I agree the Max flip-flopping is kinda a bad look. I’m still not 100% certain why he unvoted in the first place, but the re-vote does make sense, based on the conversation I had with him.
He's not worth pushing for now IMO
True. Then the question for you is why do you put so much stock in this when the alleged “scum claim” is vague and potentially non-existent, especially in comparison to the other times Fatima has done this.
…so you’re upset at Fatima for allegedly outing themself as scum, and then you do this. -_-
Sure. Like a Jester would admit to being a Jester.
So what are you basing your criteria on?
AH HA! Caps and Space are scumbuds, confirmed!
This was directed at Jinjo, not you. Surprisingly, I do talk to other people sometimes.
Nobody else has done anything else of note.
Gotta keep everyone on their toes ¯\(ツ)/¯
For Elieson specifically I want to see more, I can't read him just based off one single wall, and as such I wouldn't feel comfortable eliminating him right now.
Already explained why I’m not going to do that, since I’m forced into a break for roughly half the phase.
mmm, neato
I didn't have much of an opinion on HD at the start, just that I've seen him do the "ok X is town" thing before, and figured he was doing it again. In general I also tend to read lack of capitalization + as indicative of sarcasm/non-seriousness, so that's more of my own fault, if anything. See, I can't even tell if your scum claim is a joke or not because of how the letters get all big at the start of sentences and how there are periods at the ends of them.
Something about calling out HD's initial vote specifically and how he'd apparently "figured out" Fatima's "alliance" through the placeholder reeeeally makes me worried about this game
Max's conversation with you I could see it go both ways. He can be a really hard person to read.
Welcome back. If you don’t want to seem defensive, might I suggest commenting on something aside from the votes and arguments on you?
Nah. It’s just Elieson 101. The man loves his ITPs.
So you’re still null on Max. What does he need to clarify further?
This is a good observation- if Fatima flips Mafia then Jinjo would not be a bad look.
Thanks Snowy, I'll add you to everything now
Yes, from what I remember with your recent conversation with Max you were asking him why the unvote and saying along the lines of if he had a scum read on Space then he would have committed on the vote rather then unvote and I also remember you asking him about other players while he delivers on what he thinks about the other players. It was his voting, unvoting, to revoting which looked weird to me that needed clarifying. I see that you have been aggressive and aggressiveness does make some players uncomfortable.
How does that make me look bad if Fatima flips scum? Space misrepped me and misrepping always looks bad.
nice catch
For some batshit reason, Fatima likes to out their partners when they're scum. The fact that they've already admitted to being scum themselves, plus the fact they specifically questioned HD's intro vote on you doesn't make you look very good if Fatima's scum. Note they specifically asked about your vote rather than any of the other votes posted around that time.
Inch resting.
I assume the above is what you're referencing? Double voter ain't a guaranteed town role. It's useful information to have, but I'd hardly call it town confirmation.
This isn't Chaos Mafia. In five years of playing Mafia I have never seen a Mafia Double Voter.
It's also not just based on meta from one game, it's happened multiple times now.
