)@Karamazov
13)@Tsutarja
14)@Gotpika
15)@Zenax
16)@Soulmaster
17)@Kaustic
18)@Tris79
19)@Derier44

And since nobody else voted
Tris79 won with 0 votes
Kaustic didn't by 3 votes ...

So congratulations Tris
And now I want some feedback, could this be done better?
Should a sequel be made?Rada Rada?

 

[Bandit Keith]

Confusing voting system...

Lack of dynamic input...

Bizarre Formatting...

Sharpshooter, maybe something different, but after Total Drama and my next project are done, contact me. We both like breaking the mold of the War Room as a Mafia-only scene.

 

[Hellion]

I really liked it, but if I had one comment to make, it'd be that there were too many people eliminated each round, and I felt we, the players, didn't do enough talking in the thread, but overall, you're a good host and this was a great idea.

 

[Sharpshooter★]

Confusing voting system...

Lack of dynamic input...

Bizarre Formatting...

Sharpshooter, maybe something different, but after Total Drama and my next project are done, contact me. We both like breaking the mold of the War Room as a Mafia-only scene.

Yes or no is a confusing way to vote?But I take all your feedback to heart
Thanks for helping
Sure, let's remind this guys that War Room =/= Mafia Forum

I really liked it, but if I had one comment to make, it'd be that there were too many people eliminated each round, and I felt we, the players, didn't do enough talking in the thread, but overall, you're a good host and this was a great idea.

It is better than the original version, in which everybody from the majority left (but again there there were like 100 people, they could ship the whole lot away)
But I understand what you mean, for the second version I'll be sure to work on it

And just thought I should mention it but the idea (for this game) was taken from this awesome manga called Liar Game
It has a lot of fun games, that are very strategical
So, if you War Room Junkies want new ideas, check it out